Close Reading

Palestine never had land country state or sovereignty they are Arab Muslim occupiers

The funniest is why Muslim pepoles don't like stay on Thier land or leave in Thier neighbours country...\nWhy Arabs turkey soudi uae Qatar yamen Pakistan Afghanistan don't takes this refugees......\nAnd why most Muslims love go to USA EU... To survive?????

The response of the weak or the conspiratory. Either way (like all the arab and muslim leaders) he is a part of the problem not the solution.

so Arabs and pakistan and India and all other countries especially muslim ones show up for palestine than and for every country race religion that has been oppressed

Whilst it may seem a reasonable reply. But what have Arab countries done collectively as one Muslim voice to show unity and push for a ceasefire.

Arab muslims like to live in western countries

Saudi people are the coolest Arabs in the world! I am not a fan of Palestinian Muslims much. Hummus went to far.

None of the Arabic countries near Palestine will help them because the P.L.O. has already caused so many problems in the middle east they were exiled to Palestine. Jordan doesnt want them, Egypt doesnt want them, Iran doesnt want them, Iraq doesnt want them, how terrible must a Muslim people be to have all arabs turn there back on them.

Sorry yes in you muslim to Arab yes in pelastin muslim in so what you cu to pelastin in perang.yes in idea you no verry good you cu to amarika sarikat in idf yes.?

I left Dubai a few years ago and decided to migrate to Canada and here's why - \n1. Arab Muslims are openky intolerant of other religions\n2. As kids we were constantly subjected to abuse from Arab kids for being non- Muslim and i did not want that for my child\n3. Open racism and preference for GCC nationals after the emaratis\n4. Count wide shut down of restaraunts during fasting hours if Ramadan. All non Muslims barred from eating or driking WATER in public areas\n5. Holidays for only islamic festivals\n\nThis is a common theme among all Muslim dominant countries. Examples are Saudi, Qatar, Kuwait, Pakistan, and so on and so forth. You should definitively move out and make space for people who are secular and Christian in Canada.

He thought he ATE with that statement. \nWho is supposed to lift the weight Arab dude ? the ones putting those weights? Or perhaps you mean America? Or maybe Europeans? The only ones that should remove the weights are your Muslim brothers and sisters. That's the respond he should've given.

Arab world they don't want to know about gaza because they already rich why they want to know they to to poor Muslim country.

This is why they want to lie about calling them Palestinians. \nWe all know that the name Palestinian was given to this lamb by the Romans, when the Jews were administering Roman law. \n\nCalling it Palestine was a slap in the Jews face changing the name from Judea to Palestine basically naming it after the Jewish long-term enemy the Philistines. \n\nThere are no Philistines left there is no one claiming to be Philistine. \n\nThe people who stolen this name and claimed it as their own, are in fact Arabs who moved throughout the area is nomadic people. \n\nEven when the Muslims, the Turks the Ottoman empire controlled this territory No one called them Palestinians and there was no demand for a Palestinian state.. \n\nWhen Egypt and Jordan controlled this territory. No one called them Palestinians and no one was demanding for there to be their land. \n\nCalling themselves an adapting the term Palestinian was simply a PR move. \n\nFor the Arab Nations to adopt this terminology, is really a testimony to the fact that the Arab Nations don't want this radical brand of Islam in their countries. \n\nThe so-called Arab AKA Palestinians are in fact a more radical branch of Islam that is associated with Iran's version of Islam not the generally accepted practiced Islam amongst the Arab states and their affiliations. \n\nThis is why Egypt doesn't want them, this is why Jordan won't take them back. Because historically speaking most of these Arabs came from Jordan. This is why Saudi Arabia doesn't want them. \n\nThey don't want their extremism to be brought into their culture, into their land and causing problems there.

Obviously way too many Indians and Muslim. They stick together, hire their own and I find many of them look down on black people and other races. They want you to learn about and accommodate their culture and religion but reluctant to do the same. As a teacher it is difficult to teach Arab men. Literally if you said these things a decade ago which I have people will bc all you racist or xenophobic but thankfully more Canadians are seeing the obvious truth now.

