Close Reading

I mean we need Indian Engineers to develop India by working for India,right? We can't develop India if engineers and doctors move out all the time

Vishwaguru. Elvish bhai ke aage koi bol sakta hai kya? Pehle USA puchta tha, tu kaun hai, ab hum bolte hai, tu kaun hai? \n\nModi Modi Modi!!! Aaega to Modi hi, double engine sarkar. Zyada bacche paida karne wale mangalsutra le jaenge.

I studied with an indian who had an engineering degree from india. Couldn't even pass a diploma here. I wouldnt trust indian qualifications.

Indian talent is a hoax. Nw US and west is getting better engineers from countries like Russia, Ukraine,Vietnam,Phillipines, Brazil. Even Taiwanise/chinise are catching up fast. In next 10 years. Most of the Indian coders will be jobless, thanx to AI and good coders from south asia, brazil, china, vietnam. Indians need to learn maths, algoriths, problem solving skills and creavitiy to stay in the compettion. Slogging wont work.

Behavior, culture and hygiene, I have some indian people working with me as software engineers in Germany, idk why they smell so bad, in a meeting i always sit far away from them, dont get wrong but teach your people to behave and be hygienic

You can blame Elon his companies alone brought in 800 engineers last year we're full !!!!

How many Americans go to India to work? A wicked caste system still enforced. Why would American Software engineers travel to work for an IT or software company? Plus, India has a lot abject poverty.

Surveys and other data found that many airplane crashes occur due to Indian engineers whose work is reckless, lazy, and irresponsible.

Visas for muslim freebies on the other way has been smoothened. Let these countries have their doctors and engineers

What is the Indian government to curb scamming Indian call centres?\n\nThe scam may be affecting other countries but it is happening from India and this will hugely damage Indias reputation as hard working engineers.\n\nThe government is really doing nothing to stop these criminals. Just whataboutery will not do us any good. We need to set our own in order first.

The doctors and engineers are NOT ENOUGH???

Im from Tamilnadu and while abroad i worked in shell for a shutdown i saw north indians workers spitting pan just before the englishmen and I, as an engineer from the same nationality as these backward people have to feel 2nd hand embarrassment for what these people do.\nMany in kerala and Tamilnadu behave well and have good manners. Unfortunately the majority of north Indians are like this excluding some guys who are very well behaved than me. Not out of hate but out of frustration.

These countries have no problem taking in terrorists and rapists but have a problem with Indian engineers and doctors.

My husband is an IT engineer in Amazon. He is getting company transfer to Canada. I his wife will come along with him and will get work visa on arrival.\nI want to apply for PR. What will be the best way to go. Please guide.My daughter is US citizen and is 3 years old.

There are over 260 visa only colleges in Canada and about 200 in Australia,these colleges are of no use and over lakhs of students come here every year,why the government doesn't take action on it and close these universities,and why does they treat the illegal visa immigrants and skilled immigrant like engineers and doctors the same

Guys, I am moving to Germany this month for an internship in a construction company. I am thinking of transitioning to Civil Engineer Position. The company is helpful with finding an apartment for me. I plan to learn German to C1 level. What is your advise to me? Is the construction industry hard or discriminatory as some other industries stated here ? Thank you.

Actually it is soo true. I have considered german for my education because it is less expensive than USA but I don’t see my full life in Germany because of language barriers and not promoting other nationals in higher positions. Go to USA you will find half of the top CEO or engineers Indians but come back to Germany and you won’t find many, this is because Germans don’t usually promote other nationals in managing positions higher than them. This is not welcoming so folks it is better if you come for your education, gain some work experience, explore europe as much as you can then move to USA and build your own home and raise kids, again push them to come to germany for free education of bachelors and masters ?

American Computer Scientists and Engineers created the “ Internet” and “Artificial Intelligence”! Don’t be FOOLED by India. They were NOT here in America on OUR American Computer Systems or Universities!

Basically Canadians are saying they and their ancestors didn't fight in ww1,ww2 ,tame the cold wild environment,spend centuries building Canada just to have it turned to India 2.0 in under one decade by Trudeau.It is time the highly skilled bestest global engineers of India go fix India like China,Japan and Korea did. After all the East asians and Whites don't have 2 heads. \nMaybe they should mass convert to christianity and ditch hinduism ,The hindu gods have shown themselves incapable of building a modern successful society like the West the hindus are fleeing to.

