Close Reading

Love it here in Toronto, Im lucky though i dont pay crazy high rent even though im itching to move for some odd reason. Maybe because I know I cant be here forever, I live in an old building that wont last, isnt mine and will be forced to move out when soemoen else buys it, like I was at my previouse apartment, which is my only problem, all he condo development, basically kicking out poorer people, thats why rent is high, but they're going to have to live with no sun in the city when all those towers block it. That being said the areas is just so bueatiful, it feels like its nestled in a forest, then the lake, its a great spot. Got 4 the seasons, i hear ist the most diverse city in the world racially and its climate is just as diverse going from -30 some winters to well above +30 some summers and everything in between. That being said I am getting tired of the city life and looking for a change although i think Toronto has a lot more potential and is actually underrated right now and will just get better. Maybe not more cheaper, but hopefully politicians will wise up and stop selling out for short term profits for long term problems.

information that is hidden for almost everyone but punjab sikhs know ’ nearly 5 lakh sikhs were killed in that time most of the encounters were to gain rank by police officials torture , rape, and killings of innocent sikhs were common by army and police officials alot of goons were hired by police to kill and rape hindus to set a narrative against militant sikhs because they we’re getting support from public because most of the army was from hindu religion and due to indra gandhi death they were hating sikhs they did medival types of tortures and at that time police can do anything without asking any official they actually beated brutally to my own dad just for fun they were beating and laughing police did alot of looting to gain fortune for their own THESE ARE THE MAJOR REASON MY SIKHS LOOSE SENSE OF TOUCH FROM INDIA and even now if sikhs demand anything even issue like msp kissan the media say khalistani khalistani we tired now

We heard that people who came back to India they are going again back to Canada, reason is there is no law and orders, corrupted politicians and corrupted justice systems make your life painful in India

You should have stayed (in Canada) for your kid’s future. \nIndia has very little to offer for its young generation …. Corruption, pollution, poverty, lawlessness and youth unemployment are a few reasons why Indians should run away from India for greener pastures of western countries ?.

Born and raised in Toronto. I have lived here my whole life for over 50 years. The city has changed drastically and very rapidly. As my retirement approaches and my kids finish University, I am out of here. The crime, the cost of everything, terrible transit and roads that look like they have gone through a war. I live by the lake and we have homeless tent encampments and people living along the train tracks ( and this is the suburban part of Toronto, by the Rouge valley) These are only a few of the reasons why Toronto has changed for the negative ( and I do not see it getting any better)

Pandemic, a Corrupt premier & complicit mayor hit Toronto Hard over the past 4 years. I agree, do not move here. But not for the reason you think. Toronto needs people who will to fight her, and her most vulnerable citizens.

This is very well put together. Is there any validity in the fact that the reason that the anger from 84 has quieted down in Punjab is because the government cracks down any negative info on it? People are jailed with no court case, people are tortured in jail, people are murdered? Could this be a reason?

THE BIGGEST REASON FOR SIKH MIGRATION DURING 84 PERIOD WAS FAKE ENCOUNTERS DONE BY PUNJAB POLICE UNDER KPS GILL AND CM BEANT SINGH.

Great job n great research by the Nitish Rajput's team. This is 100% true, most of the people migrated to Canada in 80s-90s remember punjab negatively. Most of the news these people hear is through the indian media houses which very negative. They expect the same rights from indian government as they get from Canadian government. Most of the Khalistani supporting got active because of ruling party politics where a regular sikhs whose son, brother n father served in indian army and marines is called Khalistani without any reason. This has definitely created a divide in society, and media houses are also spreading the negativity towards a community. \n\nWahi baat h ki Modi is not india n humei ni pasand uski politics. Doesn't mean ki hum anti nationalist hogye or we hate modi. Bhai nahi pasand humei politics jo society mei divide kre. First thing a sikh child is taught is that everyone is equal. Ab tum fundamentals attack kroge toh humei ni pasand ayega.

