Close Reading

Bye barron.malania was not a citizen when barron was born!! Barron is illegal

If your not born from at least 1 American parent you should not have citizenship sorry but not sorry get them out

Da slave master systems children born in the USA and parents who are slaves those children are not USA citizens but they did change that law but after 400 years uts da same philosophy but it won't work out y half of Congress and senet parents are immigrants

Well what about Barron. Melania was not a citizen when she had Barron..he was born in March 2006, Melania became a citizen 4-5 months later..

Include your wife she wasnt born usa hypocritice so you convicted criminal what you idiots doing

They bring wife pregnant with disabled kids they want born ir bring to get easy money of SSI for theirs kids or for help governent benefits when they grow up give yi the parents the papers

if your parents are here illegally, and you're born here, you should not be granted citizenship!

You guys do realize that most ice agents are first and second generation Hispanic American born ..??

Trump was born in the USA. His grandparents cane from Cnada .

You are hiving false information!\nChildren who are born here of ambassadors from foreign countries \nARE NOT CITIZENS!

he's not an american he's a german born here in USA....so what's the difference??

Trump' Saying Illegal Immigrants Parents ... Born ( America ) Children's Can Be Deported IN Illegal Acts Charges. ! ??

And as I understand it's not American citizen was not born here she came here with a green card married Trump and had one son just a thought to think about

This is extremely interesting for neither of his parents were US citizens his mother came from Scotland and his father came from Germany and he Donald J Trump was born in the US does that mean we get to kick him out just a thought

President Trump would need to amend the constitution in other to remove birthright citizenship, because the 14th amendment's grant of birth right citizenship to all people born within in the country.

When they freeze the consitution, you have no protections no status, naturalization, not being born in the country.\nYour only protection is being white, and for some time to come being black american or native.

citizenship rights was for slaves whose children will be born in the USA during slavery. The context is different if you came in illegally.... President Trump is right... Congress should support him

If being born in America you're not a citizen then Donald Trump is not qualified

Wherever you are born is by the grace of God not by men’s law!

“Subject to the jurisdiction thereof” is what the constitution says. Children born to foreigners are not subjects to any jurisdiction here. They are subjects of their parent’s country. They need to go back to their own people.

you gotta understand tho.. the prices are not the same across canada... i spent 5 years in halifax and even tho i was born and raised in toronto...halifax to me was home... i payed $400/500 for my own apartment..but that was 15 years ago...halifax is cool man...i defantly wanna leave toronto...but its not easy for me to do..i came back to toronto to be with my mom..and it didnt work out..now i got lot of strings tied me to this city...and the city has alot of strings tied to me..like as much as i wanna go ..its like they have me locked up here for now.. so i more then understand you..good video and good luck to you

you said that you came from ukraine to canada thats interesting...i am 40 and was born in canada and thinking of moving from canada to ukraine for obvious reasons from also toronto...and it makes me sad too..i feel you girl..

I met a lot of indians in Canada, born and raised there, and most of them told me they were candians, seems like they have shame of their roots

born in Canada but moved to Detroit Michigan when i was 4 yrs old...on my 18th birthday came back to Montreal Canada permanently .....enjoy the people, food, medical advantage and mostly the acceptance of all racial cultures and gender preferences ...love Montreal...most beautiful and clean city.....come and visit....even if you speak only English you will be accepted and welcomed with open arms....Bienvenu my friend !!

Born to US citizens!

To all the Indian sympathizers , these folks were born in India , so they are asking visa to visit the birth place. Khalistan is being tarnished by foolish Hindus , it’s means pure land , no one is asking separate state , Majority of Sikhs know it and they are not part of the movement. However, This new breed of Hindus led by Modi seems they can tarnish Sikhs and Khalsa. It’s impossible. In next 100 years , Sikhs and Khalsa will flourish

