Close Reading

Well done justinder .\nToday they want khalistan in india \nTomorrow they will get one in canada .

im frm punjab and im sikh and i dont want khalistan, its basically the demands of the one who doesnt have far sighted vision and just on a reactionary basis put undue demand to counter the threat on their religious persecution and discrimination being faced, deep down we all know how religious politics is shaping this and promoting communal hatred , we all should unite as a single whole and discard such feelings of hatred among us and should leave peacefully, we dont want khalistan and we wont let our india to be a hindu rashtra ,, jai hind jai bharat

Most of these international students belong to the sikh community from northern india (punjab). Not all indians are like this, mostly sikhs because they are large scale fraudsters. India even asked the Canadian government to extradite these criminals back because most of them (khalistanis) are wanted in India for criminal charges...Canadian gov let them in and gave them safe passage. Hardeep singh nijjar and indian student link is all connected to sikhs - who are well known troublemakers in India. The only solution is cap the # of sikhs coming in, check for fraud and stop voting for jagmeet singh/khalistanis (who are not looking out for canadian interest but rather for khalistan interest).

Being Indian..do whatever you want to do with these students...\nBut remember one thing also.. Canada has no right to interfere in India...like khalistan issue \nAll the best ❤

These khalistani will soon ask to form there own Khalistan in bc or Brampton. The region of Punjab in India is full of criminals and drug dealers and they want to come here since no security checks are done and even if they are they can get fake certificates easily. Trudeau and jagmeet gets a massive votes from these guys. The change has to come from the top. Also requirements has to be strict and not soft to come in. This is why we are getting some of the worse people coming in.

Man, in one video, I hate this reporter, and in another, I love his work. In this video, good job on calling out fake students and Khalistanis. This is a very reasonable video but the problem is people start hating all the Indians and Punjabis after watching stuff like this.... There are neutral Indians as well who do not want to be associated with Khalistan and fake students. PLEASE COVER THOSE INDIANS AS WELL FOR ONCE!

I may disagree with you Harry, but I like you. I wish you best of luck on your career!. Try to research more on the subjects, and this is just a request.\nWhere I differ:\n1. You cant just blame federal or JT for this issue. Provisional governments are equally responsible as well. They allowed mass international students due to their (provincial) going down economy for various factors. They made false promises to students that students can get PRI in less than a year, otherwise do you think students were willing to go to these cold areas to study without any benefits? You made a promise, now its time to fulfill.\n2. International students funds the college/school by paying fee 3 times more than a Canadian one. There was no check and balance from provincial governments on school/colleges, because they liked the inflow of $$$ within their provinces.\n3. Totally agree with you that fake students should not be getting any merci. But are all the fake students from India, not really. Both the federal and provincial governments were allowing more Indian students because they wanted to have more economic ties with Indian growing economy. \n4. Punjabi (including Sikhs) is one of the best marshal races to serve in army or security agencies. Our Canadian officials never hire personals without a proper security check. \n5. Khalistan's supporters are adapting a peaceful way for their freedom land. As far they are peaceful, we should not have any issue with their struggle. Just like we do not have issues with Quebec separatists. \n6. Remember, majority of Canadians are immigrants from various part of the globe including you as well, weather you are coming from 3rd, 4th or 5th generation. Its easy to spread hate compare to love. I love you and other my fellow Canadians even though I may not be a TRUE Canadian in your books. \n\nYou may be surprised that a Pakistani born (non-Punjabi) Canadian is supporting Indian students. I may dislike India for various and obvious reasons but I want to be on the right side of the history. Love & Peace!!!

They separate Indian and Punjabi because Sikhs want to establish a separate country named Khalistan in Canada

These are Trudeau's and his buddy's friends in Brampton. Canada didn't punish the killers of the Air India flight 182 which was bombed by the Sikh separatists. RCMP and CSIS both did not act, Pierre Trudeau did not deport the offenders of terrorism carried out in India. Now Canada will have to make way for Khalistan in either Brampton or Surrey in BC. Goodluck to all of us !! Do the authorities even know that these people come with fake education certificates and discrimination certificates? When Canada puts down India through various issues, you are all going to get this rot.Canada does not want to co operate with India in cracking down on these people, instead they are putting false allegations against India. Diplomacy is at minus zero in this government. I am an Indian origin Canadian and we follow news in India. Orher Canadians should too and see the changes happening in India. Not being a G7 nation India's GDP has risen above Canada, France and UK. The politicians here have Punjabi hangers on around them. Either Indian Punjabis or Pakistani Punjabis. There is a great deal of favouritism by them. Canada must remove the chaffe and recognize the good qualified people.

