Close Reading

He's right the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip shouldn't be forced to leave their land that has been theirs for a very long time. Even though the Israeli government removed the Jews from the Gaza Strip against their free will in 2005, who had lived in the Gaza Strip for long time themselves. In 2006 a year later the Hamas came into power by killing off their opponents and rivalry. We don't want the Gaza or even the West Bank to become another Syria where millions of Syrians were forced from their homes and country because of the Civil War going there. So I understand what that Arab Saudi is talking about. ?

Haha don’t want to leave their land, that’s hilarious. They’ve been blocking refugees for decades. Don’t want to leave their land, that’s rich.

As for the land, all land west of the Jordan River belongs to Israel. If there are muslims (NIMAs) who don't want to become loyal Israeli citizens then they have to get the fork off of Israel's land.

Nobody wants Palestine, historically Jordan and Egypt have tried to help and then thrown them out unceremoniously... I wish Iran would take them! What lands tell me what are the Palestinian lands? Israel has bent over backwards in the last 30 years to help and Palestinians' have done nothing but resist in helping themselves. 20 % of Israel are Muslim... They love Israel.

If they want to leave there in Palestine they should start behaving like people and learn to live with their neighbors ( Jews, whose actual land it’s theirs) so, Palestinians should be grateful the Jews are letting them live on their lands!

They want to be on their own land and not on anyone else's land. World needs to except this.

Some countries want to Palestinian to leave their land. \nWhy should Palestinian leave their lands?

Also please do consider Oman. It’s a beautiful truly Islamic country. The Omani Arabs are most respectful and calm people. I loved living there. \nYou can drive and visit dubai in 4 hours. Believe me you don’t want to live there. It’s like Disney land. Visit have loads of fun then return home to wonderful Oman. If you work there as an expat you are provided lovely accommodation, tax free income and a tickets to your home country every year during your month off. \nIt’s super clean and many US, Canadian, European expats extend their contracts to stay longer because of the luxurious lifestyle.

I want to share my experience , me my husband and my 14 month old daughter landed in Canada Calgary on 28 June 2023, we stay for 2 weeks with our friends and start searching for apartment. Once we moved to our apartment we started looking for jobs, in the month of aug we both got a job I am working as deployment engineer and my husband is working as product owner, and a daycare for my daughter. We worked hard in searching jobs all day all night, and with the grace of god we got it. The life is tough every where, it is just the way you think of it. We left our well settle jobs in India before moving here, but yes with full determination. I want to encourage people here not to loose hope prepare a plan for your self and stick to it, you will eventually get it. All the best to all the new comers and those are planning ?❤

The Book of Amos (Bible) historically documented the people of Gaza committed a traitorous atrocity that incurred God's wrath that they lost their land against to many nations, like to Ethiopia for example in B.C. era (before Christ was born). These facts are also documented in history. So the Palestinian claim that that is their land is a big LIE to begin with. The Book of Amos should bring chills down your spine. Cause it is accurate in its prophecy. God wanted the people of Gaza to be obliterated because of what their ancestors did. If you'll research their history and culture, you'll learn that they worshipped Baal, which is a demon. They even sacrificed babies to their false gods. So its a no brainer that Gaza is destroyed right now after the barbaric atrocities they comitted on Oct. 7, 2023 against Israel. Beheadings, raping women hostages, burning Jewish babies alive would enrage God. So none of the world is surprised when Gaza was decimated after the discovery of Palestinian terror tunnels and the Palestinian hospitals,schools, mosques, residential buildings being used as hostages hideouts. Gaza keeps losing their war over and over even today, coz they never followed God's will. Bottomline, God's will be done.

What a moronic question! Why would other countries take the Palestinians in when they have their own land and don’t want to leave it?!! The problem is that Israel wants to grab Palestinian land to build more illegal settlements on it and with the added bonus of stealing Palestinian gas in the Mediterranean. Is this reporter clueless or just biased towards Israel?

What a dump answer....\nIts funny because what he rwally say and they people here dont get it is that the Arab world does not want them nor to support them by bringing them to their land. They want the issue to remain in the backyard.

Because you want Islam to take over land and push others out not retreat that’s why you help them into europe ?!!!

They should be sent back to country of origin if they don't want to follow the rules of the land

The sahabis burned the boats and came to the lands of the non-believers to give dawah, and you guys use the companions as a scapegoat. Just say you want to leave and don't use the blood and adversities of the saahbis for your gain.

