Close Reading

Now she just said her family been here 20 years and she ok with them being deported ???? glad she not my relatives.

She's right. They've been here for 10, 20, 30 years and still illegal??? C'mon, that's plenty of time to get your papers.

Too late for anything. If they really want to do something than has to stop giving PR to indians chinese next 10 years. Heavy tax on housing to drop inflated house price down atleast 42%. Which will match affordability ratio. Also Canada PR have no value anymore. Also that will make canadian citizenship devalued by nearly 85%. All developed nations are in process to put canada out of e visa entry near future. Thats happened when canada gave every indian chinese islamists PR so easily. And more than 20 millians indian asians granted PR im last 15 years . Devalued country so badly. ????

This protest is a joke! They know what they signed up for before coming to Canada. So,  they should work within the rules and find a way to legally settle (if they can) or leave. \n\n\nHowever, Canadians deserve to know more about this mess which is an outcome of aggressive marketing by Private colleges and the government's greed to get quick cash into the Canadian economy. Here are some clarifications to note:\n\n\n1. In the last six years, 1.5 million international students brought a minimum of $67,500,000,000 direct cash into the Canadian economy. (Assuming a min $40-45000 per student for 2 year diploma, between to $100,000 - 150,000 for undergrad, and around $50,000 for Masters degrees). Usually, international students have to pay most of this money before applying for the study visa. \n\n\n2. These colleges employ Canadians for their day to day operations. From cleaning, maintainance, administration to teaching, each college operates with approx 20-30million budget. So, more students lead to more employment for Canadians who further pay taxes.\n\n\n3. All students start work straightaway, pay taxes, and do not qualify for social security. They do not qualify for any student loans by Canadian govt or banks. So, they generate revenue for Canada through their work and taxes. The thing that govt LOVES.\n\n\n4. These students become new consumers and their expenditure generate revenues for local businesses.\n\n\n5. Most Colleges would not survive without international students. Which is good in the sense that only quality colleges will survive and other hanky panky colleges would shut down. However, such closures will lead to job losses, bankruptcy when the colleges won't be able to afford their expenses.\n\n\nSo, considering these factors it will be an industry collapse. Govt needs to control immigration. They need to introduce intelligent policies. The steps that current govt is currently taking are politically motivated not rational.

Stop it no more new PR for at least 20 years

Wow! Trump has brainwashed these Hispanics. Trump will put Hispanics in camps. They cannot deport all those people so they will be put in camps like what Hitler did. What makes this woman think Steven Miller will not deport her. MAGA is an alt right white Christian cult, if you are not white, able bodied, non Christian you will be brutally suffer. Trump calls Hispanics vermin just like Hitler brainwashed Germans to believe Jews carry disease. Trump has even used that fear mongering. Women will die because of not getting life saving D&Cs from miscarriages. D&C is what abortion is. These extreme zealot evil faux Christians are not pro life when women and children have no longer access to Obgyns. Obgyns are leaving US and med students refuse to become one because too much risk of going to jail for 20 years to save a woman and baby’s life. These MAGA are ignorant and uneducated. Trump loves the ignorant. He uses them and despises them at the sane time. He is a Putin’s friend and has ties to the Russian mafia and KGB going back to the 80’s.

She waited hours? People have waited 10 20 30 40 years without a chance through no fault of their own (brought has a child). Do it the right way? She has no idea what that means

Kya hi perspective banaye bhai...40s aa gaya...baki bache 20 -25 saal....\nमिट्टी ही थी... मिट्टी ही होगी...\nबाकि सब bakchodi hai...\nFokat ka struggle..\nKuch nahi tha...\nNa kuch hoga...\n...kash ache dinosaur ka yug jaldi aa jaye

Token changes. The REAL legal immigration rate last year was 1.2 million -not 500,000, like they claim. Have you seen the staes of our highways and roads? Well, it wasn't like that when we were 20 - 25 million - a golden age in Canada,

Remember 20 years ago, businesses and wealthy, looked the other way because immigrants meant cheap labor without benefits, yet they still paid into social security and other taxes.