Actually India women who is filming was behaving like I want visa but official denied for emergency bcos there is a procedure we have to follow but suddenly she started playing victim card by recording the man and if u are a bastard then u don't know that those who works for embassy cannot revealed that they are working for embassies it's a matter of safety and u are aware of khalistan issue that Pannu threaten all U.S and canadian counselors to kill them but this bitch is recording and posting that's the reason he was very angry and denied

You are correct bro,my grand parents never want to talk about Khalistan,its only some couple of people,We still love our Nation jai Hind

Im Punjabi sikh ( actually dont believe in any god now .) and never support khalistan but but if u want Hindustan for Only Hindus than i support khalistan. \n\nSo please no khalistan or Hindu stan. Leave India alone. Lets grow as Human

I hope Punjabis leave Canada and go back to Punjab to make the great nation they are dreaming of. I wonder why they still live in Canada if they want Khalistan.

Khalistan live long ... operation blue star can't forget wot u did with us you promised everything at the time of partition but now refused to give us anything .... we want freedom for our geneartion ....

U should learn abt bhindrawale Sade temple te attack hoyea saada youth genocide hoyea \nIndia di freedom ch 90 percent punjabi c ki milea sanu punjab was a huge state they divided it \nEvery state do trade for money \nHumara paani free kyu aur kis state ko dete hai\nLook at farmers protest \nThey started calling us khalistani\nNow we will make khalistan \nIf u want to know how will it work \nLook up maharaja Ranjit singh \nWhere there will be no discrimination

But they want Khalistan in India

I criticized the genocide of my Sikh brothers, sisters and children in riots in Delhi in 1984. That incident is the one that led few sikhs but not all to ask for a separate nation that should be named Khalistan and I want the media to not to call those sikhs “extremists”in foreign countries, we can call them Sikhs asking for separate country, they can not be called “Khalistanis” either because Khalistan doesn’t exist. Also, sikhs and Hindus always got along well. In all India, there are sikhs living everywhere just like Hindus. There was never a conflict or dispute between them. I grew up in a society where my neighbors are all mixed Hindus and Punjabis. As much as Sikhs visit Hindu Temples same goes for Hindus visiting Gurudawaras. How about our film industry, there are so many sikh Punjabis like the Kapoors, the Malhotras, they don’t want to leave India also. I don’t want to my Indian sikhs to make a separate nation. I want the Indian police not to discriminate against certain religion and not be biased. If a Hindu policeman saves a Hindu criminal and wrongfully and falsely put a non Hindu person in jail then it’s purely wrong and discriminatory and same thing goes for a Sikh policeman. How about our soldiers, majority of our soldiers are Hindus and Sikhs, they are protecting India and it’s citizens. I want people of all religions and backgrounds in India to live peacefully and get along.

Brilliant video Nitish...\nIm a proud Indian Sikh from Jammu, settled in Bangalore for almost 10 years as a Senior Software Professional. Quite happy with my life (apart from crazy traffic). Have visited many countries for on-site business work, including Canada but India is good despite all the chaos, espcially South India. Started my career in infosys Chandigarh, then Gurgaon then Bangalore. My parents also might move in with me next year and Im also planning to start my own Food eatery. Over 95% Sikhs are just like me and patriotic and Love India, but yes there are issues in Punjab which need to be addressed...\nBut a large portion of the blame sadly goes to Sikh politicians. I want to tell the youth that Khalistan is a waste of time and politicians in Punjab, especially sikh politicians are completely bullshit. They are corrupt and have no vision and rely on rural votes which is sikh majority and Jazbaati over every issue and largely into farming. The Punjabi Hindus, baniyas, aggarwals and Jains own the urban economy and are comparatively more practical and forward looking in life. Many of these sikh politicians sadly themselves are involved in drug, own illegal abortion centres and labs, and even coaching centres to send students to canada on fake letters in exchange for a lot of money...\nI want to tell the youth, There is a lot of good opportunity in India. I know Punjab doesnt have much as of now (hope someday one of us can take our experience and setup a startup hub there), but other cities like Pune, Hyd, Bangalore, Mum, Chennai etc are good and once you have a stable job, its quite satisfying. Punjabis especially Sikhs are also loved everywhere by common people. Please dont spend your money on fake asylum letters and Canadian Dreams without thinking and planning.

Trudeau wants Canada to be Khalistan.

