Close Reading

The problem with here is also with Khalistan issue (of course not all Punjabis there want Khalistan and are absolutely chill people and people here in India, Punjabis, also don't want Khalistan, I have some close friends who are Sikh and are most Dildaar, Big-hearted, people I know). A lot of extremist groups which want, Khalistan ARE supported and protected by the Canadian government especially by Justin Trudeau and these people are committing nothing but violence and terrorism in the name of free speech. Indian government has issued many extradition requests, but the Trudeau government has done nothing about it and has protected these extremists. Over the years Indian government has warned Canadian government about this issue constantly and after years of housing these Canadian terrorists (because Canada calls them their citizens and protects them, what else can be the correct term for them and nothing like Khalistan exists) they've started to cause problems for the people already living there (like the terrorists Pakistan was housing are causing problems to them). They know they are not gonna get a Khalistan in India so where else are they gonna build it? Voila! Canada! This is the reason behind them not assimilating with the existing culture.Trudeau has even gone to lengths of calling Amit Shah (Home minister of India) and PM Modi (if you don't know what the heck are you doing here go study geopolitics a bit) unalivers of Hardeepsingh Nijjar WITHOUT any evidence (they just keep saying they have it but have shown nothing till now) and because of which Canada has worsened its relations with the Indian Government. They are even comparing India with the likes of North Korea in terms of threat. Indian Government in reply is giving Canada the same treatment it gives to Pakistan (a bit better of course, but the diplomacy has gone to sh it. And the reason why Trudeau is doing all this, yeah VOTES for sh itty domestic politics he's sacrificing long term GOOD relations with the Indian Government. Now, you may think that worsening relations with India is a good thing for Canada, yeah no, its not good because India has trade relations with Canada which may worsen due to this (yeah, great going for an economy which is already in shambles) and UK or US are not gonna do anything to India over Canada because India geopolitically has more significance than Canada (I'm not bragging, please don't misunderstand). This rant has gone to a very different tangent but yeah a lot of problems Canada is having is mainly due to their government. Any of Canadian friends (I have not reason to hate you) and Punjabi brothers/sisters (Yeah, unless you are some sh itty extremist you are a brother/sister to me) please don't take this offensively. Peace.

Trudeau can’t stop bringing Sikh and Hindu Indians so they can live the American dream

Indian + punjabi + Sikh + Hindu is all Indian. So total should be 308k+. Why is the census showing them divided into sub categories.

I don't want more Indians coming here. I'm not a racist or a bigot etc.(not that I even care anymore if people call me that). I'm a patriotic and cultural preservationist. They do not assimilate at all. They build grotesque eyesore temples and statues, they speak loudly to each other in Punjabi, sikhs are now bringing violence to our streets, they take all the entry level jobs, then men wear dresses and turbans, they don't wear poppies and they poop on our beaches. \nThey are NOT Canadians and they don't assimilate. They should go back home.

I don't want more Indians coming here. I'm not a racist or a bigot etc.(not that I even care anymore if people call me that). I'm a patriotic and cultural preservationist. They do not assimilate at all. They build grotesque eyesore temples and statues, they speak loudly to each other in Punjabi, sikhs are now bringing violence to our streets, they take all the entry level jobs, then men wear dresses and turbans, they don't wear poppies and they poop on our beaches. \nThey are NOT Canadians and they don't assimilate. They should go back home.

What you are saying is right...but mostly Indians there are of your community only from punjab haryana...why don't you ask your Sikh brothers ...to not burn their national Indian flag there? They disrespect India..give India their homeland bad name...i wonder what your Canadian friend has to say About this!!

How beautifully you have defended the Indian government and justified the government's action against the Punjab and Sikhs..... shame on you...I hope that the video will impress your master...?

during the pandemic many restaurant chains suffered, so later Sikhs Indians, were hired to fill the gap, but now that things are getting back to normal they do not leave and even more come for these entry level jobs, but the problem is if people from India keep taking these jobs, our kids fresh out of high school are looking for their first jobs to break into the work force, which is now becoming difficult as the Sikhs already have already taken them.....

Sikhs are back bone of India and Indian army salute to sikhs

Immigrants speaking about Immigrants. The last trailer thrash speaking crap about Sikh temple shows the Cultural value of the so called Canadians. It's how they are raised and that is one of the reason that most of the Indians live in Brampton. There are good people and there are people in all the world. If you think Canada is a Clean country and having good people only then look at the history and check out what your leaders used to do. So don't blame immigrants because the base of Canada is established on immigrants.

Most indians go to foreign countries legally, except for the Sikhs.

