Close Reading

His answer is NO.\nAnd it sounds like he is fine letting everyone that wants out now too stay because it would be better if there was not war... But there is war.\nTruth is the southern border with egypt is full of people trying to flee gaza. I am sure they want to come back but right now this man's ideology doesn't help anyone living in reality

So, contrary to what others are commenting on here, he doesn’t want to take the Palestinians in for 2 actual reasons. 1. He doesn’t care about the Palestinians, but rather sees them as needed bodies because he thinks if all the Palestinians leave, Israel won’t allow them back. 2. He doesn’t want to take in Palestinians because of how many of them have extreme beliefs. Saudi Arabia doesn’t have that many terrorists, so why would he allow a population in that has a sizable percentage of terrorists?

Who in their right mind would want to live in a country that our leader's have fill to the brim with terrorists from all over the world

Haha this is so dumb always the “Palestinians don’t want to leave the land” “Palestinians are all warriors!” Most of them just want peace for there children and want hamas gone that steals there water and food supply that Israel is bringing. Remember Palestinians want to leave Gaza but Hamas would never don’t confuse these 2.

Sheikh is saying that let them die with hunger and no treatment. Kids dying and elderly are suffering. They need to stay back n tolerate? Huh! It would be better to leave rather than living like animals in Gaza.. but these sheikhs don’t want them.

Translation: we don’t want them. The Gaza- Egypt border is tighter the the Gaza- Israel border. But would u take the women and children for a little while while the war is hot? Like Europe took the Syrians?

Yes, of course the Palestinian people have the right to their land and the right to live on their land in dignity, peace and security but if nobody makes Israel stop butchering them, shouldn't someone at least offer them temporary refuge? I would want that if I were stuck there with my loved ones.

He is smart and the other way he would say we don’t want them and you can have them all

Please, ask the Palestinians if they would rather relocate to Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Egypt, Etc. Arab nations don’t want them.

Removing the Palestinians would be exactly the ethnic cleansing that some people wanted.

I WOULD NOT WANT TO LIVE THERE BUT LOVE TO VISIT CANADA SO NOW AND THEN. IT IS A BEAUTIFULL COUNTRY WHICH NEEDS TO SOLVE MANY PROBLEMS. I VISITED CANADA TWICE

What is that question? linking palestinian plight with accepting them as refugees? Palestinians don't want to be refugees, they want to live peacefully and freely with dignity on their land. Why would the arab world want to help Israel to kick them out? Silly question ?

So if Israel stops going after hamas. In a couple years will it start over again? okay so what I would do strategically. Is egypt and other nearby countries should open their borders. Palestines should leave with their children. After Israel wipes out hamas. Then come back. You want a two party democracy right or no? because my understanding was hamas had the overall choice in the election of power. Also are the tunnels for evacuation or for military?

He is very correct. It's like you have your home and someone pushes you out because they want to occupy your territory. It's wrong in the United States that would not happen. Palestinians would rather shed their blood on their homeland then have to leave. They are built a different. Such a great example for humanity.

A Chinese woman I used to know told me that she wanted to leave Shanghai for Canada to give her boy a better educational outlook. I asked her what she wanted to do there for her living, was all a bit vague... I told her she would need a big snow shovel...? myself being located in Central Europe.

He basically said: they made their bed and now they can lie in it. \n\nThere’s quite a few Palestinians trying to leave and seek refuge in Egypt since they opened their borders to take a limited number of them in.. as long as they’re not associated with Hamas. \n\nHamas brought this war to the Palestinian’s doorstep in Gaza and if other Arab nations don’t want to open their borders to the Palestinians who would like to leave because of the war, then there will be an increased number of civilian casualties. Just because their fellow Arabs refuse to take them as refugees doesn’t mean Israel loses the right to defend itself from the barbaric terrorist attack Hamas launched against them. \nAny other country would have the right to defend itself from terrorists that live at their borders. If Hamas cared about their citizens, they’d have a plan for them and their safety once they initiated this war on Oct 7th. But it seems like Hamas’s only plan for them was to be disposable pawn martyrs caught in between them and Israeli forces. \n\nYou can’t torture, rape and kill 1,400 Israeli citizens/foreign nationals and take 200+ hostages back to Gaza during a depraved terrorist attack and then cry ceasefire when that country declares war and is winning. Especially when you’re still holding onto hostages and not honoring the terms of the first ceasefire by letting the Red Cross see the hostages. \n\nIf these other countries cared about the Palestinians, they’d take any refugees that wanted to leave. They clearly don’t want to do that for some reason. They’re watching from afar with their popcorn, saying “isn’t it terrible what the Israeli’s are doing.. but we won’t let them come here to escape, which would let the Israelis fight this war with Hamas, who initiated it, without civilians in between.” With no mention of how Hamas as put them in the middle and isn’t protecting them. Also no mention of any responsibility Hamas has for bring this war onto them by the large scale terrorist attack, that includes hundreds of civilian hostages of all ages.

