Close Reading

i am an indian and i dont understand why some indian families particularly in punjab and andhra region are soo obsessed with sending there kids outside for education ??? it has little value in india unless it is an IB league college .. someone going to canada to study commerce or a BSc is very stupid . Finish your graduation in india and give exams for masters . go abroad only if you have a certain good score otherwise it is of no use .

Quality of studies by all these colleges is zero and students cannot speak up due to fear of being deported . It’s a mafia making money exploiting poor kids. Businesses come in to exploit further by taking advantage of students paying under minimum wage, all of these violators should be sacked. Shame on the government watching all this happen.

study in India only and become Job creaters ?

Studying abroad is not for everyone.

Documentary misses a major issue. PR aspirants taking study visa route and filling up Canadian career colleges is the elephant in the room.

As a indian i say canada plzz stop indians coming to canada.plzz ban them because canada is now big anti-India hub for khalistanis and terrorist who will be big national threat to india.because canada govt never take any action on them for vote bank.so either canada bans it or india will ban its citizen traveling canada for jobs and study.

When you apply to study here you have to show proof of funds to support yourself. If you don't have it, don't do it. Easy.

Thank you Fifth Estate! Ok always wondered if such topics would ever be a priority! This documentary needs to be telecast in 216 languages in India. I volunteer to help literally assist with voice over and translation in as many indian languages as I know. While returning from India, I've interacted with similar innocent and dreamy eyed kids coming for studies to institutions I have not heard of. Such a sordid exploitation!!! There are hyenas on either side of the border!

Can we take along spouse on study visa of Canada?

If one can’t afford then no need to come or study hard to get scholarships.

India Spend 24 billion dollars a year,just to study outside,hightest for Any Country.

India has the best Education in the world why parents do this for their the future generation?so sad studying is not like working

This is truly heartbreaking, I feel so sorry for International Students who came here with dreams but were given something far below that. I am a Canadian born student, brought up and raised in Brampton but I made friends with many international students. I don't understand how International students have to pay 3-4x our tuition, cover their living expenses, and have work restrictions on their study permit. The truth is competion is everywhere and companies are competing for top students who go to credible universites. I don't see how international students are suppose to compete with these students when there is a shortage of high-paying jobs. I truly feel bad. I advise students to tell their stories to their younger siblings and cousins back home and prevent them from living a hard-working life with little reward. Advise them to complete their studies back home and find a job in big cities back home. As a domestic student I struggle to pay for my own expenses and I could not imagine if I did not have my parents support. This is fraud on another level!!!

Government of Canada can do a lot to stop the exploitation: run Social media/TV/Print awareness campaigns in local languages in India to inform parents and students about studying in Canada, make it easy to search for programs and colleges/universities, and proactively work with the Government of India and provincial governments in Punjab, Gujarat etc.

Btw, garanty of success, of employment, doesn't exist and it's baked in the capitalism system that private enterprise and private college prioritize profits (btw, for non Canadian, education, is not subsidized). \nNow, if illegal/fraud practices are occurring, then like any Canadian, you will have to make a complaint to the police and/or take legal action (basically If you don't have money, you're F!). \n \nMaybe the Ontario government should have more stringent laws for private Colleges and recruiting agencies, like mandatory advertising for: \n\t- the required money for subsistence and the low likelihood of finding a good job that will enable students to work; \n\t- the % failure, homelessness, suicide,... \n\t- mental and social stress, differences,... \n \nMaybe Canada could: \n\t- be more stringent with student visa and have a written acknowledgement that states all the risks and pitfalls. \n\t- Guive visa only if the recruiting was done through accredited agencies \n\t- Do official advertisements in India about the risks and requirements of studying abroad. \n \nMaybe a full capitalism society is not moral, but it's the system we decided to live in.

Is education in India so bad that these people had to come to Canada to study in such low grade colleges?\n\nOr do these people want a permanent residence as soon as possible so migrate at early age

Study locally.. Don't suffer.. Its the same in the end..

Good research, hope it will help a lot of would be students who wants to go to Canada to study especially from India, thanks to u Fifth Estate!!\n?????

I came to Canada as international student and studied in Public College 10 years ago. There are numerous “Private” colleges in Surrey and Brampton recruit poor international students. The colleges don’t not care.

Hi Everyone, \nI am Hiranmoy Dutta a resident of India want to pursue my post graduate in diploma management in Global supply chain management in Canada . My education qualification are as follows \n1. Passed my Higher secondary examination in 2011 in Commerce . \n2. Passed my Graduation programme in 2014. \nThere are few years gap from 2014-2020 the reason behind it that I was preparing for Indian government examinations but somehow i could not crack and did not look for any alternative option at that period . \nBut later at 2021 I cracked in private sector examination and got placed in Imerit Technologies Pvt limited as an ITES executive . \nAnd currently it’s been 1 year 6 months + I am still with imerit technologies and want to pursue for further studies in Canada . \nI want to know will I be eligible to do pursue this course ? \nAnd if yes what are the necessary things to do to get admission in colleges ?

The corporate government want them not to study only for cheep hard labourers in filthy warehouses ?

