Close Reading

No one wants to leave the mother land wtf

It's not Palestinian land though

Very well spoken. Why doest the US take Israel to the land they occupied from native Indians.

Right on, the State of Satan scheme was to force them out of their land.

I am an Arab, but what makes sick this point of view for Arab officials when they speak they say their land, their right !!\nYou then realize how the colonization succeeded in making these people believe that we aren't one, we are not United any more, it happened in Iraq, it is happening in Palestine,! Even we pray for them we say I pray for them, man we are one blood and before any thing, Islam teaches us not to give up on our brothers and sisters. Wake Up!!!!!!!

Folks been fighting over land that God created to ALL for FREE.! Sad and evil

Taking the people off their land makes them refugees, removing the threat to the Palestinians, giving them the opportunity to rebuild and prosper on their land. Letting the Israelis force them from their land and make them refugees would be the worst possible outcome, not just for the Palestinian people but for the region as well. Bullies must always be defeated and taught a lesson.

Land, land, land. All based on religious nonsense. Why wouldn't anyone want to leave Gaza? Let Israel have the whole of Israel if it wants but make it pay relocation costs. Perhaps when the lunatic fringes on both sides see that land ownership doesn't end the world or inspire the return of Jehovah (or whoever) they will calm down.

Why asking Palestinians to move away from where they are from, Palestine? Should ask Israelis to move away from the land that's not their own anymore. It was their's more than 2000 years ago, but not anymore.

Yes yes yes. Why should Palestinians leave their land. I think she's pushing Israeli prapaganda. Israel want Gaza. Thats why they force out the rightful owners of the land into Egypt

Canada, the land itself and the wonderful wilderness is second to none.\nBut the culture and governance have robbed my country of all opportunities except selling houses and drilling oil.\nNo innovation, no competition, no growth.\nIts insane that a country born on third base can stagnate this badly.

That's what isreal want to leave the land to arab world

Palestinians also have some responsibilities: 1. Not to attack and commit terrorist attacks against their neighbours, 2. Sign a peace agreement to legalize the possesion of the land by creating their own country.

His Right. The Arabs will not support the zionist agenda - ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from their homes, their land.

If Israel thought they will scare Palestine by massacring,they are wrong- Palestine wont leave their land

The right response - Palestinians do not want nor need to leave their own land. Such stupid question and action just plays into Israels hands

Yeah, in a perfect world they would all get their land back. But if it isn’t exceedingly obvious by now, that is never going to happen. I hope they come to America as my neighbors Inshallah.

Why doesn't the US or Europe offer the Jews a place of safety?\nIt isn't their land, so the solution is that they leave first.

He said Palestine ?? people have the rights to their land,security and dignity that was human right spoke

Same goes for Jews. They have the right to the land, to exist and live safely, secured, not threatened by the neighbour.

Why should the Palestinians leave their land ? That would be wrong. If Israel can't handle it, they should leave.

Which land is he referring to?

I thought that land belonged to Israeal?

If Gaza Palestinians say that they are refugeed from Israel and that they have a right to return to Israel, that means that Gaza is NOT their land and they are only theer as refugees. Now suddenly we are told that Gaza IS their land, which would mean that Israel is NOT their land. They can't have it both ways.

The British terminated the Mandate at midnight at the end of 14 May 1948. On that day, the last remaining British troops and personnel departed the city of Haifa and the Jewish leadership in Palestine declared the establishment of the State of Israel.\n\nBritish ruler of Palestine gave that land to Israel in 1948..!!!!!

That’s right”” she needs to do go back and research before asking Stupid questions it’s there LAND

The Jews which you brought to Palestine after WW2 from Germany Poland are the who go as refugees not the Palestinians a Land owners

Don’t play innocent ok? Why Palestinian has to go somewhere? Is that your land ? Israeli land? They want their land. Palestinian kids even not for adoption. What kind of justice is this ?

There's one tiny issue: Gaza isn't their land. How do I know that? Because they say so themselves, they claim to be refugees, and you can't be a refugee on your own land.\n\nThey need to make up their mind, if Gaza is their land they shouldn't be fighting Israel all the time and they aren't refugees. If Gaza isn't their land, then they have no claim to it and they can be refugees elsewhere too.\n\nYou can't have your cake and eat it too.

