Close Reading

So True... we just came to canada... finally someone talked about it... canada is not what people think it is!! India is the best!!

Yaaar…kitni himmat karte hai log…living ur own country with growing up kids and without a partner and thinking of setting down in a new country which is completely different than our own country ?I can’t imagine. And why? What for? Why so much desperation?? India is not perfect but is not bad either. People r living good life despite problems. If your very young, unmarried or without kids , then ok ..u have right age and stamina to struggle and responsibilities are less but after a certain age and having kids…it’s very difficult.

Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism & Jainism are a family of religions, that originated in India and have similar value systems of empathy & kindness toward humans & nature. \n \nBefore Prime Minister Modi, India had a Sikh Prime Minister for 10 years, who is still today valued & appreciated amongst all political circles. \n \n>99% of Sikhs in INDIA want to live in the union of India, they heavily join the Indian army & are the most patriotic & nationalistic ethnic people in INDIA.

JO INDIA CHOR KE BAHAR HAI. WO HAMARA RESPONSIBILITY NAHI HAI.. WE ALREADY HAVE 1.5BILLION PEOPLE TO FEED

excellent analysis of the Punjab problem... Khalistan is not at all an issue in punjab.. economic reforms is the need... Punjabis n Sikh are brave patriotic people of India...let all Indians know this... by labelling every Sikh as Khalistani, we will be doing more harm to our country...\noverall a great video

Bro I live in nz been renting wih young people for Punjab 25 to 35. They still hate India and think BJP is responsible for all this.

Hi, bro you are doing a good job, you told many knowledgeable things some of them are right but some are not. You can make a single video on Punjab regarding that Punjab was also one country earlier time. In 1947 Punjab was combined to India. People who are asking for Khalistan they are just asking for their old Punjab.

I would advise people to not settle down in the west. Soon there will be major economic and social issues in multiple countries of the west. There are major financial crises that are coming and it will impact the west more. Threats of major wars will increase too. Where as the golden period of Bharat is just getting started. In the future the salaries offered in the US and india will be same. Jab tak apke bacche bade honge ye duniya puri tarah se badal gayi hogi. West ko log woh aspirational nazaro se nahi dekhenge jaisa aaj hota hai. Aur NRI's ke beech wapis india mai settle hone ki hodd lagi hogi. KEEP CALM AND BELIEVE IN A RISING INDIA (SONE KI CHHIDIYA)

Its such a good video if everyone who has roots from India will understand it….then Golden days of India will be back…..Be it which ever religion we follow,I hope people will start it from small acts……start respecting Indian Flag….start educating our kids what we used to learn Hindu Muslim Sikh Isayi hum sb toh hai bhai bhai…..as well as songs which used to promote love for our nation and people of our nation should be promoted again. Problems are there but its not for one community its for every community in India but they can be solved. \nRight now fights in Hindu Sikhs Muslims Isayi and other communities is because of fear created in our mind for each other. Even i will not lie now even I have a sense of Fear from people from other communities as its engraved through so many actions that they might not see me as an Indian or as a human being first but treat me like someone not from their community or brotherhood.

Brilliant video! I believe all sensible Indians already respect Sikhs in India and understands these Khalistani Sikhs are totally different people.

Now you know that how terrorist sikhs are bro this so bad if sikhs want their own nation why people start saying us khalistani and i want to say one thing that khalis meaning is pure and we want a khalsa raj like ranjit singh and before partition we have an opportunity to have a nation and now we want that so how we become terrorists sikhs are helping indians in their harsh times so it should be in people heart of india that they should support sikhs to have a nation because we are facing a lots of problem like natives of punjab are unable to get jobs because outer state individuals are getting jobs and local are still unemployed so this is the reason sikhs are going to other nations and sikhs had sacrificed their lifes and indian people are not understanding

Lazy people can't survive even in India .They need army of nauker chaaker to wash their dirt and filth??Those complain about Canada or for that matter any developed country ,because of their habit of ruling other lives and exploiting the poor ,which is considered abuse in Canada etc ??

