Close Reading

Kirpan is a religious Symbol in Sikhism. \nThis guy should NOT be arrested.\nIn USA, the police should arrest those who promotes Guns and Mass shooting. Here, the USA police has done a Wrong thing.

Sir they have asked me for 4 supporting documents,\nNational identity document \nPassport \nFunds\nImm5476 form .\nI don’t know did i do some thing wrong in the way??? \nThey didn’t even ask for invitation letter??

THIS IS WRONG

Life in Canada is isolating, lonely, depressing. People are very closed and guarded, many are snobby, elitist and passive aggressive. It is not an amazing place as it is umfriendly, gray, damp and cold most of the time. The bigger cities got hordes of meth heads and mentally ill vagrants who pollute downtown areas. Canadians like to hole up in their apartments or houses and escape into smoking weed and video games. Many young men can't get girlfriends as the women are stuck up, unapproachable or just plain wrong for long term relationship. 80% of the women chase the 15% alpha males and complain constantly that they can't get a decent guy. Oh and yes, taxes are socialist paradise high. The more you earn the more you are taxed, thus removing the incentive of even trying. Too many laws and regulations hamper development. After your family doctor retires forget finding another. Forget getting medical care unless you got a life threatening issue and even then you might just go south of the border and pay your way.\nI could go on and on, but frankly I don't care. It's a lot easier to move. It's just my opinion, because, supposedly it's a free country. However, a country is only as free as it's people and many Canadians love the prison they created.

NOT WRONG AT ALL.

This is so wrong

The part about China and Taiwan, and Russia and Ukraine should be cut out. This is very wrong. Obviously, they are not the same, very different cultures, very different backgrounds. Just as US and Canada. You might want to educate yourself.

Still as per my knowledge no one is returning from Canada to India. why ? may be I am wrong but just sharing my knowledge.

Don't take me wrong but it's their duty to research about college and life in ?? before joining the college.

I do watch many videos about the topic. First of all there's no place like home. As a human we will have tendency to resist to change. Choosing to leave a country whatever the reason will always be hard, you left a culture, family and so many good things. Diversity in a country like Canada is a good thing sometimes because somewhere somehow you find link to home. Imagine as a French Canadian like I am, I am consider as an immigrant in my own country. The natives came first from Asia, English took over the country which left us with no country we can call home. Many immigrants will say that French is an obstacle and don't understand why we need laws to keep it, we took our place following negotiations with the native not by conquest and always need to fight to keep that space because we're not making babies anymore and do need immigration like the rest of the country. That being said it brings the sensitive topic of jobs. There's types of jobs you do need Canadian experience, in Canada the construction codes are different from even a region versus another one. Do you know that St-Lawrence river is sitting on a tectonic plate and you need to construct a building which can resist a earthquake? What Canada need to do because we do lack of people on those job, is to provide fast track to help them having Canadian experience. They don't need anatomy courses, human here are pretty much the same but they need to know what medication is legal in Canada. Finally, all is on setting expectations, don't expect to feel at home in here, it take in average 3 generations to really feel at home, so be ready to feel pushed aside, be ready to live in a area where you will find mostly people of common cultural background. You will feel left over and pretty much alone. The only solution to be happy in here is embrasse change, go out of your comfort zone, embrace the local culture, talk to people from different backgrounds. There's a difference between multi cultural and integration. Sharing is caring, share your culture and your food, and most of all don't think you have the best way of life and other people don't understand. When you think everyone is wrong is usually a sign that you're the one who is wrong. Racism weirdly don't have a culture, a race or a religion, it's individual.

Canada doesn't need more immigration. The strain on the environment is already too much. Plus, we keep bringing in the wrong people. We need fewer Indians, Middle Easterners, and a lot fewer British. None of these groups assimilate into the Canadian way of life. We need more people from secular nations. Religions are a pollution.

