Close Reading

Ever tried as an AMERICAN to have a reasonable conversation with an INDIA INDIAN????? ?

Are Mexicans, Americans...?\nHow about Mexican-American, are they Americans?\nWhat about Chicanos, or American Mexican-American, are they American? Mind you, they were in coastal western north America before the indians were there, and they are of European origin.\nThat brings another question: are American Indians, American, or are they Indians?\nWhat about 'People of Colour' are they American?\nAnd finally, are low class poor white people, American?\nPotpouri gallore...

India for Indians. America for Americans, canada for canadians

Trudeau can’t stop bringing Sikh and Hindu Indians so they can live the American dream

I’m an American of Indian descent and I- now- understand why my parents never wanted to immigrate to Canada. …This is so sad and I hope Canada changes and kicks out Trudeau. Canadians, please, fight back! \n\nYours truly, \n\n-?? ?

There’s millions of Indian doctors shipped into the USA to service poor areas where American doctors don’t want to work.

I’m half Indian and a proud American. There should be zero tolerance.

Some people are dumb beyond belief, mum it's not your country!!!even trump himself is not an original American, the true Americans are Called Red Indians ,Apaches, cheyenne,kiowas etc

I heard soon there would be a hundred times more Indians, from India, than Native American Indians on their own mother land.

This woman is full of crap. Never shit where you live. All of us are immigrants including Donald Trump family. The real American people are the indigenous indians. I hope she never needs her family for anything

You made your bed Americans. Plus, Canada only seems to let in Indians ?

Everyone is a illegal immigrants, except the original, American Indians.

plz don’t come here americans u will be in tents on the streets of canada stop coming here please there’s no homes for us let alone any of you we have issues as is with indian immigrants and violance go home it’s not your right to enter illegally

I am Mexican American (Chicago). In all honesty the worst thing that can happen to a Mexican is another Mexican.. a very ? culture, the wrong mix of envious distrustful Spaniard and servant, paranoid Indian blood. ?

These Racist Congressmen, are so ignorant about the Majority Reason, why people come to this country. The Majority come because, they want a better life for themselves, and their family. They don't leave their Native Country because they want to take a Vacation to the U.S. They have every Right, to Seek A Better Future. This Country is for Every Human Being! People from All Walks Of Life, are here to STAY! Everyone has come to USA, from around the World! The Only Native Americans, were the Indians, that were here, before Christopher Columbus arrived! Did they tell Cristopher Columbus, go back to Italy, you are not Welcome Here? No Ignorant People, they ateTHANKSGIVING TOGETHER! It seems, that many people didn't learned History in School. They just went to fool around, and stay dumb! It's Ashamed!

12 Tribes of Israel \n\n1. Judah - American Blacks\n2. Benjamin - West Indian Blacks\n3. Levi - Haitians\n4. Ephraim - Puerto Ricans\n5. Manasseh - Cubans\n6. Simeon - Dominicans \n7. Zebulun - Guatemala to Panama (Mayans)\n8. Gad - Native American Indians\n9. Reuben - Seminole Indians\n10. Asher - Colombia to Uruguay (Incas)\n11. Issachar - Mexicans (Aztecs)\n12. Naphtali - Argentina/Chile \n\nThus saith the Lord our God: \nGenesis 49:28\n[28]All these are the twelve tribes of Israel: and this is it that their father spake unto them, and blessed them; every one according to his blessing he blessed them. \n\n--//-- \n\nNever Give ?️ Never Give In!\nTwelve Tribes ?-Wide! \n\n?????????????\n?⚅⚅⚅⚅???????️?\n?⚅⚅⚅???????️?️?\n?⚅⚅???????️?️?️?\n?⚅??⬜?⬜⬜⬜?️?️?️?\n????⬜???️⬜?️?️?️?\n????⬜?⬜⬜⬜?️?️??\n????⬜?️⬜?️?️?️???\n???⚔⬜?️⬜⬜⬜????\n?????️?️?️?️???⚃?\n?????️?️?️???⚃??\n?????️?️???⚃???\n?????????????

