Close Reading

This saddens me - Fellow Canadians are wanting to leave their home land because politicians have made it impossible for us to live here. \n\nI very much agree with you and with most of the reasons why you're leaving. I wish you the best in finding your new home and hope you know you will always be welcomed back to Canada with open arms.

Well said, they only want the Palestinians to leave so Israel can take their land. Give the people back their land simple simone.

Jordan is their country originally and the King of Jordan is today scared to death they can come back. Of course, the other Muslim countries do not want Hamas on their lands. They will have then to build a legal state.

Create problems and destabilize other countries expect refugees to surge into yours! \n\nNo immigrant wants to leave their land if theres safety and any level of opportunity in their own homeland to be a second class citizen somewhwre else... unless they have to. The American public doesnt lnow or understand the level of American politics agitating other parts of the world ...starting from Latin America and Palestine.

They just want them out of there land so Israel can take it over and build a canal parallel to the Siam canal mark my words there trying to do that!!!

Why should other countries be responsible for citizens who voted for Hamas. There was celebrations around the world by Palestinians, for the disgraceful attacks on the Jewish population in Israel. They want sympathy and understanding from the world, but I shall never forget their chants and behaviours, even before Israel retaliated. Countries who have taken these people in, have altered the fabric of their societies. You can try all you want in the UK, but our citizens will vote out Sunak the spineless fingers crossed they get rid of Sadiq Khan who is the racist major of London. It’s called a democracy. We may have to wait for Labour to run its election course, but Reform UK is the party who puts its citizens before those who abuse the migration process and those who chant against countries that have been good enough and have taken them in. There will be a time, in the future when racism gets called out, tougher legislation comes into effect. You have no value, then you will have to leave, by law of the land, not the law of your religion.

He says the Palestinians don't want to leave their land but the people clamoring at the Rafah border crossing would say otherwise. The tanks and troops that Egypt has mobilized at the border is evidence that Palestinians do at least temporarily want to leave their land for the safety of the Sinai desert. But Egypt is scared of the terrorists among just like the rest of the Arab world is.

Beautiful answer. She us trying to embarrass the Arab world for not taking them so zionists can keep the land. You know they want more land for their greater Israel.

Really good answer indeed, because the whole whole should be responsible for peace in every corner of the world. However, he smartly ignored the fact that Palestine claims are based on muslim ideology, and hence muslim nations do need to take a larger part of the share in this burden. Obviously, no one wants to leave their land, but no one wants terrorists to win as well.

The arab world dont care about fellow muslim refuges, they know that the west is dumb enough to take them in, if saudi arabia wanted, they could do alot of good for the refuges, but they wont, so they got blood on their hands.\nSaudi arabia got 2m tents with aircondition doing nothing, no one is saying the palestinians dont have a right to be on their land, but while bombs are falling, maybe they should help out of that situation

He speaks like this in public, but behind-the-scenes they’re all pro Israel. The Palestinians lose their right to the land when they behave like savages, and think Israel doesn’t have legitimacy to their own country. If the Palestinians wanted peace, there would be peace.

In other words 'we don't want them in KSA they should have their own land...'

They want to genocide the Palestinians to take their land and steal the gas fields.\n\nOh, you didn't know about the gas fields, did you?

The Jews have a right to their land which is Israel. Refugees fleeing their country can always go back to help rebuild their country when it is safe to do so. The truth is no Arab country wants to take in Palestinians.

The Jews have a right to their land which is Israel. Refugees fleeing their country can always go back to help rebuild their country when it is safe to do so. The truth is no Arab country wants to take in Palestinians.

Um Jordan is their land. But Jordan doesn't want them. Why does Egypt have a blocade, cause they don't want them either- scared of the terrorists among them.

Israeli wants Gaza population gone so it can take over the land of Gaza

No one wants Hamas coming to their land

If Palestinians don't want to leave their land why there are millions of Palestinians in USA, Canada, Australia, Europe, etc?

Define “their land” it’s Gaza. I don’t think Israel wants Gaza. Israel just wants to protect its citizens, Jews, Arabs, and the people who works there like the Filipinos. Peace. Palestinians must unite t challenge Hamas.

Gaza is their land. An Israeli Arab says, “Take it.” He is saying, Israel does not want Gaza. Israel is for the citizens of Israel and there are Jews and Arabs as citizens of Israel. Hamas took control of Gaza and Hamas started to kill , kidnap, and rapes the citizens of Israel. Gaza is Palestine. Free Palestine from Hamas.

He said Palestinians don't want to leave their land, how many Palestinians took Europe citizenship US citizenship \nIsrael is doing the right thing

Palestinians who don't want to leave their land should not allow Hamas to control their land either then. If their land is so sacred, why does Hamas get to launch terror attacks from their land?

That was a bs answer, What's the difference between the Ukraine war and Israeli and the palestine war? Did the ukrainian not have a claim to there land ?\nDid the the Ukrainian want to leave no, but it doesn't stop the European country to help a little bit, just by taking some of there people in.

