Close Reading

Thousands of Indians are in Canada with expired visas, they work for less than minimum wage with out paying taxes, which is causing the local employment opportunities

Immigration dept of many advanvanced countries make lot of money out of mainly indiansy, and tax heavily those who are allowed and work. That runs in billions. That helps the coward laws to house and pay for unruly immigrants!! ;And then they also condemn the indians.

I actually love this indian talent should stay in India and contribute for our country. Someone will say well pay is not good here there are no jobs here yes but rich indians should open their own companies here and be the job creators and yes government also needs to pay initiatives to these rich people so that they invest in India.

??Why not only TWO quota in India.. [Government school quota (with non creamy certificate) AND private school quota] .. ? \nWhy insulting students by giving caste quota ? \n\n[ Read the above statement AGAIN and AGAIN ]??\n--------------------------------\nCASTE AND MANAGEMENT BASED RESERVATION is the ROOT cause of all system collapse in INDIA .... ????\n\n?Caste quota in Tamilnadu is [ 69 % ] ?\n\n?Merit is a JOKE in Tamilnadu (India) ???? \n\n????? In India LESS than (30 %) (FC & BC) use ONLY Brain and HARD WORK to get a degree ?\n\nThe rest around (70 %) also use..\n1. CASTE QUOTA ( MBC & SC & ST ) \n2. MONEY (MANAGEMENT QUOTA) \n????????\n---------------------------------\n??Caste quota is used again and again by the SAME FAMILY who developed using the caste quota..How the caste quota is going to help the POOR students from the SAME caste .. ???? \n\n?? Also..Nearly 50% of collages in India is private.. DON'T sell seats using MANAGEMENT QUOTA .. Government should take control of all PRIVATE colleges... OR if the government is not able to take over the private colleges.. Give the seat to those who have the marks and let them pay with interest when they go to the job.. to the studied private college.. \n( Give the seat to those who have the brain NOT to those who have the money) ????\n\n??Education is solely depend on BRAIN ....\nMONEY and CASTE has NO place in it.. ????

You seemed to have conveniently missed a few more main points. We, Indians, put ourselves down.\n\nThey are;\n1) Out of 100 Indiands traveled abroad either for tourism or business, only 50 returns home, and the rest try to find jobs to live there.\n\n2) Many Indians forge documents or produce fake documents to get visas.\n\n3) Where the Indians go, they bring pan and pan parag items and spit sll over the place, especially the North Indians. South Indians are much better.\n\n4) We, Indians, can go any lower to get a job abroad at low pay. So, we put our own grades down.\n\nThere are numerous examples I know of. Let me cite a few below.\n\n1) In one of the Western countries, a few years ago, a real Punjabi brother and sister who staged fake a marriage, got a marriage certificate, and other documents only to migrate there. The government eventually found put and deported them.\n\n2) Canada deported a few hundred Gujarati students when the US border security found them not speaking in English. On investigation, it was found that they all came with fake IELTS certificate.\n\nThere are many incidents we get to witness the day after the day. So, we can't blame other countries. It's us who made us very cheap in the international market. Because of those Indians, the entire innocent, honest, and talented Indians community is affected.

Yeah I'm Canadian with a lot of health issues yeah you don't have to pay but sometimes the wait can be long like 21 hours at the emergency + the time to see the er doc and if you need tests that would make it longer. Just recently my waiting time was 16 hours. I live in Ontario and we get a lot of Quebec people because their waiting time can be way much longer.

Please Madame Palki, pay your taxes correctly to the government, talk about the corruption in India, and improve the purchasing power of all Indians and and then all the country in the world will open the red carpet for our Indians, a country with lot of multi millionaires but still lot of people suffering, please touch your heart and ask this questions to you.......

Most embassy earn more by visa rejection since you have to pay for submission.

I was not a big admirer of previous govts. work but this govt I can say with utmost believe that our ranking has gone down in major areas like the media, democratic institutions, income inequality, Passport ranking. Corruption. Ye log census tak nahi kara paye batao sare decision 2011 ke base pe lete hai. Fir uper se log ko blind kar diya fake nationalism se ki hum bahut developed ho gaye hai lekin haal wahi fatichar hai ?

Why is india not asking for visas to enter the country? Especially from developed countries like UK, EU, US. India should atleast ask for tourist tax from foreigners. Many EU countries impose tourist tax from tourists. Today we see many foreigners making youtube videos of Indians to make money. Pay tax for the money earned in India

Take a good look at yourself and thats why the rejection. The price to pay for being Numbawan?

how about indians entering countries on visitor visas and staying illegally ... so 1st and foremost we need to mend our ways \nlot of people are after easy money or some fake illusion of luxurious life abroad without putting hard yards in ... fact is most of these idiots end up selling their ancestral properties or forcing parents to take unfavorable loans in search of their world of fantasies .\nMy advice to all such people skill up and work on yourself you will be able to live your life with dignity irrespective of where you are either in India or abroad . Most people don't know the everyday struggles of illegal immigrants .... they are never respected hard to find white collar jobs and end up working overtime and highly underpaid (employers mostly desis/indians takes advantage of their situation and pay them less than minimum wages ) for sake of putting bread on dinner table for your family .\n\nPS : I am not discouraging anyone from seeking opportunity abroad but cautioning against using illegal means .Do it legally and live a life of dignity .

