Close Reading

What is the benefit of being a fake Canadian? Where is the profit?

This was a horribly done story. It doesn't talk enough about the money or incentives. What financial incentive did these fake immigrants have to pay thousands of dollars to become a Canadian citizen. They briefly mention a low income benefit but don't even basically explain to what it amounts. Was Canada paying these fake citizens thousands of dollars a year in cash benefits for fake reports on low income earnings? It's like doing a story on a mass murderer, how he murdered and giving no background on his mental health or motivation.

Can't speak English or French, turn them back ,Canadians paying enough of TRUDEAU'S BULLSHIT, free benefits and can't find jobs because of language and cold winters (WTF) Get rid of Queen Justin and straighten out what the LIBERAL PARTY has destroyed, DO(N in 2019!!!

Freaking Chinese...millionaires and reaking in unemployment benefits from our pockets!!!! Get them all out!!!!!

Deport him and his clients!!! Millionaire claims poor tax benefit, how disgusting!!!

So he made 10m dollars. They should at least get that back and secondly these individuals who claimed the state benefits for low wage top ups in Canada must hand every penny back for that and the legal costs. Just expelling these people who don't even live in China anyway is not much punishment.

This is nothing. You should do some research into the Muslim immigrants that come here, divorce their first wife, set up a fake apartment in the basement of the house and sponsor the 2nd wife to come in, divorce her, set up a fake apartment in the basement, repeat twice over and each divorced wife gets extra benefits from the government for being a single mother. It happens quite a lot.

The problem is the government didn't know how to make enough money in the country...... That's why they want more other people to do investment or have business in Canada in order to bring more money into the country. The fact is the social welfare is too good that government might not be able to afford that big spending. First, Government needs to know how to make money on their own, not depending rich immigrants. Second, encourage citizens to have baby by providing benefits for them, to boost the birth rate. Third, stop being so nice to refugee, stop importing refugee! The biggest problem of refugee is they don't make money to the country, they rely on social welfare heavily.

It is ridiculous that Canada and US do not even know if a particular individual have existed the country. Esp. when the benefits they are seeking are within the same agency. The US it’s all DHS. People have to file FOIA request to request the agency for information they hold in order to give it back to the exact same agency as evidence. Just beyond any logic.

A few things do not make sense. For example, they have their own translator to lie for them, How is it possible that there is no counter measures in placed? i.e. immigration's own translator. Just like sports, you have more than 1 referee in a game. Secondly, how is it possible to become to citizen without knowing either English or French? (referring to the need of translator for citizenship test) If they love the country enough to migrate, shouldn't they have similar values? It seems like they are just here for benefits? Why is the immigration criteria being so loose?

Close the gates to the Chinese. Way too many as is. All they do is steal and copy, they are like xerox bots. Send them back to mother china. The Brits and French who built this country need to take it back. Don't let these third worlders ruin what your ancestors built, or the idiotic lib-left, who are responsible for this mess, to guilt you into surrendering what's yours. You think China would welcome invaders the way we're welcoming them, with houses, healthcare, jobs and benefits?

Yes, kicking them out is the right thing to do But the government should also back charge them for their kids education/ any benefit that they had taken. After all it is our tax dollar

He should be the one who gets kicked out of the country. Along with all the other people who have abused the laws. As long as there are going to be people who bend helpful laws, the ones who are willing to responsibly and honestly gain the benefits are gonna lose out on em.

Hi guys! Did I miss this part?? What was the benefit to them of being Canadian citizens vs. Chinese?

No country for illegal immigrants!Please arrested him that he made benefits from his immigration business!All these immigrants they don't know English even had a English education!

lmao. wait, so Canadian are complaining that these Chinese are helping them prop up their existing home value, spend money there occasionally, and all of these benefits without physically taking up spaces or intrude into canadian lives? wasn't there just a news in similar time frame about how hundred of millions dollars Canadians were spending on illegals? must be a hard math there, i guess Canadian prefer illegals more cuz they got too much money.