In Reality all this Khalistan movement is started and funded by the powerful enemies of India, not even 1% Sikh want this.\nThey cant defeat India so trying to divide and make it weak

Want To Know Why They Don't Ask Place Where Guru NANAK JI BORN THAT DON'T BELONG KHALISTAN I WONDERED SO WHY INDIA ALONE

90% below comments are indian bots rubbish. See what the Sikh referendum will say 99% Sikhs will want Own Raj Khalistan

I am Sikh, not Indian, we want Khalistan

Indian Government always ignore punjab\nno jobs in punjab\nonly drugs are supplied in all over punjab\npunjabi’s love india\nour grandparents have seen 1947 nd 1984\nbut new delhi doesn’t care\n\nid new delhi wants to remove khalistan then they must take some bold steps to improve the living standards in punjab\nthey should block the drug routes in international border area\nthey should start some good industry in punjab so that young punjabi’s can live and work happily in punjab

young brother Hindus are 60% of NRI in Canada. But let you know we all are punjabi first. they all loved helped each other. Hate is new thing on religion base for Punjabis. Talwinder singh parmar we never even heard of him I lived very closed to his house. One day at the airport this guy appeared with eight nine people with garland and were told he is separates . Dr Jagjit singh chauhan was presented as a leader that wants Khalistan . He was high level Congress leader. After so much life lost hate created This bastard went back to India and died peacefully in his bed. While thousands of innocent peoples life was taken and labeled as terrorist that are killing Hindus. I am atheist but i hope i go to hell to meet Indra and sons along with some others from her party All this hare dead and destruction of Punjabis is all because of one evil lady. that wanted absolute power and control in India. She spend Billions to create hate among Punjabis.

I posted a video that showed that demand for khalistan is not their and my dear friend said to me “tu khakhi kutta banne ga tere vich quality hai” (coz i want to be a civil servant).

Main accused of kanishq bomb blast was ripudaman malik who received 400 crore from government of india and obviously government denied,\nRipudaman Indian citizen was cancelled in india and become wanted\nLater as soon as bjp come in power they provide ripudaman malik Indian citizen in 2019 and he met few rss leaders in delhi then visited panjab, later he caught carrying 400 fake sikh script which is illegal to sgpc via china and got killed in canada by private killers\n same with jagjit chuahan, he started spreading khalistan name in india and Western country after he loss MLA election, his citizenship was cancelled by government but as soon as bjp came in power they provide him Indian visa and he met rss member in delhi then he start living in panjab again and died natural death according to age, he also mentioned he's descendant of maharana pratap and he is willing to bring back his 'asthiya' to india, wonder how every khalistan top leaders including subramaniyam swami were directly linked with rss or they planed all this back then in 80-90s

Most punjabi people don't want khalistan. But indian media is always trying to label them khalistani even if we raise voice for our rights. For example, indian media creates a narrative that khalistani was behind Kisan andolan, but it was people of punjab and haryana fighting for their rights .

You did a great Job Nitish ji. You are doing a great job to educate Indians that all sikhs do not want khalistan only a small portion is asking for khalistan. We as Sikhs spread live and humanity and that is our true religion

Sant jairnail singh Bhindrawale never demanded khalistan and not even single FIR was filled against him. He was just targeted by government at that time and destroy his image by saying him terrorist. He just wanted punjab to be drug free and educated but government did not want this. We as a sikh are never supported by any party . They hate us. That’s why we want separate state. I am from todays generation and who said only elders want khalistan . Still now if we ask for rights in punjab , we are sent to jail,, they we support khalistan moment which is ultimate solution because it’s reality people of india and Indian government can never appreciate our contributions towards country which are always in majority.

No one in India wants khalistan and true sikh people will never demand the same. What i feel is that sikh people have always been radical but they have always fought to unite and save the oppressed never demanded for a different nation. Even our gurus never captured any land. I hope that everyone follows ek on kar teaching of guru nanak dev ji and all this issue of khalistan comes to an end ?

I am sikh abd I want khalistan because there is no justice for Sikhs even though Muslims, we can't forget 1984and47 .\n\n\n\nWe want indipendence nation and we are not indian

I am a Brahmin married to Sikh I can assure you Sikh never wants any Khalistan these NRI bas..rds are just looking for opportunity to debalance India because Muslim and Hindus are already in bad terms they want Sikh and Hindu should also be in Bad terms

Great video and very grateful to Nitish Rajput and team for bringing up the real issues.\nAlso for letting people know that Sikhs in the majority are not in favor of Khalistan. Not every Sikh is in favor of Khalistan and the ones wanting it are not at all present in India.

Best video watched so far and its true only sikhs outside of India wants khalistan not Indian sikhs

Thank you brother for understanding us ?. We don't want khalistan we just need development and job opportunities.

To be honest until the people of Punjab doesn't get the solutions for there problems the voice of Khalistan rise again and again because when the country makes there people happy no one wants to separate and everyone know this is the fact that most of the time center government were unfair with Punjab as he told in his older video

I must say you have a good skill of spreading Indian govt propaganda in a way like it was out of great research. We are are fed up of all these sharma verma and rajputs sitting in Delhi spinning conspiracy theories against sikhs. According to your rogue analysis the entire NDP party is infiltrated with Sikhs and sikhs are holding canadian govt to ransom. Is it not true that successive hindu majoritarian govt have done genocide and extrajudicial killings of sikhs in 1980s and 2000s for muslims to appease the hindu majority voters. After pannu made a video to threaten hindus to leave India entire Canadian parties condemn it and assured safety of hindus in Canada. In comparison every single day a hindu leader of Indian parties calls muslims to go to pakistan and labells sikhs as terrorists and no judicial system or political parties and so called independent journalists like you have guts to call it out. Its not the sikhs to want so much khalistan its the treatment of India and its majority with sikhs that creates the demand.

