Close Reading

I am Sikh Punjab\nI love my india

pls check the Punjab Debt figure. I think its wrong. Recently CM has requested Governor to ask Center for help. If I recall its somewhere in 300 cr debt.

m from Punjab n I know 90% Sikhs r very nice n true patriot..we all live happily here n Congress should apologise..????

Idk bro first mughal attacked Punjabis than English came along but when so called India was formed Punjab was divided into two halves by sm Hindustanis like it was their property even after border massacre we thought it will be ok but nah how sm Hindustani acted and participated in genocide of sikhs in Delhi and whole of India..... you think we can trust them even though land locked separated Punjab is not economically viable but still it will give us sm our protected space from cowards from both sides?

U are the only person who split the fact bro❤. I really wanted that someone make this type of video. since last 2-3 weeks many Indian YouTubers making wrong vedios for Punjab and Punjabi’s. Nobody tell the truth what is the actual point.

Hindu majority of Hindi belt has been radicalised fully now. Sikhs don’t want to risk lives of their sons and daughters by allowing them live outside Punjab. Since all Sikh youth can’t get desired jobs in Punjab, they prefer Canada Australia UK countries. Non Hindus does not want to risk their lives in Hindu Rastrawadi states.

Sir you are you really trute to Punjab

Very well researched..Such things need to be shared in mainstream media to derail the propaganda run by the Anti India elements...Sikhs are one of the most patriotic communities in the country. People should refrain of relating them to Khalistan..\n\nMoreover, It's high time for Indian Govt to focus on issues faced by Punjab so that Punjabis can have more confidence in them and they don't get the feeling of being discriminated.

The entire secessionist movement started after green revolution as local leadership sought to consolidate more power, which led to various poor decision from partition of state to emergence of khalistan sentiment. Punjab is paying the price of poor local leadership but the hate against center is so strong that it makes them overlook the path of destruction punjab is on.

Kejriwal ji ke blue print for growth of Punjab ka kaya hua

Incomplete information about Punjab issues main issues ignored

Most of the punjabi people started leave india after 1984 …. WTF your research you sit in Mumbai and Delhi and don’t know about Punjab and make video with your own facts to make other people bebkooof…. ?

Bro maine ragister kr dia hai but ye whatsapp group use kaise krna hai admin ke bina koi msg nhi kr skta na hum koi question pooch skte hain maine Blog channel start kia hai historical places ka uske liye khud mein improvement krni hai so please agar koi or application hai vo btado mujhe app ke jaisa banna hai app perfect ho main youtubers mein ek apka or ek Dhruv bhai ka hi fan hun aap dono ki videos dekh dekh kr hi maine video bnana start shuru kia hai help jroo kreo bro Love❤ from Punjab bigfan???

As a Haryanvi we have always respected Punjab as our elder brother. But these khalishtanis making it a big deal now. Here people are now losing all the respect they had for Punjab. I wish this tension come to an end soon.

Only Punjab, Rajasthan, Kashmir and Bengal were divided during Indian Partition without asking And People from that side are still suffering It remains on heart and Mind many years and generations after

Hats off to this guy. He is giving such detailed information. I always had proud emotions for Sikh community but this recent case disturbed me a little. However we are so lucky to have sikhs in India. Punjab should receive more help and support from government

We really appreciate your work and dedication . love you nitish bro from punjab❤❤❤❤❤

❤ from punjab ??

I'm from Haryana hindu. ( necessary to tell) \nOnly punjab was divided , your people punjabis were killed both side. How can a leader divide us without our consent. \nIn 1980-90 sikho ko mara gya kuki unka sar par pagg thi. Unka upar reward rakha jata tha ki 1 sikh ko marna pa 5,000-10, 000 & ispa bonus bhi milta tha. \nAbhi tak koi justice nhi mila? \nBhindrawala na kbhi khalistan ki mang nhi ki thi usna punjab ki avaj uthai thi, anandpur sahib resolution rakha tha unona. \nKhalistan ki mang sikho ki genocide ka baad hui thi. \nKPS Gill ko Punjab sa bhar vala logg bhot acha manta ha par vo general dyer sa bhi ghatiya tha, kitna sikho ko mara usna jo bilkul durr tha khalistan movement sa.

Waah I am from Punjab almost what Nitish said is right

SIKHs are Crown ? of India ?? Punjab can be into top 5 economy of India if they Elect Good Government and educate his youth

Two solutions for this.\n1. Punish who was involved in 1984.\n2. Fast sustainable and diversified Economic Growth of Punjab State.

Being a Punjabi, i do not want to leave Punjab, the people are Loving, the area is surreal and everything is like... YE TOH APNA HAI! but you have to, cause there is no oppurtunity. I am hoping that i can go back to my hometown and just relax there if the job scene is improved. BTW i am a Hindu and i have NEVER faced discrimination, yes we joke and call each other NAMES, but we as Punjabis be it SIKH or a HINDU, we never even ask the last name of the other person. That is PUNJAB for you.

Well explained bhai lot's of love and respect from punjab

This is very well put together. Is there any validity in the fact that the reason that the anger from 84 has quieted down in Punjab is because the government cracks down any negative info on it? People are jailed with no court case, people are tortured in jail, people are murdered? Could this be a reason?

Punjab issue and Khalistan ko separate dikhane ke liye thank you…. Hindutvavaadi to Punjab issues ko Khalistani se link krke demean kr dete hai ….