Good luck hiring all the doctors and engineers from Afganistan, Syria, Marocco. You didn't want the IT experts and engineers from eastern europe

Similar story, grew up in Vancouver as a kid. Can't say that I got much from Canada other than a pile of student debt. With a top engineering degree from a Canadian university, no jobs, no interviews. If it set me up for a better future, I could give it some credit, but even with visas, I had *much* better luck with opportunities in the US and even in western Europe, which is similarly socialist to Canada. I have had to move from country to country thanks to the lack of decent opportunity in Canada. More liability than asset, in my experience, other than the passport. Glad I left when I did, only regret I didn't do it sooner. Good luck to wherever you go next. I hear eastern Europe is a cool place, if you bring your income with you ;-)

Canadian government don't need your dr. . Engineer your guys keep it we have a lot here in Canada

No more hope here...sorry!!! For every doctor or engineer that comes from India, there's over 1000 McDonald's, Tim Hortons, Walmart workers and dangerous truck drivers without proper training that we don't want or need. Canadians can fill these jobs and are ready to take them back. Canadians need money too and being Canadians, we are FIRST!!!!!

I'm a newcomer, and I agree with the points, and I see that people are blaming immigrants in general, but they don't think in the structural flaws that we have in the government system, I found a shame the public transportation in some of the biggest cities and in other public services, and I found that could be easier the validation of diplomos, we have doctors and engineers driving uber, because they can't work in their profession, and I feel that they are putting limits in the immigrants from one side, but they have no limits in refugees, I understand that they need help but should have a limit that the structure can hold.

Send them home. They already invaded Canada. Don't let them come in to the USA. They come to the US to study Medicine(Doctor), Engineering and IT the they will stay. Taking jobs away from my fellow Americans?

Hello! Could you share a recruiting agency that deals with Civil Engineers? Planning relocation from Europe to British Columbia.

Not telling the Canadian government how to do their job. \n\nBut I work in tech - when something goes wrong in the pipe, we investigate by hitting the pause button and start reverse engineering to see where the corrupt code was introduced. Then isolate it, and deconstruct/rewrite it. \n\nTelling a tax-paying immigrant that we made an oopsie and the lives they’ve been living have been technically criminal and they need to be deported ASAP - not down with that. Will we have stolen their labor and money? REALLY not down with that. Their situation is in the same direction of the Dreamers in the US.

Hey where did u get all this Information, Indians are Invading Canada that is why we don't want them, you said they are engineers, healthcare workers .... kkk they are in walmart, timhortons, uber drivers and working in malls taking over all the entry jobs, that the young Candians can't get a job.... when Indian became a supervisor only hire Indians .. and reject other applications ... as soon all of this Indians left we will get the relief.

?? what u talking about doctors engineers... more like tim hortons coffee shops and uber food delivery... go back to india and bring actual doctors engineers....✌ ??

I am a skilled worker (an engineer), I graduated from a master's in Germany and speak fluent german. Housing is one of the negative points I can mention. Another one is the waiting times for a document work at Ausländerbehörde. Here in Stuttgart it is the worst as far as I see. \nAnother thing I dont like is to pay so much to the health insurance and at the end you even cannot get an appointment when you have a tooth ache for instance. \nAnother rather cultural difficulty is that you cannot find a place in the society, Germans do not make friends and when you only make friends with expats then it does not feel you are a part of the society. At least from my understanding.\n\nPositively enough, I have not yet faced racism in my daily life etc. \n\nI would be thinking to leave Germany one day maybe, but for another german speaking country probably.

I completely disagree with the international student english proficiency requirement to get a PGWP (i.e. for all international students). To get into any University program in Canada, you will need to pass an English Language proficiency test like IELTS or TOEFL anyways. At least for my four years of an Engineering degree, three co-op terms and a full-time secured Engineering position, 8 months before graduation you would think this international student knows how to communicate in English :). \n\nYes, there are certain students who just want to get the PR and don't care about the degree they are getting and probably just passed with the minimum IELTS requirement. A solution would be to make certain degrees like college diploma students take the English Language proficiency test again and at least have a language testing system which is free for these people. Spending $300-$400 after spending so much on international tuition fee to graduate from Bachelor's degree is a good policy in my honest opinion.