People keep using fear mongering by talking about denaturalization and how it can strip your citizenship and depot you against your will. And while that may be true, that only applies to those who got their citizenship through naturalization....and there are many other ways to get a citizenship lol. Granted I don't agree with his massive deportation stance at all. I just also don't want everybody to freak out without knowing the facts. I saw U.S born citizens (I am speaking about other races that white people) freaking out that they may lose their citizenship ?. Which is hilarious, because you CAN NOT lose your citizenship if you were born here unless you decide yourself to get a citizenship in a different country lol. So to all the latino, asian, african american, indian, etc people that were BORN in the united states.....please stop freaking out. Denaturalization isn't going to affect you lol.

The only people in the United States who are not immigrants or descendants of immigrants are Native American Indians. So it's the height of hypocrisy and arrogance for these people to whine against immigrants. We also have a law that justly provides safe harbor for immigrants seeking refugee protection because they are fleeing their country of origin due to persecution, violence, victimization, etc. It is morally correct to receive them here without any mistreatment or demonization. It is prejudicial, inhumane, and unlawful to turn them away or deport them. Is the administrative system and process inefficient or faulty? YES, obviously. That's not an excuse to be derelict in our duty. Our obligation is to fix whatever is lacking or broken in our system, so that it functions properly, fairly, and rapidly, for anyone seeking either asylum, or ordinary immigration processing and approval.

When she started with 'we need to take our country' back, I began to think she meant Mexican-Americans need to take back their country that was originally part of Mexico but was taken from them by the United States. eg Texas and other border states. Isn't that what the immigration north is all about? Taking back country? Of course the people who should really have the right to take back their country are the Indian Nations. They would be justified in deporting any families whose ancestors were illegal immigrants and did not get the equivalent of a green card from the original owners. I find it fascinating that descendants of illegal immigrants are so antagonistic to more recent illegal immigrants. 'We were illegal first! So we have the right to stop you illegals now!' ?

Your country belonged to the American Indians before it was violently taken by the White Man… So if you’re not an American Indian, you’re an Immigrant. It’s maddening just how ignorant (Convicted Felon) Trump Supporters are.

As an American, Indians are welcome to come to the US because they have a good reputation for being educated and hard working. The other groups of immigrants from latin America are causing problems in America.

People like this are very much responsible for representing a bad reputation towards Indians. It is very shameful and disgusting. States like Punjab, Gujrat in India have very wealthy and intelligent people. It is very shameful ? to see this is happening from the people of those states….Everyone should be punished for conducting illegal activities, doesn’t matter Indian or American but this is very shameful..

How many Indians were selling drugs or into robbery n etc ?? I don't know what's priority of American government for its citizens safety ....peaceful workers should be deported or violent criminals ???

On the other hand, American community, which seems more aware & evolved, has a different view on indinn community. They like us (See Nate Friedman's video on Indian voters in Jersey n the comments section). \nEven Donald Trump has praised indian community. I think Canada lacks visionary & powerful leader thst can bring reforms in immigration. While i acknowledge thst some of us are embarrassing the entire community, an ignorant n narrow minded society generalize the entire community which is very sad & heartbreaking.

Let's face it, we won't be flocking to these countries in hordes if Europeans hadn't already made these countries financially strong. After all, how many Indians go to , say, Vietnam and learn Vietnamese, or go to congo to learn swahili. \n\nYes , I'm aware that Indians were all over the world even before colonization, but I'm speaking specifically about the North American countries .\n\nThat said, kudos to Ashwin for shutting up the hag.

Colonial Canadians probably don't know that at one time North American 'Indians' thought the same about them. What goes around comes around.

She is right, we Indians should make our own country better place for living insted of running to Europe or American countries, which have made thier own country better places for living.

Where is the diversity in our immigration system? There are now more East Indians in Canada than Native Americans, Metis, Inuit and Dene COMBINED! Who's being bribed here?