Now you understand Why BJP is not that interested in Punjab due to these all problems.. because if something wrong happens then opposition directly blame BJP Govt.. instead they give away that to AAP which is not at all qualify for managing a state.. they introduce free schemes to win election but not for develop a state.. I suggest BJP should take matter in to their hand and show some courage to deal with this, after all Punjab is part of Bharat... also there are always good people and bad people.. we always hear bravery and sacrifice done by punjabi and Sikh people but some negative people in community ruined that image.. love and respect to hard working Sikh community and hope for the peace and respect to them...

Superb analysis. Hope you will touch base upon punjab other issues such as 'Drugs' and 'Gangwar' as well in your part 2. Thank you

Punjab has generated more revenue than Haryana this fiscal year according to CAG... ❤❤

This was the exact situation which I explain my friends. I hope every person who has watched the video might get a little idea of the current situation of Punjab and Sikhs. And I must say that majority of Sikhs loves India and doesn’t support the Khalistan Ideology. But I still hope that Sikhs who suffered in 1984 must get justice (because delayed justice has brought some people with disappointment) and there should be more development in the State of Punjab.

Can you explain why the several languages in India are slowly being wiped out and Hindi is strictly being enforced? Such as in Punjab and south India

Wow ?.. well explained. I was reallly curious about Khalistan and punjab . Thank you ?

Bai beant singh ke bare me punjab me ja ke ptaa kro kya kia tha usne ese hi bolna asaaan h jinke beksoor bche mare kbi unse milo

Ooo punjab main aoo dekho…\nTumne 84 ki video banai kabhi kk punjab ko insaaf milna chahiyee? \n\nTum log itna hi punjab ko pyaar krte ho to banaoo na video…

Punajbi ke police officers ko keu mara tha talwinder singh ne????\n\nKeunki wo log fake encounters krke promotions le rahe the, unse koi cross question bhi nhi ho raha tha..\n\nKitne sikh mare punjab police ne delhi ke order pe

I like Your videos . \nCouple of things to be corrected: Double check the data of wheat production share of punjab. Second the soil was not great , in 60s-70s it was people of punjab who worked day night to make it cultivatable. It was not only grain. Then these people moved to utrakhand and UP. They did the same.

As a Sikh living in canada now i could say all all your facts are true...Punjab needs stable political situation and development......

Thank u nitish bhai. Bringing the facts out. We as punjab have 100problms from govt. But khalistan aint one.

THE BIGGEST REASON FOR SIKH MIGRATION DURING 84 PERIOD WAS FAKE ENCOUNTERS DONE BY PUNJAB POLICE UNDER KPS GILL AND CM BEANT SINGH.

Great job n great research by the Nitish Rajput's team. This is 100% true, most of the people migrated to Canada in 80s-90s remember punjab negatively. Most of the news these people hear is through the indian media houses which very negative. They expect the same rights from indian government as they get from Canadian government. Most of the Khalistani supporting got active because of ruling party politics where a regular sikhs whose son, brother n father served in indian army and marines is called Khalistani without any reason. This has definitely created a divide in society, and media houses are also spreading the negativity towards a community. \n\nWahi baat h ki Modi is not india n humei ni pasand uski politics. Doesn't mean ki hum anti nationalist hogye or we hate modi. Bhai nahi pasand humei politics jo society mei divide kre. First thing a sikh child is taught is that everyone is equal. Ab tum fundamentals attack kroge toh humei ni pasand ayega.

I m from punjab bhai First thing is yeh ki Opportunities km hai agr log common lok bi ate hai ki job kre kaam kre \n\nBut Now as the hell like condition is developed here Or age kisi ko bi sach bi btaye to log bolte hai ki khud to chlegye hume ane se rok rhe hai And \n2nd is Nowdays most of the cities have Zero to no jobs available \nBoht struggle hai So just if any one coming learn some skills mind body prepare krke ao ki you can survive here ♥️?\n\nWELCOME JO BI AA RHA HAI

Sahi kaha.. Punjab ki problems ko khalistan ka naam de rhi hai sarkar

What about migration in punjab from up bihar?

Why Khalistanis (not Indian Sikhs) dont demand greater punjab from Pakistan and hold protests against them etc..as more of geographical punjab and birth place of Guru Nanak ji i.e. nankana sahib and 18 years of his last preaching is in kartarpur, Pakistan ?

I am not Sikh but I did my high school and college in Punjab. The Sikh community is most lovable and welcoming people I have ever seen in my life. Punjabis are proud Indians.

Slowly every state is turning into punjab in terms of migration

27:43 Well said nitish, I hope this video helps to create awareness. I recently shared some views on Akash Banerjee’s video who has a good and sensible audience like u. But still there were lots of people who were ready to put the terrorist tag without even reading the comment. And i feel people need to realise that punjabi youth can not remain silent on the issues concerning punjab and its growth, and if tgey question government and are not happy with their work it doesn’t make them anti national. Also, people feel that distributing these anti national labels is helping our nation, but in reality it is becoming the main cause why communities are separating from each other.

Farm bill was introduced to deal with agriculture problem of punjab. But the jat sikh who own 80 percent of land opposed it for their own benefit and also stated support to khalistan to fight against modi. These sikh abuse modi who is very normal about sikh community and respect them but they don't deserve it. I personally met with sikh who are more pr khalistan and anti hindu in general. They will support khalistan for their own benefits and its normal if we see in obc community along the country suppprting fragmentation of nation for their own reservation based on proportion

I am from Punjab .....thanks Nitish sir ....thanks from the bottom of heart of Punjab ....

Ek bar BJP ko Ana chahiye Punjab main Sara khalistanipan nikal jayega inka?