They're not angry at you because you support trump, they are angry because you think they should be deported after 20-30yrs of working here, paying taxes, raising their families. It really be your own people ? all skinfolk ain't kinfolk. Let's hope for her sake that she's got on all that trump gear when they start rounding up Latinos and checking paperwork for mass deportation

??????? she's an idiot...I mean they been there' for 20 30 years....house slave vibes

That lady is heartless imagine 20-30 years then to be deported not even thinking of amnesty for her family members wow

You guys all make your jokes but in 20 years when you’re living in India and not Canada you’ll look back and be like wow I know why that old lady was upset now .

WOW, JUST FCUKING WOW. idk which year she came to the US, but it takes years to get here legally bc of our immigration system, which definitely needs to be reformed. She should be ashamed, it's clear she thinks she's above her cousins who have been here for 20 YEARS. This is disturbing.

They've been here 20-30 years. Oh, so Kamala didn't let them in? America acts like you didnt have illegal immigrants prior to 2021.

20 or 30 years? So they are citizens. More media fake news.

We don’t need anymore immigrants. 20% reduction isn’t enough!

Too late???. There were 15 millions indian granted PR and citizenship in last 20 year. Chinese, Indian and other asian mostly own homes and properties in canada. Also they are the major reson behind driving inflation in housing. I know few indians cashing more than million in 5 years by just buying crap house on cheap loan.???? Canadian ( sorry indian chinese canadian??) are paying more than ever for house in canada. Black untaxed money from their home country. Too late for evetything. You can not cancel thier PR and citizenship. They all living levish lifestyle just by getting property on rent. ???? poor idiots canadian and dumb immigration minister and their policy since last 15 year. All put canada toward dark black hole. Canada totally finish in next 10 years.???

Her family have been here for 20 or 30 years illegally because there has been no pathway to become legal. Biden's recent executive order gives them a way, BUT OF COURSE ITS BEEN BLOCKED IN MANY STATES. Requirements include living here for 10 years, paying taxes and no criminal convictions. What would be wrong with that? Lady, those people have been funding your social security with possibility of ever being qualified for it themselves.

C this is what I’m talking about when I say Trump supporters are a bunch of solace puppets. How you can be OK with losing majority of your family as if getting back to this country is the easiest thing much less getting citizenship is beyond me. You still have your green card because getting citizenship in this country takes 15 to 20 years, I don’t understand what kind of flex you think you have why saying you have a green card.S

Ottawa should gave frozen immigration 20 years ago. It should have stopped by referendum in 1980.

Too many from outside moving to Toronto. The next generation has no room to grow. 20,000 living on the st.

This lady should be asked what should be done with the children of those who have been in the US for 20-30 years who were born in the US. How do you deport children to a country they were not born in? Would she be happy about her 2 or 3 year old nieces being separated from their parents? Would she care for them all?

When you said it was goin down 20% I thought that meant 20% of immigrants would be going back.

How can that woman not understand the humanity, the heartache, the struggle and challenges that her family members have faced, and WOULD face even WORSE if they were deported????? 20 years here, building a life, and being sent back???

Indian are leaving because british divide and rule reservation tactics as for lower caste 80%job is reserved and 20% have no option but to migrate usa as being in usa bring huge respect in india , people take them very respectfully....... Hollywood lure most they think usa is lala land and white are most kind-hearted person on earth ,if they find your problem they will help you with billions

Shut er’ down by more like 90% not 20%zzz

My experience has been different. Came at age 48 with family mostly for children future. Initial struggle followed by more than 20 years full time work in a company owned by Canadian but most of us working immigrants from different countries. Had a wonderful experience working as a team. Company grew from 5 including owner to about 30 when I retired. Most of of my contribution was from skills I obtained on the job. The flexibility I got was help to spouse and children. The three of them achieved good outcomes. Taxes are high. I never worried about that as children had professional education with no financial help. Only my steady basic facilities provided as I had steady though lower income than what I had back home in relative terms. What we get back from taxes we pay in health civic facilities education for children is great return of taxes paid. What I got was quality living. No luxuries. My purpose of coming here more than fulfilled. Happy family. Grand children now enjoying higher quality of life than what I had or my own children had. I do notice recent trends of immigrants expectations not very encouraging. I have enjoyed the multicultural atmosphere friendship and regard for each other. My colleagues and I have been of great asset to the company we worked in.