The problem of Canada is not migration or international students. International students bring millions of dollars to the country. They pay fees 3 times higher than local students. The problem is the economy, provinces, municipalities, private sector and professional newcomers are unable to build houses, apartments and provide services for more than 1 million of newcomers per year. The economy is completely closed to international companies, engineers, doctors. There are big monopolies who regulate and rule the market in association with a WOKE socialist government. This is why Canada doesn’t grow and isn’t able to provide services. It’s more like a third world country , banana republic or failed state.

General Motors Silao plant is one of the largest auto assembly plants in Mexico, assembling Chevy Silverados and G.M.C. Sierra full-size pickup trucks, and a variety of V8 engines and automatic transmissions. Mexico is the world’s fourth-largest vehicle exporter after Germany, Japan and the United States, and 80 percent of its vehicle exports are destined for the United States.\n\nThe starting wage at the plant is $9 per day, just 60 cents above the country’s legal minimum wage, and the top wage is $23 per day for a 12-hour day, with no overtime pay.

India looks like a shithole Country. India has a lot of engineers why the country is still poor ?

OUR PRESIDENT HAS A PHD IN SCIENCE ENGINEERING!!! LONG LIVE MEXICO ???? WE WILL NOT BOW TO USA WE ARE NOT IN THE PAST!! ???❤️❤️??

Mexican vote Claudia scientist engineer energy power full women in world leader 5 smart leader vote felon 34 count half Americans said dummy 79 half Americans said dummy Claudia hire best trump hire clowns dummy who win smart or dummy

My husband and I are engineers from the US and Mexico and have lived in Germany for 15 years. Both speak fluent German and have raised three kids here. Yes, many people are racist. But if you learn the language well it’s not that hard to integrate and then things get much better. Germans can be the best friends you’ve ever had, much better than superficial Americans, but it can be hard to break through the shell. We have always loved it here. But to be honest with the steadily declining economy, massive scarcity in housing, and no salary increases in years, we are considering leaving as well. The outlook isn’t good for the Automotive industry and we could make double or triple the salary elsewhere. It would be very difficult to pull up our roots now gs better get better quick or we won’t stay much longer.

Yeah, probably what they aren't telling you is that the ones who leave are the one's Canada wants... Canada wants doctors, engineers, and other skilled workers.... not coffee-slingers and sandwich peddlers....

Don't renew the visa , if they are not quality worker. In India you would find all sorts of people as the population is large there are loads of quality workers and very large poor quality workers. Make it hard to get visa, unless the person is coming in with the bigger jobs like engineer, doctor etc.

I am a double hater cant stand Trump and I am a farmer, i dont use immigrants because i just grow crops that can be mechanically harvested and I have a small farm, But in the past I used to manage large farms where we had a lot of immigrants most were illegal and people don't understand why they're illegal It's because there is an arbitrary cap on how many migrants can come from Guatemala and Mexico if they wanted to come legally just a normal worker They have a 60-year waiting list so it's just impossible to come here legally. Most of these people are very hardworking good people that come here to work for 5 to 7 years save up money and then go back to Mexico or Guatemala build a house and start a business in their own country. \n\nThis year i begrudgingly voted for trump because for me the biggest issue is with the federal and state regulations that make farming much harder than it needs to be especially regulations on diesel engine emissions that cost me tens of thousands of dollars a year and many months of not being able to use my equipment that I spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on. And Kamala was the one who enforced the CARB emmisions standards that diesel engine manufactures have to comply with to sell into California which is the biggest consumer of these engines. \n\nLike right now I have my pickup truck that's been down for 6 months because of emissions problems and so many of the vehicles have emissions problems that the parts to fix it don't even have an ETA because they need to fix so many trucks and I have two other tractors broke down that I can't use all my friends that are farmers have a lot more and dems want to significantly increase emmisions standards in 2026. \n\nYou simply can't grow food at scale without reliable diesel engines There is no alternative The vast majority of food is planted and harvested mechanically in the US The bigger issue with food is not well illegals get deported It is will the diesel engines run to harvest 90% of the calories in plant them. \n\nWe have robots that can milk the cows most of the things that migrants harvest can be harvested mechanically and they are in other parts of the world It's just cheaper to do it with labor once that's not the case it will be mechanized. I would prefer to keep migrants here but give them legal working status if they have productive jobs and they pay tax.