Idk i think you need to realize that we also have our bias in addition to you having yours. Meaning, to most of us , excepting the most left leaning socially progressive pockets and contexts , which even then wouldn’t be viewed that way to us just acceptable lol ?\n\nOur baseline/political middle in Canada is A LOT more left leaning than the baseline normal/political middle in the states. So while people tend to equate your democrats to our liberals or our NDP , and equate your republicans to our conservatives. It’s just not accurate. If you throw our span of parties and American span of parties on the SAME spectrum /polarity line. You might be surprised to realize how shifted left our systems range politically is from the American one. \n\nThis hugely impacts the average normal expectation , what we clutch our pearls at hearing coming out of the mouths of the general public , and our range of what we expect to not hear or see ranted about unless they’re to our view , extremely right leaning politically /social values. \n\nFor us this means that actually genuinely , a lot of America does get experiences by us as bat shit crazy racist homophobic immigrant intolerant culturally and religiously ignorant , and somewhat backwards in larger or smaller amounts ? I know that’s not fun to hear but. Being the most diverse country based so much on immigration means. What is normal and known /familiar and normal so we aren’t ignorant to , is completely different. \n\nFor us we have our pockets usually in more rural less populated areas further away from larger cities where there is more diversity but that’s the same often in many countries that you will find some of the louder racist homophobic intolerant voices typically in places that truly are unfamiliar and ignorant to the experience of growing up with and around much of any diversity of varying kinds. So it’s not to say we don’t have racism and intolerance of course like anywhere we do. It’s just contained and the range and frequency and intensity is MUCH different. We distinguish nuances of diff cultures and religions more easily and in larger numbers we’re more familiar with diff ways of life , language , food, dress , holidays , values and used to a much less segregated way of existing even when we are differnt from each other as the NORM. My parents were both born in the states and my older brother was born there but they moved up here when he was a baby. So nearly all my extended family lives down there and I’m a duelly. And my experiences discussing things with my cousins or visiting absolutely could be described as culture shock at times. The insane things that came out of my own cousins mouths when they hear our friends or partners of various cultures , our not understanding how big a deal and incredibly insulting apparently it is to have assumed someone American was lgbt lol the list goes on. Like I don’t think our most intolerant Pockets can hold a flame to even ur closet to middle a bit intolerant places and contexts in America. Quite honestly. \n\nI think the absolute undying favourable passionate upholding and support of nationalistic, capitalist, hyper individualistic mentality about society as a whole (from my Canadian born and bred perspective lol) makes the differences even more glaring blaring and hard to swallow for us lol. I think more Canadians would feel exactly how that comment stated , that you felt was not fair for us to experience America as. I think the truth is a lot of Canadians are being too polite to let you know that’s exactly how a lot of America comes off to a lot of Canada ?

What does it mean if both of your parents and their family are born and raised on US soil?

Obama's Dad is a foreigner. Hawaii was stolen , so... WHAT ? He wasn't even born in the lawful US ! A little late for you to know this.

Is Barron included? Barron was born 3/20/2006. Melania became a citizen 7/28/2006.

Trumps family were immigrants. He became a citizen because of birthright citizenship. Barron was born on our soil in March 2006 and Melania was not a citizen until July 2006. They are both anchor babies and or birthright citizenship. But you see they are white don’t you guys get it?

In the Philippines ( I'm focusing on that country as a born Canadian Filipino ) there was a 40% rise in, not only immigration, but exclusively mostly caucasian immigration to the Philippines. Prices in the Philippines then skyrocketed exponentially. Yet, they ( The Philippines ) NOT ONCE complained....in general, let alone frabricated ussues to complain about like the manner which is demonstrated in all of North America. So, how much worse, how much more problematic, is the basically small percentage of immigration is in Canada?\n\nFurthermore, in the Philippines exclusively, the immigrants there, not care to learn the Filipino language and would rather go poor, than contribute to the labour force of the Philippines. So....HOW MUCH MORE VALID are Canadian problems with immigration?

His wife wasn't even born here

Good move it should be start from first tuner of Mr President Trump. All Illegal donker Migrat must deport with his childrens born in USA too of illegal migrate deported to their own country. America is for American first.

Good move it should be start from first tuner of Mr President Trump. All Illegal donker Migrat must deport with his childrens born in USA too of illegal migrate deported to their own country. America is for American first.

Good move it should be start from first tuner of Mr President Trump. All Illegal donker Migrat must deport with his childrens born in USA too of illegal migrate deported to their own country. America is for American first.

Good move it should be start from first tuner of Mr President Trump. All Illegal donker Migrat must deport with his childrens born in USA too of illegal migrate deported to their own country. America is for American first.

Good move it should be start from first tuner of Mr President Trump. All Illegal donker Migrat must deport with his childrens born in USA too of illegal migrate deported to their own country. America is for American first.