Not happening! The incompetent Liberal government can't even look after the people who are already citizens of this country. Think you're going to import your next voter base to replace those who completely despise you? Go ahead & feel free to walk down any Canadian street. We'll see just how wrong you are about your ego thinking that everyone adores you!

the problem is immigrants that come here are vastly underemployed. very sad, very wrong.

dont get me wrong; i enjoy other cultures of people as a part of my population; that said, are we going to see double these numbers in new houses being errected? with appropriate size living areas/yards? not just complexes? are we going to see a healthcare system that can handle above 20% of our municipalities ? if we are talking about futures we need to ensure we can all have exactly that; a feasible future.

Cool, bring in more people to live off the system because we don’t have the jobs to accommodate them and also keep putting a strain on every system in the country. What could go wrong?

Good ? more population needed and better growth. Canada’s immigration policy works. As a Canadian living in Japan it’s so obvious to see what a very very wrong policy looks like as Japan gets poorer and poorer and it’s pension slowly but surely erodes. Now people will have to work until 70 to get any kind of pension.

What’s wrong with you people?

Looking at the khalistani violence the police did nothing wrong to be honest. Well deserved ?

You got it all wrong for Quebec

bro biometric fee only 85 dollar u wrong sugges everyone

Really ? Quebec no 1 ?? Don`t get me wrong I live here.... It's pretty....Socialist...Stalin Socialist. And did you ever drive from Montreal to Toronto ? *laugh* As soon as you cross the province border....Your car stop to shake. Bouaaaaaaaahahahaha Roads are better made in Ontario. Oh BTW about the French language.....Did you know that English is made of 28 % of french- words ??? Thank you William the Conqueror 1066....No matter how you look at it.... If you speak english...There always will be a little French in you... So welcome to Quebec...My brothers from any other provinces.

this wrong how dare they touched my sikh brother ???

:30 is wrong. The actual answer is winter driving in Montreal

You chose wrong country

Wrong, minister. We should scale back the International Student programme. We should not accept applications made by overseas agents.

Yea he is wrong...\nHe should wear AK203 instead of knife

Sooner you realise Better it is --> IN INDIA EVERY ILLEGAL AND WRONG DOING IS DONE LIASONING WITH G0VT, so it's same in CANADA too.\n\nSo there is nothing to cry, it's just people who should keep their eyes open. Nothing's gonna change

Thank you CBC\nA lot of students is pushing themselves to work 6 to 7 days to make money,this is wrong.

if u bring a gun or a knife in campus of course u get arrested. UR Traditions n cultural is not above the safety of childrens in institutes. N he is displaying it openly. off course peoples will think he is dangerous. I dont think peoples judging are wrong on this.

Till coming across this Fifth State Production I figured 5th State only catered for the Rich.\n\nI figured wrong.\n\nThank you.

Meanwhile the spoiled USA students are crying about using the wrong pronouns…

When in Rome, dress like a Roman. Nothing wrong in it

I am sikh and I think this student attention was good. BUT he should have worse this Knife (kirpan) Under his shirt. Just like almost every sikh dose. \nAll this gun violence going around usa ??. Very few people in USA ?? knows this sikh tradition. So you can not blame the cops. \nNo one get harm. So media need to drop this before its send the wrong message to the community

So I think Canada is ranked 3rd best in the world to live in (I might be wrong but it's top 5 for sure). Your speaking about nothing to do in Canada, Health care concerns, high taxes or cost of living and other things (honestly your video was just hurting my head listing to). While Canada does have issues (like any other country in the world) What you outline highlights the privileged life you are living. You are correct in pointing out that the health care system is flawed, it is not perfect by all means but AT LEAST YOU ARE GETTING HEALTH CARE. Take the stats for example (I had the privilege of going to the hospital in Texas) My bill came to 3000 for a twisted ankle. They charged me over 500 dollars just for walking into the hospital. I'm not knocking that stats, but if you do not have money, you're fucked for health care. Instead of waiting 8 hours to see a doctor, you're now on Web MD trying to diagnose yourself. You are bitching about high taxes, how do you think Schools, Police and fire services, Emergency service hospitals etc etc etc get paid? through wishes and hope? You are again welcome to go anywhere else and enjoy whatever bs they have going they might have low taxes in other parts of the world but your going to have to pay for certain services you are taking for granted here. As Cost of living, if you live in Toronto or BC yes the cost of living is high, but at the same time, the average household income is high as well. I'm sorry minimum wage in most of Canada is roughly 15 dollars an hour, and the average incoming for most provinces is over 100k. I'm not sure what else to say on that subject :D As for things to do, seriously, stop living under a rock. Please go and travel Canada, to name a few things you can travel to Niagara, Go to Banff, Visit hot springs or enjoy any of our national parks. Not to mention all the multicultural festivals that take place. I guess what I'm trying to say here is, Canada is flawed and has its issues. However, It's a beautiful country and is a gem of a place to put roots down. I'm sorry you guys didn't feel that way.

