Close Reading

Hamas honestly thought the other Arab countries want Israel's smoke. They still remember the six day war.

A polite way of saying that he does not want them in his country because he knows what they will bring with them.

Ummmmm I don’t think some Palestinian anyone for that matter want to stay in a conflict justified or unjustified. The Arab nation should first give an open door policy for a temporary shelter or refugee like the Europeans or America did for Ukraine. This notion that Palestinians don’t want to leave for a temporary refugee is very questionable. Just open your country and see if they will not go!!! Anyone is a free country should choice to evacuate to a safer country like Saudi, UAE, Bahrain or other golf countries. Instead of giving them aid or other form of support, give them a sanctuary and if they decide not to go back, then give them other options. Palestinians should not be dictated to stay in a conflict zone special the women and children. Even African countries rich or poor, open their doors to their neighbors during war like it happen in Sierra Leone, Liberia, Uganda and you can count many!!! Recently in Ukraine, Germany, Poland and other Ukraine neighbors, received millions of Ukrainians and never have they said Ohhhhh Ukraine love their land and they want to stay in Ukraine or they will lose their land when they left!!!!! It’s about time Arab nations to give Palestinians refugee without any preconditions. That’s obvious

No Arab countries want terrorists when they are a thorn in Israel’s side

If you want to leave, you only need one reason.. I studied in a white man s country, and being Chinese, I never felt ' at home'.. Maybe I am sensitive, but I do feel more comfortable back in my home country.

Don't waste your time watching this video.\nI certainly didn't.\n\nCanada's skyrocketing population growth rate in recent years \njumped even higher when in the third quarter of 2023 alone \nCanada's population shot up by over 430,000 people in just 3 months.\n\nThat would work out to a 4.3% growth rate on an annual basis.\n\nCanada hasn't seen population growth like that since 1957\nwhen the baby boom was booming.\n\nMost recent data has only two countries with a population growth rate that high\nand most assuredly those two countries are growing because of \nextremely high fertility rates, not because of immigrants moving there\nfrom other countries.\n\nTo give another comparison, the UK which is the fastest growing G7\ncountry other than Canada, grew by 5.9% total over TEN FULL YEARS \nfrom 2011 to 2021.\n\nSo as in any place that is extremely desirable,\nrents and real estate prices are high and rising in Canada\nand apartments are hard to find\nbut clearly a lot of people want to move to Canada - \ncertainly vastly more than want to leave Canada.\n\nSeems that this video is the usual clickbait internet thing.\nIf one believed all the pessimistic online videos talking \nabout how various countries are in disastrous downward spirals\none would conclude that the entire world is soon going to end.

You're lying, you guys don't want to receive them as refugees because they will turn your country to war zone?

They would just escape to other Muslim countries and escape the war whats the point in staying with all the death and destruction. The true reason is these Arab countries dont like them in their countries. Why dont these countries give refugee to those Palestinians who would otherwise want to seek refuge. Waiting for western countries to offer refuge I suppose.

Saudi Arabia doesn't want anything to do with the Palestinians because Hamas is a proxy of Iran. They don't want Hamas in their country, so they're happy to keep them right where they are

That is exactly what they want. Is for other Arab countries to help clear out the Palestinians from their land.

Very funny they’re all using Palestinians don’t want to leave their land as an excuse. PLO tried to take over every country that once granted them refugee.. Jordan, Lebanon and Egypt with Islamic Brotherhood. Nobody wants that in their country again..

In short. Noone wants them. Everyone wants their own country safe.

Aside from this war Palestinians, lebanese and Syrians are never welcomed in the gulf countries with open arms anyways. For example let's say a palestinian persons family works and live in Kuwait and they want to visit their family whether it is their parents etc, the Kuwaiti authorities will force them to apply for a visa the long and hard way through the Kuwaiti embassy. However on the other hand Canadians, Americans and British who are strong Israeli supporters are allowed to enter these same gulf countries with ease in a visa on arrival basis. This is not even to consider war. This is generally speaking. Can anyone see the hypocrisy of the arab world here in regards to the Palestinian cause as well as the other fellow neighboring countries?

No one want terroist and militants in their country. Jordan has past experience.

Who in their right mind would want to live in a country that our leader's have fill to the brim with terrorists from all over the world

How is everybody missing the false logic that he quietly inserted.\n\nHe states a premise that Palestinians do not want to leave their land. In that case, why not open the border and see if Palestinians come in. If they do not, then his premise is correct, if there’s a mass exodus, then there’s premise was just a way to shift responsibility.\n\nJordan and Egypt occupied the Westbank and Sasa strip from 1948 to 1967 what stopped them from creating Palestine or simulating those countries into theirs? Why was there no prosperity during that period?\n\nThe truth is that the refugees follow the 1948 and the land that was going to be given to the following. The conclusion of demand of Palestine has been in a tug of war between various factions for the last 70 years.