Indian constitution and govt failed to create high paid salary oriented jobs here in India that why most of talent people leave India

Sant jairnail singh Bhindrawale never demanded khalistan and not even single FIR was filled against him. He was just targeted by government at that time and destroy his image by saying him terrorist. He just wanted punjab to be drug free and educated but government did not want this. We as a sikh are never supported by any party . They hate us. That’s why we want separate state. I am from todays generation and who said only elders want khalistan . Still now if we ask for rights in punjab , we are sent to jail,, they we support khalistan moment which is ultimate solution because it’s reality people of india and Indian government can never appreciate our contributions towards country which are always in majority.

U actually know that Cananda Or other country is far better than India in all fields... Still u make these kind of vlogs to de motivate people... U guys were blessed to get the PR and got a chance to settle ur kids... But u are a LOOSER.. An absolute looser

No one in India wants khalistan and true sikh people will never demand the same. What i feel is that sikh people have always been radical but they have always fought to unite and save the oppressed never demanded for a different nation. Even our gurus never captured any land. I hope that everyone follows ek on kar teaching of guru nanak dev ji and all this issue of khalistan comes to an end ?

I feel informative and sincere views shared. Moving abroad is hard for most people who dont have much money to take with them or relatives to support them. If you are committed, hardworking, and patient, you are much more likely to be successful in Canada. If you think it will happen in 1 or 2 years you are mistaken. Education, health, law and order, justice, equality, and opportunities there is no comparison between Canada and India.

U hv lived for very shoet time. Basically few months. Adjustung in a new country definitely takes time. So its wrong to to give such a feedback.\nI too stay abroad. Even i felt the same whn i shifted to a new country in the first fewmonths. But now i hv liked it. People abroad get used to doing all the work on their own unlike india where we are dependent on house helpers. We learn to manage time. \nChildren are not under pressure in school. Their perspective changes snd in addition to academics they get to venture into many more areas according to their hobbies.

Excellent Video. Nitish and his team have done an excellent research and analysis on Sikh Migration and their involvement in the Indian Freedom Struggle. Many of my questions regarding the Sikhs have been resolved in this video.\n\nBrilliant work guys. Please keep up the good work and keep educating people of India and the world...???

We heard that people who came back to India they are going again back to Canada, reason is there is no law and orders, corrupted politicians and corrupted justice systems make your life painful in India

Very soon people will witness reverse migration especially to countries like India because India is doing extremely well in almost all fronts nowadays whereas the West is in total chaos.

These people who come to a foreign land have one foot back in India. They will never tell you the issues you will face in India. Life is not rosy back in India. Pollution, security, unsafe for women and children, unclean water, religion based politics, pestiside laiden produce, bad healthcare, expensive education, expensive housing, expensive fuel, average education if not studied in top university..... the list goes on and on and on....

Very well researched..Such things need to be shared in mainstream media to derail the propaganda run by the Anti India elements...Sikhs are one of the most patriotic communities in the country. People should refrain of relating them to Khalistan..\n\nMoreover, It's high time for Indian Govt to focus on issues faced by Punjab so that Punjabis can have more confidence in them and they don't get the feeling of being discriminated.

Most of the punjabi people started leave india after 1984 …. WTF your research you sit in Mumbai and Delhi and don’t know about Punjab and make video with your own facts to make other people bebkooof…. ?

Sir, Australian life far better than others developed countries. But Yes, country-side concept is true to help PR in Australia. Bro...their has an invisible policy( any body cannot prove it)which works through immigration policy, treating as country to country...As an Indian I had a good experience in Sydney...We Indian have a good chance to come back in India. Now Good going in India than Australia...but truth is our neighborhood's country people are not lucky like us nowadays. Indian should not be worried because now India, Australia and Canada are same, those are good country , no difference for life and money. 5 to 6 yrs Jabardast Paisa kamao and India bapas aayoo, now is the best policy.

Anyway the moral of the story is .. india is shit country that’s why people leaving

Great video and very grateful to Nitish Rajput and team for bringing up the real issues.\nAlso for letting people know that Sikhs in the majority are not in favor of Khalistan. Not every Sikh is in favor of Khalistan and the ones wanting it are not at all present in India.

Every community leaving outside India helps their people to grow and develop except the Bengali community of West Bengal

This was the exact situation which I explain my friends. I hope every person who has watched the video might get a little idea of the current situation of Punjab and Sikhs. And I must say that majority of Sikhs loves India and doesn’t support the Khalistan Ideology. But I still hope that Sikhs who suffered in 1984 must get justice (because delayed justice has brought some people with disappointment) and there should be more development in the State of Punjab.