But if they wanted to move to Saudi Arabia, would you take them? I think we know the answer . . . Nice dodge.

why they have to leave their country , that is exactly what the colonizers want ! Palestinians do not want to leave, they would rather die than leaving, because many had did it before thinking they are coming back , but they are never allowed!

If he was really telling the truth, like no one seems to want to recognize on this comment thread they don’t want the Palestinians as refugees even for a temporary solution because they are so dangerous. No Arab nation has said that they would help. Why is that

Actually nobody would bother the gazans if weren't bringing it up on themselves. and don't tell me they didn't, cause l know it just like everyone who wants to know it, and doesn't close his eyes.

Ha, ha, haaaaaaaa! Gaza is on the border with Egypt. Even Egypt doesn't wan them and makes it hard for them to cross the border! Why would any country want to take in rabid Palestinians?

He avoided mentioning that Hamas broke a long standing truce and that the Palestinians are suffering because of that. I agree with what he said though. There is concern that if they leave, they won’t be able to come back and Egypt doesn’t want Hamas terrorists in their country. No one wants these fools. All these factors are well known and their plan was designed with these considerations. They figured the odds were on their side and the world would feel sorry for the human shields. It’s almost working…

saudi minister is a genius. saudi has poor relations with palestine, so they don't want to take them in. he could have openly condemned hamas but he cant do it as OIC will take notice and condemn saudi for not standing up to islamic country. they could send soldiers and weapons to hamas but that would make saudi look like they are supporting terrorists which means people wont buy their oil. so it was pretty easy to blame the whole thing on israel and say ' we dont take enemies into our soil and we will let israel handle it'. in other words, terrorists are bad for bunesiness

What if they had enough and Do want to leave ? Would they get support ? probably not ☠️

What he’s saying is hell no they don’t want the Palestinians, and throughout the last couple hundred years no one has. The Arab world knows they are a danger to the monarchies and would topple their regimes with their political and religious views. So if the Arabs won’t take their brothers in why should the West?

No Arab countries would take Palestinians even if they wanted to leave their land. Palestinians get screwed over by literally everybody.

They have a right to stay in their own land in their own homes in their own country. Why would they abdicate. It is surrender to a foreign power. Do Americans think Africa should take back African Americans if we decide we want to get rid of them and confiscate their property?

Just open borders and see if Palestinians want to settle in other Arab countries or not. You guys aren’t opening your borders because you knew some of them would be trouble makers for you. West is already facing their nonsense.

The housing thing is fucked up. Nobody can buy a home bcuz selfish owners dont want their city build more houses bcuz their value would drop. Like fuck off!

I am Canadian, and while elements of this video are true, there are larger points missed. healthcare is challenging, but it could be worse- could be the American system. housing is expensive if you want to live in the large urban centres. essentially, life is good but takes effort, and there's a growing sense of entitlement... but all a Canadian need do is head south and they'll be missing it in a short period of time. I would far rather be here than in China, Ukraine, Russia, India, many African nations, many South American nations, Mexico,... Europe is more expensive in many areas... no, I'll stick with Canada, thanx

Noone wants to live in Canada anymore because spineless liberals sold this country down the river while telling everyone with a straight face the cons did it. 44 billion dollars spent on Ontario Healthcare this year, a budget decided by the premier, and liberals are complaining about the state of the Healthcare system. Have you ever heard of a time when 44 billion dollars went into one provinces Healthcare system for one year? \n\nNewsflash: it didn't give us the great healthcare system 44 billion dollars would have because most of that money had to be funneled into paying off liberal policy expenses. Then the same people will tell you Doug Ford is responsible.\n\nYeah Doug Ford is responsible for a sustained overspending effort by the liberals, and especially so when he had to pay their debts. Liberal debts just aren't necessary to pay I suppose, unless you're conservative. Liberals currently have no plan even because they realize their voters are hateful, spiteful people who will cut off their nose to spite their face so the plan is sink the upcoming conservative government in debt and come back in 8 years pretending to not have been the original problem.

