Close Reading

As much as i hate Saudi govt, he is right here. Palestinians donot want to leave their land so who are you to force them to be refugees.

Meanwhile…they don’t want Palestinians because they don’t want to invite problems into their country and bring Iran closer to them. It’s convenient to let Israel deal with it. Just like the king of Jordan got 80% of the Palestinian land but no one says anything because there were no Palestinians…just Arabs.

A very good answer to her question and everybody in this world, Mr. Foreign Minister. United Nations has already assigned Palestinians to their land some 75 years ago. The transgressors don't want Palistinians to live!!

The points highlighted are true, but the main reason is Indian student just want to go to Canada and believe the so called agents…Honestly, the agent trap these student in bogus colleges which would demand high fees and no career option…. Students also blindly take this option… when agents tell them… no Ielts required… no work experience required etc…. Even student should think when I don’t have credit how come these colleges accepted me…. Dear student please be vigilant not desperate…if students really do their research… they will land in better place and life

I believe India is the best country to stay because:\n- Rents extremely high in developed cities . Property prices unaffordable in big cities like Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata. People are paying life long EMI till death.\n- Teachers focus more on Private tutions to make money. If you don’t take lessons from them, they will fail you in education system \n-Government doctors more focus on Private practices than their Government jobs. In ICU doctors sometimes sleep because they are tired for their private pactices.\n- Court takes decades to settle court cases. \n- Extremely high inflation - Food prices uncontrolled \n- Retirees not worked for Government getting hard time to pay bills specially medical treatment cost. It’s really hard for them to stay in big cities. No Indian government help and support. Government basically don’t care them. Only big big words at the time of vote \n- middle class working upto 11 pm to save their job , no retirement money- just surviving \n- After completing MBA, lot of job seekers land in selling target oriented credit card selling and driving Uber/ Toto \n- Ministers have so much under table money they keep their money inside the walls of their property \n- Sides of Highways full of Poverty . No good food, no proper sanitation \n- Farmers have to commit suicide for manipulated Government practices \n- Police is not writing FIRs if you are categorized as opponent \n-Fake promises are given to illegal immigrants/ Hawkers/ by Ministers for creating Ministers Vote Bank\n-\n- Ministers create vote banks from Hindu- Muslim riots \n- Ambani’s spend millions of dollars inviting top celebrities where 60% poverty prevails \n\n- Health care system is changing extremely high prices for small surgeries because Insurance will pay. At age 80 , all top insurer declines coverage when you need coverage otherwise premium is extremely high so that you can’t afford \n- Middle class is pressuring their kid to get admission in a reputed Private school and still has to pay high amount of donations.\n- Modi wants to make digital India which is great. Did he cared how the uneducated citizens, needs medical attention can cope with Government rules. He didn’t care. What he did for poor Indian.- nothing.\n\n\nAfter all these ministers are saying India Rising. Is India really rising or Ambani- Adani rising\n\nAbhi when you will show real India or are you scared that Modi will throw you in Pakistan

Even the qoran said that the land belongs to the JEWS. \nBy the way, nobody wants the so called Palestinian. Egypt said NO.\nQatar said NONONO\nS Arabia said Get the F off.

Nahhhh....they do not want Palestinians on their land because Palestine is Jordan. And wherever they go they want to overthrow the government.

Just another way of saying they don't want the Arabs in their land but also spewing a false narrative that it is their land... No such thing as palestine or palestinian. NEVER. EVER.

I don't blame the canadian citizens to be anti immigration, I mean why would you want to get too many foreign people on you land where you can't even sustain there finances?

Hello, I live in BC, Canada. Canada is currently in a very rough state, and I can only hope things will improve soon. One of the biggest issues is the rampant, uncontrolled immigration. The government invited a flood of people into the country without having the necessary infrastructure in place—jobs, healthcare, housing—to support them. Now they're trying to cap immigration, hoping for a turnaround, but it's like closing the stable door after the horse has bolted.\n\nCanada's drug and crime policies are an absolute joke. I also have an Instagram account where many students ask me about studying in Canada. I always tell them that if they're doing well in India, they should stay there. The problem isn't just with India's education system—it's with the unrealistic mindset of people wanting to come to Canada.\n\nWe see students desperately going from one store to another, begging for jobs that simply aren't there. Some even sell their land or property, especially in Punjab, thinking they'll find a better life here. But right now, it's just not worth it. When I advise others, they think we're living the dream in Canada while trying to stop them from coming. I moved to Canada 12 years ago, and the country has changed beyond recognition.