It may be an ignorant question but why not study in India?

wow 5 x times what canadians pay. imagine how much it cost to study in the US when US students already get scammed themselves paying $150 000- $500 000 for a 4 year degree program, intenational students could pay $750 000-$2 500 000 lol

Met up with a young man from India. From our talk he could be from a relatively well off Family. He was lured to Europe for studies. Paying up to 20,000€ per year. For his upkeep he had to work some jobs he would never take up in his country. But we all know. An education abroad sell more ???

Aap rehte kahan par ho ? Mera Chota Bhai Canada Brampton , Calgary me hai aapse Milne bhej sakta hu usko study bhi kar raha WO Job bhi 1 week me 20 hours aur Songs bhi bana rahe ?

sir is there any age limit to apply for study abroad. \nand specific colleges who will accept fole with the age of 38

I am currently living in south korea. My family in Pakistan. I want apply for canada family visa. Sir kindly guide me. My kids are studying. I want apply for canada or Australia. Please help me. Thanks

Hello Gursahib,\nI'd like your two cents on something to make an informed decision. I'm a software engineer based out of India. I am stuck in a dilemma. I am not sure if I should move to Canada on Study Visa or wait for Express Entry (PNP)/Work Permit? My worst case CRS score is 420. \nI have approx 5 years of experience. I am starting my IELTS prep shortly and I am not sure if I should prepare both academic and general or one of them.\nThanks in advance.

please sir guidelines for students which came from Pakistan for study

I m a house wife master in pakistan studies. B.Ed . Responsible of my family never did any job . How i can apply my family visa .of canada .

Ppl commenting here are missing the point that chancellor apologized and educated people about Sikhism in his letter …unlike india where political parties would rather not muslim girls study than let them wear hijab …hijab is not a security threat ……talking about respecting all religion in current bjp ruled India …again majority of secular Indians need to stand up against this slow poison in India

Aslam e Alikum ..... please share any case study regarding a person doing job in Pakistan as a Govt. Employ BPS. 14 or above ... who applied for PR or Work visa for Canada and UK and successes .. \nThanks

Can anyone tell me .. What, if I study online outside nova Scotia but I was in canada .. and now I am in Nova Scotia bcz of in person classes .. am I eligible for aip or not

hey buddy, im an indian student currently studying in commerce.\nI'm planning for intake in 2023.\ntwo of the major countries in consideration are Canada and Australia. \nI recently researched about this and got to know that the rent prices as well as the taxes in Canada are hiking and it's now very difficult for students to survive.\nwhereas in Australia, it's the never ending story for difficulty in PR and whatnots.\nI would really like to have an advice from you on this.❤️??\n\nps. i forgot to add what course I want to pursue.\nI want to do BCA(Bachelor in Computer Application).

Probably some Khlistanis made him do it. It’ll be fun if no one comes to his recuse now! ? He’ll be crying in the prison. You go to college to study. Do that and gtfo!

Very good. In India education is good why the fuck go to USA to study INDIA ?????? HAS LOTS OF EDUCATION

Papaji ka beta study visa kya mila gaya\nkhud ko raja samaj baithai?

Bhai Canada study nahi karna na ho sirf work karna ho to aa sakte hai kya kam karne k liye ??? Mene 12th tak study kiya hai fir collage ni kiya...

We love America, we wanna study there, stay there!! ??

Or jao foreign study karne...

You cannot enter usa without agreeing for every rule and regulation of country. He as a student would have pleaded to follow all us rules and regulations to get a chance to study there. He is showing all bulshit now. He should have respected the law of land

We are well educated person outside Pakistan. They give doll to poor people you people boast government gives money to children well off people in Pakistan have no problem. We go only for studies this is hour pride

Asalam alykum. Mein karachi se hn mashAllah AP ki vedio dehki achi lagi. But mein agar apni family k sath ahna chathi hn toh kesay aon. Kindly guide me.. because. I married and mashAllah I have 3daughters .and my education in Bs.in women's studies from university of karachi . My husband did b.com and he is doing tax return work at home

Keep your religion in your area of worship not in where you go for studies and others are around

If America wants immigrants to study there, do jobs there then they need to educate themselves about those immigrants. They will bring their faith and culture with them and you can’t strip them off it

When did u study bro and go to college? Best wishes for journey ahead

Carrying a knife to a college? What was he thinking? It's an entirely new country they need not respect ones wishes. You went there to study, quietly do that and prosper

I have sikh friends , all of them keeps kirpan (knife) touched to skin not fabric ! This dude was flexing , \n\nImagine folks are studying in hall , what x student will think when he sees a knife !

Your video just popped up and I was drawn to watch it. I have been in Sydney for 7 years. Same pathway in - a student visa, but I got PR through my studies soon after my graduation and now a citizen. Yes, I agree that Australian permanent residency is tough, but I also realise that not equipping yourself with the right information creates a hurdle for many people. If PR is the goal, the SOL and every other related information leading from that list should be your manual. Let that information guide your decisions. However, I concur that Australia's stance on immigration is confusing - harping on about skilled shortages and wanting to attract the right people, but also keeping them in limbo for ages. It makes for an unsustainable system. Good luck to you in Canada. May your wishes match your expectations.

How many years we have to stay in that Atlantic canada after completing study course or after getting pr