Close Reading

Isreal perhaps the only state criticized for defending their own.

Agree all has a free choice but hate is not for anyone but defending yourself or country is a different story. Agree about the immoral laws and teachings in schools. All the best. My question is where is Allah’s Heaven for it’s not the Heaven of the Bible. All the Best and maybe like Canada we have taken in many people from other countries when in a war or famine etc. maybe some of the surrounding nations of Palestine can take in your people until war is settled.

[OUTSTANDING RESPONSE] to a western prejudice framed STATEMENT AND REQUEST faked as a question. Western Imperialism-that has to defend 1947-48!!!

A very wise decision if you place your faith above all as a marker of your identity.\nFrom a western perspective , unfolding over many decades, the ever larger influx of islam is turning into a slow motion train crash as , as you have outlined in your reasons, incompatible with appeasing the almighty.\nRef item 2 , you dont have to be a muslim to strongly agree with your position on this. Local to me there was a story that went worldwide over teaching of 'gender awareness' in a primary school that brought some unlikley alighnments together with the muslim parents and harsh critics of islam both 'singing form the same songsheet' as the saying goes.\nAs for the last item, from a western perspective who is not happy with having various sharia friendly edicts imposed upon them, from de facto blashemy laws , sharia compliant advertising on our capital's subway system and much, much else.\nWell, it isnt genocide, isreal could eliminate all of the population in gaza in an afternoon. They wont because isrealis are (mostly) not muslims.\nThis battle is the fronline of a , well, the only way to say it, war of civilizations. The west and all its advantages that your predecessors moved towards to benefit from, to defending against what you are about to emigrate into. \nI hope, for both our civilisations, you are successful and that encourages others who see things the same way you dou, which is most based on various polls, to copy your example.\nI will be watching your subsequent videos on your voyage of discovery to see if the laws of domestic economics trump the laws of god when making the descision to emigrate permanently.\nI will be , among others, interested to see if this stated intent extends to renouncing your canadian citizenship as a pledge to your faith.

I was with you until you reached #1. How can a country that is defending itself from genocide be accused of the same? I wish you two and your daughters a safe journey to your new home.

Well the isralies have the same rights and if attacked they have full rights to defend and eliminate the threat . Just as any other countries we all have the same rights .

Yea but here’s the thing…? irael also have the right to defend themselves

And the next question should have been, what about Isreal does Isreal have a right to defend itself against Hamas and does Saudi Arabia condemb what Hamas has done to Isreal to cause these actions sgainst Palestinians? If reporters don't ask these kinds of questions then they are biased and the constitution doesn't protect prejudice only unbiased.

Go to Gazza. You can defend your country more courageously. Your kids also feel the real Isalm.

It was a valid well stated question. She already knew the answer. And there is a cyber army from KSA trolling any forum to defend his hypocritical answer.

Because they know palestines have terrorist in their community - how can separate one from the other!? That’s why! Why can’t he say it out laud! Israel ?? has the right to defend itself and Hamas is using their civilians as human shields! Making the world think they are the victims of the story when is the opposite!

People should not defend him whatever i know here in india they wear it but he is not in india he should follow the rules if doesn't want go back to your country ots not a joke to carry a knife in the collage ?

On the day of judgement Allah will ask was my earth not big enough to migrate and protect yourself from oppression if you were not strong enough to fight back. What will Palestinians and Arabs will reply? God we died for you or we died for the land.?. If the strong Muslims not defending weak muslims than weak should migrate and not fight in a way that becomes suicide and leave it to Allah to punish the oppressor. Cause this was the test for stong and wealthy Arabs not weak Palestinions. And Arab world failed miserably.

Okay, but can someone give me an actual reason on why they have a right to the land? Other than they were there first? They cannot defend the land, they don’t make money with the land, they don’t invent or invest anything into that land. Why should you hold onto it? Squatters rights?

It's all about the narrative that Israel has the right to defend themselves even when they are using a defense strategy that violate numerous international humanitarian laws. Israel is using the laws of war of the Iron Age, that are in the Exodus book, to justify its current actions in Gaza. Who are the barbarians?