If a Khalistani demanding a new nation then there are many reasons which Indian Government is not fulfilling , they are not want another country Everyone want to live united but government not listening the voice of 2% people in the nation \nI appreciate the research but still some points are missing \nI can’t believe that a single person can do research like this but you still have to do more

Bhai saab!! ?\nHats off to you… so great!!\nBeing a Punjabi , we know some people are rebellious of what happened.\nBut people who saw bluestar … THEY DON’T WANT IT AGAIN!! \n\nYour R&D is superb. We actually need economic growth and it’s the factor Youth saara Abroad settle ho rha hai!! Piche sirf parents and unemployed log rh gye hai .. who are somewhat planning to move!!\n\nI consider one more reason… Ki Punjab mein zyada time alternate government hoti hai than Central .. which have affected soo much!! \n\nTo protect PUNJAB \npeople must be aware and government must also think!!

The main reason for Khalistan is because of Congress. Every problem starts from Congress

That's the reason hyper nationalism can collapse a nation.

Your video is biased and stupid at best. You should also cover the reasons for unemployment, and problems in Punjab. The problem is people from Punjab are so desperate to fly out of India, they have no intention or will to grow India's economy. How many IAS, toppers, businessmen you will see from Punjab? Its all about the mindset, look at other states like Delhi, Gujarat, Maharashtra for instance, population there is generating young entrepreneurs who are taking the country ahead. Its a shame that you are brain washing people, where you should educate people why because of such people India is at risk, they use India's resources to grow and when the time comes to contribute to country's gdp they fly to canada and other countries.

I had always a question Why most of Sikhs are wealthy. Today I got to know the reason.

Many many Sikhs in Canada do not want to support Khalistan. The main reason is that why do we alienate a state in the age of Unions. Other countries are forming unions to stay competitive and Punjabis will be at loss.

Reason to leave Toronto, the traffic on the 401. Reason to live in Toronto, weed stores every 100 feet, now magic mushrooms too.

Didn't India planned and bombed it's own Airline? To blame it on Sikh? When governments official's relative got off the plane? Just before the flight took off? But I know your helplessness. This was the reason nobody was able to find the bomber because it was planned by indian government itself to blame it on Sikhs.

Videsh jane ka Sabse pahle reason behtar life family future hota hai \nJab pet me khana pad jata hai or khali samay hota hai phir dimaag me khurafaat shuru hote hai apne logo ko kaise badya jaye achi baat hai \nLekin uske liye desh virodhi kaam nahi karna chahiye.

Awesome! \nCouldn’t agree more. Someone actually understood the reason and talked about it. \nI have also recently migrated to Vancouver, Canada with a goal to contribute to growth of Punjabi/Indian economy. ??

Punjab’s per captia is less coz of Punjab’s major institution and business went to the it’s capital Chandigarh , which was promised to Punjab but was later turned into UT. Punjab per captia is 2500 while Chandigarh per captia is 5200dollars … Punjab university , Chandigarh university , Punjab&haryana high court , punjabi music industry , punjabi film industry , punjabi politician , punjabi students has all shifted to Chandigarh , majority of business that operate in Punjab are headquartered in Chandigarh, the IT companies that were reaching Punjab had limited to Chandigarh .. even though Punjabis live in Chandigarh but this output is added separately coz it was turned into UT. I know some people will come no no Haryana also has no capital but Haryana number are more on paper coz Delhi spreads its legs ( NCR). Coz households fall in lower two wealth quintile in Punjab is 4.5% but Haryana this number is 9.3% .. while in Gujarat it is 25.6% and in Bihar it’s 75.2 percent … u can check india in pixels , the maps daily , my finology pages on Instagram they also attach sources with their information .\nThe other thing is that the reason punjab agriculture growth was 5 percent but it’s only 2 percent now coz it has peaked already .. China use to grow at 11 percent but now grow at 6 percent this doesn’t mean China is going to hell , economic growth stops once it hit plateau. The other thing is I don’t know why u keep saying that Punjab is mostly agrarian economy while 20%agriculture contributes in its economy .. Punjab has almost 13000 small and medium factories which is 9th number only low to the states which has ports and their average is 3 times the population of punjab .. the other reason it has the disadvantage of border state where if u see per captia income is less in those districts which borders with Pakistan .. investment is low on that side … Punjab also received 631 million dollars in fdi which is 6th 7th in country …. It is good to talk about problems but I guess media is trying to portray that Punjab is finished , their is nothing while reality is different .\nBTW video was amazing , u deeply researched it and make it clear that this khali bogey is also getting its attention coz of election coming up , they try to stir up the pot with amritpal but nothing happened it will all go away once election are done .

