Close Reading

He is right, the Palestinian people do not want to leave their land, they need support to stop the genocide being done to them.

In war the civilians never want to leave their land but for their safety and they should leave until the war is over. There seems to be this push to keep civilians in Palestine because without them Israel will have no trouble taking Hamas out.

Palestinians don't want to leave their land. But there were other counties in war and many peoples wanted to leave that places, did they take any one??

If you want to call it your land, you need to conquer and take it for yourself. That’s how it’s been done since the beginning of human existence. What you don’t do is cry about how unfairly your being treated and look for hand outs. If you can’t take it, it’s not yours.

Why Arab world have to take them This is their land and you Want israel Aan america to play the game On somebody else's Lend what world do we live in.??

Exactly. The whole struggle is about Palestinian people wanting to retain their land. Western journalists trying to twist the narrative

No they dont want those people in their land period. H9w does he know all of them want to stay in that land.

Obviously not encourage them out of there own land thats exactly what isreal wants but saudi and the uae and arab countries should be sending soilders weapons food

The Zionist agenda is so obvious. They think the rest of the world is stupid. They want to shame the Arab states into taking Palestinians so they can finally grab the land. It’s not going to happen.

Not want to leave their land? In Europe there's loads of Palestinians. Lol?

What about the millions of Jews that throughout the Arab nations for millennia who were thrown out by the Muslim people - they didn’t want to leave their land either. But, they moved on with life and built the best economy in the Middle East. The Palestinians would rather continue with their victim mentality and stoke the fire of antisemitism than make something of themselves.

But they have to live their land and their lives, because there are so many who want to profit from that and can sell resources to gain money! Is not fair for few to abuse and get richer, while so many, including children suffer? Excuse my sarcasm!

Why would Arab nations take people being forced out of their land. If you respect the Palestinians you would want them to stay in their land

Why would the they want to leave? It's their land after all.

Nodoby want palestinians on their lands. And there some historical reason for that. Reporter should make some research on this

They dont want to live theyr land, but never stop to arrive in England, Germany…..

Well said!!... The Palestinians do NOT want to leave their land... Let that sink in...

Im sorry but he’s saudi no? So is no one questioning the fact that he said that SA wouldn’t work with anyone that would force them or want the Palestinians to leave their land? It’s Saudi Arabia…arguably the United States biggest ally in the Middle East other then the state that is forcing the Palestinians off their land has been doing so since the post WWII Era. The US is a power that has and continues to support Israel and Israel is forcing the Palestinians off their land so if the Saudis are not gonna support a country or work with a country that supports the removal of Palestinians then they need to stop taking American money and stop being the US biggest ally, also idk why you all praise him, talk is cheap and the Arab world hasn’t done much about israel continuing to eat away at the Palestinian state, if SA truly believes that Palestine isn’t going to be forced off the world map then SA should start supporting Palestine, he didn’t even agree to let in refugees..not sure where all the praise is coming from he talks like a politician, he avoided the actual question and says what the people wanna hear despite not making efforts to make that happen.

All well in good but remember it's Palestinians land by his own words this means they don't want Jews there.\n\nI don't like any monotheistic religions they are all garbage imo.\n\nThis war will never end it has gone on since the birth of Islam and the Jews from canaanites.\n\nRemember both are genetically identical but it's a war over the land claimed by their religions.\n\nThus it is a never ending war short of genocide cause neither can prove their God is right.

But what about those that do want to leave? He’s not really answering the question.\n\nUkrainians also love their land and country, but Poland and Europe accepted millions of women, children and men that wanted to leave without questions.\n\nAlso, this is hypocrisy at its best. Saudi is supporting Russia, who’s doing the exact same to Ukraine.

As from India we stand with the Israel??. The 1948 peel commission gave most of their land to arabs but they refused it they want whole of Israel and genocide of Israeli population no way any country will stand with this hamas terrorist attack.. We unite with ?? . Peel comission 1948, 1970 the 1993summit in every chance arab had they refused 2 state solution so it's their agenda don't fall for it

Look! I respect life,\nAnd I want Palistine to live in peace in there own land, and have a good life and a good future, for the Palistinians children to grow in a peaceful world.\nAnd Israel also needs to know! That Israel can live in peace with the Palistinians as neighbours!\nThe weight can be lifted!\nThe killing can be stopped,\nBut this won't stop! Without the help! of the Arab world leaders and the Israeli leaders,\nTo stop the killings, to live in peace, to live in there own lands with dignity, with safety security on there lands!\nIt's time for peace talks on both sides, with Israel leaders, and the Arab world leaders, The humanitarian thing is peace talks, let's stop talking around the bush! and get things done!\nIt's time to swollow the pride! and revengeful hate on both sides and push for peace talks,\nBefore we have no lives to save!

Ummmmm I don’t think some Palestinian anyone for that matter want to stay in a conflict justified or unjustified. The Arab nation should first give an open door policy for a temporary shelter or refugee like the Europeans or America did for Ukraine. This notion that Palestinians don’t want to leave for a temporary refugee is very questionable. Just open your country and see if they will not go!!! Anyone is a free country should choice to evacuate to a safer country like Saudi, UAE, Bahrain or other golf countries. Instead of giving them aid or other form of support, give them a sanctuary and if they decide not to go back, then give them other options. Palestinians should not be dictated to stay in a conflict zone special the women and children. Even African countries rich or poor, open their doors to their neighbors during war like it happen in Sierra Leone, Liberia, Uganda and you can count many!!! Recently in Ukraine, Germany, Poland and other Ukraine neighbors, received millions of Ukrainians and never have they said Ohhhhh Ukraine love their land and they want to stay in Ukraine or they will lose their land when they left!!!!! It’s about time Arab nations to give Palestinians refugee without any preconditions. That’s obvious

SO DOES ISRAEL. STOP PRETENDING THEY WERE NOT THE ATTACKERS. THE LAND OF ISREAL BELONGED TO ABRAHAM, ISAAC, JACOB, THEN THEIR RETURN FROM EGYPT IN JOSHUA'S DAY. IT WAS PROMISED TO THEM. HAMAS JUST WANTS THEM GONE. STOP MASKING WHAT YOU REALLY WANT TO SAY!