Canada took separatists and terrorists - America took engineers and doctors and businesspersons and the difference is obvious

Countries full, try England, we've got enough future engineers and doctors.

Restrict Asylum and increase immigration of friendly nation's engineers and scientists. Increase U.S. educated foreign engineers and scientists immigration.

They managed to find a way to get them in with financial resources, hotel housing and airfare, I’m sure they can figure out how to reverse engineer.

I am working in Saudi Arabia as Planning Engineer but my profession on Iqama is Workshop worker. Is that a problem to apply for Canada’s visit visa? If yes, what is the solution?

You do know, that while Canada already been giving the Skilled Workers the preferential treatment fir decades, many of the Doctors, Engineers, Nurses, etc are unable to get a job of their training, bc they must write expensive, long exams! \n\nIf they had been out of the University for years, this is not easy to do! They need to support their families, study again and save Thousands of $$$ to pay for and write these exams! Canada makes it difficult for them to work in their field! \n\nThey receive many promises from the Canadian Immigration Department, which often does not deliver! A valid example, those with the Master’s Degrees, too often, receive only the Bachelor Degree equivalency in Canada, despite the promise of their degrees and experience in the field to be honoured! It’s an unjust and an unfair system! An Engineer driving a Taxi! Many, many such examples! \n\nThat’s why many highly-educated immigrants are working as taxi drivers, delivering food, or in under -educated jobs, etc! I met a hospital Medical Lab Tech, who was a Doctor in his birth country!! Another immigrant was a Lab Tech working as a Lab Assistant! Still, another immigrant with a Master’s Degree and experience in the Medical Cancer Research working as a Lab Assistant! \n\nThe bills don’t wait until they write the new exams, save the required money and qualify, etc!!

The manufacturing and high-tech jobs that Canada once prided itself on are no longer flourishing here. Instead, many Canadian millionaires and billionaires have moved significant projects overseas to countries like China and India, where labor is cheaper. My cousin, for example, manages software engineers in India who produce software for a Canadian company he works for—because the company's millionaire owner recognizes that outsourcing is far more cost-effective than employing Canadians. Similarly, a friend in Calgary mentioned that even the construction of the Peace Bridge involved components manufactured in South Korea, with only the assembly done locally. It became a political statement, but it highlighted how even critical infrastructure projects are outsourced for cost savings.\n\nSo, who is truly to blame? Politicians and business leaders, most of whom are born and raised in Canada, are at the heart of this issue. Immigrants face the same struggles as many underprivileged Canadians. For instance, a Tim Hortons owner on Southland Drive SE shared with me that he struggled to hire local workers—many would not show up or quit without notice. Eventually, he sponsored six workers from the Philippines, providing them housing nearby, and his operations became smoother without the frequent staffing issues. Another employer mentioned that when hiring local workers, he often hires two people for a one-person job because he knows that one might not show up. These stories underscore the reality that the challenges with the labor market are deeper than just immigration—they reflect structural issues within the economy and decisions made by those at the top.

Stop so many people from India. Bring Doctors, nurses, teachers, engineers & construction workers from different countries & it will be good for our economy!

Indians were invaded, indians were taught English by the brits. Indian immigrate for better life to other countries, indians pay taxes and develop all countries. It's you who needs us to keep your engine running, complaining about too many Indians won't solve the problem. High potential, big brain indians leave our country which is a concern for us as well. Its like everyone is unhappy.

Mostly are from Punjab state of India..\nElse Other Indians are hired by Big Technology companies as Highly skilled engineers and scientists and IT professional..\nI dont know why some people specially Punjabis go even to works as labourer and dirty works in other countries..