Isme ek baat h bhai , vo jo kanishk ki reports h , about those leaks that indian government was involved in that bomb blast ? Don’t it sounds its fishy like jin logon ne bomb implanted kia vo aj tak nahi mil paye but jo indian government k target the jaise k head of babar khalsa unke naam par lag gaya sab kuch ye …. Agar itne e high inputs the toh vo do bandon ka aj tak kyn ni pata chal paya , sirf unka naam e kyn pat chala paya jo highlighted names the …… another thing khalistan from last few years ye baat bhot jada highlighted ki ja rahi h … k jo bhi sikh apne rights ki baat karta h vo khalistani h …. Why ….? Aaap uspar bhi video banai kaise 100s of sikhs abhi bhi jailon me band h unki saza poori hone k baad bhi …. Kaise ye punjab se related choti choti baat ko itna jada bana dete … yeh jo chote influencers h vo kaise nafrati videos banate h … they never talked about manipur bhai agar non solhs ki taraf se hume target kia jata h …. That’s the another reason we feel violated , aj se 15 saal pehle ye moments kuch jada bari nahi thi lekin yr 5-6 saalon me itni kyn highlighted kardi gai ….

That's what i've been saying, we need economic reform. Whenever i've raised my concerns for the punjab's issue, i've been called anti national, terrorists by the Indians. That is one reason why sikhs here in canada have started using their identity as Punjabi over Indian. Whenever anyone asks me where I'm from, I just simply say Punjab not India.

Why don't you talk about fact that Punjab is the only state in india who doesn't have control over its water. 70% of Punjab water is given to Rajasthan, Haryana and Delhi. Then you guys give an argument that Haryana was with Punjab before, but the fact is when you calculate the water sharing between Punjab and Haryana, India doesn't include yamuna water. Yamuna water is only reserved for Haryana and Punjab water is forced to be shared. Narmada tribunal denied Rajasthan any water because its non riparian state. only 0.5 MAF water was given to them after taking Guj,MP and Maha Cm's consent. Where as 8.5MAF water ie 51% of punjab's water is given to Rajasthan. Every state has a right over its water and headworks except Punjab. we have no option other than using pumps. Punjab is nothing more than a food producing colony for the Indian state. Indian state has used and thrown Punjab.You seem like a reasonable man Mr Rajput I hope you take up this issue. Ive read alot about it issue I'm willing to share NASA, UN and indian govt data with you if you wish.

Punjab economic fail main reason is AAP

Bjp is the only reason for divide of India because there leaders calls publicly khalistani to all sikh and terrorists to all muslims ?

air India attack was a false flag operation done by Indian agencies .you cant say this here for obvious reasons but as an honest researcher Nitish I would like you to go deeper in that matter and find out the reality.peace

Sikh community and Hindu community were very closed to each other from many years❤❤ now they becom enemy for Indians...... Britishers are the main reason behind every dispute and discrimination from years and we Indians hate shikhs and muslim instead of Britishers...??\n\n\nThank You very much Nitish Rajput Sir for the truth❤❤

Main reason for migration was 1970s riots against sikhs

Bahut achha laga aapki video dekhke. Aapne bahut honestly sbkuchh admit kiya hai. Mera Bharat mahan h. Ma'am aapne safety security ki baat kri uska reason ye hai ki our Country is highly populated whereas no other countries except China is so populated. Population ratio is lower in other countries so everything is manageable. But kuch bhi kahe koi Mere Bharat jaisa kahin bhi nhi hai.

Still i couldn't understand the real reason for your return back to India because what ever you narrated no where it felt that you will go back, so the real reason is not revealed here.

Actually Canada has become hostile land for Indians because Indians officials have caught involved in murder of Sikh Khalisa Leader. I think this is the reason this family left Canada

Funny. But the reason he the NEW speaker. *Giga Chad meme*

You could not really suggest your 'real' reason for coming back. Apart from the obvious reason of - working with your own hand - which is not very convincing

As a Canadian I would say the US is a far superior & interesting place to live, but the health care is something I can never wrap my brain around & for that one reason i would not choose to live in the states but aside from that US by a long mile..

