Close Reading

True or false. Jordan has been a state for Palestinian people almost 100 years. The Jews were not present in the numbers that exist now. The Palestinian people were not allowed to stay and they were forced to leave. Who was responsible??

Define “their land” it’s Gaza. I don’t think Israel wants Gaza. Israel just wants to protect its citizens, Jews, Arabs, and the people who works there like the Filipinos. Peace. Palestinians must unite t challenge Hamas.

Gaza is their land. An Israeli Arab says, “Take it.” He is saying, Israel does not want Gaza. Israel is for the citizens of Israel and there are Jews and Arabs as citizens of Israel. Hamas took control of Gaza and Hamas started to kill , kidnap, and rapes the citizens of Israel. Gaza is Palestine. Free Palestine from Hamas.

He is a snitch -- pushing aside the responsibility the Arabs shd shoulder.\n\nThey were the reason for the weight.\nRefused to accept the 2 state solution 5 times without consulting the Palestinian Arabs even when Isreal accepted them since 1949 (if not wrong where Isreal only agreed to possess 20% land then) which was refuted by the Arab league and chose to hv the UNRWA instead and left Palestine stateless. Go check it out.\n\nEach time the Arab league states decided for the Palestine people (Arabs, Jews, Christian and orthodox Christian) and not the Palestine people themselves.\n\nWhy not lift the weight by demanding Hamas and the other terror outfits to quit terrorising the Palestinian and Isreal, stop attacking, release the hostages and refrain from forcefully using the people as human shield. \n\nHamas and some Arab states are responsible for these conflict and how cunning of him to turn the tables on others. \n\nHe hd a smirk on his face suggesting he pussyfooted to prevaricate the question to his surprise.\n\nCheers ?

Are we talking about the same Palestinians whose stated goal is the genocide of the Jewish people? I wonder what the Saudi response would be if the Hamas started a campaign of terrorist attacks on the Saudi people for not helping them to kill all the Jews.

The Jews were blessed with that land by God! From the river to the sea!! You are just visiting. You have over stayed ur visit.

Ethnic cleansing of Jews has been going on for a very long time in all Arab states .

Ethnic cleansing of the Jews has been going on in all the Arab states for a long long time .

And they were offered all of that but they refuse accept Jews there to point the want them all gone so here lays the cycle of violence

Palestinians have no land. Judea belongs to the Jews..

Exactly they have the right to their land. How do you attack the hands that fed you huh Jews come on shame.

That reporter doesn’t get it. Why would they help to remove the very population that they left there in the first place in order to weaponize them? Like who’s going to wage their proxy war against the Jews if they help them leave?

What about the Jews? They dont have a right to their land?

Quran 5:20-21 says that the Jews have the right to the Holy Land. So why do the Palestinians keep complaining about occupation ?

What is Palestine? Quran mentions Israel and Jews ?? but no Palestine anywhere (Quran: 2-Al Baqara, verse 47) Prove the Quran wrong ?

Why should another country take Palestinians? The Palestinians have their own land. Just put the jew out of Palestine and the problem would be solved.

70 years old of failed diplomacy by Palestinian. The refusal of accepting a Jewish state and electing a terrorist organization with a charter that declares they will eradicate the Jews and its up to the Jews to lift the weight which is the result of them protecting themselves and their people? Deflecting blame on the people who were attacked because they’re Jewish, thats all it is.

Right but isreal does too and so do jews... contrary to Palestinians beliefs.....

Assalamu alaikum I live in the Island of Trinidad in the West Indies. We have poor political leadership and progress is slow. However, our religious tolerance is second to none. We have hundreds of masaajids and many Sunni islamic institutions. We are happy muslims here living side by side with Hindus and Christians, Jews etc. Our Government is neutral on the Palestinian issue but we are free to demonstrate and march and sign petitions. We do have a crime problem. I do hope you will consider our beautiful country with its warm weather and beautiful beaches. We are also halal food center for the region. Alhamdulillah hearing your plight has helped me to appreciate my country even more. Ameen.

No games,no emotional nonsense, no agenda, just straight to the point \n \nneed to give 80 % land to palestine no need to compromise with usa or jews ...

About the Jews and Christians had the right to the Saudi lands head through the air peninsula if they were there long before the Arabs were

I am a Christian in America so for your last issue I’m opposite from you politically because I believe that my God promised his people (the Jews) that land. With that said, your family is the type of Muslim that would be extremely welcome in America by the Christian community because of your views on LGBT+. There are Muslim YouTubers, have you considered reaching out to some of them like BakemydayMimo? It might be easier if you had someone who had your faith and unique job to introduce you to a new community. Even though I disagree with you on some things, I wish you the best of luck, and if you move to my community in Pennsylvania you will be welcomed (even though it’s still cold)

40 Muslim countries around israel area and they won’t help. They don’t care about the Palestinian people at all, they are just using them because they hate the Jews.

When he say, “their land”, what is he talking about? Gaza? Because, their land in the Palestinian eyes is from the river to the sea. So while this may seem like a simple reply, it answers little to the question of the overall problem. They wanting the complete genocide of the Jews.

