Close Reading

The Saudi crown price already said Israel has a right to existence

All of this shenanigans for migrants from across the world especially Muslims ,make me feel sorry for one sector of Canadian society who are always forgotten, never given any mention or notice about their wellbeing, and those people are the NATIVE CANADIANS...they should be the ones to first & foremost have a say about what is happening in Canada afterall they are the original & first people of that land...but sadly they have been neglected for such a long time by the White political establishment...I wonder what they have to say about the state Canada is in right now....what they think about the Muslim immigrants whom their government is taking much a care of.

Did Hamas care for wellbeing Palestinians when they attacked Israel civilians, or is it Palestine people that has some utopia human rights? Not to mention that Israel provides humanitarian aid, food, medicine and Hamas takes it.

In philippines, theres no room for bully muslims..they just stayed in their right place

Right! But he didn't care to explain how the attacks and genocide will end, when neither UN nor Arab world has done anything in this regard!

There are two sides to a coin. Everybody’s rights must be respected

Is he understand him from the beginning of what happened? What is right about passing through holes into another person's country and killings peaceful citizens and thinking you will go free? Arabs and Muslims need to go to school for a change of mind

Blame yourselves for giving up all your rights to your government, America is on the dame path...2024 we will have to take our country back at the voting polls..you should do the same grow a backbone

I am an Arab, but what makes sick this point of view for Arab officials when they speak they say their land, their right !!\nYou then realize how the colonization succeeded in making these people believe that we aren't one, we are not United any more, it happened in Iraq, it is happening in Palestine,! Even we pray for them we say I pray for them, man we are one blood and before any thing, Islam teaches us not to give up on our brothers and sisters. Wake Up!!!!!!!

That’s what the Israelis want, to make them refugees with no right to return

The right response - Palestinians do not want nor need to leave their own land. Such stupid question and action just plays into Israels hands

He said Palestine ?? people have the rights to their land,security and dignity that was human right spoke

Right, many Canadians are moving to south Asian countries, some sold everything they owned and just ride it out on their savings, which can be a very long time.

So let's get this right you're SNP leader for over a decade was found for fraud now they are hiking taxes. All this will do is damage Scotlands economy not help it.\n\nYou want to make working in Scotland financially rewarding you want people to afford a home, car and enjoy life.. That creates an increase in micro economics being people spending more of their income.\n\nIf you go out your way punishing people for earning you will damage local spending.\n\nThis isn't difficult

If Gaza Palestinians say that they are refugeed from Israel and that they have a right to return to Israel, that means that Gaza is NOT their land and they are only theer as refugees. Now suddenly we are told that Gaza IS their land, which would mean that Israel is NOT their land. They can't have it both ways.

That’s right”” she needs to do go back and research before asking Stupid questions it’s there LAND

Thats means they have a right yo fight for it.

????? …. \nThe only thing missing in this are him saying the words : “Israel” … and “USA and all those who claim Israel has a right to defend itself”

Excellent video. I am a 29 years old Canadian with high education. I make 125K/year and yet after 2-3 years of looking actively I still can't manage to buy a house near the city as a first time buyer. I made many offers but lost every time. The demand is so high and the offer so low that many people bid way above the asking price even though the prices are sky high. Most of those people sold their previous house for a lot more than they bought it many years ago and therefore, are able to do so. First time buyers like myself don't have this advantage and the ones with lower salaries might never have the chance to have a house except if they move far from the city. Our government does not slow down on immigration because there is a labor shortage due to the older generation retiring but they don't build enough houses and allowed foreign investors for too long which results in the housing crisis we are currently in. My father bought a decent house near the city for the equivalent of 2 years of his gross salary at the time... Now the equivalent is more than 4-5 times my gross salary even though I make more than him at the time (taking inflation into account). Our healthcare and education systems are falling apart as well. Both are currently on strike in the province I live in due to terrible work conditions and salaries from our government. The cost of living has increased considerably in the last few years as well, especially the food even though the companies are making record net profits this year. Yeah... Canada is not doing well right now.