As FRENCH, I think it is more an issue with policies set by both governments!!! You know you bring students IN and why don’t you build houses and encourage construction???? In France, many students (mainly Africa, and French departments like Guadeloupe, Tahiti or Martinique) come to study there (for free and we are proud of it!!!) BUT - unlike Canada - we do NOT have the same issues as Canada (our healthcare is NOT under pressure and our housing prices haven’t really increased that much as compared to Canada for example!!!) to me, the students are NOT to blame!!! It is the fault of the deciders (at different level) who have FAILED to set the right policies!!!! The schools are also to blame as some (not all) are so obsessed with making profits out of the higher international fees, which by way, subsidize Canadian students!!! So in Canada (not in France or Germany), the money that allows schools to function come from international students who BRING LOTS OF MONEY for the Canadian economy!!!! in France, it is different as the universities are FREE and are fully subsidized by the French government… but yes;) you have to speak French fluently to attend them!!! \nSo dear Canadians, do not blame foreign students thanks to whom your universities thrive and remain existant!!! Without them (namely the Indians too), the Canadian universities will struggle to find money and funding! Remember, the system in France is TOTALLY different!!!!\nAlso, reading from comments, I notice that many here have NEVER alert their own country!!! Stop blaming foreigners if YOU, YOURSELF DID NOT even get the BALLS to dare studying in places different than yours (like Germany, France, Sweden, Japan…)!!!! Blame and NO BALLS!!! “Grosse gueule mais Pas de couilles” as we say in France!!! Go to Europe if you dare, deal with another language, other cultural codes (we French are big complainers and are very very rude when behind wheels!!!! And we hate people who cannot speak French properly … like North Americans) and We will see how good some of you will do!!!

By her logic, every american and Canadians should go back to Europe because that land belongs to red indians (native Americans). Or better all humans should go back to Africa because humanity orgins from that continent ?

This is how every indian treated in European and American countries

Canda was actually Indians (indigenous inhabitants)land we know them as red Indians & you white Europeans are the intruders your place of origin is Europe just look at yourself in the mirror,can you call yourself the people of Canadian or North American civilization.

Then she needs to go back to Europe or Britain wherever her parents grandparents were from. She's not a native of this land. American Indians were the native here.

Indians form third-largest illegal immigrant population in U.S.: Pew Research...bz of people doing these Indians are unable to get visa even if qualified and applying legally... Anything to US reports...The fiscal burden of providing essential services and benefits to illegal aliens costs American taxpayers nearly $151 billion each year.... Finally these people will be underpaid, tortured or end up in slavery....Pls don't do this and bring shame to our country...

Indians form third-largest illegal immigrant population in U.S.: Pew Research...bz of people doing these Indians are unable to get visa even if qualified and applying legally... Anything to US reports...The fiscal burden of providing essential services and benefits to illegal aliens costs American taxpayers nearly $151 billion each year.... Finally these people will be underpaid, tortured or end up in slavery....Pls don't do this and bring shame to our country...

All those illegal American Indians crossing the Canadian border into the United States. oops, typo. ? f**k you, I'm funny. ✌️?♟️Service Apartheid

I personally believe her concern is right.\n\nIn future white people may come settle in India and their children will be known as Indians.\nWe need to protect every kind of races.\nThis land of Bharatvarsh belongs to Arya people similarly all the land should be for their orginal people only.\n\nEDIT : I know Native Americans are the real inhabitants of USA but in terms of race they are similar to modern Americans.\n\nRegarding Aryan migration theory, it is just a hypothesis and not a proven fact.\nWe can't 100% say that Arya are outsiders.\nThere's no literary or archeological evidence that proves it.\nThere is *Out of India* theory to explain the DNA & language similarities.

Fr frisco isn’t American like it used to be it’s really cause of Indians are taking their family’s over to frisco and I’m the only American there though makes us look like people who are minority in frisco but seriously though….