Great job n great research by the Nitish Rajput's team. This is 100% true, most of the people migrated to Canada in 80s-90s remember punjab negatively. Most of the news these people hear is through the indian media houses which very negative. They expect the same rights from indian government as they get from Canadian government. Most of the Khalistani supporting got active because of ruling party politics where a regular sikhs whose son, brother n father served in indian army and marines is called Khalistani without any reason. This has definitely created a divide in society, and media houses are also spreading the negativity towards a community. \n\nWahi baat h ki Modi is not india n humei ni pasand uski politics. Doesn't mean ki hum anti nationalist hogye or we hate modi. Bhai nahi pasand humei politics jo society mei divide kre. First thing a sikh child is taught is that everyone is equal. Ab tum fundamentals attack kroge toh humei ni pasand ayega.

People say us khalistani but dont realize why this demand is arising. We contributed maximum to freedom and freedom struggle was fought from canada also. But when all things promised to us were not given after 47..the same fight resumed again but now with our own people. India and its politicians just used and throwed sikhs?. We donot have any power.only up biharis elect pm and now they are making hindu rashtra despite the fact that they did nothing for indias independence

Read Canada’s history first bro - Canada wasn’t developed because it had white people - Canada is land of Indigenous and first nations tribes - Britishers and French came to Canada and exploit their resources just like how they came to India to loot and exploit people and resources. \n\nThis is no less than fake news

You are not SIKH or PUNJABI if you support indian media , hindu raster but you against khalistan because you know actual conditions of punjab but ignore them , and most of people jo bol rhe hain ki hum sikh hai but india se love krte hai ye wo unme se most of accounts vaise hi fake hain, hum lokk india ko hate nahi krte we love india and most of freedom fighters v punjab se hi hain india me but you don't understand conditions of Punjab so ik cricketer aggr catch nh pkkd pane pe khalistani ho jata hai or uske baad 3 3 baar brickets todne k baad wo indian ho jata hai tu app samj hi sakte ho loko ka mindset kaisa ho chuka hai

Nitish bhai please make a detailed video of why so many karela people are going to Saudi, why so many Gujju and Telgu people moving to the US. Often we see immigration linked to Punjab only but there are more non-punjabis living outside India..

They know very well that the competition is so high in india and rhier weak mind can not beat other people

One of the Major fact is that sikh people feel unsecure in india as a majority ruler country!!

I dont understand the point of all this today. 90% of Punjab fields are taken care by people from Bihar. It will become interesting when say by chance, if separate Punjab country is formed, then later on the current Bihar people demand for separate Bihar in Punjab then annex that Bihar into India. Also to keep in mind there aren't many Sikhs remaining in Punjab, most are converted to Christianity.

Nitish Brother I’m from Punjab and I really really appreciate your work. really a Big thanks to you bro. Thanks for raising our voice. Because currently this Modi government introduced our selves as a Khalistani or Atankvaadi. Every punjabi who wear a turban is donated as a Khalistani. This image is created by this government in the whole India. We are very weak now our economy our culture is in danger zone. political peoples destroyed us on the basis of religion. Unemployment is on peak but nobody watching us except this Khalistani badge. Every sikh is not khalistani. just imagine if any person who gives harms to the mandir how will you accept it?\nWe are very possessive about our religion A punjab gives food to every people of India or the world because our gurus teach us that. but nobody care for us. All of them just pinch the nerve of our religion for votes and if you know punjabies are paying 20 lakh₹ to go for canada today. because of these issues. i want to say this to whole India “Guys please come out of this religious war these political peoples just dividing us. You guys knows that before modi in India there was not any issue of Hindu/Sikh or muslim. Because they needs votes for 2024 elections that’s why they are using this method” So, pls I request to the every indian support the india do not divide India?

You have great opinion sir, but you should also make a video on why hindus people want india to be hindu rastra particularly dekha jaye toh sabhi ik ko he target kre ja rhe hai, thora Hindu ka bi bta do ki kya credibility ya contribution hai india main unka and i'm neither the supporter of khalistan and also for hindustan. I wish for humanitystan.

