Close Reading

720000 PEW documented illegal indians in USA but the real figure may even be higher then a milllion. When will they get deported back as more still appear to be coming.

It was millions coming from Canada. Especially Indians, not 16,000 ??

These are Indians who were on student visas with the only intention was to fast track into entering the country. It was out of control as they were coming in by the hundreds of thousands. Crooked people were forming fake schools to get government money and these fake students weren't even attending class.\nCanadians were fed up of seeing this invasion of Indians and slimy Trudeau decided stop this quick entry scam scared he was going to lose the next election.\nThese cheaters are supposed to go home and now it looks like their looking for another scam. These people has no respect for anyone let them freeze.

Ohhhh look bunch of east Indians..... same issue we are trying to deal with here where they come under a student visa but never actually goto school and just stay illegally

Canada imported 1m Indians to Canada to a country that has few job, high rents and hard to survive. They knew when those migrants weren't happy, they would cross over to New York. We all know that. There are tons of them driving Uber, DoorDash. Come to Elmhurst Queens, Jersey City, Edison.

If they want to come to North America ,speak English and stop thinking they can defraud people to make make money,it’s time countries change their rules not only for Indians but for every one who think they can cheat our countries.

While I don't approve of giving low tips or being rude, a problem is we have an over immigration problem here with the same number of Indian immigrants coming here as in the U.S despite 10x less people and tens of thousands of less towns. So it's getting hard for Canadians who were born or grew up here to find jobs and many are upset and some will take it out in inappropriate ways. It's best for government to limit immigration so that Canadians can have these jobs. Sometimes you have to put up with jerks in retail. You can always not work there

Well, if you clean ur toilet. Inidian wont come\nIf u wash cars, clean, cook, become doctors, pharmacist the list goes on, the Indian or the migrants won’t come to Canada.

Indians dont adapt they are the worst immigrants this coming from an immigrant myself.

This message is for all foreigners - South Indians come legally and North Indians illegally. Just research and then make a judgement.

In uae….Indians are coming and scamming the country…Taking loans and going back to India.\nIndians are just spoiling the name across the globe

Make Indian people specially men more civilized specially when they are abroad. In Australia they are terrible to be around. Not many people want to be around them. I met very civil Indians here who are mainly from cities like Delhi or Mumbai, but majority come from villages or remote cities of Punjab. And these people are truly uncivil and their behaviour is super unpleasant.

It must also be noted that many people from India are already in those countries. I live in Indiana and the number of people from India has doubled or tripled in the last few years. They do jobs like research and other medical field related things. There's also a large number of Indian students in colleges too. The reality is the newer generation will have to work harder to get the things the last did, because the last generation is still there. Then there's the fact the Indian's here often don't want new Indian's coming over...

there are much indians in our country. they live very rich. Very. and can not stay any other peoples. they forced off them.. and new indians come and come. Welcome. you are billions and don t want to live in İndia. you come for luxury life. you more rich, than englishmen, americans .... because you don t let work us too.

Come on Palki, you can do much better! I have a huge respect for you so please don't make it sound like a political issue. \nThe primary reason behind these rejections are Indians lack in civic sense and really don't know how to behave while in overseas, a majority of them make other Indians look bad, us Indians don't have a good reputation overseas. Also, let's not forget to address the elephant in the room, a majority of them tend to overstay their welcome. Thank you

Indians are great at setting up scam call centers. If we depart them off US it would be easier to recognize scam call by country number. So yes deportation makes total sense, but should come in bigger quantities.

Let's be honest, Indians come into your country as an invading force, you don't see Americans in the millions migrating everywhere trying to dominate those countries, we visit and then we go home.

Coming from outside the country going to Canada I found there to be a shocking number of Indians.

This isn’t the problem. Is the Massive amounts of Indian people that have come in is the problem..

Step 1: Study at a legitimate school if you come here to study. 60-70% of the Indians, especially those from Punjab and Haryana study at these scam colleges attending bogus diplomas, often lured by agencies in India. How do you expect to get a good paying job with that diploma? Plus almost all these students barely speak any English. So you get automatically cornered to low-paying jobs at restaurants, fast food chains, etc. Working in the Canadian corporate world requires you to have the right skills and a good handle with English, which almost all these diploma graduates lack. I have not seen a single Indian student who graduated from UBC, McGill, McMaster, UVic, UofA, UWaterloo, etc struggle to find a job or get PR, and they almost always land good paying jobs.\n\nCanada has entered a correction phase. In the next 2-3 years, you will see a lot of these diploma students forced to leave the country.