No one has the right to property, has the right to land. That's determined by military strength, by brute force, from the smallest tribe to largest imperial nation. Feeling bad for someone who wants what they feel like is theirs is propaganda, in hopes others will join to overpower the military defenses. That's not what I believe, that's how this world operates and will continue to operate.

What isarel want his for arabs to take Palestinians so they can take the land

Not even the Arabs want them.. don't blame them.. and by the way it's not their land.. God gave it to Isreal thru Moses.

Exactly. This false narrative of the Arabs not wanting them is stupid. That’s those people land and the Jewish government is trying to steal it.The Palestinians have every right to stay in their own country

She wants the land without the people, in other words ethnic cleansing. This was the agenda from day one until today.

Arabs/muslims always state Palestinians ahve a right to their land...but never that Israelis do. Isreal has attempted to collaborate in assisting Palestine in becoming a state and having offically recognised territory. But in the view of all muslims they do not want isreal to exist there. The arabs use Palestinians as canon fodder for their puppeteering

I think your reading of the situation is slight from the wrong end of scope. \n\n1> the job of the Canadian gov is to look after Canadians. (Yes they allow immigrants but that is for the benefit of Canadians and not the other way around. \n\nThe house prices are intentionally kept high. The reason is because it makes existing citizens richer. (Year on year) these people vote and the gov would like their vote) . Creating huge supply of housing is going to crash the market and that will end up people feeling poor. (Values will drop : demand and supply) . Falling values mean people will feel poor and then less likely to vote for the current administration.\n\nI am based in UK which is experiencing record amount of immigration. \n\nTaxes here are high.(I don’t mind high taxes as long as there are good public services to show for them) \n\nGood roads \nHigh speed internet \nGood infrastructure \nHospitals \n\nSo the job of the gov (in western hemisphere) generally is to keep the voting public happy. \n\nThat involves \n\n1>Good public services (most are social states and people accept high taxation as a trade off for good public services) \n\n2> rising house prices. (Voting public wants to feel richer and owning your home is like your retirement and pension pot. Most of the wealth in uk is stored in property. (I guess same in Canada to some extent ) \n\n3> control of immigration. People want immigration but want good immigration l. People who will come and contribute to society. Too much of it can be an issue for existing citizens and also immigrants themselves selves.\n\n\nOn a separate note. People deciding where to settle always remember. Long term the proximity to the world matters . Europe is still the centre of the world. Cross east to Asia and west to Canada and USA etc. living in Canada (west coast specially is like the edge of the world just like living in NZ ) \n\nPopulation matters. \nThe Canadian population and Australian population is less than of Uk (as far as I know ) and the land mass is huge. It is not a big market compared to some of the countries compared to Europe. \n\nMore people = more demand = more big companies want to compete =lower prices for consumers and less inflation .\n\nJust some thoughts on this last day of 2023z happy new years all .

As someone who moved Canada 3.5 years ago, I agree with all the reasons mentioned. There are many things government could have done better to fight against the inflation, housing crisis, high cost of living and rise in crime and homelessness. I don't even want to mention about the taxes. Like I am almost giving half of my salary to the government yet they are still taking %13 more on what we spend on, yet I've never seen a single place where that money was used to address any of these problems. One of the reasons I moved to Canada was to have a better life style, more buying power and better future for my future kids. But at this point I feel like I am living in a zombie land. High skilled workers will have some other opportunities elsewhere but refugees and low skilled workers will be stuck in Canada and it will get only worse with the current policies.

Islam came hundreds of years AFTER Christianity and Judaism. It is NOT Palestinian land and the truth is Arabs don't want Hamas terrorists moving in.

They want to go back to thei land

If the palistinians dont want to leave there land then why do they fight for it if Israel is not going to stop. The Ukrainians are fighting for there land and leaving other countries to fifht agenst russia thennwhy dont the palistinians.

When he say, “their land”, what is he talking about? Gaza? Because, their land in the Palestinian eyes is from the river to the sea. So while this may seem like a simple reply, it answers little to the question of the overall problem. They wanting the complete genocide of the Jews.

Palestinians have a right to their land and they have a right to live in safety and security and dignity on those lands.......\nWhat about the Jews? They have the same rights but nobody wants to talk about that. They were persecuted out of their homeland and hunted throughout most of the world. Israel was the land of Jews and it was taken from them by force.

why is western world always concern about why arab world doesnt want to take the palestinians as refugees? its their home their land, they are the one who have the right to live there as a citizen not as a refugee, and their resistance movement will protect their dignity

Where are all of the Confederates, KKK, Southern ??‍???‍? Supremest, that’s always saying Texas is the South & it’s going to “rise again” ?? Why aren’t you protecting your border?? And Arizona was a confederate State too that joined the war to team up with the South, Tucson, Arizona to be exact. We’re sitting back eating popcorn ? wondering what are you guys going to do besides getting on your knees blowing Joe Biden crying for help? Because it looks like the “Migrants” want their land back ??? so who cares

If they want Sharia, deport them to their own land.

The Jews didn’t want to leave their land that they were kicked out of all throughout the Middle East. And they are still not allowed there. The double standards is crazy.

