Close Reading

Canada should stop bringing millions of people from India.

India is a country where most of the people are right winged but expect leftist treatment from foreigners

Actually she's isn't wrong if indians start taking over jobs and properties or businesses in canada where will the natives go? It's their country so they have the right to speak up if your presence or actions is hurting them atleast she didn't abuse you she was honest about the problem she and her family might be facing because of indians and indian government should bs ashamed that every year massive amounts of indians abandon their citizenship and settle in other countries spreading like a virus engulfing opportunities that the natives deserved... So if u get hate for that... You can either be shameless and bare it or have some shame and return to your country give the natives some releif.... Put yourself in their place for a second and think...even in india Mumbai used to be peacefull and clean all those beautiful beaches... As soon as people from other states were allowed to settle in Maharashtra they overpopulated the state making it very conjusted for natives....indians especially the sanatani community once they spread beyond a limit in a country they try to force their ideologies on the natives thus ruining the peacefull environment and now even the indian government seems to be involved in a murder of some sikh guy which was expected considering the hate for sikhs they spread here in india which is how they win elections...

Indians have the mkst racist mind and culture in the world. \nIts 2024 and still people are been atracked tortured and killed in india in rhe name of colour and Caste. \nIndia needs to throw away such a hateful culture and learn how to live like a human being.

The root cause of bitterness between Canada and India is Canada sheltering Khalistani extremists who have known history of violence, assassinations, bombings. These Khalistani extremists have now formed a state within state and have progressed from influencing internal politics to Canada’s foreign policy using their mass mobilization and fund raising capabilities. No wonder they got away with blowing up Air India plane killing 329 people. There are very serious cases pending against some Khalistani extremists in India even as they continue to foment trouble in Indian Punjab using family ties. India is naturally worried. Canada has disdainfully rejected India’s repeated requests. There are 26 Extradition requests pending with Canada since decades. It is India which is aggrieved party, not Canada. This is underlying issue which is causing bitterness.

CANADA DOES NOT NEED INDIA- INDIA NEEDS TO EXPORT ITS SURPLUS PEOPLE TO CANADA.

They are Canadian terrorist because they are Canadian citizen's who involved directly several incident in India but Canada called it activist ?? Dozens of people are most wanted man of india.

1:01 this man was terrorist wanted in india by NIA and welcomed as hero in Canada. All kind of wanted people around the world find safe harbour in Canada or America

Indians are tasting their own bitter medicine,if he’s a Hindu.lots of Muslim Indians has been & are still treating like they don’t belong to India.in their opinion,India is only for Hindus & others are outsiders.they call Muslims Pakistanis,north-east peoples Chinese,Korean,Japanese..\nThat’s why western countries treat them brutally..

British created separatism issue between India and Pakistan. Now that is getting settled so now their Canada (controlled by Britain) creating new separatism movement and this time they are using Sikhs. See the pattern! If Canada interested in Sikhs having their own homeland, give them a piece of their country and move everyone who wants from India to there. Anyway these people don't live in India and they are not Indians.

Too many now and people are sick of these brown roaches coming from a dirty, polluted, corrupt, backward and their leader meanwhile proclaims India as supoerpower, trillion GDP, world #3 economy. Stay in India and go suck Modi and the cows. Brown roach infestation

Though he doesnt belong to canada still he claims he is canadian n here in India people with dirty mind says their fellows to go to any other country which doesnt belong to them inorder to satisfy their grudges for them..karma faced by ours outside then?

Nobody cares much about either country but India is getting China level cocky. Cut the number of Indian students coming to study and allow them to more friendly people such as Vietnam or countries in Africa.