Palestinians have a right to their land and they have a right to live in safety and security and dignity on those lands.......\nWhat about the Jews? They have the same rights but nobody wants to talk about that. They were persecuted out of their homeland and hunted throughout most of the world. Israel was the land of Jews and it was taken from them by force.

what about jews? they even have their own police and jews only hospitals.

If there is one group of people that has not taken responsibility for this situation it is the countries of Egypt, Jordan, Syria and the rest of the Arab world. They ejected 1m Jews from their lands but did not take in the resulting 600k Palestinians from their war of conquest. Both '48 and '67 were Arab wars of conquest that they lost.

The Jews didn’t want to leave their land that they were kicked out of all throughout the Middle East. And they are still not allowed there. The double standards is crazy.

No blockade until the intifada. And look at the tunnels they built. No Jews in Gaza since 2006. What has their government done besides killing Israeli civilians.

The Palestinian people have been used by all of the other Muslim countries in the world since the 1940s to be a proxy Force so they can attack Jews and Christians in claim that it wasn't them.

As an Australian I agree with this. Why should the Arab world help the Jews remove the Palestinians? Anyone that wants the Palestinians to leave Palestine just wants to give Israelis exactly what they want. Why not just come out and say you want Palestinians genocided or completely removed so that Israel can steal the rest of the land?

All the people of the world and all Mohammeddens get food water clothes houses, education etc and live due to the modern scientific inventions which are all by Christians and Jews. No invention by any Mohammedden. What does it prove?

But he still didn't answer the question basically he's saying they don't want them and just let them keep terrorizing the jews and everything will be okay. that's basically what this Arab leader is telling you?.

Their agenda is to use the Palestinians to destroy the Jews...the same as Hamas..they care not for the Palestinians.

Yes stopping war and aid for suffering people is necessary .very true.\n*But at least why can't yu take few* vulnerable population inside,there are so many middle east countries and the **rest people staying can safeguard their land \n*Why yu cant yu stand against hammas like yu stand against Israel.\n*Jews and judiasm existed right before 70 BC ,they are the origin of Palestine right from beginning and they were named as Palestine by Romans empire .although many Jews who migrated out during Roman empire ,came back during British rule ,there were Jews right there from beginning in Palestine and Jews are ancestors to Christians which originated * 1 st century and ** Islam which originated 7 th century .we need to accept first both ISRAEL AND PALESTINE has the right to exist.only peace can bring this on either sides.All cultures ,all religions have Their \nRights.

when the muslims lost their genocidal war against jews they lost the land. that's how wars work. maybe next time they shouldn't side with hitler

Looks like both jews and Arabs believe it is each their own land. Looks like this will lead to biblical\nConfrontations.

So do the Jews

So, they do not want to be where they are, or they are happy to be where they are? \n\nBecause they say they are imprisoned and oppressed (honestly, they’re two feet of foreign land away from being indistinguishable from the Jews they massacred). \n\nImprisoned and in a foreign land, the plight of the Palestinians will be to spend the next thousand years until they reconquer the land of their ancestors: the dark side of the moon. ?

Hamas are bad terrorists. Gaza is part of The Jewish land promissed By God to the Jews

Everything would be better if the Arab world did take them in, it’s called a partition and all the Jews left the Arab countries in the 1950’s, but the Arabs won’t leave the one Jewish country.

The Jews have a right to their land too. ??

Why don’t the US unite and take the Jews in?

One more thing.. anybody remember what happened in 1948 when Israel claimed its independence after failed negotiations and the arabs denouncing a two state solution (as they've done multiple time later)? Who remembers the nearly half a million jews that were thrown out or numerous arab countries? Where is the UN organisation for them and their right to claim back their stolen property? These arab countries should be called to compensate and take the jews back, that would only be par for the course right?

It sickens me that the narrative by white and black politicians that are on apaics payroll is that the. Arab world does not want the bad Palestinians on their land when in-fact that dehumanizing rhetoric should always be met with Israel and Jews should stop trying to steal their lands a free Palestine is the only way !

They forget they forced all the Jews out of their lands, taking their homes ,land and business's thus forcing them to go to the only place they could find safety-Israel. Most of the so-called Palestinians were brought in by the Turks from other countries and them the British to work for them.

Why don't the United States take all the jews. Israel runs the U.S already

A person could say the wrong thing in the most articulate way. We must look into his statements that the people are unable to live in peace. What policies does Hamas have for the region. Who is UNRAW and what policies do they have for the region. To blame the Jews is the easy way out but doesn’t solve the problem. There needs to be a framework for a peaceful society so that yes regular citizens can live in peace. This needs to happen not just in Gaza but the entire world as we are seeing now. A quick google search of the 7 noachide laws will reveal why God demands obedience and peace

Palestinians are not refugees! Jews are the refugees! US should provide them asylum!!

Then they need to stop killing Jew and everyone else ? there was Russians Asians Americans french Canadians all killed there by Palestinians