Bro I haven't seen the video yet but I know the reason of migration.. you should change the title nd name it why Indians want to migrate to canada. Just look at gujratis nd maharastra ppl craze. They r not Punjabis .. nd one another thing your team need look around nd see .. muslims ko terrorist bna diya .. ab Sikhs ko khalistani bna rhe . If some ppl think k India sirf unka hi hai to they need to think twice about history... M not a khalistani supporter.. but saying we ll make India only a Hindu rastra is same a asking khalistan..

Bro You are 100% right..Ethe koi nahi chahnda Khalistan.. I am from Punjab and We love Sikh Community as much as They love us.We all are Punjabis.There is complete Love and Respect.. Yes we want solutions and Economic Growth in Punjab.. We all are pure hearted people. Thanks for making this video and creating awareness among people.. hatsoff to you ?

If you want khalistani. You have to face india and pak?? and toilet cleaner wants khalistan??

You have great opinion sir, but you should also make a video on why hindus people want india to be hindu rastra particularly dekha jaye toh sabhi ik ko he target kre ja rhe hai, thora Hindu ka bi bta do ki kya credibility ya contribution hai india main unka and i'm neither the supporter of khalistan and also for hindustan. I wish for humanitystan.

We want Khalistan If not give the Sikh riots ???????

Thank you to make this video\nCan you please make a video on SIKH RAJ (KHALSA RAJ MAHARAJA RANJIT SINGH RAJ) from where it started and how it ends till MAHARAJA DULEEP Singh and how we sikhs loose MAHARANI JINDAH and seperation of punjab in 1947\nSo then people will know why we sikhs want khalistan\nWe don’t want khalistan we want our sikh empire and that era back\nThat was promised by nehru and politicians at that time.

Many many Sikhs in Canada do not want to support Khalistan. The main reason is that why do we alienate a state in the age of Unions. Other countries are forming unions to stay competitive and Punjabis will be at loss.

Yes, your talk on Khalistan movement is true ..it is purely selfish demand by few selfish sikhs living abroad here in India no one wants, we have better things to think of and are proud of being an Indian.

You made good video but it is biased towards india not totally 100% true you showing fact what is india wated to show rest of the world. In reality after 1984 rss india planted so many fake sikhs in panjab so you see in delhi some people stand by government no matter what & kanisha blast by india gov. to defame sikhs because western countries were supporting for seprate state after 1984 attack. India involving in each and every country where ever indian sikhs & muslim population last tym in germany gov. arrested indian spy agent keeping eye on sikh and musli. And biggest mistake you have done in the video is khalistan movement hasn't started after 1984 it was before 1947 you have to do more research when pak india was getting devided religion base there was sikh homeland demand that time some leader choose to go with india there was agreement with nehru to give panjab autonomy soverign state all power of panjab in thier land. Still it was written with india panjab will be soverign state in india not capture by india same goes for kashmir by british in writing. sikh were getting khalistan that time if we wanted we would have get it from british we choose to go with india.

the aiplane blast was planned by RAW to defame babbar khalsa, all the influential indians and Indian diplomats cancelled there flight tickets, because they know its gonna happen\nAnd the CM Beant Singh murdered thousands of sikh youth in fame encounters....thats why he got killed....ask any sikh in punjab abut beant and KPS, they will curse them.\n\nBro if you say that Punjab ka sikh nahi chahta khalistan, to Referendum krlo India me, or sikh koi India me bomb dhamake krte to ghum nahi rahre.... bahar v Referndum hi karwa rahe hao....indian govt should give cahnce and see what hapens,.... the same way Canada gave to Quebec...\npeacefully demnding for a separate ation is not a crime.... we can get seperated by peace...sikhs just want their own control...The same way majority hindu is asking for Hindu Rasthra being a majority.\n\nWhy dont you talk about betrayal of Nehru?? He allured sikhs to be by his side and after India was made, he showed up his real face and deceived the sikhs??\n\n\nWHY DONT SOME ONE TALK ABOUT HINDU RASTRA??? IS IT CONSTITUTIONAL???

You didn't talk about other activities that happened in 1971.\nPakistan wanted to separate punjab from india because they lost Bangladesh.\nThis is when pakistan started investing money for khalistan

We are living in INDIA and we want khalistan . KHALISTAN KA MATLAB INDIA K ANDR EK WO STATE JHA SIKHO KO UNKE RIGHT MILE LIKE EMPEROR OF MAHARAJA RANJIT SINGH?