Though they don't have the right to hit and not get hit back harder

You nailed it Sonia, me and my family of as been living here for about 17 years and yes we have been through it all, so I could actually feel the clock turning as you spoke. I would like to add one thing though which you are right about that, if you are planning to come and start now, it definitely is not the time to come, 17 years ago was a different time and I can also tell you that we feel the pain yet even now to make ends meet. Honestly, life was good until a few years ago but now the value is declining to a great extent, again as a disclaimer this is my personal experience and would probably apply differently to different individuals. In short, as you said, if you are doing well somewhere else, don't hit the axe on your own feet by coming here.

Getting them out as refugees is defeat. We know and they know there will be no right to return. Its disgusting that the woman even had the ordasity to raise such a question.

Israel has those same rights aslo

We support for the right for Palestinians to be in their land. (Sorry we aren’t taking any refugees in)\n\nWe also support and aid Israel in mutual convenience issues. (we won’t oppose your actions)\n\nDiplomacy

and who decided that they're refugees in the first place , they're being bombed head on and they didnt even hesitate to go anywhere, ask palastenians directly with as many as you can. they will always answer with a straight face that we are not going anywhere \nif you want to see the truth about the land, at times like this you will find occupier fleaing to airports running away and the rightful land owner is picking stones to fight for what belongs to him.

Too little too late foreign minister stop killing in Gaza right now enough already move supplies right now you are Saudi not yahoodi

Lets all.see once hamsa is gone what Gaza people say about hamsters sorry hamsa if Syria people had right to go to Europe qhy not palstain

The Israelis also have a right to safety and security.

He is, unfortunately, only half right. The Arab world DOES have a card to play and that is gas and oil. Threaten to cut that off to Israel and the US, they start listening because nothing speaks louder than money. The OIC can do something about it indirectly but i dunno why they won't do even that.

NO WHERE in this piece of propoganda, did the author mention human rights. Some of the alternative countries have even more bigotry than Canada and restrictions on letting people choose their own lives. \nAsk a BLM person, a Muslim person, or LGBTQ person in America how confident they are about their entire country.

Healthcare: Governments have fkked this up. Admittedly, there has been a problem with nurses and overtime, but we are seeing the Alberta government attacking healthcare workers and allowing them to have also be subjected to the ignorant and misinformed attacks from the far right base over vaccine issues. Unvaccinated people caused more grief than was necessary when hospitals were being overwhelmed. \nTrain more doctors and nurses. Pay for their entire education. Pay them a healthy salary with reasonable workloads. Government should be paying for medical administration costs, rather than having every doctor and NP reinvent the wheel. Let the medical people do their primary job. Pay rural docs and nurses appropriately for having to endure the small town folks and farmers who think that only certain people are worthy. Privatized (and even profitized) healthcare solutions have become a nightmare for Americans who are not well off. And yet, we see our far right A hole political parties trying to push for this.

WHERE are municipal politicians supposedly limiting the construction of homes? I don’t see it. \n\nWe are aware that there are regulations in place to protect buyers and that self-serving industries lobby to do away with, as those protective regulations can reduce profits. Some provincial governments (like Alberta) are highly sympathetic to lobbies and industries, to the detriment of citizens. \nWhy are you not pointing to the fact that successive federal governments of the past stopped funding the construction of lower cost housing (thereby creating more demand AND our number one problem of unmitigated greed throughout the real estate and home building industries? We have some people in government attempting to get more low cost homes built while industries know that they can make more money building houses that are far, far bigger than people NEED. Dumbasses and keep-up-the-Jones folks unwisely buy these homes and then many of them have difficulty affording a lifestyle that they think they are entitled to. Meanwhile, lower income earners have been priced right out the market. Of course, capitalists and real estate investors like Pierre Poilievre will never admit that these are our actual problems. Regulating the construction and real estate industries could have gotten a lot more homes built in higher density for young and lower income Canadians, as well as for our newcomers. \n\nToo much blind and poorly informed anger, selfishness, and foolishness going around. Canadians of the past who pulled together during world wars would call us weak and entitled.

I agree ❤with him. Everyone has a right to their dignity, to live free on the land of their birth, raising their children like any other citizens.. peace ✌️ ☮️ to all mankind ❤❤❤❤❤stop the ki....g

Canada is a failed state where you have zero rights

Ms Francesca Albanese of the UN would have put journalists asking such questions in the rightful place (politely shut them down), this FM is very tactful and diplomatic but his response is equally excellent.