Because sikh community is hard and honest worker hea canada is best for fair and equality jo bomb ki histry uske ppishe ka main and correct reason hea 1947 me kiya gya promise jo aaj tak ignore Indian government try to sikhs ko dba ke rakhna chahte hea ab hamare guru sahib ji da aane wale samay ke liye bola hea vo ho ker rhega Raj krega khalsa meaning of pure people not betrayer . Nature always cleanup kerti hea

Just remember for white people any brown person or south asian people are Indian . They might be Pakistanis, Bangladeshis, Afghanistan’s, Sri Lankans and whatever may be their religion, they are all Indians . So don’t take it personally . May be she was sick of those Sikh khalistanis ???

In third world countries everything is either fake or substandard, democracy is not an exception. The entire Indian society is based on the caste system of Hindu religion which promotes discrimination, apartheid, segregation, hatred and injustice against minorities like Christians, Muslims, Sikhs and others. Indian Prime Minister Modi who was once called the “Butcher of Gujarat” was even banned from entering western countries due to his heinous role in ethnic massacre in which more than 2000 muslims were killed by hindu RSS organization ( millitant wing of BJP ) with the help of Modi then Chief Minister of Gujarat, but after Mr. Modi won the elections and became the Prime Minister, western countries lowered their moral standards in pursuit of business opportunities. Prime Minister Modi has now gone from being the Butcher of Gujarat to the Butcher of the World. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau may have made many mistakes in his policies but he is a man of honor.

Only people of color/ sikh people who do not follow law and order in Canada are the terrorists which ran away from India to gain protection under trudeau. The people you are refering as Indian are actually the terrorists. Indian government has repeatedly asked Canadian goverment to handover these people so we could imprison them for terrorism they did in India. But Canada did not even once comment on it, beacuse Canada is sheltering terrorists. Weird how Candian people dont even know about their own PM's doing in their own country. Indian have contributed in health and social services of Canda and actually improved their economic growth. You have poor government with poor restrictions. We are not the culprits. If you have proper laws they will follow.

They think they know sikhs better than indians?

If Indian journalists had done better jobs, some innocent people would be free without any problems now. \n\nDo you know if Canadian citizens learn something about sikh independentist? \n\nDo you know if Hardeep Singh Nijjar did something from Canada to India? Never forget media across the world have people to translate your news. \n\nCanada doesn't make enough effort to protect the population and accepts everything from strangers. It is not acceptable for a country to commit murders in another country. The Indian government is not rational on this point; only small policies without any vision. Reputation of India for only one citizen at this point, they could have 1,428,627,663 conflicts around the world, one for each citizen, good luck. \n\nI would boycott a lot of newcomers from India to avoid this kind of problem until having a real solution. Canadians can't inquire about newcomers from India. Canada is not a prison, we don't have to make effort to receive immigration. I think Canadians deserve a safe country. This is not refusal, but we don't need to import problem in this beautiful country.

All those commenting here supporting the Indian regime and pretending to be Sikhs, are actually Hindus?????????????

Unfortunately India spreads terrorism all around the world and minority religions in India are not safe..In 1984 Hindus in India massacred over 20 thousand Sikhs in the genocide of Sikhs in Amritsar....in 2002 Hindu extremists massacred thousands of Muslims in the Gujrat riots led by India's prime minister Modi who was the-then chief minister of the Indian state of Gujrat....In India Christians or anyone caught or seen by Hindus eating beef are attacked and often fatally but the Indian media never reports this. In India, Indian YouTubers, government ministers often use insulting words toward the West and particularly toward the British.....India's RAW agent is 100% a terrorist organisation and I fully believe its agents murdered Hardeep Singh on the orders of the Indian regime. The West must speak up to protect Christian and all minority rights in India. The above are all facts which anyone can research to establish its validity.

This discrimination is all over Canada against Indian, because they mistake Sikhs(khalistanis) living in Canada as indian, most of them poop on streets and outside their home. It's same tactics what muslims play in india, first they settle in one locality and starts slowly to expand by irritating Hindus communities to make them leave their house and run away.

Wish they would all leave Canada, they are ruining it by the day, nobody wanted any of this, except Indians and Sikhs....

Actually she's isn't wrong if indians start taking over jobs and properties or businesses in canada where will the natives go? It's their country so they have the right to speak up if your presence or actions is hurting them atleast she didn't abuse you she was honest about the problem she and her family might be facing because of indians and indian government should bs ashamed that every year massive amounts of indians abandon their citizenship and settle in other countries spreading like a virus engulfing opportunities that the natives deserved... So if u get hate for that... You can either be shameless and bare it or have some shame and return to your country give the natives some releif.... Put yourself in their place for a second and think...even in india Mumbai used to be peacefull and clean all those beautiful beaches... As soon as people from other states were allowed to settle in Maharashtra they overpopulated the state making it very conjusted for natives....indians especially the sanatani community once they spread beyond a limit in a country they try to force their ideologies on the natives thus ruining the peacefull environment and now even the indian government seems to be involved in a murder of some sikh guy which was expected considering the hate for sikhs they spread here in india which is how they win elections...

