Close Reading

Then why Palestine people moving to western countries. Canada, Europe and Australia should stop talking Palestine refugees

Poor lady at least Indians are decent but you are getting all kind of refugees who might want to convert you

Why they should leave their country and go as refugees?

Does the same yard stick apply to the one million Ukraine refugees. Guess not.

He knew what happened to lebanon now coz it accepted refugees fr 6d war in 1967 in which arab worlds fought together and against Israrl and lost .lebanon used to be christian country bf 1970 now under control of hezbullah coz of accepting refugeees fr palestine

The Arab world accepting the refugees is Israel's strategic goal

Why don't they allow the Palestinians that want to leave out ? They're trapped in there while Israel is taking their land . Yes it is true there's some that might not want to leave. But the ones that do can't get out of there . Egypt won't open the border to the ones that want to leave . Yes they're all so right . All these Arab countries especially the ones that have money ?. They're not taking in any Palestinian refugees they don't want them in their country .

So no Arab countries wont take Palestinian refugees

Dear Hind Hassan why I never seen any of your videos on topics like criminality in Europe caused by immigrants? Drugs, rapes, religion based assaults, homophobic or xenophobic attacks, violence and sexism against females?! Hm ? You always just advocates for this poor immigrants who try to flee war zones!! Where in the heck is war in Afghanistan now? Isn’t status of war refugee obtained by the law that they can apply for asylum in first safe country? If they doesn’t do ir then they are not refugees, they are economic migrants and therefore without right to demand the entry to Europe!! Me as well as European citizen if I want to go out of EU and we have no free visa policy with that country I need to apply for Visa, I do not go simply to the border with that country and requesting the entry out of nowhere!! There are certain legal procedures what applies even to us westerners and we need to follow them as well!!!

Oh, I agree that Saudia Arabia should not be taking in refugees.

This takes no consideration of the fact that Hamas is using the Palestinians as human shields and will continue to do so. He just doesn’t want his day to be disrupted with a bunch of refugees. This is a way of deflecting, while eloquently spoken, it explains why the Palestinians have been left to fend for themselves.

The biggest mistake in colonizing Palestine is that you are fighting against the Palestinians.\nIts in Arab folklore that there are no people on this face of the earth that are as tied to their land as the Palestinians.\n\nThey tend to it, they farm its olives and oil, and they live or die by it. This is not a simple refugee problem, these people are tied mentally and physically to their land.

They just don't want to take any refugees.

Why didn’t they take Syria refugees?

Very oloquently said... Isreal would love for the Arab world to just open its borders and take the millions of Palestinian refugees so they can expell then from their land.... They tried to do that with Egypt and Egypt was not buying what isreal was selling.... The SAUDI FM is absolutely right in what he said...

This so call reporter or journalist is asking a very stupid question, is she ignorant or purposely asking the Arab world to take Palestinian refugees so that Israel can takeover and occupy the the Palestinian land? She should be ashamed of herself!!!

They don't want to accept Palestinians refugees we understand ??

This is how the west are twisting & distorting the arguments of war. It's not that the Arabs need to take refugees, it's tell americans that need to stop the war. No war no refugees.

Pfft. What a rubbish answer. They refuse to accept refugees, just like virtually every other Arab state, because Hamas is also considered a terrorist organisation by Saudi Arabia, and 70% of Palestinians support Hamas.

Arab countries denied citizenship to Palestinians even if they are born in other Arab country because they want to keep them as permanent refugees for political issues

She keeps trying to make europe responsible but they don't have any obligation to the refugees.

It’s true; they take no refugees but they always try and complain refuge in western countries… they don’t even help their own so called brothers.

Except the Arab world is not the one sending aid into Gaza. Not the one taking refugees. Help coming from the west, the same west they hate so much.

And what about the forced refugees that were told to leave the area while they attempted to delete Israel? It has been like 50 years, and those people still live in refugee camps, and those Arab countries have not bothered to give them any protection within their lands.

Simply , if Saudi takes refugees, they would attempt to overthrow the monarchy in Saudi (proven in Jordan)

In another words he said no refugees in his country no one wants the Palestinians why how come no Arab countries are willing to help these people what’s the real reason behind this

He’s smart, the kingdom of Jordan was very pro Palestinian and accepted a ton of refugees from Palestine after his real warfare independence, but in 1951 a Palestinian assassinated king Abdullah the 1st\n\n\nEgypt doesn’t want anything to do with the Palestinians because the Palestinians are the ones who started the Muslim brotherhood which the Egyptians view as a terrorist organization\n\nThe Palestinians don’t have a good reputation in the region

So they are not going take refugees?

