Close Reading

How dare they make demands. Their actions prove they shouldn't stay.

Who in the right mind would come to Canada to study paying so much money in student tuition and not hope to become a citizen? It’s not their fault that they’ve been scammed out of money and now kicked out of the country because of poor administrative decisions. \n\nDual intent (of studying and wanting to stay) is completely legal and worked for decades. I don’t see any issues here. \n\nInstead of criticizing the actions of the government officials of screwing this up in the first place, it’s a shame to see you demonize the poor international students that have been defrauded in the first place.

Yes sometimes your illegaal actions have consequences. So that is on your own account.

Regarding Khalistan nationalists, Harrison failed to mention that Maxime Bernier, the People’s Party of Canada leader is the only party leader not to pander to Sikh nationalists. Maxime said: “I am certainly concerned that relations between India and Canada are in danger of deteriorating because of Canada's official indifference towards the actions and rhetoric of Sikh radical militants in my country,” He also said: “I believe Canada should not get involved in internal conflicts in India, and our government and political leaders should stop pandering to extremists in order to get votes.” He is the only one of our party leaders who ever served as Canada’s top diplomat; he was Foreign Affairs Minister under PM Harper.

Marc Miller is fooling Canadians.And vote bank politics in action! More temporary workers, more future voters for the Liberals and NDP!!

They should be treated as others diaspora communities. If Gov. do not justify these action crimes will unstoppable like immigrants issue and housing issue.

THOUGHT EXPERIMENT: If 100K Canadian students went to India for university and demanded the same rights these Indian students are wanting, what would the Modi government's actions be? Methinks fire hoses and tear gas would be the answer. Non citizens visiting in any country have no ***RIGHT** to be in the country they are a guest in. They have alternatives, like going home and enriching their own native lands.

Well we all know Arabs are not united by their own actions BUT Palestinians should not have to leave and us Jews should promote Israel STOPPING the war unless Hamas strikes again

He’s super cute ❤❤❤ Whomever he’s with is very lucky. He’s got perfect control over his actions.

his words sounds like they know the issue, if actions backed it up, could make a difference.

Canadian Government's discriminatory actions towards the Chinese who were brought over to Canada to build their national railways in 1881-1884 and this graph proves this fact !\n1885-1900: 0485-4107 The Chinese Immigration Act invokes a $50 head tax on Chinese immigrants (equivalent to $1,576 in 2021)\n1900-1923 4107-38133 The Head Tax was increased to $500 (equivalent to $16,200 in 2021) equivalent to a two-year salary of an immigrant worker at that time !\n1923-1947 38133-29955 The Chinese Exclusion Act

The hypocrisy of the whites in the comment section is so telling. The mew immigrants didnt kill your family. Didnt steal your children, abuse them in all way possible and bury them. As a first nations person, haha karma is a b….h. Enjoy the consequences of your ancestors action. You think god would ignore the cruelty you dealt?

well he did not tell really why. Look at what happen in Jordan and Lebanon because of the PLO. Jordans were forced to take military actions against the PLO to force them to leave, and lebanon got into a civil war that marked them until now. The palestinians they took bare arms against them, so some arab nations can be against it but won't really say it is because they don't want to face those circumstances again.\nAnd he is totally right, it their homes so nothing forces them to become refugees anyway. It has its consequences for sure

I'm reading a lot of peoples problems here and I keep asking myself why has all our systems in this country keep failing us? I have noticed a aggressively progressive decline in the last 10 yrs in Banking, Healthcare, Community Services, Safety etc. I can list pages of issues and yet we tolerate this by continuously electing our government at all levels keeping them in power and not holding them accountable for their actions or decisions. We need to do better and get more involved!