You can see AK47 on posters in Canada and KHALISTAN flags. Why Canadian citizens asking for separate nation in India?\n\nIf Canadian citizens want a separate homeland for Sikhs, they can create it from Canadian land. If they try it in India, they will meet same fate as Those Terrorists \n\nProud to be a Sikh, proud to be an INDIAN??

For those who live in the U.K., your indian community is made up of all the indians from all india. Here in Canada, 97% of all the Indians are Sikh from Punjab. All of our political parties consistent defend Sikh policies and the Sikh leaders because they are desperate for the votes of this community. It is a community in which eligible voters do vote actively and they also gather more money through fundraising than any other party.

He was no khalistani its all bloody indian media propaganda \nindia is doing its best by paying dogs to make khalistani demands\nmajority of sikhs do not support or trust khalistanis\ninnocent people get Khalistan flags put in their hands by indian agents\nso all sikhs get targeted God bless canada God bless Canadian prime minster

Sikh man was a convicted terr$#@st which canada gave refuge to and destroyed diplomatic relations with india on\n\nPoint 2 - Not just Indian Govt opposes seperate land for sikhs of India, we the sikhs of India overwhelmingly rejected this notion in mid 80's... So BBC please show responsibility and accountability while painting any narrative ! Also learn to state facts NOT itoned out narratives ...please ..

Well Indian government is saying #Canadian #Citizen Sikh leader Hardeep Singh #Nijjar is a #terrorist , why is Canadian government not arresting Hardeep Singh Nijjar ? I say Canadian Prime Minister Justin Tredau should establish Khalistan in Canada for Canadian Citizen Sikh leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar.

BBC is a racist News channel.\nWe Sikhs hate Khalistani Terrorists like Nijjar & parmar who killed 300 innocent passengers of a plane.\nJustin Trudeau is a clown & a idiot born with a silver spoon or golden spoon. He supported Khalistani sikh terrorists like Jagmeet singh and destroyed India relationship by the lying about Indian government.\n\nUSA is keeping SFJ Terrorists. Shameless fellows.\n\nEven UK has Khalistani Terrorists.

British created separatism issue between India and Pakistan. Now that is getting settled so now their Canada (controlled by Britain) creating new separatism movement and this time they are using Sikhs. See the pattern! If Canada interested in Sikhs having their own homeland, give them a piece of their country and move everyone who wants from India to there. Anyway these people don't live in India and they are not Indians.

With the implicit backing of the Government of Canada, some Sikh citizens in Canada are constantly interfering in India's internal matters, attempting to destabilize the country. In response, India has no choice but to protect its territorial integrity. Canada has not provided any evidence regarding the murder of an individual designated as a terrorist by Indian authorities. On the contrary, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau misused India's hospitality by inviting a known terrorist to a dinner held in his honor during his state visit to India.

China has Trudeau in ther pocket and he loves terror groups like Hamas, Hezbullah, Khalistan and all Vancouver and Montreal gangs - he says he is against India and Israel for cleaning up those bad actors - only conservatives can save Canada or god - does anyone know the Indian army has more than 60% in sikhs ? The whole Khalistan is a movement funded by drug lords and Islamic groups in Pakistan

China has Trudeau in ther pocket and he loves terror groups like Hamas, Hezbullah, Khalistan and all Vancouver and Montreal gangs - he says he is against India and Israel for cleaning up those bad actors - only conservatives can save Canada or god - does anyone know the Indian army has more than 60% in sikhs ? The whole Khalistan is a movement funded by drug lords and Islamic groups in Pakistan

@nitishrajput sir konsa step positive liya tha indian govt ne ,, kya mtlb h ki indian ke sikho ko govt ne smjha diya ,, saff bolo ki indian ke logo ko gumrah kiya ,, sant bhindrawale ko atankwadi bna diya ,, unke sikho ke liye hito ki baat ko ,, be fajul bna diya unhone kbhi nhi kha ki unhe khalistan chahiye pr apne media main bar bar ye hi bataya ki unhe alag desh chahiye tha ,, lakho sikho ka katlyam kiya ,, sirf akal takh ,, harmandir sahib pr hamla nhi kiya or bht sari jgahk pr bhi indian govt ne hmle kiye ,, ye kyu nhi btate ho ,, agr govt ko sirf bhindrawale se hi taklif thi to baki gurdwaro main to wo nhi the ,, kitna jhoot bologe apne serch sirf ye hi ki h ki jo bhi khalistan mang rhe h wo to 1 2 hi h ,, ?? please kam se kam apni serch bdhiya kijiye ek paksh ki hi bat mat kro ,, glt ko glt bolna sikho ,, apko kya lgta h sikh pgl h jo apne hakk mang rhe the ,, or unhe mar diya gya bina mtlv ke ,, 6 mnth ke bche se lekr 60 70 sall ke bajurg tak shaheed kr diye gai atankwadi bol kr ,,

Can u pls also tell how Indian govt agents target Sikhs

Sikhs;punjabis; hindus can also be considered as Indian orgin..