?Why world says it started on October7? It started 75 years back. Hamaz resistance group was born in “refugee camps” just in 1988 after tolerating oppression & occupation for 48 years. Israel supported hamaz to create internal fights & suppress freedom resistance just like CIA created Taliban to fight Russia. Why Palestinians living in refugee camp in their own country long before hamas born? Why killing Palestinians & demolishing their houses in West Bank where there is no hamaz? When u treat other humans as animals for decades, one day they will revolt as animals, that’s hamas did (though I condemn any violence). \n\nAnd why is it called war not genocide? War shud be between states that have its own military, missiles, bombs. But here Palestine state’s existence itself is denied, they can’t even have airport, water & electricity facilities, their daily movement is controlled by Israel checkpoints, Zionist settlers burn olives ? & snatch homes of Palestinians daily. Isn’t it hypocritical to claim to support 2 state solution when only 1 state is recognised by supplying genocidal weapon and other is occupied?\n\nIf you love Zionists, give 1 of the state in US. You conducted holocaust & Palestinians pay the price just because they gave shelter when no other country accepted these zionists?\n\nAs per UN charter, armed resistance against occupation is legal, then isn’t Hamas resisting as per same law against illegal occupation by illegal apartheid state? If you don’t like Hamas, world shud take responsibility - end occupation, implement UN & ICJ’s judgement & arrest Netyanahu immediately. Or ICJ/UN is to serve west interest only? Occupation can’t give peace, FREE PLESTINE.

?Why world says it started on October7? It started 75 years back. Hamaz resistance group was born in “refugee camps” just in 1988 after tolerating oppression & occupation for 48 years. Israel supported hamaz to create internal fights & suppress freedom resistance just like CIA created Taliban to fight Russia. Why Palestinians living in refugee camp in their own country long before hamas born? Why killing Palestinians & demolishing their houses in West Bank where there is no hamaz? When u treat other humans as animals for decades, one day they will revolt as animals, that’s hamas did (though I condemn any violence). \n\nAnd why is it called war not genocide? War shud be between states that have its own military, missiles, bombs. But here Palestine state’s existence itself is denied, they can’t even have airport, water & electricity facilities, their daily movement is controlled by Israel checkpoints, Zionist settlers burn olives ? & snatch homes of Palestinians daily. Isn’t it hypocritical to claim to support 2 state solution when only 1 state is recognised by supplying genocidal weapon and other is occupied?\n\nIf you love Zionists, give 1 of the state in US. You conducted holocaust & Palestinians pay the price just because they gave shelter when no other country accepted these zionists?\n\nAs per UN charter, armed resistance against occupation is legal, then isn’t Hamas resisting as per same law against illegal occupation by illegal apartheid state? If you don’t like Hamas, world shud take responsibility - end occupation, implement UN & ICJ’s judgement & arrest Netyanahu immediately. Or ICJ/UN is to serve west interest only? Occupation can’t give peace, FREE PLESTINE.

Come on, folks, what B.S. Letting some of the refugees relocate to Arab states is not forgetting the agenda, that Palestinians want to self rule.

Every refugee doesn't want to leave their land and deserve everything he said. So he basically said nothing. If the west said the same about Syria or Syrians it would be seen as imperialist...

The sharp side of the question is sending Palestinians as refugees to other countries as part of evacuating the land so Israel can occupy the vacuum so intelligent journalist ?

Fantastic answer but it's only half true... they don't want to take refugees because you can't take in Palestinians without taking in hamas and Hamas has destabilized every Muslim country that housed them just look at lebenon or Jordan... Israel treats them like crap and hamas sacrifices them for political capital. Literally between A rock and hard place

How is she a refugee ?

Well they do all sort of wrong things especially eve teasing. I saw in my local no frills in Brampton yesterday 4 punjabi looking at girls that work there and making vulgar comments. Poor girls have to tolerate, funnily enough the girls were Indian as well. I think it's vast cultural difference that makes it harder.How do you filter these shit coming into Canada. Also a valid point why government taking refugees. A lot of them come as refugee and they still try to make protests about the politics of their countries. Need a big change in government

why should the west take those people? The west has no obligation to take them. lets stop our government from taking any refugee, especially those from high risk area

I suspect that the more pragmatic reason is that the arab world saw what happened to Lebanon when they let the Palestinians in. Civil war, refugees and Hezbollah and the country has become a mess. Beirut was once called The Paris of the East.

Zionist jornalism, using refugee status as a way of displacement.

Is he not concerned over the refugees reached western countries but not arab countries? He did not answered the question straight but throw it back to the reporter ignoring the fact that he actually not concerned at all or planning to give home to some on dire need.

What she's saying is , would they take the refugees while the war is going on. His answer is NO ! in another way .

Dont make it easy for Israel by gettimg Palestinians to leave their land. No more refugees. It is a scam business _ people movement. Everytime there is a war, no displaced people should have to be housed abroad.

Israel , us and nato free palestinians.they can't go as refugees and leave there land behind.palestinians are also human beings and Palastina is there home and they will defend it with life and blood.

Nobody wants to take palistini refugees ?

where are all muslim countries ?? where is aljazira muslim channel.. who always target non muslim country's and shows negativity all time.. double standard aljazira thay didn't care about those type of muslim refugees... thay are just creat propaganda... \n all muslim country's people must watch this video.. and tell your own country govt...

So no to taking any refugees ?

Europe should learn how they do, stop taking refugees

Why should ANY COUNTRY KEEP ON AND ON TAKING REFUGEES LIKE INDIA DOES.

That is why the reporter is asking the Arab world for help because the weight has not been lifted to the Palestinian refugees. Why is he not answering her question directly?

Palistainian refugees??? Bloody it's their own land. Why would they leave? It's like Russia is invaded America, and many Americans are homeless then we are asking Europian countries why are you not taking Americans to your country.