Sorry as a British born Indian I must say this when Indians from the motherland come it pushes down the salary we natives get as big companies pay Indians from India less than natives. It is a massive problem for us local people??????? I am a proud Indian but I am also a proud Brit from my lovely west country, 80s born. We have too much illegal and legal immigration and it is a problem for us natives.

Tell the truth. \nIndians violate VISA rules.\nThey take a student visa and then run off and find jobs at a low pay.\nOther people don't like that.

Indian news reporting is almost like ccp news - both want to push only good news but life & reality isnt so idealistic if it was there wid b no need for govts ! The purpose of a democracy is to highlight the weaknesses to get those in power per state to be held accountable & correct it to benefit the ppl. Indias education system is deplorable from content ( outdated ) to language skills. As a ex European colony there is english , portuguese & french - the no. Of campuses being built ? In covid sitharaman made a big thing inda budget for correspondence campuses & distance learning what happened ? 1 of indias greatest exports was its intellectual capital many that hold top global posts graduated from iit & others - the indian that saved nokia hails from an indian institute along with so many others on a long list many eirk for spaceX & nasa so the break is obvious & is getting wider as more indians in the lower economic scale aim to make babies like a production factory then expect givt to dole out free food , guaranteed jobs & education etc ! When too much is tsken out for social welfare vs the amt put in - u hve a problem ! A ticking time bomb. In the u.k most billionaires live outside to avoid paying crazy taxes to feed & clothe paki grooming gangs & the royal family & india is heading that way ! A recent report from china observer showed that china has held back on foxconn employees going to india for what ? To teach indians ! Now foxconn has to get taiwanese ppl to go to india to teach staff otherwise it wont meet its targets.

Indian govt must grow some kahoonas and reciprocate the same conditions and hoops for tourists from usa, UK, Australia, nz, Europe that are subjected on indians. Its incredible how foreign tourists are allowed to do other things and get away scot free. Bjp is celebrating us soil in Bengaluru which speaks volumes of their commitment to indian pride and hypocrisy. The least india can do is ask for the visa fees back or atleast part of it. With a failed judiciary, corrupt real estate, benami rule, failed police , failed education, children are being born into state and central debt. Who is going to pay for the endless borrowing ? No sane aspiring youth would choose to live in this mess.

This is why we need Trump to clean this up!! It's a disaster. And where are they all gonna go? How they going to make money and who pays for their care?? We do! Insane. Just so upsetting

I tell you in New Delhi there is special section of the city that dedicated to students going overseas. They make fake documents and fake college degrees and fake passports and fake visas. You just go and pay the guy ₹5000 and your process to come to Canada.

No tennant has to go thru this? You dont even pay rent. Youre squatting in this man condo.

Yeah they may have small business but they have to be vetted and with the courts approval if they want this hear and been approved rhey will have to pay a fine because it is illegal to cross into this country illegally.second part the will have to pay back taxes . They will have to get green cards this will be a great cost and if they cant psy then they need to be deported asap

He is calm n will be calm, he knows he is working, we INDIANS work hard pay taxes, what is the problem with these people.

You can have a baby in Canada and walk out of hospital with 0 amount to pay!!!

The idiots are pushing away law abiding highly skilled immigrants who love Canadian culture for Uber drivers and Tim Hortons worker who barely pay taxes to support social services.

Wake up Indian parents the money you are paying is a joke. The education has no value. Better to stay and get a degree back home with experience.

These students came for an education. You accepted the terms of that student visa and should thereby adhere to those terms. Many countries do offer jobs to international students who excel in their studies if there are available positions in that field that Canadians can not fill. It is Indian recruiters who have sold the residency idea both in India and Canada. It is these recruters that teach them how to defraud our systems and take your money. If you think about it, how many successful companies hire people with strip mall college certificates in high paying jobs.\n\nWho they should be protesting against are their recruiters who sold them this illusion, not our government. There are processes for residency, not privileges.

