Close Reading

Excellent Video. Nitish and his team have done an excellent research and analysis on Sikh Migration and their involvement in the Indian Freedom Struggle. Many of my questions regarding the Sikhs have been resolved in this video.\n\nBrilliant work guys. Please keep up the good work and keep educating people of India and the world...???

We heard that people who came back to India they are going again back to Canada, reason is there is no law and orders, corrupted politicians and corrupted justice systems make your life painful in India

Shiks are Shiks ??\n\nNothing to do with india.

You should have stayed (in Canada) for your kid’s future. \nIndia has very little to offer for its young generation …. Corruption, pollution, poverty, lawlessness and youth unemployment are a few reasons why Indians should run away from India for greener pastures of western countries ?.

With due respect bhai you Post bais Information about India \n\nI think you need to Stop this.

Sirf 2 and half months ke experience pr aap ne apne opinions share kiye h itne km time m aap khi b adjust ni ho skte not even in India.

Brother ye matter ke bad ek bar india ke gaming community par bhi video bana do aage jakar new gamers aaeynge unke liye samajhne me easy hoga \nAur unke future ke liye better hoga \nAgar aap ye comment padoge to plzzz ek bar aap check out karlo gaming community ke bareme \nAur clearity dedo brother

After staying for two years in India shewillgo back to canada permanently...... Because they have completed all the requirements of pr

Very well researched..Such things need to be shared in mainstream media to derail the propaganda run by the Anti India elements...Sikhs are one of the most patriotic communities in the country. People should refrain of relating them to Khalistan..\n\nMoreover, It's high time for Indian Govt to focus on issues faced by Punjab so that Punjabis can have more confidence in them and they don't get the feeling of being discriminated.

India m minority ko full freedom nahi h isliy bahar jana padta h nahi to kisko shaunk h apne family ko chhod k jane ka

My india ?? ?Sikh brothers ❤

Explain dark reality of real estate in India?

Anyway the moral of the story is .. india is shit country that’s why people leaving

I have same silver chain you are wearing..did you buy it from png..I am facing similar situation like you…last 10 din se I am feeling so depressive crying like helll… agar ghar se bahar chale jao weekend pe then you are ok but we spend alot for indian veg food restaurant in London…but hum ko habbit hai India ki trah weekends pe bahar khane ki but paisa Pani ki trah beh raha yahan London mai agar aap bahar achey restaurants mai khatey raho ..kaam hota nahi hai when you are depressive…jabkj Mainey India mai Covid ke time se maid hatta di thi still m struggling…yeh toh sahi kaha India mai studies bahut achi hai my daughter is 5yrs old n India mai ussey nursery mai online classes thi Covid k karan but still itni poems learn Kara Di thi Maine yahan uk mai school of kids matlab enjoy karo BAs ..struggle hai sab Khud karo chaltey raho as humne abhi car nahi liya hai coz we r also confused rukna hai ya nahi..job bhi easy nahi hai milna ..yeh mere Dimag mai bhi rahta hai weed n all… mai Pune mai thi mera koi circle nahi tha wahan bhi …mera native place himachal mai hai wahan bhi koi nahi aa pata tha humare ghar dur hone ki vja se..but yaHan aa ke India ko itna miss karna Woh Khalipan sahi kaha apne jabki hum Akele he the Pune mai mujhey laga ki Humara yahan bhi Kon hai chalo chaltey hai but nahi mai Galat thi u start missing India ki vibe online sab aana ..life is very easy in India 8months ho Gaye London mai still missing India ?? like crazy…yes London is very beautiful Indian food is amazing here sab milta hai yahan …but India toh jaan hai

SIKHs are Crown ? of India ?? Punjab can be into top 5 economy of India if they Elect Good Government and educate his youth

Great video and very grateful to Nitish Rajput and team for bringing up the real issues.\nAlso for letting people know that Sikhs in the majority are not in favor of Khalistan. Not every Sikh is in favor of Khalistan and the ones wanting it are not at all present in India.