He's right, but stop Hamas first.

On their own land, thay have every right as humans’

Disgusting get them and their families out of the country. They come to the west Christian countries and they dictate what we should do. Follow the rules and cultures of the countries you go to . Can you imagine a Christian doing this in a Muslim country. They’d be beheaded in the street in front of baying crowds. No such thing as Shari law in Britain. Go to a Muslim country if you want Shari law or learn to live and respect other people’s rights and choices.

They have a right to stay in their own land in their own homes in their own country. Why would they abdicate. It is surrender to a foreign power. Do Americans think Africa should take back African Americans if we decide we want to get rid of them and confiscate their property?

They have no right. Put them in jail then send them out of country. \nThey come here and think they can change law

❤❤❤Maashallah, ?% You are right everything. Palestinian want to live their land safe and sound. Thank you very my young gentleman.

It's astonishing to see so many Canadians voicing serious complaints about their country. More to hear complaints coming from immigrants who then left Canada in disgust and found better lives elsewhere is even more astonishing.\n Yet I warn everyone else. It's okay for Canadians to complain about their own country. They have every right. As for immigrants or immigrants who left Canada, well, they were there and experienced the downside, so they have legitimacy.\n But for any other non-Canadian, including me, keep our mouths shut and say nothing. Let only the Canadians speak here. If you non-Canadians are foolish enough to open your mouth, a hundred angry Canadians will come here to loudly denounce you and maybe swear profanities for demeaning their perfect nation, Canada, and that all these complaints really don't exist and are made up.

That is right, why the Arabs are taking Palestinians as refugees. Why not the Europeans take the Israeli people as refugees????

Western colonialism causes pain worldwide, and the price has to be paid by others?! He is so right.

Political Correctness should be right on top.

Indirect invasion. This shit is working in the west because they are too soft, going extreme for human rights. That's why I prefer China's way more.

Its not their land, it was once Jordanian land but Jordan lost. The only reason Gaza and the West Bank exist in its present form is because Israel wants to live in peace with the people in THEIR land. Personally I think Israel should invade Lebanon and forceably move all Palestinians to that area. They could do the same thing in Syria. At that point, all the Arabs can give all the Palestinians all the aid they want because they will no longert be in Israel. \nIran should be being blockaded and Tehran should look just like Gaza. I do appreciate that these Islamic countries have the arrogance they do, doesnt make them right though, at all.

What sick notion is that. Every Palestinian has the right To live on that land with dignity and respect. Did we forget Nabi Esa (AS) (Prophet Jesus) is Palestine born in Jerusalem.

Right answer ! The stupidity to ask this question is not seeing the agenda of Israel to take all the land in the name of self defense. It's like that from the beginning of colonisation with or without terrorist attacks. The lessons givers won't see that refugees are the treat for European countries where extremism are growing.

I lived and worked in TO in a few areas for several years. I left in 2016. I am glad I left before it got bad. I started witnessing more racist comments on subway and platforms were becoming too crowded. After 30 plus years I moved to live in a rural area before moving to live in a similar setting to where I grew up in Oakville. I do love TO and it has so much to offer. I worked downtown and just could not keep up. I spent my spare time walking along the beaches especially Scarborough Bluffs and skating at Harbourfront on a weekday. These are fond memories that I will cherish.\n\n I heard that the shelters were over crowded and unhealthy places. I met a nice man in my building who was successful, lived on street for 13 years before successfully integrating into low-income housing. I learned the most from his stories and met some of the most fabulous people in the worst buildings. I had to leave for safety and mental health reasons. I could not see myself remaining in TO without support. \n\n I made the right move in the right time. Not everyone can afford city living. My quality of life and mental health are better but I cherish the friendships I made in TO. My Grandfather was a Mcleod and I am amazed how much you look like my mother when she was younger. She modeled for Ford and volunteered for a local Vet and hospital. I wish you well. I appreciate your honesty. Since I left, I have driven by TO on 407 a few times. I just didn't have the right mix of education and work to survive in the city any more.