As an Australian I agree with this. Why should the Arab world help the Jews remove the Palestinians? Anyone that wants the Palestinians to leave Palestine just wants to give Israelis exactly what they want. Why not just come out and say you want Palestinians genocided or completely removed so that Israel can steal the rest of the land?

I think we all know Israel ?? does not want to live there land too. So it is best to promote peace and not pick sides. The Lord Jesus Christ said love your neighbours and who are our neighbours the people who are of different faith from us and neighbours are also our enemies. So we can't false Israel ?? and Palestine to leave there land but let's pray for them to live in harmony.

Ma'sha'Allah may Allah make the move easy and beneficial for you. I am black born to Rastafatian parents in the UK. Since i was a child my parents have wanted to repatriate (move to an Afican land). I'm now Muslim Alhamdulillah and I really want to make Hijra with my children. Possible to a African Muslim country (Gambia maybe) but i hear Malaysia is lovely also. It's definitely beneficial be among the ummah

Not a fan of the Saudis but you simply can’t argue with what he’s saying. The entire reason there’s a narrative around the Arab world taking refugees is so Israel gets to ethnically cleanse the land like they want. Israel shouldn’t be getting anything out of this

Where did you get the idea that the Palestinians want you to displace them according to your will, the man explained, they don't want to go anywhere, they want their lives and their land

I wish you the best ?\nWe, (me my husband and my 7 years old girl) live in the UK Kent county BUT for the last year I stayed to think about moving. We are originally from Bulgaria but Turks and came to UK 10 years ago, we just bought our house 3 years ago, basically created everything from scratch. It is bot an easy task to start from the beginning again but I believe that if Allah maid to think about moving that means He will help you.\nAs a hijabi muslim woman in a community that there are not other Muslims around I can say I feel relatively safe BUT some days I notice the look of hatred in n some peoples eyes. The other thing my girl started to question some topics they have been receiving at school and it is a constant battle for me to keep explaining to her the right and wrong. More over she is listening for now but not sure for future and this scares me.\nAs you said praying and being a practicing Muslim is difficult here as well. We are Turks but do not have Turkish nationality but when we go for religious holidays in Istanbul I feel completely different, it just feels like I have to live there near the mosque. My inner me begging me when we are in Istanbul in the old part of the city to stay there forever. \nI really know what you feel and want. I am looking for Muslim countries where possible we can move BUT unfortunately I made the conclusion that there is not a place even in a Muslim land that we can live the way of peaceful practicing and being a Muslim what we want to be. \nJust advise be careful with the Arab world, other than that if you look at Türkiye I would say do your research really well, not in every town there you can live your religion. Azerbaijan is excellent I would say but they are still under the influence of Russia. \nSo really difficult decision, may Allah guide you. Amin

May Allah Subhaanahu Wa Taala protect you guys, may He make this hijra easy for you, may He grant you what you seek, may He make you and your chilren from the ones He loves, Aameen! I am from Pakistan and can't ever imagine leaving my country to go live in foreign lands. Alhamdullilah, I feel very safe here. It is a Muslim country, alhamdullilah, although there is a major class of citizen coming up here who'd like it to be more 'open minded' like the West. May Allah protect us from that day. I would suggest that you move to Saudi Arabia, preferably into or around Makkah or Madinah. I believe that these two are the best cities in the world for Muslims. Imagine saying your five daily prayers in Masjid-e-Haraam or Masjid-e-Nabawi! You kids could study there and grow up speaking and understanding Arabic like Arabs. Imagine the understanding and appreciation they'd have of the Quran and Hadith moreover, they'd be able to reap benefits from the work of all major scholars. InshaaAllah. BUT, on the other hand, you guys are Allah's workers there in Canada. You could do dawah, spread Allah's word (you're doing that beautifully already). You'd be doing what the messengers of Allah did. Think of it this way, if you leave, there'll be one less family supporting Palestine and the Islamic way of life in Canada. Maybe, Allah wants someone like you to represent Him there. Allahu Aalam. There's this beautiful piece of Urdu poetry by Syed Sadiq Hussain, it goes something like this ' Tundi-e-baad-e mukhalif se na ghabraa ae uqaab --- Yeh to chalti hai tujhay ooncha uranay ke liye!' translation:- Do not fear the strength of the head-winds (opposing wind) O' eagle -- it but blows only to help you soar higher! All I'm saying is that there's another way of looking at your dilemma. You guys are like a small, bright light in a dark night and can help lost travelers reach safety. Cheesy, I know. Do Istikhara, let Allah give you His suggestion. Follow it and you can never go wrong innshaaAllah. What ever you decide, our dua'a are with you, uhhibukum fi'llah. Wassalam Wa Rahmah!!

Just as Isreal does. It is Isreals land. Isreal offered to share but Arabs want NO ISREAL!

Im American and sad to say i hate being american i hate being a westerner for the fact america has gotten horrible with high crimes , drugs our Government is corrupted our judicical system is terrible and america took Jesus out of schools , the public plus they encouraged the Lgbtq groups doing book readings , teaching our children to become transgender and i want to move out of america i want to move to Africa to the mother land i always wanted to live were jesus actually walked and taught the gospel..❤