Yes! Why would I encourage someone to leave their home? I’d encourage them to defend it and I’d help them defending it too!

As an atheist I wish you all the best, it's true the political games destroying the West from within. Though I'm on the side of LGBT and i believe that they should have rights like everyone else, at the same time I understand that some extreme ideologies can go and push so far and I agree that let kids be kids. My only concern is that Islamic countries do not have any rights for LGBT people at all, in fact, they are being prosecuted based on religion since religion is basically the law. I guess only time will tell if you made the right choice, I can not recommend any country this is something that you need to research deeply and make a decision for yourself.\nI'm in British Columbia, and my child had never experienced any drug queen library stories or anything like that, nor did teachers teach them anything without our consent, there is full transparency between teachers and parents.\nAt the same time, I'm just like you disproving collective punishment of Palestinian citizens, the atrocities are sickening and I couldn't believe that the United Nations is tiptoeing and not being proactive in defending Palestinian children, it's just unthinkable to me that it's happening in the 21st Century.

He spoke rubbish.\nBrother go read what God has commanded you to do in your own native language of the Qur'an. \n\nYou are suppose to help your brethren. You are suppose to shield them from the oppressors who aren't stopping the bombardments and destructions of hospitals, homes , schools and infrastructure. You are suppose to aide them with your armies, so that they can defend their land.

100% Correct. What times are these, when we have to defend the obvious?... Bertolt Brecht.

In other words hes saying Israel should not defend themselves against a terrorist regime. Stop the killing he says. He should denounce Hamas

Defend our country

A right to live in safety and security? I couldn't agree more! Israel has a right to defend itself. They have a right to live in safety and security (as anyone does). Hamas jeopardizes the security of Palestinian people, the fault lies with them. They (Hamas) brought this on the Palestinian people.

Can't Texans defend their country? They all seem to be armed?

For rhose that did not understand I will explain what he is saying. Just like Jordan and Egypt are saying 'no' to accepting Palestinian refugees from Gaza. They are a pawn to be used to push are agenda aganist Israel who is defending themselves after years of Hamas terrorism.

Well Saudia Arabia and the Arab world could support Palestinians by equipping them to fight back and defend their land. But they won't, because of their business relations with the terrorists who are supporting the genocide. Saudi Arabia and the Arab world care more about ? than Palestinian lives.

Why you condammed a country that are defending themself and not condemn the terrorists that did nothing good for their people and only bring dead and misery to them?

As the US is sending warships to the Sues chanel to defend ships full of goods for the west. Wouldn't it be the least they could do to send a ship, to dock at the Gaza strip and supply medical assistance to the palestinian people? Last time I checked they supplied the boms killing these allrrady struggling people as well.

Israel has a right to defend it self.

Palestinians are very resilient and they will defend their land and they will not leave until they are free

What he said was he will not work with the idf but help defend hamas. But he first noted that the killing must stop. Even from hamas.

Stop bombing their precious people \nOthers must DEFEND themselves \nGod Loves HIS Land. It's the Apple of HIS Eye \nGOD will defend the Righteous. \nHe Knows the difference \nJulie kilburn USA

Israelis have the right to their land and the right to defend themselves. Hamas takes all the aid for themselves.

Basically he's saying that the weight needs to be shifted back to oppressing Israel and that they have no right to defend themselves

He forgot to say that they also have the right to defend themselves

You should have asked him why the Arab world dont fight back to defend Palestine

If you can't defend your land is not yours

I would have liked his answer because this is the right way of doing things, only hiccup is Hamas attacked first and its been elected by Palestinians and protected in public areas, so there's no way the weight should be lifted to ensure Palestinian right by crossing Israel's boundaries and crushing its right to defend itself. If Arab world is so concerned about Palestinian rights then they should give them temporary refuge, help Israel eradicate Hamas and then let the Humanitarian aid to rebuild Palestine and safely send the Palestinians back to their land. \n\nIf you are not helping them in tough situations then your pushing for ceasefire is just a show off, because you are not helping with actual issue of Hamas terrorism.

