Close Reading

It’s too late. This is now India 2.0. Whether people want to admit it or not we all know they get first pick at jobs and housing. They are nice people with good intentions, but there’s too many and it’s costing Canadians their happiness and livelihood.

Despite being the 5th largest economy, India still faces significant challenges in wealth distribution and visa compliance. While economic strength is a factor in visa approvals, it is not the only consideration. One major issue is visa misuse and overstaying. With a population of 1.4 billion, even if 10% were to overstay in foreign countries, that would be 140 million people—almost half the population of the United States. This creates serious concerns for immigration systems worldwide, leading to strict visa vetting processes for Indian applicants.\nFurthermore, while India’s economy is large, the majority of the wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few. A high GDP does not necessarily mean the average citizen enjoys financial security. Many people seek better opportunities abroad, sometimes through illegal means, which further justifies the need for stringent immigration policies.\nAnother issue that affects how Indians are perceived abroad is the behavior of some tourists. While not all are at fault, a growing number of incidents involving disrespectful behavior, disregard for local laws, and unruly conduct have led to Indian tourists gaining a negative reputation in some countries, including Nepal. This has made them among the least desired tourists in certain regions.\nUltimately, visas are not just about how much money a country has. Factors like overstays, illegal migration risks, and tourist behavior all play a role in shaping immigration policies. Respect and reputation are earned, not entitled. If you want to be welcomed and respected abroad, it’s essential to create a positive impression through responsible actions and cultural sensitivity.

The strength depends on abuse of visa. Indians abuse rate of visa is very high. Illegal migration is high. In US Indians are number 2 in illegals behind only Mexico. Story is same in canada, new zealand, australia, UK and other western countries.\nwhen we abuse the visa then what do you expect !!\nSorry elite indians may think India is a super power but the reality is India is a poor nations and people are willing to do anything for a better life

Unfortunately, there are many scammers in India scamming people in America and the UK. They have damaged the reputation of the great country of India. Not sure why Modi allows their behavior to go on.

Why can't India Do the same to US people who are here like that. Legs chained hands cuffed . And also make our rules strict. Rule is Rule where ever we are. Our Indians must be proud to earn here in India, even if it is little. Your dignity is not lost. Slow and steadly you can make Money. It's a digital world. Young Indians can become enterprenurs here giv jobs for our youth. Train them skilfully. Indian Govt. Must provide jobs and easy the rules for business.\nThe world is looking at India to sell their products. We won our independence long Back. ??. PM must provide jobs for all those who have been deported. Pass a law to all states to accomodate them.

Indiana are very difficult nation to respect the rules and laws in the housing sector to during to jobs - and education. They don't want to learn the foreign rule except just want to make money by ignoring all rules. \nI rule said to allow the apartment to be sized and rules to all nations 2 people the indians will bring the same apartment 10-15 person minimum, damages within a days weeks, non-respect the rules they agreed to respect. \nWhen landlords are the same rules as all others indians think it's only for them, and cleanliness maintenance is the main issue. Before indians rented the buildings front, corridors, and inside all was super clean as soon Indians rented the apartment all the bags full of garbage, compost, dresses, and shoe food all in front and everywhere. The apartment and building itself are not livable and others are complaining threatening the landlord to quiet the building. For Indians tennats many landlords lost. their good respectable tenant, None want to stay with them, It's not about color or language its about cleanness and noise sharing s with many and inviting all friends which is allowed only in India, not other developed countries or Canada. U.S. If they can't respect the rules of law in Canada they should not come. Canad landlords will not allow 11/2 or 21/2 apartments with 10-15 peoples, who breaks all inside out crowd noise, deny damages, and blame Landlords.

Most Indians going abroad behave like monkeys on the loose. The lack of civic sense and their entitlement is what makes Indians face hostility around the world. Its very necessary to impose strict rules within India against such people and education system needs to bring changes into the curriculum, incorporating habits of public cleanliness and respect for public property.

India is an immoral, dishonest, and valueless country where people can buy any documents. People are scammers. That is the logic.

They are working illegally. Solution: build restrooms in India for your people and give them what to eat. Then it won't leave their country.

Why don’t people just STAY in their own lands ??? Huh ? Madness. Desperate people. \n-Message from India

I'm born canadian indian we dont want people using our system go back to india we only need smart educated people not these people ?

India should reciprocate the visa policy. While many Indians certainly lack civic sense, most white people & media going to India love to show how poor, smelly & dirty it is, rarely showing the good side. Like how they have declared a beautiful n vibrant country like Mexico, a dangerous place run by cartels ?

