Close Reading

just a thought of logic:\nokaaaay and while they aren't able to take advantage of having their land have to flee bcs there are military operations against terrorists under their population, the population should be given the right to flee to countries of equal culture, language and religion or additionally, that are geograohically closer to reach than Europe!

By this logic, those who lied on thier visas like elon and melania should go too.

Why is it controversial? Isnt it logical to deport someone who enter your country illegally ?

By her logic she is still Mexican and should be deported with her family.

Not the“back in my day” ass logic!!! of course it was 1000x easier to get residency/green cards/citizenship like 50 years ago ???

Shes a true American citizen who is here legally, she believes people who are here illegally should have to leave, even her family. She’s actually only in the right. The illegal immigration needs to stop know matter who it is. Like thats only pure sanity, logicality, and realness. Know one should ever support illegal immigration no matter what nation you’re in, especially if its your home, each and every nation only has the resources to support its citizens, not billions of other nations citizens along with its own. America is the only nation with people who actually support illegal immigration, and thats sad.

These people are running away from their countries, and they should leave all the issues and ideologies behind. Otherwise their logic is to leave an oppressive situation to subsequently try and recreate the oppressive situation here… crazy

If this is what it takes to teach these people who voted against their own friends and families, so be it. I have lost all sympathy for the right wing. They went full religiously driven nutty with an obsession with believing every little crazy story and never looked back. Every person I meet that give me cooky vibes or talks about Jesus or some sort of outdated fucked up thing is a Trumper and nothing will change their minds. Everyone now has at least one relative who, on the surface, would appear to be a perfectly logical person but ask them to justify why they love Trump so much and they give you some totally wacky fact or false claim about some sort of random thing in our world like social security or trans people or immigration and cant seem to wrap their minds around the idea that it isn't true and that those claims are being used to manipulate them.

Deporting illegals out of our country...why is that controversial? They're here illegally! By that logic, I should be able to live in Mexico and vote in their elections as a US citizen?

Pure BAT$HIT!\nNone of these insane scenarios can logically be explained,\nI give up?

Her logic is flawed. What makes any of the people of color think Trump will stop at deporting only non white illegal immigrants?

It's time to get LEGAL AND PAY TAXES ALSO OR LEAVE. They are GIVING billions of taxpayers dollars to illegals who come here and strain our systems while AMERICANS ARE LOSING OUT. We need our manufacturing back in our own countries. And our own farmers can handle our food. Our farmers are under fire. They need our support. And we have always had WORK VISAS for seasonal workers for AG. That doesn't mean they can come here illegally and DRAIN OUR RESOURCES . This isn't even remotely logical. You cannot have a successful economy or a secure safe country WITHOUT LAWS to govern immigration.

They will make noise but reality will dictate much smaller goals than they have. IT is just as practical if they say they will give every American 1 Million dollars so everyone is a millionaire. STUPID is as STUPID does. Mass deportation is a logical and resource nightmare. War is about resources and logistics and this war is not winnable on deportation, they will rely on terrorism and fear more than practicality.

This is logical, someone living in your house without your permission would you throw them out or keep them. Go out and maybe you can come back legally.

Same People who live in Gated Communities, and who do not Allow poor people to Live in their Big Homes Permanently, are the Same People who want to Flood Poor communities around America with Immigrants from Third world Countries.\nTheir Logic Borders Only for Us who Live in Gated Communities, and for everybody else specially you peasants you have to live with Third world Immigrants and enjoy Diversity.

As a non American it’s hilarious to see how stupid these news outlets are. They are so full of their wokeness that they defy all logic and not focused on addressing the problem. They still don’t see that the people have voted for this in majority. God just saved America.

I wonder how much trauma these Democratic individuals have gone through for their ability to think logically and use common sense to seem completely lost. It’s truly sad for them.

Where’s her logic!!!!????

These white people should seriously go back to their own land first by that logic? maybe UK or somewhere from where their ancestors actually came and invaded the Americas.

Lady should go back to Britain. \nBritish looted from India. \nAs per her logic, she owes that man money and grains.\nA=B, B=C hence A=C . Its simple math.

Joke that BBC can ever report on anything logically.. anyway countries like UK and Canada with inferior economies to India shouldn't matter..Trudeau is desperate to stay in power, pathetic !

By her logic, every american and Canadians should go back to Europe because that land belongs to red indians (native Americans). Or better all humans should go back to Africa because humanity orgins from that continent ?

By that logic white people should move back to Europe

Indians are over running Canada. Its logical they will bring there problems there.

Is she wrong ?... logically no... any country's citizen get distressed bcoz of too many immigrants \nEg pakistan & iran ousted afghans etc etc

by that logic majority of races are not natives, also whats wrong with this comment section she's in no position to say that to someone else. \n\nAlso people get opinion of your own, instead of just wanting validation to go with rest of comment section.