Canada's Justice system is weak and has no teeth. Better to have sympathy for the Devil than risk offending the bleeding hearts and artists. This guy only got a $900K fine and 2 years for scamming $10M, plus all the social benefits fraud he enabled... Are you kidding me?

hang on, I don't understand. why would they want Canadian status if they don't even want to live here? how does it benefit them

Investors from other countries (including China) can get an investors visa from the Canadian government for $1,200,000.00 which is refundable after a period of time. or $350,000.00 non refundable and have an agent invest their money for them. Free health care and international benefits of possessing a Canadian Passport are enticements for wealthy business people and relatively cheap. The cost of doing business in included in their overall fiduciary investments.

why do we let them in when they don't even know how to speak english? SERIOUSLY.... they don't pay taxes and they use our benefits.

If the Islamic followers want to be more accepted it would benefit for them to denounce the radical Islamic parts more openly and more often, also even the Christians have tone down or even speak against how some things in the Bible are written and or interpreted and have even fought against groups or individuals who would radicalize things from the Bible.\n\nBut it appears that even the moderate follower of Islamic faith may say something to a non believer just to appear helpful, but while later it seems those moderates talk different when around others of their faith, no longer ready to speak against their teachings or leadership. The groups or individuals I hear talk from the Islamic side of things, like Council on American-Islamic Relations is only the victimhood against Muslims, it seems that the Council avoids asking it's others how to fit into Western or American type culture/ life. Why does it seem that it's the community's etc that needs to change? If I went to Saudi Arabia could I expect the country to change to my standards? If even I went to the Vatican City and Said hey Pope I'm here now so you all need to change to my way of thinking? I truly think that there are some of the Muslim faith who exploit the western society kindness, generosity and laws to further their own goals, and it's a sad situation to be so deceitful.

They are given 50,000 and I'm given nothing to start up my family while being born here and being raised in a poor family! Also those crossing the border Illgeally should be treated like criminals! Can I go to your country illegally? So why with mine??? More people made rent higher, lower wages from competition and traffic is crazy now! Immigration has helped anyone but the immigrant and made my life harder.. all for being nice. Being nice doenst have any benefits except for being Walked on. Trudeau is just trying to buy votes

A well balanced report, something sadly missing in today's news. \n\nThat said, I do not see how Islam is of benefit to any western country. Wearing the burka or niqab is antithetical to our culture. I believe that in the 1990's, there was a small movement of Canadian women that wanted to go topless. That movement was also rejected by our culture. \n\nThere are at least 49 Muslim majority countries in the world where one can practice Islam if that is what is important to you. Canada should not become the 50 th.

Islam is the fastest religion because they keep recruiting non muslim people to join Islam a faith wich is mainly simply only benefiting prophet muhammed hungry for power, terrorism and slavery for women.

What does it cost to imprison a 100,000 foreigners? A million? What does it cost the justice system to get an arrest, trial and conviction? What does it cost in damages and ruined lives with illegals crimes? In America I figure we pay about 50 billion a year for all the above... every year, year in, year out.What does it cost America with the illegals sending unreported earnings out of the country, what does it cost in terms of uncollected government revenues? What does it cost to provide free birth services to 10% of the total population- being illegals getting 'Welfare baby' services? What does it cost the education system?I figure another 50 billion a year, year in and year out...For those that say America WAS built on immigration, realize America did NOT build on immigration with all these benefits... hence Immigrants had to become full fledged participants and be absorbed into the common fabric of America.For those expecting a 'One World Order, realize the immigrants must first fix their own country first.. if there is to be a 'One World Order' fabric otherwise 'Our Fabric' becomes their 'Fabric' and not a Fabric of Democratic principles we have in our society.Only by observing a common pattern in other countries where immigrants get the same benefits in those other countries is there any 'One World order' capable of extending benefits to all the same way.For now, all we have is immigration collapsing the ability for this Nation to provide Social services to everyone. And then what?