So the jews can't defend themselves? Who constantly attacks? Who has never accepted a peace deal? Thats right palestine

No. You have the right to fight to protect your land. They have a right to fight for that land. If you can’t defend it, you won’t keep it. Too late?

And Isreal have a right to defend its self Isreal will hand back their land without Hamas they say got no water no food but plenty rockets …..

Palestinians only have a right to the land if they can defend it. Also dude is a massive hypocrite. He had the opportunity to use his stage to call for Hamas to surrender and all the bloodshed would stop immediately. We’ve seen the videos of Hamas stealing the humanitarian aid for themselves and not distributing it.

The Palestinian people have no original authority/ties to the land in which they occupy. At best, they are squatters privileged by Israel to live in those designated zones, peacefully I might add. They have allowed Hamas, funded by Iran to control their lives, and bring havoc. Israel has every right to control, and defend its sovereignty. And people who support the Hamas, especially here in the US, should be ashamed of their ignorance….

Haha, this doesn't answer the question—kind of an oblivious response. Hamas attacked Israel so they have a right to defend their land. We don't need to be rocket scientists to know that they are going to do it again. Further Hamas uses its people when it attacks Israelis. Where have any other Arab nations shown any type of involvement in condemning Hamas and intervening by stopping Hamas whether it's through negotiations or by force? it's because most of them back Hamas and know if they don't take any refugees it's only going to cause Israel more harm than if they were terrorists. People condemning Israel are stupid. Take your time to look into the entire matter before pointing a finger to entertain your life.

They have the right to that land if they can defend it. They took 20 years of support and built weapons with it. The rest of the Arab world needs to step up.

Land belongs to those that conquer it and defend it, like King Saud did to make Saudi Arabia.

But it’s not their land because they can’t defend it

Isreal has the right to exist and defend themselves

Yeah \nI assume he is talking about stopping Hamas right ?\nAs he said stopping the killing \nBecause Israel is just defending \nBut Hamas started “ long ago perhaps \n Hamas , all the supporters and followers \nAre the same \nTerrorists \n.

Trudope and Canadian oligarchs are too addicted to Chinese and Indian money laundering, that's what chasing the Canadians away. Why bother staying and defending a place that doesn't look after you?

He basically said: they made their bed and now they can lie in it. \n\nThere’s quite a few Palestinians trying to leave and seek refuge in Egypt since they opened their borders to take a limited number of them in.. as long as they’re not associated with Hamas. \n\nHamas brought this war to the Palestinian’s doorstep in Gaza and if other Arab nations don’t want to open their borders to the Palestinians who would like to leave because of the war, then there will be an increased number of civilian casualties. Just because their fellow Arabs refuse to take them as refugees doesn’t mean Israel loses the right to defend itself from the barbaric terrorist attack Hamas launched against them. \nAny other country would have the right to defend itself from terrorists that live at their borders. If Hamas cared about their citizens, they’d have a plan for them and their safety once they initiated this war on Oct 7th. But it seems like Hamas’s only plan for them was to be disposable pawn martyrs caught in between them and Israeli forces. \n\nYou can’t torture, rape and kill 1,400 Israeli citizens/foreign nationals and take 200+ hostages back to Gaza during a depraved terrorist attack and then cry ceasefire when that country declares war and is winning. Especially when you’re still holding onto hostages and not honoring the terms of the first ceasefire by letting the Red Cross see the hostages. \n\nIf these other countries cared about the Palestinians, they’d take any refugees that wanted to leave. They clearly don’t want to do that for some reason. They’re watching from afar with their popcorn, saying “isn’t it terrible what the Israeli’s are doing.. but we won’t let them come here to escape, which would let the Israelis fight this war with Hamas, who initiated it, without civilians in between.” With no mention of how Hamas as put them in the middle and isn’t protecting them. Also no mention of any responsibility Hamas has for bring this war onto them by the large scale terrorist attack, that includes hundreds of civilian hostages of all ages.