Indiana are very difficult nation to respect the rules and laws in the housing sector to during to jobs - and education. They don't want to learn the foreign rule except just want to make money by ignoring all rules. \nI rule said to allow the apartment to be sized and rules to all nations 2 people the indians will bring the same apartment 10-15 person minimum, damages within a days weeks, non-respect the rules they agreed to respect. \nWhen landlords are the same rules as all others indians think it's only for them, and cleanliness maintenance is the main issue. Before indians rented the buildings front, corridors, and inside all was super clean as soon Indians rented the apartment all the bags full of garbage, compost, dresses, and shoe food all in front and everywhere. The apartment and building itself are not livable and others are complaining threatening the landlord to quiet the building. For Indians tennats many landlords lost. their good respectable tenant, None want to stay with them, It's not about color or language its about cleanness and noise sharing s with many and inviting all friends which is allowed only in India, not other developed countries or Canada. U.S. If they can't respect the rules of law in Canada they should not come. Canad landlords will not allow 11/2 or 21/2 apartments with 10-15 peoples, who breaks all inside out crowd noise, deny damages, and blame Landlords.

The bogus 'education Institution' near my home in Toronto has closed. Sadly, many Indian students were left with nothing. Do not come to Canada unless it's a top Canadian university. Do not waste your parents' hard earned money.

The government of India should find ways to use the human resources locally. There has been a widespread anti-Indian sentiment in the West and in Australia. Behavior and cleanliness are a big issues when it comes to Indians. The government must treat all its citizens equally and make them to love the country and work for uplifting the nation. Hindutva is not good for the future of this wonderful nation. Let's wake up!

The reason for denying room to students is because they mess the place. Dont know how to maintain the place they live\n Not all are like tat but majority comes in. And i myself faced it. I gv my place to live to almost 5 different Indian students ar different times.. all messed the room also left me repairs which i had to spent. I had sympathy wen students come for accomodation so i gave a helping hand instead i ended up spending 1000s

Don’t forget to mention all the fake Indian Agencies misleading Indians when they come to “Study in Canada”??

It's right. I agree, it's not hatred but an on other people's land. If India is great, stay in India. Why are Indians wanting to come abroad if they don't like the western culture? Stay back & make India great.

Most Indians since of late are hooligans. What atrocities do Indians have to come to a foreign Country & try to take over. Indians may he smart but are not wanted anywhere. Alot of Indians are staying illegally in Canada. They have taken undue advantage of the Canadians & the Americans. Will India or any other Country for that matter allow such things? So Indians go back. Don't bring your culture here. Try to embrace & adapt to their culture because you have come to their land. Go back Indians.

Funny paet is 32 Gujrati are shouting Modi Modi inside the plane. Who went there saying Modi hain tho mumkin hain... ? 90% of illegal Indian migrants in USA comes from north india.

Don't blame all to the Indian students. Corrupt and spineless guy like Trudeau leading Canada & their Universities collaborate with Sikh terrorists and issues fake Canadian visas and facilitate and send to USA in collaboration with Soros-Biden to destroy USA. Wait there will be more things to come from DOGE and tear the face of Canada! Even terrorist like Nijjar came in student visa to Canada!

When Westerners become impotent and became gays and lesbians, we potent, intelligent smart Indians have to fill the gap - US & Canada must pay their respect to those Indians coming to US-Canada and work for their economy - unlike Chinese or Pakistanis Indians are very loyal & hardworking, reliable people! America and Canada should appreciate and support Indians who blend with western culture and never be a problem for them! Look at UK, France, Germany, Sweden even Canadian Sikhs(who hijacked Canadian politics & play dirty role) with bunch of groomers and rapists - do you want that kind of people?

Don’t come from North Indian states. Canada is already destroyed by these uncivilized people. Once you are educated and civilized, then come. Otherwise stay in your Gujarat, UP, Delhi, Haryana, Bihar and Punjab.

Now all big Indian Techies and other influential and powerful Indians in abroad should come forward to give voice for Indians living abroad particularly who all hold legal visas like students and other legal permits etc and if possible they should create a fund to help our Indian students in financial, legal and other distress - may be given as loan. Influential Indians in USA should have used USAID program to channeled some funds to Indian students - no one wants to take risk but want to be good in American's Book! All big shots of Indian origin throw a little money may help these helpless students or may create like sovereign fund to help Indians who needs help in abroad!

If I were an American of Indian Origin n well documented then I would say I am an Innocent Indian in America (meaning Not So Clever) & these Clever Indians are coming into the US & ruining my Party in The US. Well moral of the story is Burey Kaam Ka Bura Nateeja ie Do Wrong & Get Treated Wrong. But it’s definitely a Shame & a Momentary Set Back on The Countries that promote Democracy & The Free World.