Best video watched so far and its true only sikhs outside of India wants khalistan not Indian sikhs

Sab English comment kar raha hai ?? or Barat ko INDIA bolney Mai kuch gobar vakt ko dikkat ho raha \n??? Thank god Nitish ji Educate person hai warna wo bhi gobar or muttro sey canser treatment karney lagta

What is black Canadian?\nIn India there are only Indian, neither black nor white Indian

Matlab ye log pehle sey hi menial jobs kartein thhe. India is not a hotel or lodge. Jinko Jana hai jao. Humein Desh ke liye log chahiye Naa ki apni aiyaashiyon ke liye

Yar kya kya Kiya he Sikhs ne India ke leya \nAapni Jane de di Sikhs ne India ke leya \n2% Sikh he India me \nLakin desh ke leya shahhedi di he 80% \n2% Sikho ne \nDesh ke leya 80% kurbani aa di he \nKya Kom he yar Sikh Kom \nMujhe maan he ki me Sikh jatt family me janam leya he \nSikh jitna pyar desh se krta he \nKash he koi etna pyar desh se krta ho \nMe ik panjabi Sikh jatt family se hu \nMe janam v India me leya \nMruga v India me \nIk din ke leya India se Bahar nhi jauga me \nJaha he marna he \nBas India me rehna he \n1 din ke leya v desh se Bahar nhi jauga me \nHmesha India me rhuga \nAgar gumne jana hoga \nTo India gumne ke leya jauga \nEtna badha desh he hamara aapna khud ka desh dekha ge gum ke \nBahar kyo jana he \nWahiguru mehar kre sab te

India is not safe for indians ? Indians kill indians ?

As a Sikh thank you but in your wording sikh kept India always on front but what India doing for Sikhs

Australian intelligence agencies also recently announced that Indian officials targeted their own Hindu temples in Australia with graffiti just to tarnish Sikhs image when the Australian pm was visiting India so Australia authorities would share their intelligence information on Sikhs living in Australia. India is just making fools out of western leaders because they’re too gullible.\n\nJust thinking if Hindus can do that to their own places of worship what they wouldn’t do? Like maybe even blowing up their own Indian airline in 1985 killing all passengers and then blaming it on Sikhs so they wouldn’t get any sympathy from the world when Indian government attacked the Golden Temple of the Sikhs in 1984 killing thousands of Sikh men women and children just to teach them lesson also so nobody would then support their cause for a homeland (Khalistan)?

India ke bahar jane wale sabhi log.. money-minded & selfish hote hai.. Period

Great job n great research by the Nitish Rajput's team. This is 100% true, most of the people migrated to Canada in 80s-90s remember punjab negatively. Most of the news these people hear is through the indian media houses which very negative. They expect the same rights from indian government as they get from Canadian government. Most of the Khalistani supporting got active because of ruling party politics where a regular sikhs whose son, brother n father served in indian army and marines is called Khalistani without any reason. This has definitely created a divide in society, and media houses are also spreading the negativity towards a community. \n\nWahi baat h ki Modi is not india n humei ni pasand uski politics. Doesn't mean ki hum anti nationalist hogye or we hate modi. Bhai nahi pasand humei politics jo society mei divide kre. First thing a sikh child is taught is that everyone is equal. Ab tum fundamentals attack kroge toh humei ni pasand ayega.

Soch samaj kar bola Karo, nhi toh Indra Gandhi etc. ki tra thoke jayo gye. Bina poora sach jaane speech daine naa beth jayia karo. Jitna Khalistani Supporters ko tum lokk badnaam karo gye, Khali-Stan ki utna hi boost hoga. Kisi ki India main jabardasti rakho gye toh fights toh hogi hi naa, barwara hoga tabhi baat khtam hogi. ????

Sikhs are already second class citizens in india, you can see yourself hindus promote only hindu, sacrifices done for freedom by hindu , no one cares about sikh sacrifices, kuch ko to gadar party ky bary main abb pata chla hoga,.....

Maano ya na maano. Hinduo ne ghanta bhi kuch nahi kiya kuch india k liye. Bs cow ka urine pina or patthar poojna sikhaya hai saare india ko. Jo panjabiyo ne kiya wo tum jaise ehsaan faramosh log nahi smjh skte.