I am from India and accept that my government has been criminal in this event.\nCanada should present its evidence to the ICJ and have our PM Modi tried for a war crime and whoever else was linked in this incident.\nMy country is going in the direction of Russia and China. And, like those two countries, the crimes are cheered by the citizens.\nSuch countries and people have no place in civil society.

people are missing the main point... YOU CAN'T KILL A CANADIAN CITIZEN ON CANADIAN SOIL - it doesn't matter if you disagree with that person's beliefs or are against the Khalistan movement. The move by India was a direct attack on Canada's sovereignty

Canada with is 41 million people is equivalent to a Municipal Corporation of India. Let that sink in first! Justin is like a mayor for us. Too insignificant to get noticed

Indian GDP per capita is $2,731. Canadian GDP per capita is 55,000 per year. INDIA IS A DIRT POOR shithole, meanwhile Canada is rich. That is why Indian students are trying to get into Canada to study. People in India still have to defecate in the streets.

The Khalistani terrorists and supporters have had funded to Trudeau govt. and some of the western media to make this propaganda against India. Meanwhile the Canadian people don't have hope in Trudeau govt. Trudeau will lose his upcoming elections. The Trudeau is a mouth piece of the terrorist gang, he's raising this issue to divert Canadian people mindset to a different dimension so that he gains sympathy.

Please extradite the 26+ people wanted by India. Why has the RCMP and Canadian Govt. been sitting on that request without any action? This govt. took no action and is now conveniently shifting the blame. You'll probably get cooperation from the Indian govt. if you take the hate speech occurring on our soil here in Canada more seriously!

Obviously i never met somebody fresh outta India, lol coming thru an embassy\nSo its not that i dispute Justins Claim just\nthe two Sihks i knew were alright people.\nOne even try help me when i was depressed so.\nback when i was 19 or 20 or something. or 21, or 22 or whatever i dont remember specificially\n\nThey also provided help during Covid as a community. So.\nTheres that aswell.

It's funny how we as Indians hate when Bangladeshi/Nepali/Pakistani people move to India but play the victim card when it happens to us in some other country?

In India almost everyone is a victim of racism.\nBihar people\nSC ST OBC\nNorth east people\nMuslim\nChristian\nAlso poor people in general\n\nThis is 80 % to 85% of Indias population. \n\nI personally have given up on India.

She is right. Being an Indian I have faced discrimination in Maharashtra originating from Uttar Pradesh. My fellow north east friends face discrimination everyday across India. \nWe Indians ourselves are the most discriminating people.

Same things happen with bihari,UP jharkhand people in south , maharshtra. In India we guys discriminate these people and outside they does to us . \nI'm not justifying anything.

I am indian I know how it feels when someone take over mine... We hated Britishers for taking over stuff... In many states in India people doesn't like other States people when they take over... Mumbai is good example... I understand her concerns... We are human and that's a raw feeling what she showed...

I mean she isn't wrong though. People are tired of immigrants. This is what happens when we run away instead of fixing the country. India should have controlled the population post independence now we seeing the aftermath of it

Lets be practical here lets assume same situation happened in india i am sure some indians would also have been behaved exactly like that way but people just remember one thing it takes generations to be a part of that country it cannot happen just by changing passport enjoy that country and help those countries for giving opportunities but don't forget to come to india if you get persecuted bcoz in india u r us no katter what

anti-India? stop playing a victim card. the real victims here are other people who live in Canada.

Even the white folks over there is invader over 100 years ago , folks from India came with at least with visa ?. The Canadian ?? land ( if she say candan white country) from Canadian indigenous people.

The lady is not wrong though. Imagine millions of people from another country came to settle here in India. I mean like. We will feel the same way..

Even I feel why Indians have to migrate. Live a respectable life back home instead of making people outside uncomfortable in there on land. Nobody like there population dynamics changing in front of there eyes. \n\nI can see in India. Indians do not like seeing Nigerians around them, they they do no rent there homes to them. Basically these immigrants are getting taste of their own medicine. I would suggest shut up live low life or come back home.