It's because of the Arabs that innocent Palestinians are being killed. ALL Muslim leaders are to blame.

Yes, I agree wholeheartedly with his answer because the Gaza Strip and the West Bank are rightfully the sole property of the Palestinians and no one else, Isreali or other Arabs etc. has no right to determine where Palestinians may live.\n\nHowever, even even if I am in favor of both self-determination and autonomy for Palestinians, it doesn't mean I am a not a supporter of Isreal's right to exist thus, defend itself.\n\nIsreal has every right to both exist and defend itself against Hamas, Hezbolah, Al-Qeda or any other Arab terrorists organization or Arab state as well as especially Iran, that may wish or has declared its intent to wipe Isreal from the face of the world.\n\nAs for Arab states like Saudi Arabia, the Gulf States or any Muslim dominated state in the Mideast or northern Africa taking in refugees is concerned.\n\nThe short answer is that none of these states will take in refugees by the fact that these states failed to take in refugees from recent war zones like Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria or Libya in any great and significant numbers.\n\nRecent conflicts in Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan saw the West come to the aid of these refugees before any Muslim led country.\n\nIf a Muslim country like Turkey took in refugees, it had to be paid by the West to take in refugees from Syria, Afghanistanand Iraq...in the past Lebanon and Jordan likewise have only taken in limited amounts of Palestinians and these refugees are still stuck in refugee camps in Lebanon and Jordan eventhough it's been decades that they were forced to settle in these two countries.\n\nSo, don't worry asking if the Arab or Muslim led world takes in refugees because the short answer is they don't in significant numbers and if they do, they begrudgingly do so and in a marginalize fashion.

It’s ruled by israel because of Arabs fighting and loosing therefore become part of peaceful Israeli society as an Arab Muslim like hundred of thousands or leave quietly.

It's very easy to say these words\non the contrary\nthe question should be\nHow much help or effort\nyou are making towards Palestine?\n\nThe actions are very different\nto what you say\nif Arab muslim nation\nor any other Muslim nation\nwould have helped honestly\njust not by talking\nbut by their action\nPalestine would not\nhave suffered this brutality\nas they are facing now\nbecause these Muslim nations\nare just talking and talking\n\n\nA random wise man says\nTalking does not\nbring any peace itself\nwithout any good act.\nYour good words\nmust match\nyour good actions\n\nin the end\nif it's not that\nthen every single thing\nyou say\nit's an absolutely a lie.

..Black September when Bedouins forces loyal to king Hussein slaughtered 160’000 Palestinians--Jordania had annexed the 80% of Palestine and went to war against PLO and Syria..the killing of Palestinian refugees was seen as a brotherly misunderstanding by most ARAB STATES--20 MILLION MUSLIMS or ARABS KILLED BY MUSLIM or ARABS SINCE 1945--BROTHERLY MISUNDERSTANDINGS-? \n \n•\tIn the Middle East, 1.4 million Arabs experience true freedom. They live in Israel. They are citizens of the Jewish state and enjoy same legal and political rights as the rest. \n300 million Arabs do not experience true freedom. They live outside the tiny strip of Israel under a misogynistic yokes posing as sovereignty and independence. The contrast between the Arabs in Israel and counterparts outside the strip are becoming distinct.

Muslim arab no happy in muslim country so thats why living im the west country

500,000,000 Muslims in middle east...about 9,000,000 jews....the problem is within the arab countries

When you give the rights to the Christians in Egypt and Iraq and Lebanon then ask the jews to give the right to the Muslims they are not Palestinians the Palestinians gone since the time of Roman empire the Muslims are the grand children of the Muslim invasion who killed and oppressed the Christians for 1500 years and they still do in Iraq and Egypt and Lebanon this lands not for Arab this our lands for the Christians and the jews we have the right to live free in dignity in our Lebanon too stop terrorizing the Christians at the hands of the Islamic brotherhood and ISIS and pro Iranian regime Islamic terrorist group hizballah but I like to give credit to the gulf state Saudi Arabia and imarat they are great leaders and they have good hands on our country and people

He knows and the Arab World knows the danger of the Muslim Brotherhood and want no part of it.