The noun “Israel” occurs 2,507 times in the Hebrew text of the Old Testament. Twice “Israel” has a verb in the feminine singular form: 1 Samuel 17:21 and 2 Samuel 24:9.The Land of Israel has been inhabited since 2000 B.C.E. Populated by the Jewish people. Here is the timeline in case you didn't know it is their homeland as designated by GOD.\n\n1900 B.C. 400 BC: Abraham is chosen by God to be the father of the Jewish nation.\n1900 B.C. 400 BC: Isaac, son of Abraham, rules over Israel.\n1850 B.C. BC: Jacob, son of Issac, rules over Israel.\n1400 B.C. BC: Moses leads the people from Egypt back to Israel.\n1010 B.C. BC: King David unites the 12 tribes into one nation.\n970 B.C. BC: King Solomon, son of David, builds the first temple building in Jerusalem\n930 B.C. 400 BC: Israel is divided into two kingdoms, the Kingdom of Israel and the Kingdom of Judah. 800s B.C. BC: The rise of the prophets, God's messengers.\n722 B.C. BC: The Kingdom of Israel is conquered by the Assyrians.\n605 B.C. BC: The Kingdom of Judah is conquered by the Babylonians.\n586 B.C. 400 BC: Solomon's Temple is destroyed by the Babylonians.\n539 B.C. 400 BC: Persians conquer the Babylonians and take control of Israel.\n538 B.C. BC: The Jews return from exile to Israel.\n520 B.C. BC: The temple is rebuilt.\n450 B.C. BC: Reforms by Ezra and Nehemiah.\n433 B.C. 400 BC: Malachi is the end of the prophetic age.\n432 B.C. BC: The last group of Jews returns from exile.\n333 B.C. BC: The Greeks conquer the Persian Empire.\n323 B.C. 400 BC: The Egyptian and Syrian empires take over Israel.\n167 B.C. 400 BC: The Hasmoneans recapture Israel and the Jews are ruled independently.\n70 B.C. BC: Romans conquer Israel.\n20 B.C. BC: King Herod builds the “third” temple\n6 B.C. BC: Jesus Christ is born in Bethlehem\n70 AD: Romans destroy the temple Afterwards the people were prisoners of the Romans, Byzantines, Arabs and Crusaders. Despite all these events, the Jewish people continued to live in Israel. There were more or less of them depending on the century, but there was never a time when Jews did not live in the country. They stayed, they built their communities, they raised their families, they practiced their faith, and they suffered at the hands of many outside rulers, but they always kept their faith. It's what keeps her alive even now.\n\nIn 1948, the United Nations founded the State of Israel, the Nation of the Jews. Don't buy the Palestinians' lie that they are entitled to the land. It's simply not true. Yahweh will also provide His chosen people with an opportunity to live in Israel as He has for thousands of years. Pray for the people of Israel.

Israel wants Palestinians out of Palestine, Americans make it sound like it’s the right thing to do and Arabs are monsters for not taking Palestinians as refugees. The truth is, Palestinians do not want to leave their land, they don’t want to be refugees, they want to stay in their homes. So no, Arabs have no intention to aid Israel in displacing Palestinians.

I'm sure they don't want to PERMANENTLY leave their lands, but that doesn't mean they wouldn't like to be able to go to Egypt to get treatment or until it calms a bit down.

Palestine is their home why should they leave. \nThey left 2x’s in history & were not allowed to return. Their homes were taken over & their land was stolen. \nSo no they will never leave again. \nFool me once shame on you. Fool me twice shame on me.

This is not the Palestinians land to begin with !

He is completely wrong and ignorant. Israel is the true holy land which belongs to the Jews. There is no such thing as Palestine. Palestine was made from stolen Israeli land. \nPeace for Israel! ?? ??

ancient rome called it palestine when they were expelling jews from their land and nailing jesus to a cross!

Western wants Palestinian to left so Israel will have the land

But it’s not their land, it belongs to the Israelis, the Palestinians of today are transplanted Arabs!! Nobody’s going anywhere?

Ummm.... Pretty sure that was originally Israel's land.

But it is not their land. They should move to an Arab country. But no Arab country will have them... I wonder why that is? There is history of Palestinians in other Arab countries... until they were kicked out.

I hear this a lot recently, that others should take the Palestinians in their countries, totally disregarding the fact that they insinuate that they should leave their lands and homes and go somewhere else. Why should they? They have more rights on that land than any Zionist from Europe, or America.

Excuse me, that's not palestinian land, the land belongs to the jews...

Why would they have to leave their land to the occupiers

They need to be sent back to their home land. The world needs to wake up!

A very wise answer. Well said.?\nInsha Allah, one day the palestinian people will be free, and have their land back. Ameen ?

The same arguments also apply to Israelis. They too do not want to leave their land.

WHY DOES NEWS MEDIA THESE DAYS SEND REPORTERS WHO ARE SUPPOSEDLY EDUCATED but Not Intelligent and DOES NOT READ HISTORY before they ask dumb questions and make a fool of themselves ? We all know that Palestinian have some rights based on their Caanan ancestors in that land and so are the Jews ( Israeli Prophets ) ... WHY and How on earth does the Arab world need to accept Palestinians as refugees in their countries ? For what ? The only way is 2 state independent and sovereign . I suggest the News Media get their reporters to learn about Middle East history before coming forward ?

Oh it’s their land is it? Says who, you the Muslim leadership. Or perhaps it’s the Jewish leaders who actually occupy and cultivate the land. If a group of people. Any group wants to band together. To create terror, fear, and violence. They shouldn’t be acting surprised and playing the victim. When they receive the same treatment.

Israels plan was all along to push the Palestinians into Egypt and take their land.

Palestinians have the right to be safe in their land but not even his own people are safe in his land.