Google says the average cost to have a child (give birth) in the USA is $18,865. This would translate to $27,207.10 CAD at the time I'm writing this comment. Basically, a year of minimum wage take home pay. Very few people would find that amount of money easy to deal with.\n\nIn Canada it's not only free, but the government pays you monthly amounts if your income is less than what they deem enough to provide for them. This amount can be significant and continues until the child is 19.

you couldn't pay me to live there and I have no interest in visiting the USA

(1) Motherhood: I was flabbergasted when I found out that people have to pay to give birth in the US - even though they have some of the worst maternity outcomes in the developed world

You also pay extra if you use a Qtip or bandaid!!!!!!

Two Serious questions from a Canadian, \n1. If you pay for health insurance, why do you have to pay to see a doctor? \n2. If you have private health care insurance, how long of a wait do you have in the ER?

Government should pay then

Due to indians swarmed canada like grasshopper pooing the beaches dishonouring environment which was made clean by paying billions. But undians font care they are keeping their poo and pee jobs

I came to Canada from India as an international student, worked hard to pay my tuition, and earned permanent residency through the express entry points system. It wasn’t easy—I had to balance studies, work, and adapting to a new country.\n\nI understand concerns about immigration, and yes, some take advantage of the system. Part of the issue lies in the aggressive marketing of the “Canadian dream” by certain colleges and recruiters in India, exploiting vulnerable people and leading to misuse of Canada’s policies.\n\nI also recognize frustrations with those who protest after failing to meet the points or hire only friends instead of deserving candidates, even if they’re from my country. But that doesn’t mean we’re all the same. Just as Hitler and Anne Frank were both Germans, nationality doesn’t define character.\n\nIndia is incredibly diverse, and judging an entire group based on the actions of a few is deeply unfair. Experiencing racism simply because of where I’m from is heartbreaking. I hope we can move past stereotypes and see people for who they truly are.

Canada is in crisis, politically, economically and financially. Our health care system is hanging on by a thread. The Crime Minister Justa Traitor has served his WEF masters well in dismantling this once great nation. We are hardly in a position to except legal immigrants never mind illegal ones. To anyone who wants to jump the line, break the rules and take up space otherwise desperately needed by law abiding, hard working, life long tax paying Canadian citizens I say, no way Jose!

Please Guys I need help\n,if my 1 year tuition is 20,000 cad and I’ve paid 10k cad already for my first semester tuition.\n\nDo I demonstrate a balance of 10k cad + 20,635 living expenses?\n\nOr\n\n20,000 Cad + 20,635 living expenses\n\ndespite paying half of it already.

?????? This is Mexico fault letting thin pass through their country. They want this to happen. Trump should make Mexico pay for letting them pass through their country. Trump should stop Mexico foreign aid of 600 million dollar a year until all illegal are deported back to Mexico. The way Mexico received them by letting them in their country. Now they should have no issue receiving them back from the US. ??????

Canadians live on average 5 years longer than Americans because we have affordable healthcare...AGAIN...IT IS NOT FREE...even our politicians need to stop saying it's free...WE ARE TAXED TO PAY FOR IT...and most of us are absolutely okay with that system....well the billionaire class isn't of course...but they don't count.

It's unfair to those who pay legally just to get their family member here in the US. So yes to deported illegal immigrants.

this shit make me dont want to pay taxes

Need to if not pay rent 2 months then Woner charge look like Bussnes system

Liberals find common sense, only when they have to pay for it, feel it, and see it

Homelessness in Canada and US is because of high property tax and because of very high inheritance tax. Indians would rather come back to India and live in their negligible property tax homes which they inherit from their parents without paying any tax on their inheritance than to stay homeless in Canada. Or homelessness is because of high price of land and redtapism in making a home for yourself in the west which is not the case in India.

if the customer says he’s going to pay in cash why would you not bring change???? scammers all of them lmfao

I don't believe their numbers on fake/real refugees and asylums. We have noticed a real change, and for that to happen, it has to be more people. Many of these people are not assimilating, nor are they following our laws. We also have the students who need to leave protesting as if they have rights. Many of them never even went to schools, and they broke laws coming in by paying to have LMIA's. It will take years to course correct, if it does at all

Thank God for our Us Border patrol and thank God for Trump. I don’t understand why these people don’t fight this hard to change their own government. Everyone wants to come here and get a free ride off of the taxes that we pay. What about our homeless and hungry,they should be taken care of first!!!!! I have a heart, but do it the right now. God watch over our country,we need you Lord to stop this madness?

I wouldn’t be the customer from hell about it. But I would politely tell the delivery guy that I’m not accepting or paying unless he can break a 20.

My daughter was born in philippines in usd was only 1,200 vs America not pay 10 k

I think it’s going to impossible to do this … because who is going to pay for this process.. just charge a fee to process whatever needs to be processed and make them legal … then move on..

We need these people in our country working and paying into social security so that we don't have to lower the funding

Yes! Yes! Yes!! End birthright citizen's!! These moochers come in through a hole in the fence and expect us taxpayers to pay for the to give birth and then get automatic citizenship..NO MORE!!!