Thank you Nitish for clearing up d fog around this issue . Normally people fail to understand this core issue. U explained it perfectly that the migration during the 90's brought along with it all d hurt, pain and resentment that the community experienced in India.

Your video is biased and stupid at best. You should also cover the reasons for unemployment, and problems in Punjab. The problem is people from Punjab are so desperate to fly out of India, they have no intention or will to grow India's economy. How many IAS, toppers, businessmen you will see from Punjab? Its all about the mindset, look at other states like Delhi, Gujarat, Maharashtra for instance, population there is generating young entrepreneurs who are taking the country ahead. Its a shame that you are brain washing people, where you should educate people why because of such people India is at risk, they use India's resources to grow and when the time comes to contribute to country's gdp they fly to canada and other countries.

Watching this video i am very sad today got to know how much sikh people gave to india in freedom fight and what they got in return golden temple attack, 1984 genocide, a small punjab,looted waters, i think thats why nowadays they dont want to live in india

During early days of migration, Sikhs had faced lot of struggles in Canada, but they still created Printing press, Gadar movement to free Indians from Britishhers,participated in freedom struggle, though they could silently live in Canada......but they not, they fight for freedom, got hanged,got kale panni de saza....but now some people think Sikhs are not loyal to India?

I have been living in Toronto for more than 2 year now and in addition to their contribution to India, I have huge respect for the Punjabi/ Sikh community in Canada. Despite whatever derogatory comments the locals might have, reality is they are honest and extremely hardworking people. The seva offered to everyone at various Gurudwaras is just so emotionally overwhelming. Unfortunately, there is one section- mostly the international students who have recently arrived seem to be influenced by Punjabi pop music and try to emulate which looks absolutely cringe and stupid. The situation now is their stupidity gets recorded and posted on social media which has resulted in local stereotyping the entire Punjabi/ Sikh population as destructive immigration.

You made good video but it is biased towards india not totally 100% true you showing fact what is india wated to show rest of the world. In reality after 1984 rss india planted so many fake sikhs in panjab so you see in delhi some people stand by government no matter what & kanisha blast by india gov. to defame sikhs because western countries were supporting for seprate state after 1984 attack. India involving in each and every country where ever indian sikhs & muslim population last tym in germany gov. arrested indian spy agent keeping eye on sikh and musli. And biggest mistake you have done in the video is khalistan movement hasn't started after 1984 it was before 1947 you have to do more research when pak india was getting devided religion base there was sikh homeland demand that time some leader choose to go with india there was agreement with nehru to give panjab autonomy soverign state all power of panjab in thier land. Still it was written with india panjab will be soverign state in india not capture by india same goes for kashmir by british in writing. sikh were getting khalistan that time if we wanted we would have get it from british we choose to go with india.

Dada please make a detailed video on Bengal’s current situation. No job, no political stability, we are dying. All the people of India should know about it. We are at dead end.

Indian people are not fit for a foreign life, they are used to comforts and laziness in India. So when they go abroad they are shocked and taken aback by hyperactivity of any foreign countries. Then they start whining and complaining and start making grumbling videos, which are instantly liked by the other lazy and easygoing Indians who are watching these YouTube videos.

Finally a well appointed explanation of the situation. \n1 thing I really want to know the people who are protesting for Khalisthan from UK and Canada .. will they come back from these countries and live in Khalisthan (just imagine if Punjab is separated from India to become Khalisthan)?\nWhy there is so much protesting in those countries and there's a no-show in India ?, where it really should be . \nThis determines its all political.\nMere Sikh bhaiyo sadda India Tyada India !! (Don't know if the Punjabi is correct)\nJai Hind !!

NOW only two options are available for canada :- 1. Substantiate your claim/allegation with PUBLICLY PUBLISHING CREDIBLE EVIDENCE with a CONVICTION from a court of law using this published evidence. 2. OR ELSE, APOLOGISE PUBLICLY to the GOVT OF INDIA and its people under lack of CONVICTION FROM A COURT OF LAW. ................OR ELSE, INDIA will exercise its full might to PUNISH trudeau and its govt responsible for this DEBACLE.

And andhas bhaktas says we got freedom as “ bheekh “. This BJ party and its people has no role in India’s freedom and they were mainly informers of Britishers.