Are you kidding me. Are you not in Canada right now. Canada is now the most poor country in the World. Immigration has gone to the roof. No housing. Rents and forget about buying a house in BC, AB, Quebec, Ontario. High unemployment, Inflation is high and going up more. We also do not have a military defense system and the U.S. is tired of Canada not spending money to meet their responsibility as a Nato country. Many Canadians are leaving the country permanent. Investors and businesses are pulling out. Canada is trillions in debt but keep printing more money (toilet paper). Canada has gone downhill significantly over the past ten years. Born Canadians and legit immigrants having to go through a rigorous immigration process are very unhappy and cause conflict. Besides all the different ethnicities cause unrest and are ungrateful, daring the burn the Canadian flag, uttering death to Canada, death the US and Israel. These trouble makers have not intentions to assimilate into Canada's culture and are disrespectful to the Canadian government and it's citizens. Our youth are very unhappy and do not see a future for themselves yet have to work very hard and pay unbelievable high taxes. The minimum wages are only 15 bucks an hour which cannot sustain life here in this country. Please stop making false promises to foreigners to come here and be disappointed. This is not a country of milk and honey any longer but poor and enormous homelessness. Hunger, terrible health care, incredible post secondary tuitions and books. Now that president Trump has won the election he is going to place tariffs on Canadian goods and rightfully so. Russia is very interested in the Antarctica and should they or anyone invade Canada we got 3 days of ammunition. The food in AB is very bad for your health. Everything has pesticides, hormones, and by the time fruit and vegies arrive here from the US all the nutrition have gone. A extremely high cancer rate, young and old, diabetes, depression and other mental disorders are rampant. Our children and grandchildren do not have a future so why bother going to school or work. Our kids live on the streets, shelters, camping in the woods and using fentanyl and meth all kinds of dangerous drugs. The cities and small towns are full of used needles, pipes, and more paraphelia just thrown on the trails everywhere. The US will not assist Canada when a possible War 3 will occur, and we the people of Canada and the land are easy prey. If you do not believe me, just come visit RED Deer shelters and walk around on the trails, go to Vancouver but becareful because random assaults are happening every day, people living in tents, using the streets as toilets, drugs galore, even the police is unable to act nor arrest criminal activities caused by desperate people who need to survive. Canada's economy is about to collapse and fall into a recession. We have too many people coming in our country without checking their back ground and many criminals and terrorist groups are entering declaring refugee status whether it is true or not, we do not know. The people of Canada who work and pay highest taxes are used to house these newcomers and education, jobs, food and money. Our government take better care of these illegal people than their own people especially our youth. So please let us not pretend Canada is a land of opportunity and great. We have to vote for the right leader who will have a very difficult time and challenges to overcome if at all possible and make Canada Great Again!

I agree with him it's cheapening America citizenship also we can't be Indian if we are born in India

only a few countries in the world have birth right citizenship. no country in europe for example has it. and its correct. just because you were born in a country doesnt make you a citizen. lets say my mother was travelling to Slovakia while pregnant and she gave birth to me there, does this make me a Slovak?

Don't leave your country being born in united states doesn't make you American with two immigrant parents

I thought birth right was just for the military back in the day! I believe at least one parent has to be a US citizen for the new born to be a US citizen at birth. Just running across the US border and dropping a kid out should not be a US citizen.

Only a citizen if born to citizens, Europe does this.

Once upon a time, a former slave made a case to the Supreme Court, and they said he wasn't American. So, the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution was passed to address that issue. \n\nThe Wong Kim Ark case, which went to the Supreme Court, was a different issue, as his parents were legal residents. \n\nHowever, the issue of children born to illegal immigrants was truly left unsettled by the Supreme Court.

Where was Trump born????

Im born in Canada \n?

Well if they’re born from illegal migrants that’s only fair

Australia ended it's birth right citizen in 1981. Now, the babies born here have to have at least 1 parent who is a citizen or PR, in order to be a citizen. If both parents are not citizens, the child automatically becomes a citizen when the child turns 10 and both parents become citizens too, but the parents have to have some kind of work visa, Student visa, or some kind of visa that allows them to stay and work here. Unless they have changed it. So, good for you America. Boris Johnson was born in the USA and grew up in the UK but the US gov wanted some of that tax money when he tried to sell his house in the UK.

My parents, grandparents and great grandparents were all born in the USA. Having pregnant women coming as illegal immigrants should not become a citizen even though the baby is born here. Actually she knew she was pregnant before she came, but that doesn’t mean she can’t become a legal citizen, but it needs documentation like I have had to prove many times to get work.