Close Reading

Here's the Saudis they have plenty they can give land to the palastinians then Israel won't have to pay for everything they want an the Saudis are mmuslim

1. Before Israel there was a British Mandate, not a Palestinian state\n\n2. Before the British Mandate, it was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.\n\n3. Before the Ottoman Empire Was the Islamic State of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.\n\n4. Before the Islamic State of the Mamluks from Egypt, the Arab-Kurdish Empire was the Ayyubid, not a Palestinian state.\n\n5. Before the Ayyubid Empire was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.\n\n6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem was the Umayyad and Fatimid empire, not a Palestinian state.\n\n7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, the Byzantine Empire was not a Palestinian state.\n\n8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.\n\n9. Before the Sassanid Empire was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.\n\n10. Before the Byzantine Empire was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.\n\n11. Before the Roman Empire it was a Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.\n\n12. Before the Hasmonean state was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.\n\n13. Before the Seleucid Empire was the Empire of Alexander, not a Palestinian state.\n\n14. Before Alexander's empire it was the Persian Empire, not a Palestinian state.\n\n15. Before the Persian Empire was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.\n\n16. Before the Babylonian Empire were the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.\n\n17. Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was no kingdom of Israel in the kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.\n\n18. Before the Kingdom of Israel, the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel was not a Palestinian state.\n\n19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an accumulation of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.\n\n20. In fact, in this plot of land kingdoms fell and fell .. But there was never a Palestinian state or a people

Right of living is also for israel. Palestine should stop the killing of Israeli

Translation: we don’t want them. The Gaza- Egypt border is tighter the the Gaza- Israel border. But would u take the women and children for a little while while the war is hot? Like Europe took the Syrians?

unfortunately, the government of that land started a war with its neighbor. Now the citizens are stuck between Israel and a corrupt terrorist government. Mind you the aid is used for the war effort

sure, other Muslim countries are aware of who the Palestinians are and don't accept them as refugees. instead, Palestinians are encouraged and supported to fight against Jews and destroy Israel.

Then dont cry as gaza gets flatten by greater allah protected Israel

So basically he said HAMAS has to be destroyed, without saying it.... SUPPORT ISRAEL, Free Gaza!!!!

who's blockade are we talking about? Is it from egypt, an arab country that has blockade in gaza or it lebanon also and arab that also has one? And why single out israel by putting walls on their boundaries?? US has walls...SK and NK has walls etc.

That right there Palestinian will not be pushed off their land so Israel can steal and all its oil.. Israel has go

The arabs will not assist. They put the palestinians there to poke the chest of israel. Same as the jews were put there to poke the arabs in the chest.

Haha, this doesn't answer the question—kind of an oblivious response. Hamas attacked Israel so they have a right to defend their land. We don't need to be rocket scientists to know that they are going to do it again. Further Hamas uses its people when it attacks Israelis. Where have any other Arab nations shown any type of involvement in condemning Hamas and intervening by stopping Hamas whether it's through negotiations or by force? it's because most of them back Hamas and know if they don't take any refugees it's only going to cause Israel more harm than if they were terrorists. People condemning Israel are stupid. Take your time to look into the entire matter before pointing a finger to entertain your life.

And Israel shouldn't have the right to then take away the Palestinians' right of return when they think they have the right of return thousands of years later! So ridiculous! Who the hell do they think they are?!

It would be nice if one Islamic nation offered assistance or refuge instead of all their tough love. Gaza borders on Egypt and Israel. Why didn’t Egypt ever offer electricity, food and water to the Palestinian civilians?

Yes, of course the Palestinian people have the right to their land and the right to live on their land in dignity, peace and security but if nobody makes Israel stop butchering them, shouldn't someone at least offer them temporary refuge? I would want that if I were stuck there with my loved ones.

I don’t understand why they keep saying free palistine ...when the neighboring arab country can’t keep them for a while ...while there’s still a war between them and israel...what’s the point...?...

Why are they helping Israel then?

This men are still in support of the Palestinians. If I were a Palestinians, I will sell my own land potion to Israeli government and have peace, then migrate to any Arab country because Israel are the real owner of the land and supported by strong countries.

The reporter is basically saying “please help Israel with ethnic cleansing”. Do they think we are stupid? ??‍♂️

Israel is trying to make the occupied territories as unlivable as possible for the Palestinians so that they leave and then Israel fully annexes the territories and makes them a part of Israel!… That’s how Israel was created and that’s how Israel has slowly but surely grown bigger!

The Quran says in Chapter 5 verses 21 to 26 that Allah has assigned that land to the Jews. Does this Muslim not read his Quran. Its not the land of the Palestinians. The Jews have been living in Israel for thousands of years. Its is NOT their land. The Arabs want to wipe out the Jews and Israel. This is not political its religious. They want to establish a World Islamic State.... Israel today....Europe tomorrow. But the God of Abraham has a covenant with the Jews...they are Gods chosen people. The evil Islamic religion will NEVER defeat Israel. God Bless Israel.

Except he will say all of Israel is Palestinian land.\n\nI really hope those who are immigrants aren’t in support of this ideology, or you’re a hypocrite.

Israel recognize KOSOVO ???