I personally believe her concern is right.\n\nIn future white people may come settle in India and their children will be known as Indians.\nWe need to protect every kind of races.\nThis land of Bharatvarsh belongs to Arya people similarly all the land should be for their orginal people only.\n\nEDIT : I know Native Americans are the real inhabitants of USA but in terms of race they are similar to modern Americans.\n\nRegarding Aryan migration theory, it is just a hypothesis and not a proven fact.\nWe can't 100% say that Arya are outsiders.\nThere's no literary or archeological evidence that proves it.\nThere is *Out of India* theory to explain the DNA & language similarities.

But ,why sikh community want to protest against india while leaving in canada ? If they really wants solution then come to india and talk to government. Why need to involve other nation government in our country matters ? If someone country people migrat to our performing protect then how it feels us . Firstly think what is write or wrong

I mean the native tribals must be arguing that the great continent their ancestors knew back 400 years ago is not feeling whatever they called it back then. Funnily enough I have a deep sympathy about the immigration crisis in UK and all of Europe. But this is weirdly hillarious. Sorry I know I don't understand the issue enough. But isn't canada a country made up by immigrants just like USA. Its not like you actually got mixed with natives like Portuguese and Spanish colonisers did in south america. And canada has what? 20 million people for all that land. Bro it is inevitable people coming to these lands wont be lily whites like you hope to. I agree that all people being from India is very suspicious and I feel there might be some invincible hand behind this. Can the central government intervene if proved there is something fishy going on. I mean concentrating in a single city instead of spreading in the country to find job oppurtunities doesn't make sense from my POV.

Canada is still better than India in many aspects, more safe for women, healthcare is free, clean country with low pollution, lots of beautiful parks, most people are tolerant, crime rate is low, multicultural, standard of living is high, Canadian passport allows you to travel easily, gov pension, lots of opportunities, i was able to change my career at 50 and became a private investigator, i was born and raised in India.

Come to London Ontario to do a video next. \nWe have a 5-8 year waiting list for subsidized housing and our own citizens are having to compete with in Huge increase of people from India who come on a student Visa and then drop out and just stay. They are buying up entire subdivisions and businesses. There is not one Subway in London that is not Indian run and if you order any food or package it is guaranteed an Indian is delivering it. And when they buy these businesses they change the food menus to better suit their tastes and Only hire other Indians. If white people did that it would be considered racism and highly illegal. \nThey also go out in large groups of only young men, of course, and do not care about our culture whatsoever and are entitled and Extremely rude. I guess they feel they Can be like this because they will soon outnumber Canadian born citizens. \nIt’s a disgrace that the Canadian government has Sold Out Canada and our Canadian values. \nI’m sure in time we will no longer Be Canada, they will change the name appropriately to India 2.

Within India, there is immigration from north to South. And, you don't need any passport or Visa to immigrate within the states of India. Bangalore, an important city in South India s Karnataka State is brimming with people from the North. The Kannadigas become the minority in their own state. The population of Tamils in the state of Tamilnadu is shrinking. In another 50 years north Indians will dominate South India. So, all over the world , the adverse side effects of immigration are felt. People from overpopulated regions have been migrating to less populated are for resources, from Europe to America, and now Asia to Europe and north America. There was, is, and will be murmurs, hiccups and clashes leading to violence. Animals resist their own species, crossing their borders, so are men. This is the bitter truth, take it with a pinch of salt.

I believe that Indian students can get good education in India. It appears that recruiters simply want to make money out of young people who have not really thought the issue through.

It's amazing how the people in comments are like there must be another part of the story with absolutely no regard for the part of the story they actually saw here in this clip. Way to go colonial India, way to go. Kudos to these young brown brits that grew up in India, the North Korea of South Asia.