The root cause of many societal issues is often greed. For example, lax immigration laws can lead to increased tax revenue for the government. Landlords exploit the housing market by overcharging tenants, while some homeowners resist new developments in their neighborhoods to maintain the value of their properties. When greed is prioritized, everyone loses. The government should act to support the people and set a positive example.\n\nTo address the cost of living and soaring housing prices, policymakers should consider revising immigration policies, implementing rental rate controls to curb excessive landlord greed, and streamlining processes to build more affordable housing. Additionally, subsidies could be used to encourage new construction.\n\nThere's also concern about money laundering through real estate investments by foreign actors, with little action taken by the government to tackle this issue. The carbon tax, intended to address environmental concerns, is ineffective, unnecessary, and nothing short of a cash grab by the Liberal Govt.\n\nIt's crucial for the government to recognize these problems and take steps to resolve them, but that won't happen with Trudeau in power. By fostering a fairer and more just society, we can work towards a more equitable future for everyone. Until then, welcome to Commusocialtatorship Canada.

Why don't people take action instead of posting useless messages on here that won't do jack shit

What a failure . All countries speak empty words of support for Palestine from their own comfort zone while the blood thirsty regime is ripping the soul of Humanity. May Allah give justice, may the corrupt greedy regime learn that their actions is only comparable to Nazi Germany. What this regime is doing now will reverberate for centuries to come. Nazi Germany is no more, Pharaohs dynasty were tyrant and ruled for several centuries , but that is no more, their dead bodies are in museums, they couldn't find a resting place even.

Yup. As a Canadian citizen with Chinese background who is now moving permanently to the US, I testify. I’m not settling for the cold characterless mediocrity that is Canada. It just doesn’t sit well with me. The US has its problems but I’d rather deal with a nation with problems than a nation with no spirit or character. \n\nBest example is racism. The Canadians aren’t any less racist but they’ll stay quiet. I’d rather deal with the Americans who straight up call me chink and hate crime me, because it’s impossible to make change happen when there’s no spark, no action, no acknowledgement or honesty.

Waiting for real action. It's said 4 Moth ago.. ?

This is a worldwide phenomenon. Since the early 80's reactionary forces, the rich, the politically connected, became successful in fooling the middle class into voting themselves out of the middle class. It's too late now for the middle class to put progressives in power and expect real change. The reactionary forces are the real deep state that control the money and power. They are able to stop any action toward income equality that would build a new middle class by scaring and angering an easilty led electorate into voting against their own best interests. Yes, the future doesn't bode well for Canadians, Americans, French, Germans, Australians, Japanese, well you get the picture.

Justin looks like Rahul Gandhi in India. All words and smile, but sadly no plan and action.

We dont even know if they r pro Palestinians they look like thry r just walking maybe shopping not being aggressive at all hes wrong for his actions but i get why hes acting this way hes not being blind to how Palestinians are acting in America and in UK so u all take it how u want i wouldnt put up with the BS thats being brought non of the Arab states want the BS neither does the US UK and everywhere else so dont bring it my door step there wont b a happy ending here for you if u disrespect my home