All this debate about israel/palestine, theoretically what would happen if israel gave back all the land they took and everything became peaceful, what would become of the israelis, would anyone care or help them, be interesting to know the outcome, as i said a theoretical question

The terrorist government they elected invaded Israel.\nIsrael responded.

Israel has the right to safety and security in their own land, and Palestinians won’t let that be, so Palestinians seem surprised that when they refuse to let Israel be safe and secure in their own land, for some reason, Palestinians are no longer safe and secure in their own land. Gee, go figure?

I hope this guy realizes Israel has a right to exist and a right to live on their land.

If soudi is concerned they should ship oil to Israel. Soudi government is usa puphet

Well said it, Palestinians deserve to live in peace in THEIR LAND, Israel it’s the one that need to stop committing atrocities against Palestinians

Normal, Saudia supports tacidly Israel. MBS believes he has hebrew ancestry.

He deflected to the actual reason they don't take refugees. They want casualties and Palestinians to distract and attack Israel. They can't do that if the innocent and others are not present.

The Saudi's had no problem kicking tens of thousands of Jews out of their land back in the late 40's and early 50's. Islamic countries kicked out almost 1 million Jews and stole just about everything they had. Israel took in every last one of them. In Contrast, Jordan killed 25,000 Palestinians back then. The Arab Spring saw over 200,000 Palestinians die by the hands of other Muslim Arabs. Anyone complain about that? Nope. So his answer is nonsense.

That's all that Israel has been asking for for what 60 years?

israel would love to hear other countries are ready to absorb the Palestinians and allow them to inherit the vacated lands. not our watch

But their refusal to accept the Palestinians as refugees, also contribute to more deaths. Like Israel not stopping + Arab countries not letting Palestinians in = More dead Palestinians.\nARABS: We're are so concerned about the Palestinians.\nMEDIA: Oh really? How so?\nARABS: By giving interviews like this, and posting our support in social media, and maybe a little bit of money.

Ummm, but what about Israels rights?

He is right. We have to find a way for palestinians to stay and leave peacefully on THEIR land. \nWe know the dream of israel is to see them leave. So they can keep the territory for themself.

This Prince is worth billions of dollars. He could help but he chooses not money and power is more important to him. Since he has Money probably supports hamas to do is job against israel. These Arab countries have so much hate to the Jewish nation And it's people.. There is no way they're gonna move the Palestinian people for that reason. If they did the world would be a better place. But this would never happen to much bloodshed and hate for thousands of years.

The weight is HAMAS!!!!! The weight is also the rest of the Arab world refusing to help & allow other Arabs to live and move freely!!!!! HAMAS is keeping Palestinians hostage as a tool to prod against Israel!!!!!!!!

Israel has a right to their land too...

The UN is crap. The Gazans could have lived in peace for the last 75 years if they accepted Israel's right to exist. The Gaza is apartheid. No Jews allowed. Israel is not apartheid. There are millions of Muslims in Israel.

'Their land ' is 'from the river to the sea' \n\nNO Israel ?

Palestine is not a country. It's never been a country. Palestinians are a combination of Egyptians, Jordanians, Syrians, and Lebanese arabs that were expelled from their countries and the British Mandate. The area of land you're referring to is not Palestine. It's Israel or, if you want to go back further, Judea and Sumaria. The people who rightfully live there, and have lived there for thousands of years, are happy to let others live there as well; as long as they're peaceful. Seems to be hard for some.

That's exactly what Israel wants? They want the Palestinians to leave so they can seize the land.

Missed out on the perfect follow up question: should Palestinians give Israel the same respect they are asking for? They cannot wrap their heads around it: they believe Israel does not have the right to live in their own land in safety and security, and not be forced out, nor will they stop the killing of Israelis by rockets and other attacks.

Whatever he said and demanded , Israel and West have refused already to do so , Now Question is , Will Saudia or Iran refuge Palestinians , Answer is NO absolutely NOT. they neither have balls to fight Israel , nor to refuge Other Muslims.

Any single GCC countries will not accept Palestinian as migrants ?? they know Palestinian \nSee here in Kuwait so many Palestinian are living since birth but they don’t have Kuwaiti citizenship \nAll this GCC countries are fighting with Israel for their own benefits and to satisfy their ego, not for Palestinian

Israel uses rockets to protect its civilians, Hamas uses civilians to protect its rockets.

Stinking Arab States have stopped Arab Palestinians from migrating to their countries since 1947 so as to put pressure on Israel. \nWhy are their refugee camps (now cities) ? \nJordan ejected one million Palestinian refugees by military force in the late 1960’s, Kuwait took 300,000 for labor then threw them out after the gulf war because they backed Hussain.\nArabs have consistently failed Arab Palestinians and have since 1947, they, the Palestinians are their pawns and their real enemies are the Arab States but their bigotry blames the Jews. \n\nArabs don’t care for the deaths of over 600,000 Arabs in Syria or 400,000 in Yemen nor do they care of the ethnic cleansing of 2 million Afghanis from Pakistan but we are supposed to believe they are full of tears for a few thousand Palestinians?

They never identified themselves as Palestinian before the creation of Israel. This is bizarre to take a Roman name to call yourself. Also no blinked an eye as Arabs forced the majority of Lebanese Christians from their homes. Lot's of blind eyes ? to things from the past. Wealthy Arab countries that have the means to house them but they don't really care.