Why do refugees have access to social benefits at all? Do like Gulf countries, you can get work permit and work, but never citizenship, AND NEVER ACCESS TO SOCIAL BENEFITS, which are reserved to citizens only. They don't have income and don't pay taxes. Did the gouvernment ask tax payers whether they want to pay for the living of refugees in this country?? How the hell can someone justify this? Or should we say the lefty extremist gouvernment hijacks tax payers for their superior feelings?

Citizen are FIRST!!! stop benefit to international student’s children and no more refugees

Bring your poor, your unskilled and Justin Trudeau, with Canadian tax dollars, (not his because he shelters this taxes by using banks outside Canada) will make sure you get all the benefits you need to live a stress free life.

They should not get any benefits.

I wish in USa to give child benefits better!

To have, apparently, no English whatsoever after so many years does not indicate a desire to integrate. The (once) United Kingdom's seriously overburdened NHS spends 23 million a year on translators in 128 languages and many 'migrants' see this as an entitlement; indeed, it is a disincentive for some to even bother trying to learn English. This particularly pertains to many migrants from the middle-east and china and one Afghan patient whose family are regular beneficiaries of both the NHS and its translation services recently claimed (having been here for several years) that his wife (only in her 30s) would not be learning English because; 'It's too difficult' so for some, unfortunately, there is no will at all to assimilate. Housing and social security payments are, of course, part of the package and these individuals produce no net benefit at all either socially or economically and it's getting worse so spare me the bleeding heart rhetoric we keep hearing from mainstream (almost exclusively liberal) media. The BBC which is funded by the British Taxpayer cannot be relied upon to tell the truth or give the facts and continues to actively promote uncontrolled 'migration' so I think it's fair to say that they are fully facilitating the 'Kalergi Plan' and the decimation of the cultures and peoples of Europe!

Thought there would be more welfare benefits in Canada , this is hilarious ..... he was doing fine reaping the welfare benefits and then he got greedy and got himself in actual hardship ....... this should be an example for immigrants like this man.