Most of what was reported here is true but the housing market and rents have skyrocketed all over the world since the Chinese government F'd everyone with Covid-19. At first there were supply chain issues with all goods so businesses said we have to increase prices. Once supply issues were back to pre-Covid-19 levels businesses did not & will not lower their prices on goods because , we as a society do not take matters into our own hands and boycott products\\company's etc. Now obviously we cannot boycott all goods & services but the majority we could and that is the only thing that would cause action among companies to lower bank fees, fast food prices, grocery prices, cell plan costs etc.\n\nWith that said, you picked two of the highest and most sought after city's in CAN to rent & or try to buy a home. Although rent & home prices have really jumped all over the world in the past 3-4 years, more affordable (still not cheap) housing, compared to Toronto, Vancouver, can be found all across CAN. My sister & brother in law found an apartment to rent in Winnipeg without any difficulty or waiting. \nThey are immigrants and entered on her student Visa & he is a computer programmer. They are not struggling to eat but they have to follow a tight budget since she cannot work but 20 hours a week as a student and they have 1 kid, a car payment,utilities, cell plan, etc. They have filed for their PR and I suspect they will be approved since his job is in demand and she will graduate from College there in 4 months or so.\n\nOne thing I noticed, when my wife & I went up to get them settled in, is that the government (national & local) taxes you all pay out of the wazzoo on everything! I think the only thing that wasn't taxed was air. ? I know most of this is due to the healthcare system, because the money has to come from somewhere. Don't misunderstand, I like the CAN healthcare system better than the US's, because the insurance companies stick it to us as well, but both have their pluses and minuses.\n\nCAN does have a much easier system for immigration. If my sister & bro in law could have come here we would have been glad for them to stay with us and help them get started but the backlog is just so long to wait (10 + years). I also LOVE CAN because you uphold your laws and DEPORT illegal immigrants instead of letting them pour into the Country, by the millions each year, and the majority eventually trickle into the population illegally, who get jobs & pay no taxes (other than sales tax) no driver's licenses or vehicle insurance and get 100% free medical and hospital care anytime while legal US citizen's pay high premiums, into social security and their income taxes each year.

It's very easy to say these words\non the contrary\nthe question should be\nHow much help or effort\nyou are making towards Palestine?\n\nThe actions are very different\nto what you say\nif Arab muslim nation\nor any other Muslim nation\nwould have helped honestly\njust not by talking\nbut by their action\nPalestine would not\nhave suffered this brutality\nas they are facing now\nbecause these Muslim nations\nare just talking and talking\n\n\nA random wise man says\nTalking does not\nbring any peace itself\nwithout any good act.\nYour good words\nmust match\nyour good actions\n\nin the end\nif it's not that\nthen every single thing\nyou say\nit's an absolutely a lie.

How the ugly bias people protect this barbaric action, what story behind the man seems to be so bias and arrogant

Everything belongs by ndp Singh.....he did this action.

This is how Australia is now. About 15% try to fit in. The rest are able to buy houses driving up home prices. Dangerous drivers, no care and distracted actions causing accidents so insurance has gone up a third

People, especially American citizens who are giving lectures citing law of the country and police doing their duty should stop being hypocrites. Your government can't help being loud-mouthed nose-pokers- meddling into affairs of internal security of our Nation and calling us intolerant whenever we take strong action against troublemongers in our own country who attempt to break laws and create discord in society. Every country has its own way of dealing with law and order issues. Don't call the kettle black when you yourself are a singed pot

Thay were in thair Country until the Israeelis came and killed and forced peoples to leave thair homes... how many Israeelis are migrating in Palestinian and how many Palestinian has bin killed and displayced ??? Its the normal action to fight back and try to take whats are belong you. You can't expect somting els not from palestinian or some one else. Israeelis have every kind of Support over decade from western Countries and thay manipulate the situation for them. No one can ever understand whats really happened to palestain and palestinian....

All those who leave Canada will come back in 5 years. They will worship the country for its economic growth beginning with a new Clean energy sector. Liberals are on the right path, but with a lacklustre message that doesn't really counter the escape artists' conservative expense slashing without an alternative plan to place before the public for comparison. It's obvious that nobody wants to lose their earned income either through taxes or any other fees. But, the progressive conservatives say that environment and pollution is a business decision whereas Nature and environment is everybody's business. Every citizens business.If not for the natural resources the Fossil fuel industry fully backed by the conservatives would not make any money or profits. Hence shareholder primacy is a hoax in front of human energy that is sustained by clean environment. Mark Carney leads that mission internationally. Money is not Energy, it's only a lever. Therefore, you need people living in good health to action the lever. Canada is full of natural resources, untapped critical minerals etc. and has been able to garner large amounts of foreign investment from large corporations like Honda, Dow and BHP to develop the much demanded clean energy and Energy transformation better than the USA. These companies know Canada's potential for a reliable economy and economic growth.