Absolutely correct… Palestinians don’t want to leave their land & yes ! This is a humanitarian issue. Don’t divide the world into two groups & a war…\nFree Palestine ?? stop the Genocide !!!

That’s alié because Egypt, Lebanon and Saudi Arabia rejected Palestinians when they were seeking asylum in the late 40’s. Palestinians have their land already, it’s Gaza, they just want Jews dead

Very well spoken -- really, I envy Saudi-Arabia for having such an eloquent speaker. I wish Israel had someone like him instead of the the morons we have in the Israeli government now.\n\nThat said, you understand this is baloney - the Arab world could have put tent camps in Sinai that is 3x larger than Israel and Gaza combined, and take civilians out of harm's way for the duration of the war under international guarantee that they will be allowed to go back. That didn't happen, because frankly no one want the Palestinian in their land - especially not Jordan and Egypt.

They don’t want to leave their land and we don’t want to leave our money

So they can leave and lose the last land they have left??? ??‍♀️ And then, what, Israel will use their help to try to start yet another war w them? I love that Iran did not fall for that trap. If we had normal relations w Iran, Israel wouldn’t even have dared. That’s been their biggest scam and nonsensical trap that we somehow fell in anyway. They may have an iron dome but they don’t have the military numbers needed to wage war against Iran, Lebanon, etc. so, they want to use OUR soldiers and OUR money, to start WW3. Cause they failed to take us there w the Iraq war too. Which was also their doing by the way.

Frankly, two things can be true, and they are. The Palestinians, however you want to define them can be a problem, they are majority fundamentalists, and at the same time, they can deserve to not be massacred. How you deal with them as a problem is another story, one nobody wants to address. Can there be a treaty, wherein, Palestinians agree to permanent peace, and Israel can have some portion of the land, independly to themselves (where they do indeed continue to accept Palestinian immigrants). What portion and how to about this will take real geopolitical maneuvering, but no one will tackle the real issue.

Leaving their land isn't the issue, Israel has a right to live in safety on their land, and they are quite happy to let the Gazans live there but that's not what HAMAS and Gazans want.\nThey have been expelled by so many Arab countries because they cause trouble wherever they go - by the way they are not Palestinians they are mainly Egyptian and Saudi, rather misinformation from this man.

Your luring the arabs don’t want them. And hey it’s Israel’s land. Thank you. ❤️???✝️✡️??

As a white Canadian who loves living in Canada because of how MY friends respect and invite all people of all colours in our lives - it breaks my heart to hear this.\nHER WARNING IS NO SURPRISE... I WOULDN'T EVEN WANT TO GO TO EDMONTON OR CALGARY (ALBERTA)... I consider it the Texas of Canada / very conservative in nature... like American Republicans. IF you want to live anywhere in Canada - be sure to land in provinces that are either Liberal and/or NDP in political attitude.\nI feel so bad for her and others - I hate this crap... and it has escalated since the Trump took the Presidency in 2016. \nAlberta is very much the closest thing to a American state that I hate to admit.\nPLEASE REMEMBER: there are sooo many of us that welcome you - Canada is full of every ethnicity and religion... but Edmonton, man - pick Ontario or Quebec. COSMOPOLITAN AND PROGRESSIVE.\nI would never want to live alongside Albertan Cowboys (sorry, Alberta - but relatively speaking...you must admit this is the case more-so than anywhere else in the TRUE NORTH)

The israelis have a policy that any Palestinian who leaves their land will not be permitted to return. He is correct that the Palestinian people do not want to leave.

I want them to be people who keep their word, like when they agreed to return home after finishing school. They are not refugees, we owe them nothing. They should go home and re-apply to become landed immigrants, like everyone else had to do who came here in the past. If they can't keep their word, they are not the kind of people we need in Canada. ?

What's one of the main reasons why a foreign country would invite foreign workers into their country to work?? Because there are native citizens of that particular nation that don't want to work, they are lazy.. I understand the issue about overpopulation, but on the other hand, the opportunities have always been there for the natives to take advantage of, but did they?? So the government had to come up with a system to fill those vacancies, and in some cases, another reason why natives can't get a job, is because they are not qualified.. I think if an immigrant should be there with the aim to create a better life, I'm sure it can be achieved with hardwork and sacrifices, because a lot of us want to live above our means/ budget, spending more than we earn, instead of saving towards accomplishing a specific goal.. And i think a lot of people go with this false belief that that particular country is paradise, so they think as they land, their lives would be changed instantly, not knowing that they have to work very hard and make sacrifices to achieve their goals, and that's the main issue, they go without having any aims or goals, they go with the wrong mindset and attitude, and the list goes on.. And these students that are protesting, they should be trying to make a difference in the country to demonstrate to the government and the natives there that they are worthy to be a part of the nation, because they are not taking from it, but rather adding more values to it.. I think it all depends on the mindset.. And of course, i do agree that an immigrant should assimilate..