Basically Arab countries dont want refugees because of Black September in the 1970's.\nWhen Palestinian refugees entered Jordan, they tried to kill the King and overthrow him.\nThats the real truth why they dont want them.

I am certain she wasn’t expecting that answer, that one I also didn’t expect myself but I am 100% with him. No person wants to leave their country unless they are forced to or just want a different experience elsewhere but all people want to live in their country its just the politicians always chasing their citizens away.

Muslim countries wants non Muslim countries to acknowledge Islam but Muslim countries don't want to acknowledge other religion in their country.

So if they want to stay in Palestine then why don’t they stay there and spend all the billions of dollars they receive to build electric plants, water plants, etc. so they don’t need to rely on foreign countries to produce it for them, instead of spending that money on rockets and tunnels in order to kill people? The other Arab countries want nothing to do with them. That’s the truth.

Palestinians want to take refuge but when asked to the neighbour country they answer the same... the real deal is that even Islamic countries don't want to give refuge.

What he's saying is they don't want terrorists in their country

Thay don't want them in their country at all

It's not to be lifted by other Arab countries because they want these refugees to claim asylum in western countries so eventually they can claim them for islam

Palestinians are seeking refuge status from their war torn country to remove terrorists Hamas from their country. Isreal removed themselves from Gaza so the Palestinians can have their own territory. But was forced to accept Hamas as the government controlling Gaza. Palestinians have not been able to live in peace under Hamas control. Who can point the blame for the Isreal invasion. Hamas who want to destroy Isreal don't care about the Palestinian people because they are useful and a tool to make Isreal look bad in world views for them. Palestinians are not being protected by Hamas. Palestinians deaths are wanted by Hamas. Think about it.

The agenda of you taking care of your own for once? Course not, every muslim country is authoritarian and a dump. You want to talk about Elitist countries? Its 2023 and the only countries w Monarchs who run things are all Muslim..welcome to the Dark Ages.

Answer: No, we do not want Hamas or Hezbollah. Let them stay where they are. Egypt withdrew from Gaza, Jordan withdrew from West Bank because they couldn’t stand Iran meddling using both terrorist groups. No Arab country wants that problem.

Palestine is not a country. It's never been a country. Palestinians are a combination of Egyptians, Jordanians, Syrians, and Lebanese arabs that were expelled from their countries and the British Mandate. The area of land you're referring to is not Palestine. It's Israel or, if you want to go back further, Judea and Sumaria. The people who rightfully live there, and have lived there for thousands of years, are happy to let others live there as well; as long as they're peaceful. Seems to be hard for some.

This guy knows his country and other Arab nations want nothing to do with the Palestinians.

No Arab country truly wants to help the Palestinians, words are cheap

What blockade? Hamas are murderous! Palestine is ruled by Hamas! Not Israel! Israel did not start the war Hamas did so blame Hamas not Israel! Israel is surrounded by 21 Muslim countries? Where is there aide for the Palestinians? Hamas wants nothing more than to destroy Israel!?

Its because they want to send them to western countries

What needs to happen is to find out what us driving them to the USAMERICA. \n\nUsamericans don't really want to know. It's not the immigration policy, it's Usamerican policy in these countries.\n\n\nIt's the USAMERICAN's dependence on drugs, corporate America, and USAMERICANs sending guns to these regions.

I WOULD NOT WANT TO LIVE THERE BUT LOVE TO VISIT CANADA SO NOW AND THEN. IT IS A BEAUTIFULL COUNTRY WHICH NEEDS TO SOLVE MANY PROBLEMS. I VISITED CANADA TWICE

As long they don’t need take any refugees from Palestine , no Arab country’s want the , Egypt have border, they don’t let any one in

What type of mind wants to create refugees by displacing people from their own country? The crocodile tears from the journalist is bizarre and a reverse psychology play. The minister answered the real question perfectly!

Other Muslims play dumb while the smart people know that other Muslim countries just don't want them. Yes they deserve to stay but what if some want a better life someplace else. Your saying all 2 million want to stay. Idk so.

They want their people to seek refuge in other countries But not in their own and he just trying to avoid the answer by giving other nonsense to divert it to hate other as if they are the good ones and other are the bad ones.