You are indeed great. I have been written off bc l had 3rd class in my first degree on secretarial Administration. I went in for a post graduate diploma in sociology had an upper credit. I went in for masters in dept of sociology(option- peace and conflict studies) had an upper credit. I want to go in for a PhD but don't know a school that will accept me. Would go in for any other good course outside sociology pls for 2024 academic session.

Oh brilliant mate doesn’t sound like he cares much about the children or you’d come up with a better answer than that.. all the Arab world want is trouble, otherwise they would help solve the problem

If they wanted to help the Palestinians, they would have said that they would welcome all Palestinians who wanted to go to other Arab countries. But as expected they haven't done it.

Why do you want Palestinian people to leave their homes? Would you leave your home if the next door thug tries to take over your home? Why this ridiculous question?

A lot of people don't understand how hard it is to live as a refugee in another country. Most regular people would never want that life, refugees are forced into it because they have no choice.\nThe people saying that should just 'move somewhere else' are so insensitive!

There’s no such thing called Muslim areas in western countries, Period! If Muslims want sharia laws then head back to those countries that practice sharia, The western world would be a better place without theses sharia laws… ☹️

Would be amazing to make a video about your tax structure. Or a fictional similar one if you don't want to disclose your specifics. ♥

Come on down to the USA. \n\nThe USA should just allow any Canadian that wants to immigrate, permission to do so. It would be the easiest transition of any immigrant, which is good for the USA.

But what about those who want to leave? Would you accept them or not?

Canada is a great country. Many rich countries around the world have their issues. Population here is booming. If you want to leave for greener pastures good for you. For every person who wants to leave terrible Canada you will be able to find 10 who would love to come here. Proudly born and raised here. ??♥️

Even if the Palestinians would want to stay in other arab countries, they dont want any Palestinians. Ofcourse he says it in this way. But in reality noone wants them

This is f****** crazy\nPeople are dying this problem needs some bigger better people that would handle it carefully\nHe's just sitting there listening to his own voice\nHaving a good afternoon telling those people to stay there\nfree Palestine hamas is no one's helper\nit won't improve anything this problem is not simple there many to blame include israel\nIm not even Jewish but this s*** is insane you guys don't care about the truth you hear all this insane stories and you don't doubt them for a moment obviously doubt everything on the other side that it's insane doesn't even resembles truth you don't care about the people you don't want peace\nI pray for the people in gaza \nhave a better government soon one that actually cares for them and a country where they can have a good life not just kill or die

What he is saying is that they don’t want the Palestinians in their country either. They are fine with the fact that Hamas is holding their people there as human shields, and the fact that if they did leave, that the Hamas soldiers that are still there would be cannon fodder, and they definitely do not want that.

What does the person presenting the video and probably ninety percent of responding to it have in common and really do not want to tell you this. There political ideology lines up closer to the far right in the USA. So it’s no surprise they would be sad and angry living in Canada and am glad they live by their convictions and move out.

Why would any country want or welcome Muslims into their society? They never intergrate

Im glad that people are being dissuaded from coming to canada.if you work hard and avoid big cities its great here. We dont want grifters like the harkles here. Why would anyone want to move to vancouver or toronto anyway?

Most of the money that is suposed to go to the homeless is wasted on bureaucracy and fraud/corruption. The people handling that money does not want homelessness to end since it would end their cash cow.

why would anyone want to go to Australia

Absolutely on point. What the Arab world can do though is Demand sanctions on Israel and call out Israel’s brutality and call out the United States. They are still tiptoeing. Every time I watch United Nations interviews. The Arab world is too afraid to call out the United States for this type of genocidal support, and it’s not just the Arab world. I’ve noticed that the entire world is afraid to criticize, especially after the last veto on the Floor of the United Nations vote coming from the United States. And the fact that Britain abstained I just don’t understand why they’re not called out by name and I don’t believe the world should go down to the scumbag level that Israel goes down to buy speaking ill of everyone but themselves, but I do want to see more aggressive talk Saudi Arabia has so much leverage I mean so much leverage I would have to say it’s quite dangerous that even with all the power Saudi has over the west, it doesn’t take advantage of this to protect the holy land, Saudi, needs to get their heads on straight and realize we need to stop fighting Muslims and start standing together Unfortunately Saudi and their population have been acting like they are superiors to the remainder of the air of world even though they are the reason Muslims living across the world have been demonized and we feel that we are always being attacked as Muslims because of the policies of Saudi Arabia on its own people. Just saying.?