There are no Palestinian refugees anywhere for a reason because we dont wanna leave our land no matter what and we dont want anyone to take us in because we are not going anywhere i know its kinda hard for people to understand how we dont want to leave with everything thats going on in Palistine but we are not letting go of our mother land

The Palestinians will leave their homeland to other Arab or European countries they want to be free from occupation by Israel since 1948 with the assistance of British and foreign governments who sent the Israeli to the land of palastian... \nIt is time to Palestinians to be free as other nations in the world. .\nIs it sin to the people of Palestine to be free after brutal offensive suffering by inhuman Israel for more than 75 years of violence crimes .

Says the same people who want to take the Israelis out of THEIR land. Extremely hypocritical

This is the appropriate comeback, to this lady question. Instead of running from others people across this earth to America and other countries why not go and help their home lands become better. Question: if thousands.of emigrants are running to America, how will the leardership in these countries keep a job.? Why not be better leardership so your people would want to stay in their homeland. The common masses is missing some type of scheme that's allowing this behavior. Many society don't allow this behavior.why not use the millions of dollars to established and build instead of using the Millions to destroy people homeland by invaders. This is what America did once in it's ugliest history. Keep going forward America, don't go backward, because someone tells you to. Man plans, G-d Plans, but G-d is the Best of Planners. PEACE

If they want to live in their land \nWhy can’t they want to live without first attacking

Wow, what a nice way to say that they don’t want anything to do with Palestinian refugees, just like any other arab country doesn’t. The premise that they have the right to their land doesn’t mean that some of them wouldn’t want to leave yet literally every arab state denies them that possibility. Gee, I wonder why.

Making refugees of the Palestine people IS NOT THE ANSWER. The Palestinians DO NOT want to leave their homes and land. What don’t these journalist get when constantly asking this line of questioning?

I hope the grass is greener wherever you decide to land (unfortunately I somehow doubt it...your next destination will have inherent challenges of its own). I would also forewarn you that you can't simply emigrate anywhere you want. Most countries have highly restrictive immigration policies (Canada is very much an outlier on this). And very few countries fully respect human rights, including freedom of expression (especially for women). Be careful what you wish for (even if I agree with a couple of your criticisms). Best of luck

Well said it is there land and want to live on the same way as anyone else wants to live

The west want the Arab world to take the people of Palestine just give Isreal and his friends the land.

They dont want to take the risk that the terrorist will flood there lands

Is Gaza their land and by war looses it is it still their land? Strange how they and Egypt do not want to take Palestinians under their care .. why?????

Their land? The problem is people think they own land so this is a perpetual excuse for conduct. Only Kings care about the land of a country. Citizens just want to live in peace upon the land. Kings are into owning things kind sir.

To simplify things, the arab world don't want to let the radicals stay in their lands.

Same with jews they also want their land back.

1st - there is no more blockade. The moment israel has managed to create sufficient infrastructure to i spect incoming aid trucks (to make sure they are not smuggling weapons in) than there is zero blockade.\nThe bottleneck is from UN countries that can't or won't send enough aid.\n\n2nd. The palestinians already had their own land. In Gaza. They had their own Hamas government and policies and rules. \nThe problem is that they have been waging on-and-off war against a neighbouring country since 2007 with the goal to exterminate that other country, and now they went too far and lost. \n\nThis is the consequence of waging war on a far stronger coubtry - you lose and get effed.\n\nAnd most of their resident want this war to continue (according to polls. I didnt ask them all myself) so the fate of whatever coubtry they want to have again will be the same.\n\nThe problem is with the Gazan mentality that leads to their govermental mentality , which is all-or-nothing. No pragmatic solution and no desire to co-exist. \nTheir refugee status is their fault and the aolution is to slowly replace the mentality. Since can not be done by them alone. The same way that nazi germany had to have external aid by the UN to replace the nazi part of their mentality.

Realize how he said the Palestinians don't want to leave their land of dignity and he never mentioned anything about soverign territory ?\nAlso he wants more humanitarian aid to gaza strip? Sure I was thinking if donating 100 dollars to them but like it will just end up into corrupted hamas leaders' pockets who do not care about their people so ?

I have lived in many different countries as a Muslim. I have found the perfect balance of Islam, freedom in my day to day life to do things, finding halal, masjids 10-15mins within where I live with programs for my kids and social/educational events. I homeschool my kids and the laws for it are very easy. I absolutely abhor the government though and your no. 1 reason would be mine to leave. However as I explore other options I don’t see options for Muslim country that is easy to naturalize into. \n\nI have joined groups to make future changes through congress and government and trying to learn how I can help with these efforts. I try to imagine what would happen if all the Muslims left these colonizing countries. Boy do they need us yet make us feel like we are powerless. I try to imagine well what if we unified more and kept working for change? While being able to live and practice e Islam how we want. Anyways. Just mumbling some of my own thoughts. I wish you guys the best though and make istikara prayer. Wherever you land may you find baraka there for your life.\n\nAlso surprise: I live in USA Florida.