If Sikh nation was not there in India, Indians would have an earned extremely bad reputation.

sikh logo sa modi panga lega anuro haha degya sikh go down modi on your knees indian padhna likna audhar araah hain canada wallon na kaha punjab ka sikh ko right nhi Deya anh canada india Galo ko right bho nhi degya tum hindu and punjab ka kaki logo ko target karegya aah karegya barbad ek din india ka kahi log barbad hogya internationally bezati hoagy visa phi rokdiya canada ko nah janya sa indian joh gaya nhi wait karahi tha india main future khrab funds today ghar vagere beecha audhar jaata vaisa bhi khraab india main sikh na baachaya hindus ko abe sabak thi yahi sikh seekhaygya understand hindu

Khalistan sa panga leya hain canada ek sath hain sikh log abt sikhaya ga hindu ko maja indians ko aunki dukat dhikhana ka leya

Iam also sikh me and my all family live in uk i wanna tell one things my grand dad was served in Indian British army i lot of respect india and Indian army I am never support khalistan but when someone said to me a khalistani in comments then it is hurting me

It’s about time they are doing this . Indians have been living in these countries for decades many immigrated from the 60’s . And assimilated and live happily in these countries . But this new set of arrogant ,entitled, semi educated . Immigrants .especially north Indian. Sikh and Punjabi Foreign students have destroyed the image of india . \nThey are rude ,crude ,have no manners not polite , are aggressive ,don’t know how to drive .don’t follow the rules or laws of the land.they think their culture and religion is better that the locals .. and scream racism or Hindu phobia .for every thing.\nThese low class Indians are giving the Indian Americans and other Indians in other countries a bad name .and causing racism for the local Indians like . For the ones who are born and settled in these countries. For decades .\nTime to deport all Sikh and Punjabi. Students as they are the main trouble makers.most barely speak English .

Why don't people get it? Western governments are pandering to Modi the Indian Prime Minister. Modi is building ties with Russia. These governments don't want it so they're accomodating by allowing Sikhs into the country who are a thorn on Modis side. He wants to take over agricultural land from the Sikhs and nationalize farming. The Sikh farmers won't allow that.

Punjabi and Sikhs are overlapping so are Hindus and Indians. Pakistani is not an ethnicity.Who compiled this data don't know anything about south Asians :D. This is so dumb.

They're fudging the categories, as Indians are mostly Hindu with some Muslims, Pakistanis are Muslim, Punjabis are mostly Hindu and and Sikh, Pakistanis are of Punjabi ethnicity, etc. That's not even counting Bangladeshis and Sri Lankans. Even accounting for duplicate entries, that's still a lot of Indians.

i never understand your issue with indians our peoples are hardworking we respect every community dont hurt them likr hindus buddhist sikhs help the poor peoples most top companies ceos are indians the next president of USA is indian kamala harris canada should be happy that islam isn't growing tht much here otherwise it will end up like europe muslim states where sharia will be approved on everyone non Muslim will forced to become muslims hindus sikh of indian are most helping people's

Funny how people who colonized this land in search of India and Indians and later named it Canada are worried about real Indians taking over. \nIndia will definitely create k........inside Canada. Maps already been created, look it up. \nYou guys took in punjabi, atleast should have done some research why Hindus had created sikhs 500yrs ago

Here in my little town in Australia's Top End, we have a genuine melting pot. Filipinos, Chinese, Nepalis and the list goes on. The Sikhs are fantastic and I hope we get more, but younger Indians and Babgladeshis can be annoying. Still, our PM seems sure that they will repopulate our overpriced nation - c'est la vie.

India is one of the fastest economy in the world they will need to be representing as in many countries in the world . I personally think Canadians gets confused thinking they are muslims and they are not. If i have to choose i would certainly prefer them instead of bringin so many muslims from muslims countries around the world because they will never adapt to other cultures. Indian people are so adaptable to other countries more that any country in the world. I don't live in Canadá or any other country. By the way is so sad that Indian people with turbans g confused with muslims and people get worry about them not knowing they following the Sikh religious wich is one of the most adaptable religions in the world similar to cristian religious. I remember taking my two children to their festivities and they make us feel so welcome without any interests of persuading us to folowing their religion. I have sweet memory of indian people in general .

Hindu or sikh is not ethnicity. It is religion. Catagories should be white & non white. Indians pakistani & middle easterns etc. You make catagories like indians sikh punjabi etc.

Sikhs are Punjabi not indian.

The Canadians don't even know that Punjabi ,Hindu and Sikh are all from India. Why would to they say Indians and then seperate it. But I guess White people can tell them apart anyway.