Good bhai sahi baat he ha sikho ko jo respect milni chahiye thee woo kabhi nahi milli ha sahi galat aadmi in cheejo me aa hi jato he lekin sikh khalishen kabi nahi chahteein thee doo chaar ko chood kar lekin india ne woo riseapact nahi di na Congres na bjp ne

Hum sab Ek hai. ?? Hindu Sikh Jain Buddhist. Sanatan Dharma se nikle hue 4 bhai. 10 o Gurus Hindu family se belong karte the toh uss hisab se ek hi hue hum sab.. Kalyan Singh Das Bedi jo Guru Nanak ji k pita the Kshtriya family se the.. hai na.. \nHamesha se iss dharti maa ko bachane k liye Sikh bhai agge aaye.. maine kabhi bhi kisi Sikh bhai k saath kisi Hindu se ladai hote hue nahi dekha.. I'm from 90's. \nR re Pakistan wale haste hai fayda uthana chahte hai.. woh toh yahi dekhna chahte hai India k tukde tukde ho jaye aur Khalistani wale yeh nahi samaj paa rahe hai kya? Pandit o k saath , partition k time Hindu o k saath bhi bahut julum hue the iska matlab yeh nahi ab ulta hum karenge... 1984 mein ek tarfa kuch nahi hua tha ... \n\nLekin ab humein ek jut rehna hoga.. Bharat Maa hai humari maa ko barbad mat karo kabhi dharam k naam pe. Maa ko weak maat karo aur. Forget past forget religion caste and all. We are Indians. God is same for us all. Jai hind. Vande Mataram ??

1.5 - 2 lac monthly mazaak mat karo madam \n50-70k mai bahut acha lifestyle hai india mai \nI save 40k monthly from 75k

India may not be the best Country but i love India and will never think about leaving my Country.

Thanks Punjab for feeding India duing hunder and still feeding. Salute

Punjab is a GEM ? of India

They know very well that the competition is so high in india and rhier weak mind can not beat other people

This AiR india attack in 1985 also By RAW not by Talwinder by parmar how much are aware journalism but you are still unaware

I dont understand the point of all this today. 90% of Punjab fields are taken care by people from Bihar. It will become interesting when say by chance, if separate Punjab country is formed, then later on the current Bihar people demand for separate Bihar in Punjab then annex that Bihar into India. Also to keep in mind there aren't many Sikhs remaining in Punjab, most are converted to Christianity.

Congress made India slaughter house for Hindus & Sikhs. Congressmen should be banned.

Air India blast ko bhai ne kitna light liya, nobody call them terrorist, haha.

Bro Khalistan to ban kar raha ga \n2022/25 se halat dekhna suru ho gaye pakistan china v India ke war ho ge india 4/5 day me india ka hall Russia ke jasa ho ga \nUSA Ukraine ke taha \nPakistan ko weapons send karg dekhna lana \n2030 tak india ke 9 parts ho ge Soviet union ke Traha

India ke liye sikho ne bahut kurbaniya di hai \nLekin India me respect nahi \nWaki sabhi country sikho ki respect kar ti hai\nKabhi kisi bekasur ko nahi mara \nLangar lagate , yahan tak ke corona kaal me oxygen cylinder ka langar lagaa Diya tha Delhi me fer bhi sikho ke saath discrimination hota hai

You have great opinion sir, but you should also make a video on why hindus people want india to be hindu rastra particularly dekha jaye toh sabhi ik ko he target kre ja rhe hai, thora Hindu ka bi bta do ki kya credibility ya contribution hai india main unka and i'm neither the supporter of khalistan and also for hindustan. I wish for humanitystan.

Thank you Nitish for clearing up d fog around this issue . Normally people fail to understand this core issue. U explained it perfectly that the migration during the 90's brought along with it all d hurt, pain and resentment that the community experienced in India.

Your video is biased and stupid at best. You should also cover the reasons for unemployment, and problems in Punjab. The problem is people from Punjab are so desperate to fly out of India, they have no intention or will to grow India's economy. How many IAS, toppers, businessmen you will see from Punjab? Its all about the mindset, look at other states like Delhi, Gujarat, Maharashtra for instance, population there is generating young entrepreneurs who are taking the country ahead. Its a shame that you are brain washing people, where you should educate people why because of such people India is at risk, they use India's resources to grow and when the time comes to contribute to country's gdp they fly to canada and other countries.