Stop blaming other countries… we need to find our own mistakes… then we have at least little hope to change our mindset….we have habit of blaming others for our own mistakes..if you are not fitting in the rule- regulations of visa process of- course it will get rejected… most people have fake paper work for visas. \n\nSimple example… if someone enter illegally in our country we will call them terrorist … some countries put them in jail according to illegal act… I appreciate that they are sending them back to their own country… actually we should thank them for saving these people future.\n\nMaharashtra took a step earlier when they send UP citizens out of Maharashtra… in their own country they cannot go to other state.. how you think other countries should let them enter illegally n not take any action… I think we should think before saying anything.\n\nIllegally enter people don’t pay tax… indirectly they put so much pressure on health n other systems…we the tax payer bear that cost.. is that fare ? \n\nThey don’t follow rules of country… they behave similar how they behave in India … they don’t follow health- hygiene , equality rules.\n\nOur country more diverse but no equality… still people get priority based on reach- poor or on caste basis.\n\nIn other country any Indian do something exceptional then we say they are Indian… but no one think that they got that opportunity to prove themself because they were in other country… in our country people doesn’t get opportunity based on their calibre… \n\nWe have habit that we go abroad… earn money… get ideas of business n going back to India we say that’s our own idea… no appreciation at all… so many new businesses has got ideas from other developed countries but no courtesy to appreciate others or thank them.\n\nEven our news channels… everything is happening first time in the world… even it happens so many year earlier in other countries….some people they really don’t know n they believe that…. It’s just playing with people emotions… not providing real information… we all are human beings… we need to appreciate each other… \n\nThese countries have some rules n regulations for human beings to develop equality n equal opportunities. Most of the NRI appreciate that as we haven’t got that in our own country.

Why do Indians need to travel abroad? According to supereme leader in India sab changa si. Pakora jobs are being created, 12 lacs are being transferred to peoples' account, make in India is a great success, 5 trillion economy will be achieved magically, Ram rajya is returning, cities and rivers are in their best shape, and much more.\n\nKyon jana hai pardes? India mein raho aur paisa, career, good infrastructure, good air quality, good healthcare, yeh sab enjoy karo!!! Aur tourism hi karna hai, to statue of unity dekh ke aao, bhai! \n\nJai Hind\n- extra 2AB

Protest for India's government to charter their own planes to come get their people.

Biren wanted to do this in manipur but kukis welcome all illegal people to india.. Shame shame india

It's right. I agree, it's not hatred but an on other people's land. If India is great, stay in India. Why are Indians wanting to come abroad if they don't like the western culture? Stay back & make India great.

Almost 1 million Indians people are gonna deported to India ?? here in Canada ?? eh Hopefully they will be all Well they thinks they can be immigrants rights away being international students

India is the traitor to the developing countries. India doesn't get respect because India keep bootlicking their former white colonial powers . How stxpid is that? Do you realise how low people look at you for doing that? \n?? You choose to impress the US government, the biggest bully of developing countries. Not intellignt at all. You choose to support Israel, a country created by the colonial power that raped your country poor. What's wrong with all of you ? Why do you hate China so much ? This sudden hate of China started after the closer relationship to the US and Israel. Well Israel and the US government doesn't even respect your leader. In fact, they don't like dark skin people. They only wants you as slaves

People move to countries with wild dreams fantasising that everything will be easier and they will be richer. A lot of people just can't adapt to a new country. Some do extremely well. I know a lot of entrepreneurs that have gone to the US and Canada to start businesses and then they move back to their countries in South America or India to live an amazing lifestyle and travel a lot. I suppose it's nice to accumulate wealth faster and know that you have a Canadian passport to fall back on if you need to get out? I'm part first nations. I do not live in Canada for related reasons - but I love my country and what we stand for.

India and Indian students and other like minded people should support Trump plan of Canada merge with USA will be good for all! All Indian & other like minded voters in Canada should unite and form an association for collective bargaining show the strength like Sikh group and Islamist groups in Canada. Disunity in Indians are the biggest root cause of all problems Indians faces in West! Irrespective of party affiliation - all Indian must show their solidarity and make local politicians & lawmakers can't ignore and undermine your interest!

People from India vote for this.

It is good lesson for people with a mindset of always looking down on their motherland and aspire to work abroad doing menial jobs there which they won't touch here and boast before neighbors and friends that our children are settled abroad. \nCriminals are also going abroad from India too. It is an organised racket which many here are more than willing to be part of to keep their collars up.

At least we're not killing or lynching them like minorities in India. In India, people get killed or beaten just because they don't believe in the same religion or align with Hindu extremists. Worse, their lawmakers allow it.

luckily I escaped India in 2017, living pleasant life in USA !! got US passport .. I dint come US for White people, I came here for quality of life n opportunitites!

Good for her . People like Singh deserve what he is getting. I have bid over 300 projects for people from India and they will not pay a white man so the hire hispanics and then they do not pay them.