The problem is that the Palestinians not only want their land, they also want the Israelis land. When in actual fact all the land in question belongs to the Jews.

But they are living on their land. They however want Israel's land and that's not on.

That would be like Poland not taking Ukrainian refugees because Russia shouldn’t be forcing them of their land.\n\nThey don’t take in Palestinian refugees because they don’t want them in their country.\n\nFact is they could be taking in thousands of people temporarily and saving a lot of lives. But for some reason no one seems to want to take them in?

As a PROUD Mi'kmaq Metis Canadian....You made your voice ON STOLEN LAND, you want special treatments the indigenous Canadians don't even have....you want to ? off about stolen land half way around the world YET oblivious to the fact YOU ARE ON STOLEN LAND....yikes. enjoy, don't let the door hit you on the way out. I seen on twitter thousands of Canadians willing to drive you to the airport. Maybe one day you'll recognize how narcissistic your complaints true are ?

But they want the Israeli land\nThe Israelis don’t want to leave their land.\nSo let Palestinians be refugees:)

Im not against it. We may need the numbers soon. They come here for more than just the narrative. Its alot for the states to take on currently cant say it isnt. Things become more hyped in everyway..it almost seems like were bound for another war close to home if not just home.. Theyre leavibg for a reason. I ca only guess that they dnt want t be there. We have a good portion of state side troops home and ready. But if mexico cant protect whats theirs, i dont think they should have it. My arguement being..we the mf people will need the land. Hater gunna hate, u ca suck it up when this gets pushed in to fluition. I didnt want it. I just saw this shit coming.

Well said! The land belongs to the Palestinians and they want to stay there. They have the right to live there in peace and without oppression from the Israelis!

let them in..since is the stolen land belong to no one...we Native Amerika we want them...is our land...let them inn

He avoided to answer the point of the question. Period. Whether diplomatic or not. \nPalestinians don’t want to leave and shouldn’t, idealistically talking. But the fact is that the same happened for any other group that has been displaced in f____g history from any place they used to live, including jewish people in that piece of land before it was Palestina.\n\nUkrainians, Syria, any of these conflicts in Africa…examples are abundant in the last 30-40 years not to talk about jewish in the 1930-40s. Or do we want to ignore that Arabs made deals with Adolph Hitler to continue exterminating jews???\n\nHe doesn’t want to answer because he is bot interested in receiving any Palestinian in his country, nor any other Arab country. They learned what happened to Jordan, Egypt, Lebanon, etc. Even Egypt said they were willing to sacrifice millions to protect the border to avoid having Palestinian refugees…

Long..long.. long question, what's a question !\nThe Palestinians do not want to leave their lands, understand ?

Exactly no one want leave their land . We kurds can die every day for getting back our land so i can understand how land is so dear to them it is like their honor

If a country opens its borders to Palestinian refugees, they facilitate Israel’s objective of flattering Gaza and ethically cleansing the land to allow for further expansion and illegal settlement. Israel want to get rid of Palestine and all its people, chasing them out and killing those who are too slow. By standing their ground, the Arab world are forcing the west to see what they have supported and see what Israel are doing and encouraging them to change and to act and to stop the genocide. But it is also at the expense of tens of thousands of lives and an entire nations facilities. The Arab world are letting the bodies pile high until the west can't look away any more. I understand both sides of this and dislike both options, letting Palestinians die, and letting Israel take Gaza by accepting refugees. I can't say I support Saudi Arabias actions, but I also would feel the same if they opened their doors to refugees. Neither one are the right solution, and only we westerners can make this stop. And believe me, I am trying to do my part. I have signed. I have shared. I have donated. I have protested. And I will continue to do so until there is a free Palestine

Tell Israel that the Palestinians' want their stolen land by an agreement to give half of Israel back to them. Then agree to live as neighbors 'Ceasefire' daily to arrange by '25. Stop attacking my Middle Eastern Muslims, Christians & Jews that have converted to be our Muslims.

I am surprised he got her agenda right away, she want to remove Palestinians from their home land.

He doesn't want them to lose their land because he doesn't want them on his land. Same can be said about their other Muslim comrades.

The Palestinians DO NOT want to leave their land!

I dont think even Isreal wants to take the land from the palestinians. They're afraid if they leave, they won't return. They're just as culpable for the children dying in this conflict. They could take women with children. People over 50.