This is Canada In a nutshell someone comes to someone house “can I come in “. Sure put we are to to full\nBut I am sure we can stick you somewhere “ oh and here is a paper you have to pay taxes between 20% to 53% the more you make the more taxes you pay so if you make say 100k you pay 9.15% if you make 120K to 150K 11.16% if you make 150K to 220k 12.16% so you will never get ahead no matter how much you make lots of people find out how living in Canada is really like all they see are the mountains , rivers. That’s how they get you . Preety soon Canada will have 1 billion people ??. People that work on minimum wage don’t know how they are affording things ?. We need to cut immigration

A 20% decrease doesn't mean anything. Kick them all out.. free up all this space and land and let real Canadians get it.

Many Indian-based IT companies not only employ Indians living in Canada but also hire (offshore) Indians who are living in India. There should be a law in Canada to regulate employment: you cannot have 19 Indians working on a team of 20.

They increased 500% and decreased 20% what a joke… stop it already 12 millions people came to Canada since liberal NDP Trudeau Jagmet

Thats only 20% it's not enough.

20% in 3 years? And then what happens to the other 80%?

we understand your house is on fire, we will reduce the fire by 20% - the liberals

We need 80% cut! 20% is not enough!! We need to reform and fix our country for this massive immigration problem!

As someone who grew up in Canada - Vancouver and has lived here for 20 years, I agree with the housing issues. But you are exaggerating too much. Some of your examples are just too extreme. Be more factual and provide proper statistical support for all scenarios provided in the video.

Born Canadians are paying g Lee because of a ignorant government. They should be giving us all 20”000 back in taxes and money the government a stolen through immigration that we are paying way too much for….

I am an immigrant who came here 20 years ago i believe it worked out well when we had 200-250k immigrant target per year and reduced when theres economic crisis below 100k for only critically short industries. I highly recommend to restrict immigration to avoid housing shortage first because theres nothing worse than Canadians living in tent even if many of them worked and tried.... - as an immigrant i supprt Canadian first direction to honor this great country

Needs to be cut by way more than 20%

2:20 bringing in the 3rd world is NOT the solution to our aging demographic problem. We need to encourage young Canadians to have more children by offering affordable housing, lower taxes and higher paycheques. If in the future Canada was ever to go to war these immigrants and refugees assholes will tuck their tails between their legs and run to another country. We need a population that is patriotic and will fight to defend Canada.

20% is barely scratching the surface. We need to cut 75%-90% for the next 5 years to let the system catch up to the massive surplus that we have already let in under Trudeau over the past 5 years or so. Then we can re-open it, responsibly, to the levels that Harper and Chretien were admitting.

20% drop is still 80% too many. We cannot cope with the numbers that are already here. More, no matter how few, just makes the problem worse. No immigration until everyone is housed.

The guy recording this is an arsehole, I'm always kind to delivery workers, 99.9% of problems are actually caused by the restaurant, not the delivery worker. It's only $20 yet the guy is literally mocking the workers accent, for a meal to be delivered there surely wouldn't be much change from $20 anyway so who's the real prick here. I'd just tell the worker to keep the change and enjoy the rest of his evening, the venom in the customers voice can't be justified

What a cowardly flip flopping move in pity attempt to get votes. You already ruined the system and we have streetful of people from you know where. Surely they are helping “building the homes” ?. What will reduction of 20% do when NDP Liberals have flooded the pool by 1000%. Just resign already.

She just said her family has been in the US for over 20 years. She sounds so cold about how Trump can just yank them out and deport the. Guess it's family she doesn't like. wow

wow, maybe I will be able to afford a house in 20 years when i'm 47 - great news :D

Dose Trudeau live under a rock, this is not enough maybe 20 thousand coming in in a year not 400,000 thousand he has ruined Canada. Not a single home or job for them here.

Should be a 80% cut, not 20%. 20% is a JOKE. However, the last time they announce cuts, such as student permits, they later announce immediate permanent residency for any foreign long term care workers. So what is happening is they announce they will cut something to appease Canadians, then turn around and come up with some new way to increase immigration.