Stupid politician's statement that USA and Europe should allow Indians to live there without a visa is quite unrealistic. Every country has its own immigration laws and regulations, and it's standard practice to deport individuals who don't have proper documentation or visas ¹. \n \nIn fact, even India has its own set of rules and regulations when it comes to foreign nationals living and working in the country. It's not uncommon for countries to take action against individuals who violate their laws and regulations. \n \nThe concept of visa-free travel is not entirely unheard of, though. There are currently 16 countries that offer visa-free travel to Indian citizens, including Thailand, Mauritius, Nepal, and Bhutan. However, these countries still have their own set of rules and regulations that visitors must follow. \n \nIt's worth noting that the US government has been deporting illegal immigrants, regardless of their nationality, and it's not something that the Indian Prime Minister can simply override. \n \nRather than criticizing the politician's statement, it's essential to understand the complexities of international immigration laws and regulations. It's crucial to respect the rules and regulations of other countries, just as we expect foreign nationals to respect India's laws.

The lesson we have learnt from us indians join togather come back to indian lets make our country a heaven indian should change india 1000 டைம்ஸ் better place then us india is god built heaven in this world need some changes in attitude of people and political changes india is number one \n\nSame thing happened in burma, in malayasia ect \n\nAny were you go india for indians dont forget

News flash, you put criminals in restraints. Especially on an airctaft, come on people, think! \nQuestion: Now that Kamala lost is she back to identify as an Indian or hanging with being black?

As an Indian I think these people do deserve to be deported because they chose to come to America illegally, but the way they r being deported is terrifying

We have way too many here it's creating resentment. It'd be like living in India but literally every place you went all u see is white ppl speaking English and not respecting Indians culture. After years of seeing your quality of life and services decline you'd get upset too. If u had kids that can't even find a summer job because they're all taken by foreigners or can't find an apartment to live in then that's where problems start. Imagine getting hurt but your wait to see a doctor is 12 hours because 100 east Indians are there at the ER slowing things down because they can't even speak our language. Poor Canadians are now fighting with Indians at food banks it's gotten so bad. We just have too many, if you're reading this in Indian please dont come to Canada

Spending so much money to come illegally what’s wrong to Indian people mind set . You have lots of opportunities in India itself that kind of money spent to come USA you could have used that money to start a business in India . Mindset of Indian should be change make in India make your own country great. Any other countries come to India no they don’t . If you see at the airport only Indian crowd . They go anywhere. Leaving their family their culture there food . What craziness ???

This is done deliberately by Trump organisation to tarnish Indians image. But we Indian will make our country great definitely.\n\nWe will rise and shine in coming years soon. ❤

Why don't black Indians go to work in Israel? Why do they come to Arab countries? Aren't they fans of Israel? Then work and take oil and gas from Israel.?

I'm sorry you didn't like being cuffed and shackled, but you came into a country Illegally. That's what happens to criminals in America. I'm sure you will get over it. The Indian people are good people, we just want them to come in Legally.

Inhumane...shame on US treating like this... I wish that all indians should return back and let the Americans show intelligence in software development....\n\nVery annoyed to see our people had been chained like a convict..\n\nIn india , how many foreigners are living you know... Their visa got expired and most of them look like half indian face ... and they live here... \n\nToo much Bangladeshis have come here to India... and even from Africa some guys are roaming here... If at all they were caught we just deport him and they can't come to India for minimum 5 years..and some fine..that's it.\n\nBut we don't ill-treat..We respect humanity..\n\nLet the U S understand this....

This is a complete disgrace! India, a nation with a history of resilience and struggle, is once again humiliating its own people to appease external powers. The British ruled us for centuries because we betrayed our own, and now history repeats itself—except this time, it's not the British, it's our own so-called leadership bowing down.\n\nWe are not criminals like the U.S., invading countries for selfish gains. We are not as bold as Israel, standing firm against the world to protect its people. Instead, we are spineless when it comes to defending our own dignity. Handcuffing an Indian citizen and sending them on a military plane like a terrorist—what kind of message does this send to the world? That India is weak? That we are puppets willing to humiliate our own just to satisfy some foreign pressure?\n\nIt is shameful that even after 75+ years of independence, we still act like a colony, treating our own worse than enemies. If our leaders had even a fraction of self-respect, they would never allow such a disgraceful display. This is not just about one person—it is about the dignity of our entire nation!

As an Indian who lives abroad, there's no better place on this planet earth like India. People should start making use of the opportunities in India than come abroad and aping the west. People in the west are miserable.

Indians deserve it. Just teach Indians to stop arrogance, ignorance and false expectations to be treated like some Royals. Majority of Indians are coming with fake visa, fake CV, fake experience. A very few smart and intelligent make it to the top. And the worst thing is they will go to foreign land and play like victim card and expect foreigners to learn Indian culture instead of them learning foreign culture.

CNN is bankrupt for a reason. The Indian GOVERNMENT CAN send their planes over to come get them

Why Indians different all other immigrants are treated the same way too . Indians should stay their country. Instead of coming to Canada and US.

Come to Canada. Our Liberal govnt will accept all Indians including those who don’t know how to use a toilet but do it on our beaches. Better hurry, as they may no longer be in power.

Just imagine someone comes to your house illegally and stay ,eat the food....Indian mentality