Canada was not like this before Trudeau. Trudeau has turned Canada into a third-world country, and he's not done. Plus, he is bringing in millions of illegal immigrants, mostly muslims . Nothing but ungrateful trouble maker's. If you want to live under a communist dictator, then come here . But bring a tent and be ready to live outside in minus 30 weather . Winter is here, and there is no place to go.

hang on a sec. 800K-900K house looks quite cheap. you will rarely see 1M dollars house in Asia such as Singapore, Seoul, Hong Kong and so on. you will need easily 2-3M dollars. the rental doesn’t look super expensive in Canada, either. which countries are cheaper than Canada unless you want to downgrade? if you think Canada is expensive, you will see other countries are crazy expensive. so stay there.

Everybody licking his ringpiece \n\nOf course they dont want to leave their land. But the ones that do. Why dont any arab countries take them in if they are so concerned?

He basically said: they made their bed and now they can lie in it. \n\nThere’s quite a few Palestinians trying to leave and seek refuge in Egypt since they opened their borders to take a limited number of them in.. as long as they’re not associated with Hamas. \n\nHamas brought this war to the Palestinian’s doorstep in Gaza and if other Arab nations don’t want to open their borders to the Palestinians who would like to leave because of the war, then there will be an increased number of civilian casualties. Just because their fellow Arabs refuse to take them as refugees doesn’t mean Israel loses the right to defend itself from the barbaric terrorist attack Hamas launched against them. \nAny other country would have the right to defend itself from terrorists that live at their borders. If Hamas cared about their citizens, they’d have a plan for them and their safety once they initiated this war on Oct 7th. But it seems like Hamas’s only plan for them was to be disposable pawn martyrs caught in between them and Israeli forces. \n\nYou can’t torture, rape and kill 1,400 Israeli citizens/foreign nationals and take 200+ hostages back to Gaza during a depraved terrorist attack and then cry ceasefire when that country declares war and is winning. Especially when you’re still holding onto hostages and not honoring the terms of the first ceasefire by letting the Red Cross see the hostages. \n\nIf these other countries cared about the Palestinians, they’d take any refugees that wanted to leave. They clearly don’t want to do that for some reason. They’re watching from afar with their popcorn, saying “isn’t it terrible what the Israeli’s are doing.. but we won’t let them come here to escape, which would let the Israelis fight this war with Hamas, who initiated it, without civilians in between.” With no mention of how Hamas as put them in the middle and isn’t protecting them. Also no mention of any responsibility Hamas has for bring this war onto them by the large scale terrorist attack, that includes hundreds of civilian hostages of all ages.

Saudi Arabia kicked the Palestinians out of their country because they supported Saddam Hussein. The last thing any Arab nation wants is any Palestinians because they know it's trouble. Everywhere the Palestinians go they try to overthrow the government. In Jordan the king had to kick them out for trying to assassinate him. The king killed 25,000 of them kicking them out of his country and sending them to Lebanon where they immediately tried to overthrow the government again.

I criticized the genocide of my Sikh brothers, sisters and children in riots in Delhi in 1984. That incident is the one that led few sikhs but not all to ask for a separate nation that should be named Khalistan and I want the media to not to call those sikhs “extremists”in foreign countries, we can call them Sikhs asking for separate country, they can not be called “Khalistanis” either because Khalistan doesn’t exist. Also, sikhs and Hindus always got along well. In all India, there are sikhs living everywhere just like Hindus. There was never a conflict or dispute between them. I grew up in a society where my neighbors are all mixed Hindus and Punjabis. As much as Sikhs visit Hindu Temples same goes for Hindus visiting Gurudawaras. How about our film industry, there are so many sikh Punjabis like the Kapoors, the Malhotras, they don’t want to leave India also. I don’t want to my Indian sikhs to make a separate nation. I want the Indian police not to discriminate against certain religion and not be biased. If a Hindu policeman saves a Hindu criminal and wrongfully and falsely put a non Hindu person in jail then it’s purely wrong and discriminatory and same thing goes for a Sikh policeman. How about our soldiers, majority of our soldiers are Hindus and Sikhs, they are protecting India and it’s citizens. I want people of all religions and backgrounds in India to live peacefully and get along.

He is clever saying what people wants to hear and not committing to saying they do not want them in their country. You all fall for it hook and sinker.

They just don’t want to take the Palestinians… if you notice NO Arab country has pledge to take them.. they wants to resolve.. but no one wants to take them..

Or the truth is even the other arab countries dont want them in their countries.

WE DONT WANT YOUUUU. GOD DAMN JUST LEAVE US AND OUR COUNTRY ALONE!

funny no arab country wants them lol

They had a land for one day and they attack Israel, They don't want a land what they don't want is a non Muslim land in the area, they proved it in 1948, and they keep saying it, why don't we listen to them. Arabs want to conquer the world, soon or later the pro palestinians woke all over the western countries will understand, but will it be too late?.