This video is truth for Indian history and Sikh genocide in India, so aware of hate rising between Sikhs and Other Indians.??

M bhi punjab se hu apn har baat sahi boli sirf sikh ni hindu bhi bahar jaate punjab se ab m khud germany jana h but bro aisa ni ki humh india ko hate krte

Sach sach sach or sach ke siwa or kush v nahi je jo news wale ha je sikhs ke dilo maye or agg laga rahe ha mai ek Sikh hu Punjab se Canada ?? aya and I love ❤️ my India ?? har saal jata hu nitish mere bhai app naye bilkul sahi baat Ki kush mejar or pannu jase log ha jo dilo maye nafrat bhar rahe ha love you brother

bhai nitish pehli baat tu ye apne sb history kahaa sey padyi hai google se mre khyal sey bhai saab phley sikho k barey mai puri history kitabu sey leykr wikipedia tak padho or hate sepach mat failyu sikh aisey sikh vaisey khalistan ka mtlab pta hai apko oss word ka mtlb kya hai phley ye research kro or khlasa raj rahaa hai humne raj kiya hai osko boltey they khalistan tum loggo ne aise boll boll ke hume teriorist bolne lgey ho brainwash ki baat kr rhey o hume sb pta hai humrey ithaas key barey mai bhai kya they hum or purey punjab ku pta hai jab india ajad hoya tha india govt ne kyaa promisw kiya tha sikho ke saath ju aj tak pura nhi huya yeh bola apney video mai sikho ke sath govt ne kyaa kya jyaatia ki ye bolla apne desh ku ajadi sikho ki vjah sey mili or jabh hum apney hakk mangey tu yeh khalistani hai waah hum terrorist hai shi hai tum hindyu k ne kya kiya hai desh ku bchaney k liye kya kurbani di hai desh k liye sbsey jyda kurbaniya humari marey hum logg or jab apna hak magney k baat aye tu ye khalistani hai han hum hai khalisatni fir sikh guru humarey hindu dharm ku bchaney k liye shaheed ho gye or vahi hindu hume terrorist boltey hai hum apna khalistan mangtey hai kyuki humarey saath vadhey huye they jab desh azad ho raha tha ki humarq alag ek state hoga uk mai aj bhi written mai padaa hoya hai ki sikh ek alag kum hai enko enka ek alag state diya jaye shuru sey lekr aj tak humarey saath kyaa kyaa kiya hai govt ne bs hum jantey ju punjab mai rhey he nhi kuch face nhi kiiya kya pta tumhey ager video bnani hai tu sach ki bnao or sach dikhao thk a sirf views k liye mat kro or phley sikh ithas pado achey sey ju koi bhi ataa hai moh uthaa k sikho k barey aisey hqi vaisey tumko koi or dharm nhi dikhta hum chupp hai ager kisi ku kuch kehtey nhi iska mtlb ye ki kuch bhi jhooth failatey rho tum logg ground level pey or ju tum logg face kret na first pta chlta ki sikh kum kya hai ithas pado humara pta chleyga lekin fir bhi tum loggo ne jhooth he bolna hai tu views k chkr mai tu alag hai sikh raj raha hai or rahega or ayega british desh sikho ki vjaah sey desh shod kr gye they abhi tum part 2 ki baat kr rhey they bhai hate speach mat kro sikho k barey mai ju just humeny kiya apna badla liya ju ju humarey sath julam huya hai sach bollo bs

Love sir ji bohat sara piyar sir ji muje laga thaa k britishh se india k liye panjabi logo ne nhi lada. Lagta thaa k panjabi logo ne sirf panjab k liye ladai ki lekin ajj pata chlaa k panjabiyon ne shuruaat india k liye hi ki thi..\nLekin india k ander chal rhe halaato ne panjabi logo ko panjab k liye ladne pe majboor kiya thaa......\nThank you so much sir sach me thanks sir