Let's help there countries \nDEMOCRATS ARE REALLY EVIL \nUs this another way to depopulate population we all can benift by the land of each other countries as long as there is peace between each other DEMOCRATS LEFTIST SHADOW GOV BEHIND THIS MESS THEY HAVE DONE THIS TATIC TO OTHER COUNTRIES FOR YEARS NOW WE ALL CAN SEE IT UNFOLDING DEMOCRATS SHUT THEM DOWN NOW THEY HAVE CREATED WREAKING HAVOC ON OUR COUNTRY'S WORLD WIDE..\nTRUST TRUMP \nDEMOCRATS HAVE DONE ENOUGH DAMAGE TO UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND OTHER COUNTRIES FOR YEARS MANIPULATE PUBLIC CHANGE THE BALANCE OF POWER PERIOD \nDEMOCRATS USE PPL AS PAWNS ENGAGE IN THERE SICK PLANS COLLAPSE USA DEPOPULATE BOMBINGS CLAIM TERRORIST ATTACKS THEY CREATED THEMSELVES NULLIFY YOUNG GENERATION EAISER TO BRAINWASH THE PUBLIC REALIZE THAT BEFORE YOU HAVE NO SAY ABOUT IT...\nWE HAVE TO STAND TOGETHER TO STOP THE CORRUPTION CHAOS CASTROHICHIC EVENTS DEMOCRATS LEFTIST SHADOW GOV HAVE CREATED WREAKING HAVOC FOR YEARS NOW IT'S PERTAINING TO THE WORLD ORDER LEADERS GET MORE POWER TO DESTROY OTHER COUNTRIES REBUILT THEM LATER ON PUT IN DIFFERENT POSITION OF POWER POPULATION REBUILD FIX THE MESS OBAMA HILLARY SOROS WANT TO BRING DOWN MANY OTHER COUNTRIES BUILDING UP THERE EMPIRE DEMOCRATS ARE REALLY EVIL HYPOCRITES LIERS WHO BETRAYED US ALL ..\nWE ALL HAVE TO HELP TO REBUILD COMMUNITIES CHILDREN FAMILIES WE ALL CAN BENEFIT BUT DEMOCRATIC PARTY'S DON'T CARE ABOUT HUMANITY FAIRNESS AND RESPECT FOR EACH OTHER COUNTRIES CLEARLY DEMOCRATS ARE BEHIND THE SCENES OF THE DESTRUCTION OF THERE OWN PERSONAL MILITARY MAKE NO MISTAKE ABOUT IT..\nWE HAVE TO DECIDE HOW MUCH SUFFERING WE ALL CAN ENDURE \nLAW'S THAT KEEP US ALL SAFE SECURE THE DEMOCRATS LEFTIST CORRUPT ONLY WANT TO GET CONTROL OVER POWER WHAT A MESS THEY HAVE CREATED WREAKING HAVOC ON OUR COUNTRY JUST AS DEMOCRATS HAVE DONE TO OTHER COUNTRIES 911 CREATED A WAR ON IRAQ UNNECESSARY WAR'S THAT SHOUDNT OF HAPPENED NOW IT'S A MESS BUT WE CAN CHANGE IT..\nWE HAVE TO TRUST TRUMP..\nHE'S NOT PART OF THE CORRUPT ONE'S HE'S FOR PEACEFUL PROCESS HEALING AND FAIR TRADES DEAL'S AS PROMISED WHERE WE CAN BEGIN WITH HEALING PROCESS TOGETHER WE CAN CHANGE IT DEMOCRATS HAVE DONE THIS TO MANY COUNTRIES WORLDWIDE SADLY IT ISN'T EASY TO WATCH INNOCENT CIVILIANS PPL FAMILIES CHILDREN SUFFERING FROM DEMOCRATS WITH GLOBALIST LEFTIST INVESTORS PROFITING OFF THE PEOPLE OR ELES..\nI PRAY FOR PEACE PROCESS HEALING AND FAIR TRADES DEAL'S AS PROMISED WE HAVE TO TRUST TRYING SOMETHING NEW DIFFERENT FROM THE HARDSHIPS OF DEMOCRATS CLICK CHAIN OF POWER GREED ACTIONS DEATH'S OF GOOD INNOCENT PEOPLE COUNTRIES WHO HAVE SUFFERED BECAUSE OF DEMOCRATS CLICK CHAIN OF POWER GREED ACTIONS OF GREED POWER TO BENEFIT THEMSELVES USING THE PPL AS PAWNS ENGAGE IN THERE SICK PLANS COLLAPSE COUNTRIES PROVIDE WEAPONS ANGER HATRED ENOUGH DAMAGE HAS BEEN DONE TO ALL OF US DEMOCRATS ARE REALLY EVIL TRYING TO COLLAPSE CHRISTIANITY PEOPLE WHO HELPED MANY COUNTRIES WORLDWIDE SADLY IT IS A WAY TO LOOSE HOPE BUILD UP ANGER SUCIDE MURDERS DEATH'S \nWE HAVE TO STOP DEMOCRATS LEFTIST HELP THE SUFFERING REBUILD THERE LAND HOMESTEAD FOR THOSE WHO WANT TO GO HOME ?

They get 50k and then can apply for social benefits like other Canadians even though they’re NOT Canadians? Their kids go to public schools, and probably get free lunch and other things, at the benefit of tax payers. Asian immigrants are a different breed. They work, and education is very important to them, do you can’t compare the two. A bunch of BS liberal propaganda.

Applications are rejected for a reason, Our laws are meant to bring in people who benefit our nation and economy and are designed to protect our own people from losing jobs. We have every right to protect our people and our best interest.