The cop didn’t do much wrong I see. If one has to follow these customs, better stay in India….

You remain calm into this situation that is really something and right thing. Now they already know it was wrong.

If yu are planning to migrate to canada, be ready to go back to school..bcoz your degrees are NOT recognize here!!..forget abt getting hired! .so this video is wrong..nice try to sell yourselves, and I feel sorry for the people to buy this BS!..Dont listen to anything whatever is shared, it is not easy otherwise everybody wud hv been in US n Canada.

What's wrong with this? Even if it's ceremonial you are not in India, considering the violence that happens in the schools of America that's was probably what anyone would have done.

What is wrong with people i mean we should try and respect everyones religion respect for this guy

I know that the actions seen out here in the video is kind of an extrem, but I believe whatever measures were taken it was for the welfare of keeping everybody safe in which my Sikh brother had no bad intentions but it was all an honest mistake.  According to my understanding he could've worn the Kripan under his T-shirt.. no disrespect to nobody but I'm here with all my Love and Respect to all.. \nAnd He being out of India.. people might have heard or know about Sikhism but respectively being in a totally different country it'll be a cultural shock to some of its fellow country's residents and that too he is in an educational environment or zone where a lot of unfortunate events had occur in the past few years due to violence.. so taking these reasons and unfortunate incidents under consideration.. our dear Sikh brother did not do anything wrong in openly carrying a Kripan (knife) for it is his cultural right and had gone some kind of a rituals in order to carry a Kripan for self-defense. But people will still feel some kind of uneasiness when it comes to weapons seen in and around educational area or zones. \nSo whatever measures had been taken for the safty of all.. especially by the security as he was doing his job by understanding the situation. No heard feeling to nobody but I just wanted to get my point across regarding this incident. N I know my Sikh brothers n sisters will definitely come to an agreement of understanding in what I'm trying to say..

Who the fuck cares what it’s for it’s a knife on a school campus kids a jackass for thinking it would fly then acting like he’s not in the wrong smh

i don’t see anything wrong with this. i understand religious stuff but if it’s basically a literal knife, you can’t be branding that in the open in a time like this.

I never thought what the police did was wrong . They did the right thing agreed it’s a Sikh religious thing, but come on have some\nSense ! In a college ! God wouldn’t punish you if you keep it at home ! It’s a weapon man !

Oh my God as a Muslim I understand him. This is totally wrong how can they do that. The kirpan is allowed to sikh in all over world.

I don't think anything wrong in arresting him. He can not flash weapons like that. All need to get away from traditions if those do not fit social harmony.

Look I get it you know like it’s a spiritual thing and it’s important to him but it’s still a knife and it’s in a college like I’m sorry bro but you’re in the wrong here

There's nothing wrong in informing a police about this, saying this as am Indian. With so much of killing incidents in the USA, it's wise enough to inform the police when one's unsure about the reason for carrying a knife.

Bringing weapons into a place of knowledge is totally wrong.....

It’s a campus. Student safety is a higher priority than religious customs. No one can guarantee that the knife falls on the wrong hand or is misused.

Sikh man is wrong. Terribly wrong. Stupid religious practise has to end. If he want to carry the stupid knife then stay in Punjab and not go anywhere. Thats it. HATS OFF to the police ??