Indian government should also deport all western citizens from Goa we also fed up with these dirty American

Like I explained, to those who say this will sour the us and canada's relationship. Americans don't care because even though Canada is less than 50% white, in they minds its still a majority white nation. That's why you don't see the BUILD A WALL etc, like you see with mexico, because even though the majority of immigrants crossing into the us from Mexico, might have been Mexican in the early 2000's, now that's not the case, 300k Colombians in one years, 175k indians, 75k turks, 150k, from Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal, Afghanistan, 500k from Russia and Ukraine since the war began, 200k from ecuador, 75k Chinese per year etc etc. And they scream, build a wall, and make mexico pay for it. Because mexico is less than 20% white. At this point with all the immigrants canada gives citizenship too, mexico is probably more white than canada at this point or will be in the near future. But y'all don't see as that, like i said y'all still think canada is a majority white nation when it's not, and mexico is a amarindiean majority nation when with all the immigrants canada has now, sorry, new Canadians mexico is probably just as white or even more so than canada. And for those that think I'm exaggerating, read the comments or the lack thereof, and the ones that do comments completely overlook the fact that they can use and are using canada to reach the us, and completely want to change the conversation to the ones crossing from Mexico, why? Are there or are there not using canada to cross into the us, and the thing is this people pick which country to use, as we choose which restaurant to eat at!!!!!!! Well, I like.... I would prefer..... today the majority choose mexico. Tomorrow as you just saw will be canada, will y'all also scream build a wall???

As an Indian American I do apologize, Canadian Indians need to assimilate. Canadians are very welcoming.

Under the British rule, Canada had four provinces. Britain made it as a federal dominion in 1867. It was considered as one of the three British North American colonies. \n \nThough today the majority of Canadians are white, the land that is now “Canada” was first occupied for thousands of years by the aboriginal peoples of North America. \n \nWhen the first European explorers came to Canada they found all regions occupied by native peoples they called “Indians,” thinking they had reached the East India

It’s about time they are doing this . Indians have been living in these countries for decades many immigrated from the 60’s . And assimilated and live happily in these countries . But this new set of arrogant ,entitled, semi educated . Immigrants .especially north Indian. Sikh and Punjabi Foreign students have destroyed the image of india . \nThey are rude ,crude ,have no manners not polite , are aggressive ,don’t know how to drive .don’t follow the rules or laws of the land.they think their culture and religion is better that the locals .. and scream racism or Hindu phobia .for every thing.\nThese low class Indians are giving the Indian Americans and other Indians in other countries a bad name .and causing racism for the local Indians like . For the ones who are born and settled in these countries. For decades .\nTime to deport all Sikh and Punjabi. Students as they are the main trouble makers.most barely speak English .

I was born here 55 years ago, I am mixed race and have been asked if I was Indian. I think that my time growing up in Canada is that Indians have had the most racism towards them. However, There are too many coming here right now. 99% of the Indians I have met with are nice and great people. With that , the shear amount of Indians that are not desirable are here. Cannot drive, rude, no understanding of customer service and take over public spaces and are litter bugs. You guys have to help transition into the western american canadian tradition. I have seen influxes of other countries come over here in my 55 years but I have never seen one group come over with these huge numbers. It is a massive displacement

North Americans don't want the religious dramas and loud Bollywood dance of Indians on a daily basis?.\nThey want their own culture to be preserved first I guess ?

what else is new? Indians, Mexicans, who else want to enter illegally??? tbh, pretty soon, America will be a Hispanic country, mark my words! even American employers now prefer that workers speak Spanish like wtf!

Our native American Indians are not being taken care of like the government is taking care of illegals

Europeans are funny many of them fear being what they are the minority in the sea of people of color which is the truth and what about how they go to places like India colonize and cause issues there? Maybe if the racist leave everyone lone they can have no worries. They don’t want to you to compete with American and Indian has a large number or Muslim practicing people I am sure that this has a lot to do.

keep them americans. we are at our maximum capacity of indians.

I wonder what the native American Indians are thinking looking at there country been invaded again by people who call themselves Indian and the first invaders complaining about it hypocrisy is the word that come to mind