Give dem there sharia law let dem live with it & take back their Canadian rights & divide them from Canadian law abiding non Muslim citizens so they can not enjoy & benefit from the country welfare and opportunity they will only have the right to citizenship

Cali GOV Moonbeam should pay US taxpayers back from his salary after 66 yo California illegal alien Andres Avelino Anduaga used the birth certificate of a U.S. citizen to acquire a California driver's license, a social security card and a U.S. passport. Anduaga then stole $244,441 in Supplemental Security Income benefits, $112,981 in Medi-Cal benefits and $3,486 in food stamps.

how much taxes do they pay? I was in California and they don't have to get a license but they drive cars with no plates on them. In taxachusetts i know a guy who got in an accident with a truck that was driven by an illegal...he did not have a license and they let him go...the company that owned the truck paid. They get more benefits than us and they pay no taxes. I was unemployed once and had no health care. every place I applied refused me health care so at the end of the year I had to pay a penalty for each month I didn't have health care. What penalty do they pay? I am discriminated against for being a poor white american citizen. This country is a joke and I wish I was never born here.

Canada needs to open up its borders to all and provide free housing and benefits like they do in the uk to the people. Mass immigration will make Canada stronger.

Every country WILL accept immigrants as long as they do it the LEGAL way, except israel. You don't break into a home and expect the owner to help you stay. Those politicians that promote such illegal way of entering a country and give them the citizen's benefits are TREASONOUS!

Suckered by SOROS and the liberal lefts promises of milk and honey for their votes !! Instead,they milk the system here for all benefits and complain when turned down,to get seconds.

So if he has been told that he is being deported, so he moves his family to Vancouver to hide them. This brings his case to the bottom of the line. He stayed in Edmonton & continues to work there underground not paying any taxes, while his family takes advantage of Canadian benefits hospitals, schools & welfare. What a joke round them up & get them out of here as quick as you can. We don't need the cheats.

This video is typical CBC smokescreen, yes Immigrants and refugees get sponsored. The Legal ones! No issue. But all the illegal immigrants get one year of social insurance too.And the health care benefit they get is the same program the natives get.CBC kind of blends the rules for legal immigration with illegals kind of watering it down to make it not seem as bad. Typical blur the lines!

Stay in Canada. We don't want you here. You are a criminal. You owe the US tax money and money for all of the benefits that you collected in our country illegally. You dirt bag.

People are not fleeing from the USA for the great Benefits, Fox news doesn't have a clue why.

You were in the U.S. for 15 years and never became a citizen. Did you ever learn to speak English? What about your family. What was stopping you? Please help me understand why you want to live in the U.S. and the benefits but hate this country?

Ice is sending all illegals backs costing citizens to much when they don't work and demand things that really their not even suppose to get . They work the minimum if that and then stay on welfare while everyone else who works taxes go up bunch of free loaders . In fact we are cutting welfare and and benefits because of this we try to be nice but when we are token advantage of . Sorry are states are full of these freeloaders were also cutting letting people in because they don't do anything but demand money when their not even suppose to get in the first place then they hate us anyway and go around flying their damm flag around hollering Mexico . Mexico don't even want them they refuse to take them . They are just using them to get votes . We have enough people Canada can keep them . If he get caught here they will jail him. We are tired of the Victim act many people here have issues here to . United States has taken care of everyone around the whole world when war happens , trading but we get the short stick everytime . Beside when war break out which it will. Do you really think United States is the safest considering we're Babylon. Tell me something why are Hollywood people moving to different places ? It's only a matter of time .

Wtf Trudeau, i want my tax money to be spent on something that benefits normal Canadians, like healthcare, people die or get more serious in the ER while waiting way too often! Getting rid of Liberals next year!

As a Canadian whose parents immigrated to Canada legally, I’m disgusted that illegals pay nothing and are given these much benefits. Why the hell did my parents pay thousands of dollars yet received no help with housing while illegals are given jobs and hotel rooms as accommodation. Trudeau is out in 2019, what a failure.

People who believe his BS should open ur door and invite the refugees to live at ur house and use ur money! \nAll the tax we pay benefits the people who don’t pay themselves. Goes to people do nothing, all they will be doing is sitting their fat ass in hotel paid by us! Room service included! People who support Trudeau will make Canada go broke! Keep it up! Support him! U will start to need pay ur own medical bills and school. Because all the “free” Benefits will go to refugees! Good thing they keep coming to spend our tax dollars or we might actually see something improve for Canadians.