Unfortunately mississauga is going the same way with a difference of mississauga being not only Indians but Muslims Arabs and Pakistanis, reason way I left mississauga.

Just a second, when all arabs country was in local wars, Europe take milions of muslims refugees, why muslims arab take 0 muslims refugees?

Good question. Out of sympathy developed nations, European countries and USA take Muslim refugees but neighboring Arab countries won’t take them.\n\nThis also happened while I was in a GCC member country back in 2012 when ISIS attacked Syria. Naturally, Syrian expats expected that if worst comes to worst they will be absorbed by the GCC country where they were working since they are fellow Arabs and Muslims. To our surprise, their work visas were cancelled and never renewed, which mean they have to leave the country or stay undocumented.

Is wrong what is wrong with what he is saying? It is true that Muslims and Arabs they do go to western countries and then they push their religion and beliefs on us and then they say death to America death to the western world so how do you not see that is wrong? This guy said absolutely nothing wrong, Land let Land stop pushing your beliefs on other people

Yes, I agree that they don’t need to leave their land. However, all Muslim countries need to raise their voice and to do something to stop this. You Arab countries have power, money and influence so use this.

Not one arab nation, not one muslim country, is willing to take the palestinian people in if that doesn't say something to the world about the palestinians and the The arabs the Muslims.\nI don't know what does?

This is kingdom area not muslim area.country arab afganistan pakistan suriah is musslim area

Why aren’t the rich Muslim nations putting their money where their mouth is. Palestinians have been monetarily supported for 50 years by mostly US & German money…the west would gladly leave the area if someone else would put money n troops as peacekeepers, but they never will. Egypt will continue the blockade as they have always done. Unfortunately, no one in the Arab world ACTUALLY cares, money is the proof(Saudis spend the most on Palestine and it’s minuscule)

Israelis also have a right to live on their land without arab countries supporting terror groups to launch missiles at isrsel constantly. The Jewish people had a right to the homes they were pushed out of by Arab Muslims.

?????? Nobody sanctioned the USA and its EU accomplices for the genocides in Iraq and their war crimes and crimes against humanity in Iraq, neither the UN nor the ICC have judged them as they did against the genocide of Yugoslavia, why do the rest of the nations continue? following the orders of the USA to sanction those who do not invade sovereign territories or commit the atrocities that the USA commits where there are natural resources to steal, why some Muslim and Arab countries still continue to lick the boots of the USA, the UNITED KINGDOM, France, the Nazi Germany and other lackey countries of the USA instead of uniting to recover their natural resources and expel them from their territories?

Omg this is so ironical... okay which countries were blocking mainly aid to Palestine?\nHow about it's direct neighbour Egypt? They did not and still are not allowing any Palestinian who are willing to leave the country due to health or maybe because they don't want their children and woman to suffer under constant bombing and terror from Israel and Hamas ...\nIt's not only always the west or Israel the biggest problem is that the Arab countries rather out of political and ideological reason watch how the Palestinian ppl suffer each day under horrible conditions then letting at least the children, woman and hurted ones escape to safety ... This is not about Palestinian not wanting to give up their land ... It's more about them getting used by politicians and radical islamic ideologies and as a result being ropped their freedom and being used as human shields to use it as a political weapon against Israel and the west ... And the sad thing about it is that so far they are quite successful with it ... Look I'm not saying Israel is doing everything right they are also making constant use of inhumane methods to justify their cause and goal but at least they are fighting also for the Arab refugees in their state ... In terms of Western values and basic humane rights Muslim ppl living in Israel have it by far better than in most other radical islamic countries

The Arab world won’t take Palestinians in because the last time they did it, multiple riots and civil wars broke out. Palestinians disrupted the Kuwaiti government, tried to assassinate the Jordanian king, disrupted Lebanon by supporting Hezbollah and caused chaos in Syria. They also joined militants of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt when they crossed the Sinai peninsula and caused chaos there as well. \n\nSo in what world is anyone going to help them? The only countries trying to help them are Turkey, who themselves commit genocide against the Kurds, Iran which is a theocracy that has been killing innocent women for just not wearing the hijab, and Afghanistan for obvious reasons. I love that the western people have no clue about middle eastern history and politics and just think Israel is the sole bad guy in this conflict.