Because they invade every western country and it’s non stop with extended family and non stop breeding in the country they invade. They expect to be welcomed and kept by a country who owes them nothing. We are sick of them trying to take over Britain when they are not British and are very different to the British. Stay in India and Pakistan where you were born and build your own country not try and take off western countries what the indigenous people built.

India treats its own people worse .The various caste at the bottom of the caste system are treated as plebs

With so many military personnels present where the hell these people will run. Anything illegal is not right... ?% agreed but only Indians were bound in chains and handcuffed. It is better to Please stay in India and work hard here.

Now im really scared to go outside the india .\nOther country people have so much hate on india?

As a Indian who faces same problem here in India aswell..... For all the US people, this protest is organized by our Opposition as they do not have any other issue to oppose. Illegal means crime, results in punishment. (I mean atleast the comeback flight was free.)

Investors have driven housing/rentals up, particlarly after covid. In BC, its $500 - $750 each for 2 persons on a small room in a Punjabi owned house... As for students, theres a middleman growing rich somewhere misleading people in India.

Well there goes a good bit of phone scammers. Fuck ya . Those people definitely live better in India it's just there government won't let them jack up the prices of slurpys?

In India people are born into slavery and their government does nothing to stop it. \nIn India people aren’t treated with dignity. \nIn India their government rather put their money into a space program instead of helping their people. \nITS THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT THAT NEEDS TO CHANGE. \nIf people are handcuffed is for a good reason; the last thing the US needs is a bunch of mad Indians hijacking planes.

India Should now understand... \nAmerica is not like India. \nIt care for its people.. And make strong moves of deporting people. \nWhere on other hand.. India is scilence and get opposed by Indian Muslims.. \nIf Gov try to deport Bangladeshi and Pakistanis.. \nLearn India Learn...

The lesson we have learnt from us indians join togather come back to indian lets make our country a heaven indian should change india 1000 டைம்ஸ் better place then us india is god built heaven in this world need some changes in attitude of people and political changes india is number one \n\nSame thing happened in burma, in malayasia ect \n\nAny were you go india for indians dont forget

Trump sending those cross border illegal is fine they broke the law but all of them from india they just those normal people not criminal or murderer or rapist.

You are in such denial lady you are in such denial if you're the fifth largest ranking superpower then why in the world do we have 5 million plus sanctuary applications from people in India, you heard me correctly 5 million plus ok Canada's a big country but it doesn't have very many people in it okay

India should not get into direct confrontation or discussions for such petty matters specially with Americans, UK, Germany, France, China, Japan, Russia, Oman, Saudi Arabia. People suggesting and raising such issues for illegal people are actually selfish , our quality of life (environment, safety, food, shelter, employment, education, basic needs) is average and not below average as portrayed in movies, tv and social media. Why should the government use tax payers money to bring illegal and greedy people and why we should show any sympathy. First be a practical and economic and security power house then go high on moral & ethical grounds.

These people are not Indians it is fake to tarnish image of india

Spending so much money to come illegally what’s wrong to Indian people mind set . You have lots of opportunities in India itself that kind of money spent to come USA you could have used that money to start a business in India . Mindset of Indian should be change make in India make your own country great. Any other countries come to India no they don’t . If you see at the airport only Indian crowd . They go anywhere. Leaving their family their culture there food . What craziness ???

Co sir here is crux i need help inform modi je = crux = you nailed ?it honorable sir \nonce your elected Honorable Pierre Marcel Poilievre= the ( elections canada2025???) priminister of Canada , we will our best try by best to acess of canada ??? India ??? consumer market of 1,454 million( 2025 ) \ni give u my word\nRoad map = travel through the Pacific Ocean, likely using the Panama Canal to reach the Indian Ocean, & your in india consumer market of 1,454 million people, which is roughly 1,454,000,000 individuals. \n\nits that easy ??????

They were treated the same way as all illegal deportees. India should’ve sent an airplane to take their people back and save our tax payer money from being spent on these deportation flights. Their countries should pay for it.

Your people should feel proud of India Nd be ashamed to have left India in a disgrace manner, any how welcome back home we will take care of U yet

The Columbian president sent its own plane for its people. They flew with dignity unlike India

Please cleaned up Canada , please send all India people back home , we need it clean country we have i noph mess around lots off dirt and pulp on the beach , kids can't play on the beach just sheet everywhere thay can do that in India,

India must recognise their own people skills and pay well accordingly ???

Indian people brag about indian superpower but begging for Western countries' entry. After becoming a citizen, they brag india, and the superpower go back to india, your superpower. Their culture is best they are best. Their everything is best. Take your best and go back.

Send back the Bangladeshi immigrants. Already there are too many people in India. We don't need more

These people spoil the name of india very shame.