Also right now, India and Canada are nto international friends. India sends some people here to kill a Canadian citizen, and gets caught red handed doing it. India is doing a hell of a job dealing with its Muslim population and their leader is a populist asshat. He talks like Trump and offers little in return except to find scapegoats. Then that BS is brought here, along with a lot of daily life cultural garbage. \n\nSo yeah. A lot of Canadians want Indians to leave. And it sucks for Indians who come here out of good faith and excellent intention. But it's not enough. The negatives are far outweighing the positives. Yeah. Send'em home.

If tim hortons need more people from india why tim horton dont move to india so the can serve the garbege they give to canadian people so give to indians and hire as much you want but not here.

I am so sorry, as a native Canadian, that Indians are feeling attacked. It is difficult, no matter your ethnic background, if you are not Indian to even acknowledge these issues because people are afraid of being labelled as racist so I thank you for bringing this topic up. Please understand this is the result of runaway immigrations with no real screening. The government quadrupled immigration, hundreds of percents increase in students, asylum seekers, and illegal entries, even though there was already a housing crisis, and a completely predictable doctor shortage due to aging out. Covid was just starting to get under control but many still needed treatment and BOOM, the population went from 30 million in 2014 to over 40 million in a decade, most of it in the last 3 years. We native Canadians are scratching our heads, we don't understand what the Liberals are trying to accomplish but to create suspicion and racism between groups of people -- divide and conquer? Maybe...but ultimately it is a complete lack of planning! Still 99 percent of Canadian born do not blame Iindividual ndians for this. I've lived and worked with Indians my entire life of over 60 years. There are now Indian gangs, particularly Punjabi gangs because of lack of oversight, and while they are small they are constantly committing crimes, selling drugs, shooting people all in the last few years. I hear gun shots nightly in my ethnically mixed neighbourhood, and we are all afraid to walk at night. Unfortunately the people arrested are mostly from continental India. Some have a political agenda that has to do more with India than Canada, so they recruit young Indo-Canadian children from good families and tell them they are being oppressed, and next thing these kids are acting as drug mules and enforcers, being told that they are fighting systemic racism. As for dancing and music, I love the cultural events, we are happy to see and even take part in Indian cultural events. IWhen I do hear people blaming India and Indians it breaks my heart too! Hopefully together we can fix this. Our governments are at odds, and I hate this -- they need to respectfully talk and work this out. You are good neighbours, good people, you are welcome here and have helped build Canada in so many positive ways. ?

I am sorry to say. This is not India problem. This is a Punjab problem. I have a few rentals and these peoples from Punjab and North India ( delhi, haryana, UP) especially young ones don't follow any rules, they think they can do whatever they want and aren't afraid of laws.

That is great what primer minister. Trudeau is doing right now it's the right thing since Canada is population is being outnumbered by immigrants from India and the Philippines in every city where barely you will see a Canadian native or an English speaking people i think it's time for them to go home ?? ??

India was robbed of 43 trillion dollars from the British which is considered the greatest crime in history. You can’t exploit a country get rich off a country and then blame the people of the country.

India needs to fix the population problem first and fix the problems in the country so their people will stay there otherwise in a 100 years there will be 2.4 billion people and they will keep moving to other countries like Canada and Canada’s population could then be like 1.4 billion ?

To start with India needs to do something about their population problem or else hundred years from now India will have 2.4 billion people it will be a mess for India and half of them will be running away to other countries like Canada

You crossed the line. So what if lots of brown people moved here from India? They are hard working people who want the opportunity for a better life. \nThis video is offensive. \nShame on you, unfortunately you have justified the MSM accusations of racism.

Why? I like and respect so many individual Indians, but governments are using people from India as if they are stacks of timber to make a profit off of and they're flooding into Western communities in larger numbers. My friends in India would feel the very same way if the roles were reversed ( a nod to irony here regarding British interference in India.) Respect to Indians. Yet we do have a problem in the West with overwhelming #s

This is the attitude that people face in India from these kind of officials, but even coming to a foreign country their behaviour does not change, the reason being a free hand given to these officials by the Politicians in India to openly abuse their power