I moved to Toronto in 2021. I've wanted to live in the city and have finally bought my condo in the city of Toronto. I love the city, especially during the summer time. Toronto Summer is so much fun and a great place to be in Canada. I am sick of all the Toronto bashing the past couple months. Yes, there are a lot of problems and yes they're all really bad and need to get resolved. And in all honesty, Toronto is probably one of the better big cities to live in in Canada. Despite all the negativity, TTC violence hasn't really gone up on paper. A lot of aspects about Canada are still strong even among western countries. I've been to Vancouver and Montreal. And those are cities have a lot of problems and a lot of different problems than Toronto.\n\nThe reasons that she specified in her video are all valid and they all make sense. I just want to say that I'm sick of all the Canada bashing and all the Toronto bashing. Toronto is a great place. I'm going to be still living in this city as some years it's going to be down and it's going to come right back up again in another few years.

Is there a reason she pronounces it Ch’rano? Is that how the locals colloquially pronounce it? Never been there so I’m just wondering.

I love my india ! YOu have Stupid reason to leave India !

People have different reasons for wanting to go abroad. If you truly feel Kenya imekufikisha mwisho, by all means go abroad, but also be prepared to pay the price to break through till you get to a point of thriving. Its not easy, but Kenyans are resilient!

I live in Canada as a Kenyan and I have been here for sometime .I work as a HR/Payroll Specialist also certified in the field. The problem is not Canada , Canada is a very good county which I love and I am gland God gave me the Opportunity to Come and settle here with my family.. The problem with some people coming here is lacking of knowledge how Canada works .It’s system is very far from how things work in Dubai or Gulf countries. A lot people are thinking than you can just come and get any job even without proper papers or you can earn a lot of money and then build wealth quickly. Which is A BIG FAT LIE. The tax in Canada keeps you humble. That is how Canada funds it's high end life many admire and want to be part of. The more you work in Canada the more tax you pay and many don't know this, and it is one of the main reasons why a lot of people start to regrets, because they realize there effort of working hard is not paying as they hoped. Another thing in Canada is next to impossible to get jobs or rent a place without proper paper work, like work permit, It is not like USA where you can use someone else papers to work. the The main available jobs , easy to get , don’t pay much. And also the cost of living is very high in some provinces like Ontario and BC. They hardly recognize credentials from outside unless you came through a job offer. Also because a lot of things in Canada are paid by the government through taxes, like health care, education. Unless you are tax paper with (and I repeat) Paper work, you cant access the benefit, including thee free food available for the needy. \nMany people forget Canada is looking for people to work for them. Not to grow rich and leave. The system is meant to keep you working. Unless you understand how a system of a country works, one will continue to blame it. Let people get well informed and well educated first , before they jump in the river. And it’s not Canada a lone , but any country in the world. Also a lot of these media post about Canada are misleading. And there is also another trap called debt, a lot of people once they getting working, rush to but things they cant afford and it becomes a stress instead of a blessings.\nIf you want to live well and enjoy Canada . One of the top thing to do is, go back to school once you enter in it, get a good education and you will get a good job. Also give yourself time to adjust. REMEMBER you are starting from square one. You are not continuing where you left in Kenya or in the country you get from. Also, the general social climate is not as friendly as those in USA for example. Not many people are willing to help for free. The most jobs advertised in Canada are the lower end paying jobs, which a lot of people pay a lot of money to come for, just to realize the job they left behind was far much better than this, but no one told them that, just because it said $18 hrs and you converted it to your country and looked a lot, doesnt mean it carries the same wait once you earn in from here. The living expense are very different. The reality is, it is not where you are , but whom you are and determination knows no barrier. Anyone who will trust God for help, work hard/smart and be patience in life, they will make. It might take longer than they expect, but they will get their eventually.

Two things\n1. Comments section resulted our faith, people have matured now \n2. There must have been some reason for the official to vent out. WHY WOULD ANYONE ON DUTY BE FURIOUS AND RESTLESS for no reason? Someone must have hurt him with words, actions or both.

Reason why he smiling on stupidity.... our belief. B peaceful and reason to the end... when all else fails.... you know what it is...oh well

Alina have you tried York Region? I agree Downtown Toronto prices are ridiculous. Richmond Hill, Oakridges, Aurora and Newmarket is still considered part of the GTA and the prices are pretty reasonable for now. Hopping on a GO Train downtown is only 40 mins. TTC is the worst.