Everyone saying stupid question, 6 months on and the genocidal data is growing by the thousands. So the real question is, how are influencial neighbouring countries with billions of dollars helping to establish this ideology? This man has spoken in an eloquent manner but until these words are put into actions then we’re just going to be taking turns kicking the ball and actually avoiding a final resolution for the people of Palestine.

How could the government do this to their own citizens. We could have secured such a good life for the average Canadian. It’s not only inaction it’s action that directly hurts the most vulnerable in our society, which is becoming the majority

Hate speech apartheid systen in action the real colour ultra racism in action

You manipulated the Muslim countries for ages and unhinged their communities resulting in their emigration for better life.\nYou robbed their countries of their wealth.\nNow you complain of their existence on your land?\nEvery action requires a reaction. And everything has a price.

May be ask Hamas to stop killing? Don't be surprised by reaction when taking action.

i am pro-palestine, but not anti-muslim. it just doesn't make sense. blaming the citizens of a country for something their government is responsible for is just stupidity. in the same breath we do not judge Russians for the actions of Putin, so why is this acceptable?

Has this been reported to the police and has any action been taken by them for his hate crime ?

In all fairness India is #1 the most racist country in the world, the least trusted country in the world and the only race that will use white names culturally appropriate and hold businesses that hire only Indians, and scam English countries. See the Uber driver that was murdered by an old man being scam. That was Indian scammers. They never face consequences for their behaviour. They bring down the quality of life whereever they live, watch a Ted Talk with evidence, they dont follow rules and regulations and abuse loopholes more than any culture. \nAs a white person, ive never experienced racism except by Indians.\nRefused work for not speaking Punjabi in Canada and refused housing for not being Indian, refused servicer for not being Indian.\nNo Korean, chinese, arab of any kind has treated me with aloof and diamissive behaviour the way an Indian has, as though I'm beneath them.\nEvery burger fast food restaurant that serves beef is now extra sketchy to me now while people that have never eaten beef and frown on me for doing so speaking to other staff members in Hindi maybe saying, these burgers fell on the floor, aah who cares its just a white person.\nWhy is the staff all Indians now.\nBecause of preferential hiring by Indian management. Youll see homeless white and black people outside though who's country failed them and handed off power to outsiders while framing white people as racist and Indians as victims.\nTurns out Hassan Minhaj lied about his victimhood, and I bet this Indian caused the anger this woman caused and although the man never uttered racist words, I bet his actions to bait her anger were motivated by racism. Afterall Indians are clever and are masters of social engineering.

I don’t agree with his language at all..or speaking to someone like that. But..Palestinians have constantly attacked Israel..until it gets to a point where they have had enough…then of course, Israel is called the oppressor. There are records of all criminal actions and every attack, and every death or injury.

These Palestinians people need a good lawyer and a class-action lawsuit. ??

Unfortunately the text said they took action against the official. Hope justice is done and no arbitrary action on official without knowing full truth.

take legel action against customer.\nwhat a unsafe or poor police department of which country is not taken action against customer .\nif this type of incident happened in india then customer was in police custody.....

What happened then, did the gvt take any action??!

A strong action is required against this Racist Customer

You can clearly understand that this person was high or used illegal drugs to behave like that. He should be arrested and prosecuted for his actions and for what he did to this guy.

A disgraceful human being. I hope action was taken against him.

Any action against this rude Man nothing else

It's the same old story, isn't it? Harassment happens every day, someone records it, people watch, some find it entertaining while others express sympathy, and then the cycle repeats with a new incident the next day. Unfortunately, no one takes action against the perpetrators, and nothing changes. It's a sad reality we live in. ?

Quite frankly, if the government isn't going to take action, then it's up to Canadians to spread the word worldwide of the horrors of Canada to at least try and disincentive more people from coming.

Take action against this narcissist,what a looser who act like this with the person who is delivering u ur food? As….le