Those are supporting the karen remember one thing Canadian government is willingly accepting Indian students if they really didn't cared about the revenue generated by it then they would have created a more restricted entry for immigrants like Japanese government do\n\nSo supporters of Karen your logic is flawed?

The only logical explanation is that they are allowing this for a reason, and that reason is to build a voter-base for the Democratic Party.

Why has the Arab world had to take refugees who are being kicked out of their homeland?? This logic is ridiculous.

It is undeniably sad these people are going through this, and it should have been handled more intelligently and logically from the beginning. If your belief is either they should all be left to drown, or that we should have no borders at all, you are at an extreme and you are why we have this problem today. When the Nazis take Germany over again, it will in part because the left was so naive and stupid. And all of you who saw this coming, should have rightfully spoken out while condemning an all out nationalist and hateful ideologies. \n\nEither extreme just leads to the other, and if you fell for either one, shame on you. History is already proving this to be true. The fact speaking concern about immigration is instantly labeled as racism has endangered the lives of the very people you claim you wanted to protect, how stupid are you?

Why don’t you go to Palestine and “free Palestine” and live up to your values instead of asking Canada to become Palestine?! I for example immigrated here because my values match liberal western democracy lifestyle. Does it sound logical to you?!

A covert way of saying Israel shouldn't exist. If anyone believes that, then you have to apply the same logic to Pakistan and Bangladesh as they were created as homelands for Muslims carved out from another. The difference is of course is that Jews settled in the area before Islam even existed.

All Hamas has to do is stop attacking Israel and focus on taking care of their own people, let me known what country in this world wouid allow a neighboring country attack them and launch rockets into their country, according to this guys logic do you think Mexico can do this to America? It’s a joke that Hamas thinks they have found the cheat code to warfare were all they have to do is have their fighters not wear uniforms and use human shields? Like no other military in history ever thought of this ?

simple logic , all khalisthany hijadas are not safe in canada anymore , so they are sending them to US. dont call them Indians

They never answer the questions! How can the be accepted by colleges here with such logic and reasoning skills.

Don't use logic with them, they don't get it. ?

Canadian logic : send back international student who paid to study and graduated then worked then bring refugees give them PR educate them from tax payer money then put them on welfare.

India is ridiculously overpopulated. They probably live in a constant state of competition for every possible resource imaginable to the point that they literally have not developed the same sense of empathy, logic or morals when considering how their behaviour impacts others. Which is why there are so many issues with scamming and manipulating. You can literally see the woman in this video trying to manipulate the reporter.

Someone needs to give that dis-Honorable MP a clown nose, and honk her horn, and while at it a duns hat and tell her to go sit in the corner. Crazy logic of the liberals. if honking a horn was racist, then it would never be a feature allowed by transport Canada to be implemented in a vehicle.

So if Canada is considered stolen land by their logic. Do they view themselves as active participants in the colo n ization? i want to know as a native american myself. Ofcourse imo the claim is ridiculous.

Saying Canadians are anti immigration is like saying being opposed to drone strikes means being anti aircraft. That simple form of logic is called syllogism.

I thought the environment was a priority. How does bringing extreme breeders from far away lands help the environment. Won't this land become like their land, overpopulated and heavily polluted. The natural world is being obliterated in the region of Canada I live in. Forest and farmlands being replaced with breeders and SUVs. It's not logical or scientific.

I can't believe that he had to logicalize the logic

The same person wrote all those protest signs! These people cant speak english but want all Canadian rights, not logical.

No. Just because I travel to a foreign country doesn't give me the right to stay there forever. Pretty simple logic for some.

Don’t condone this man’s actions. If you have an opinion, take all that frustration and direct it to the people in power to try and change things. You can’t harass people just walking on the street like this. Taking it out on pedestrians won’t change anything and will just make things worse. Furthermore, he couldn’t even think of a Muslim country. Do you think this geezer would be capable of rational, logical and fair discussion?

I’m in Canada for past 2 years. Despite its negatives what I appreciate the most is work life balance and women’s safety. Life is difficult for international students but for those who come here with PR or jobs it’s a little better for them. Anti India sentiments are mostly among Khalistanis. There is absolute logic for non Khalistani Canadians to not like Indians- the quality of people who have been coming here are not exactly the ‘brains’ and crème de la crème of India. They lack basic etiquette and civic sense and have been caught shoplifting, evading fares on public transit. We have no one to blame other than ourselves for this. Otherwise Canadians are very polite and friendly to immigrants. I’ve never had strangers holding doors to public places open for me back in India which I have experienced here.

Venezuela had rich petroleum resources with your logic it should be richest country……..

Lot of comments, next time you vote.\n\nDo not use feelings, use logic..

I don’t find this racist at all. It is very logical and needed discussion. Immigration department needs to evaluate all the options before granting entry to newcomers. Jobs, housing, what skills they bring, what is needed for the country, and most importantly adaptability of newcomers.