Indians are Hindu. Punjabs are Muslims. And Indians hate Punjabs because they see them as traitors to their roots. Celebrating arab traditions over their own.

Here in England we are happy with our Indians, the Sikhs and Hindus dont bother anyone and are law abiding. Whereas the muslims esp Pakistanis are constantly grooming our children and women, pushing their religion on us etc. I find it odd that so many Canadians have an issue with Indians. If they were Arabs or Pakistanis you guys would be in for a lot of trouble lol

It is politically convenient for Arab states to have continual turmoil in what was the Palestinian mandate before 1948. Palestinian refugee ghetto camps have existed for 75 years in arabic countries. Why have those countries not integrated their fellow Muslims?

Scotland minister - needs to address how the middle eastern countries lack Christian leaders. Pakistan leader - Muslim. Saudi - Muslim. Qatar - Muslim, turkey - Muslim. Atleast Scotland and UK has a no Christian leader. Now it's Arab countries turn.

I can't say I blame them with regards to the Arab community. You let them go on gaining Government offices and you'll end up like Germany. 3 cities renamed to Muslim names and Sharia Law implemented. One of those cities was very famous historically. I guess their citizens will know it from there history book. They take all offices over time and once the City Counsel and the Mayor are of like minds, they create a Little Libya in your country. Marvelous, isn't it. Democracy at work. freedom ... isn't free.

Sry to say but the Arabs were just names Muslim

If the Arabs wanted to destroy the Jews it would not matter, Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) prophesie, Arabs will indulge in luxury while Muslims around the world will be bribed

He lying, Saudi Arabia is against the muslim brotherhood which Hamas is apart off. Look it up, why most Arab countries wont take them in. Palestinians started the civil war in Jordan and Lebanon, and tried to remove the leadership in Egypt and Saudi Arabia which both countries designate the muslim brotherhood a terrorist organization.

I’m muslim arab alhamudlilah but this is wrong, my opinion is sharia is the best law to be applied it doesn’t care about your feelings it cares about getting people in line, and one of the rules of sharia is respecting the laws of the people of the land you live in which these guys are apparently not following, yes there’s hypocrisy in London when they give Jews their own police and hospitals and appliance of their Jewish law but the Jews have won by grabbing every powerful persons balls in the west so they can do whatever they want unlike you being who thinks being loud is gonna get you what you want. and for westerners who are angry in the comment section about their laws being changed I say you know what it feels like now for someone else to lecture you about laws and how wrong they are, so now so stop lecturing the Middle East about changing they’re laws to something that suits your western criteria.

Sheem on arabs and all Muslims to watch all that only shia Muslims is fighting sunni still sleep ?

They are waiting for Europe and other Christian country to take as Muslim refugee, Arab don't allow any other country Muslim bcoz they are of different cast ( firka).

All Arab Muslim Sleeping ?

As a muslim I THOUGHT WE ARE UNITED WHEN SOMETHING BAD WILL HAPPEN OUR ARAB KHALIFA WILL GONA SAVE US BUT THEY ARE DOING NOTHING INSTEAD OF WATCHING AND MAKING HAPPY THIER WESTERN PEOPLE THATS WHY IM NOT PRACTISING AS A MUSLIM MY IMAAN IS REALLY FADDING

also isnt it because of arab nations working with britian that caused rivers to dry up borders to be made from their dealings in ww1 and 2 and now everyone blames israel when all they do is defend themselves and their lands like muslim nations all around them have done

Good question, Arabs should take them in as refugees instead of having them fight a battle they know they can't win.. They have PLENTY of space since they invaded during the Ottoman Empire.\n\nAnd last time I checked, the prophets (that even the muslims follow) are all Jewish and have ties to that land.. There is written history that proves that is their country, where is the Palestinian written history that proves they lived there..?\n\nThey took their language, religion and land.