Ok so then how will this ever come to be if Palestine keeps sending bombs to Isreal? I know that Isreal is bombing them back to really badly but they brought it on to thier selfs just imagine a state in Iran that says it don't want to be a state in Iran so Iran gives them land to be in but then the people who are in that land want more they are not happy so they start bombing Iran and then Iran attacks the land you would all be ok with that right? Why because its the same religion killing each other all Palestine has to do is stopping fighting Isreal make peace work together stop spending all your money on weapons and armies that are just dying Palestine with the land it has can be great but they just want war! And the jews are not so innocent also they take land they mistreated people of other ethnicities but that being said war is not the way they both need to stop

one problem, this is not their land. Palestine is Judaea , and they arejudean Arabs. that’s all and he knows that he’s lying, it’s just that none of them need these Arabs and he doesn’t want them on his land and he doesn’t want to help them either?

they dont want to leave their land? bs but if the destination is europe they will go

That is exactly what they want. Is for other Arab countries to help clear out the Palestinians from their land.

THEN WHY DID YOUR PRECIOUS HAMAS ATTACK THE ISRAELITES FIRST KILLING INNOCENT WOMEN AND CHILDREN IF THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE WANTED TO STAY IN THEIR LAND PEACEFULLY AND SAFELY??

They want the Palestinian to run and leave their land for the Israelis, that will not work,

They don’t want to leave their land so badly that Jordan and Egypt are lining APCs and tanks up on the border of Gaza and the West Bank to make sure the Palestinians don’t try to leave. \n\nThe Arab world wants to keep the Palestinians in suffering so that they can use Israel as a distraction because their own record on human rights is much worse.

Very funny they’re all using Palestinians don’t want to leave their land as an excuse. PLO tried to take over every country that once granted them refugee.. Jordan, Lebanon and Egypt with Islamic Brotherhood. Nobody wants that in their country again..

And the Jews have the right to their land. They have the righy to live in Isreal. The Palestinians must stop their nonsense. Its the Palestinians who doesn't want peace. Hamas doesnt care about their own peoples lives. And the world is starting to see that.

Accept that you don't want the Palestinians in your land ?. The hypocrisy

The palestinians do want to leave their land but they cant since the border with egypt is closed and no one wants to take them, egypts president A Sisi said it himself... open the border and then we will see what the palestinians really want.

They want to leave the land, but only for UE and US

How is everybody missing the false logic that he quietly inserted.\n\nHe states a premise that Palestinians do not want to leave their land. In that case, why not open the border and see if Palestinians come in. If they do not, then his premise is correct, if there’s a mass exodus, then there’s premise was just a way to shift responsibility.\n\nJordan and Egypt occupied the Westbank and Sasa strip from 1948 to 1967 what stopped them from creating Palestine or simulating those countries into theirs? Why was there no prosperity during that period?\n\nThe truth is that the refugees follow the 1948 and the land that was going to be given to the following. The conclusion of demand of Palestine has been in a tug of war between various factions for the last 70 years.

Haha this is so dumb always the “Palestinians don’t want to leave the land” “Palestinians are all warriors!” Most of them just want peace for there children and want hamas gone that steals there water and food supply that Israel is bringing. Remember Palestinians want to leave Gaza but Hamas would never don’t confuse these 2.

So say they want to stay in there land, so what doesn’t hamas move out?

Idk why these people are trying to force the image that the Palestinians want to leave \n\nThey don’t want to leave their land it is simple as that

This is the right answer. The Palestinians don’t want to leave their land period

Here's the Saudis they have plenty they can give land to the palastinians then Israel won't have to pay for everything they want an the Saudis are mmuslim

What about the ones who DO want to leave their land? (Refugees). Will they open their doors to them? (No)

Yes, of course the Palestinian people have the right to their land and the right to live on their land in dignity, peace and security but if nobody makes Israel stop butchering them, shouldn't someone at least offer them temporary refuge? I would want that if I were stuck there with my loved ones.

The Quran says in Chapter 5 verses 21 to 26 that Allah has assigned that land to the Jews. Does this Muslim not read his Quran. Its not the land of the Palestinians. The Jews have been living in Israel for thousands of years. Its is NOT their land. The Arabs want to wipe out the Jews and Israel. This is not political its religious. They want to establish a World Islamic State.... Israel today....Europe tomorrow. But the God of Abraham has a covenant with the Jews...they are Gods chosen people. The evil Islamic religion will NEVER defeat Israel. God Bless Israel.

Its not THEIR land its actually a piece of Egypt technically but they dont want it

Palestine is not a country. It's never been a country. Palestinians are a combination of Egyptians, Jordanians, Syrians, and Lebanese arabs that were expelled from their countries and the British Mandate. The area of land you're referring to is not Palestine. It's Israel or, if you want to go back further, Judea and Sumaria. The people who rightfully live there, and have lived there for thousands of years, are happy to let others live there as well; as long as they're peaceful. Seems to be hard for some.

That's exactly what Israel wants? They want the Palestinians to leave so they can seize the land.

Palestinians came from Jordan, Jordan through them out for hijacking planes and landing them in Jordan and the Arabs don't want them anyway.

Well said How dare an outsider wants to displace the Palestinians from their land.