In general I like Toronto, I lived there for a couple of yrs a long time ago, but with these prices, I won't move back, forget it. It is impossible to live there, period. I live in London and even over here the prices became much higher than before. My mom is in real estate, renting out bachelor apartments and she is nice, she doesn't rip ppl off, she rents them for reasonable prices, utilities, parking included like in the good old days and ppl sometimes beg her to pick them to move in, it's that bad. No one wants to move out once someone moves in. Gee, I wonder why.

Hi Lynn, l live in Banbury, Oxfordshire. There is nothing in the west, Africans are better off in Africa. Life in England is like attending a top school where you have to work so hard to keep up. Theoretically in the west, the first 40% to 50% of your wages goes in taxes. This leaves you with half your income. Your half income will then cover your rent/mortgage and all other bills. Once you have paid eve body, your basically left with nothing. Our lifes are in forever debt spinning wheel. I am a Ugandan, lived in the UK for 33yrs. This is home and is l know. But l am sure many places are better than here. What is guaranteed is food and health. Food is very cheap in relation to people's income. Health services are free, kids education are free too. These are the things you can't guarantee in Africa. Could be the main reason many foreigners choose to settle in the UK. Thank you.

Lynn, this Canada thing is a common sense thing. Same reason a Tanzanian will not come to kenya to sell tomatoes on the streets due to high competition on the field. Any country you move to it depends on what you will go to do and who will help you get on your feet. Canada is extremely beautiful and one can prosper extremely well financially compared to kenya BY FAR! But you can’t come from the village and land in Toronto and wait for a job and opportunity to come get you from the airport! Am very honest. I live abroad, in one of the richest countries in the world and believe me, I have seen even their own citizens suffering economically. Why? What are their skills and plans and expectations? I read somewhere, with all the wealth in the world, if all was to be shared equally to every one the universe, the rich will become rich and the poor poor -again. So a kenyan should first plan who they will live with for atleast a year while they get on their feet, put their hustle mood on n be willing to take any jobs, plus get out of the mentality that one must be in a big city! Other places outside cities really have low costs of life and offer more opportunities. Just saying

Most people have sold their souls to the devil in the name of living abroad esp canada, us, uk, austraila, germany etc. Let me tell you what they do, they go with visitors visa then go and surrender to government seeking asylum. They are told by their lawyers to say they are members of lgbtq and they are not accepted in africa. That way, cos wazungu wanapenda lgbtq people, they are given assylum. Isnt that selling ones soul?. My 24 years daughter had chance to go to canada and i would have afforded the agent and ticket but when we heard about the plans once she landed there, nilisema shidwe, i can NEVER SACRIFICE MY CHILD IN DEVILS ALTER FOR MONEY HOWEVER MUCH SHE WILL MAKE WHILE THERE. God made us born in Africa Kenya with a reason. He will prosper us here. Mimi siwezi omba God watoto and then i hand them over to devil for money, wacha ikae. Infact God honoured our faith and gave us a very good opportunity to make money here and shes doing better than some of those abroad. Heri kwa Mungu, hakuna hasara.

Lynn some of these people say it is a trap but if you ask them why they are still in Canada, they won't tell you. He left Canada and was back after 7 years. Why not buy the properties in his country. Why go back to Canada to buy those properties? For some reason I feel bad that those who have gone have found a way of discouraging those who aspire to be there yet themselves don't want to leave. I am yet to meet a Kenyan in the streets of Kenya who will tell me that he/she came back because Canada, US, or Canada is a trap. They all say that in the streets of Canada. And those who come back, benefit a lot from the knowledge and money they made while in Canada,US, Australia, or UK. I think it's too much now.

There are families in Canada that have been here for generations that have been taxed so hard all their lives. And don’t live near any colleges or universities. That can’t afford to go to school. Why should international students come first here????? That’s right. There is No Reason!!!!!!!

f****** invasion wonder what they did in the old days when people invaded another country's borders will they just try to reason with The Invader and tell him go back or did a rain down Hellfire Spears and arrows collect them know they cross this border maybe a price to pay I don't know looks like kind of reason humane is kind of soft today and results are evident look at that army of Invaders just walking on through