He is correct Israel has to take them Isaelis and US UK want Palestinians to leave Palestine and israel to Grab the land

Interesting that the west’s answer to war is to displace people affected by war as refugees in other countries and that has become the norm… the Saudi fm got it right… if people are fighting to stay on a piece of land … why should we move them somewhere else? They need to learn live where they want without killing each other… that seems logical .. unlike the west’s solution to displace and export a problem/populace with a volatile/violent mentality to new lands

It's not their land , you all just don't want what comes with them. That we all know is Hamas!! They want the Hamas to govern and that's been the problem. So I didn't buy your answer you just don't want them because of the evil that goes along with them.

It’s not their land. And the Arabs don’t want them either. Case closed.

Common, you just don't want their terror ways in your land.

That question is pure gaslighting and deflection.\nThe west wants the Arab nations to take in Palestinians so that it will make it easier for the occupiers to steal more Palestinian lands with little to no resistance. Nope. Europe needs to take in those fake people who invaded and call themselves what they are not. Away with those strangers. Nobody knows who they are.

He is articulating this so well. Love his views and still wanting support for Palestine keeping their land.

You don't care about Palestinians, you just want Palestinian land go to Israel. Palestinians are here to stay and claim their homeland. End occupation.

It’s not Arabs or any country that are not ready to take Palestinians. Everyone is happy to take them and help. But Palestinians don’t want to leave their land. They want to live there or die there. I believe it’s their right to live in their own land instead of going to another country where they get harassed by such racist people.

He says that they dont want to leave their land. So only take in the ones that want to leave

Immigrant here, brown as well, and a worker in the international educational industry. Pin points why Canada and even immigrants, including international students and temporary works dislike immigrants from Punjab:\n\n- They are rude. They have little to none concept of living in society. They are selfish, they are arrogant, and anyone who works in the serving/retail industry will they are the worst customers ever. \n\n- The level of entitlement is beyond absurd. When the leader of this protests in PEI was told “Canada needs doctors and nurses, not you (the guy graduated from a business program, and works at Tim Hortons still), he responded: “I don’t care what Canada needs, is what I need, for myself”, displaying what a great citizen he’d be.\n\n- They refuse to integrate. They left Punjab to pursue a better life, but they want to live like are still in Punjab. \n\n- They scam their way in. Banks in India will lend them money to come to Canada, they buy their IELTS results. 99.9% of all the students I dealt with who got caught cheating on their exams were from India.\n\n- The people we are receiving in Canada are members of a separatist movement. They have often blocked roads to protest against India, because they want Punjab to be separated from India, and turned into a new country called Khalistan. I highly doubt they would all move there if that actually happened.\n\n- Going back to the entitlement: They often abuse the human rights nature of Canada. They sued the government for the right to ride bikes without helmets, or to not be forced to used safety equipment in construction sites, and for the right to walk around carrying a dagger, because it’s a “religious item”. Canada also for some dumb reason accepts their arranged marriages as a real one. Any person from anywhere in the world has to undergo an invasive scrutiny of their relationship, being forced to provide private conversations, and witness. Punjab people need none of it, and Punjab fathers are selling their daughters to strange men, so the family can move to Canada together.\n\n- Statistics Canada often talk about how our population is aging: However, they do not disclose how many of these aging population is due to Indian nationals bringing their parents and grandparents with them. If we got a million Indian people in the past years, that would mean around extra 4 million people over 50 years old. That’s 10% of the entire population. \n\n- They are scammers. You said yourself: To be eligible for a mortgage , you need to make at least $250k per year. They are landing in Canada with no money, and buying houses right away, because they have a network of people forging financial documents, and the also have people infiltrated in banks to approve these processes. Not me saying, that was national news. \n\n- They are extremely racist. They will openly tell you they only rent/hire/do business with Punjab people. Now, even the buses are driven by Punjab people, is insane. And you can tell they are new comers, because some of them can barely speak English. But is a well-known fact: Once one of them is in, they will make sure to bring in as many of their countrymen as possible, and only them. The DEI department of my company approved a Punjab manager, and now more than half of the staff is Punjab. English is no longer spoken in the hallways. \n\nSo these are just few of the complaints I have about them. I moved to Canada for a better life, and I have fully adapted to this country, and I’m resentful that this government allowed these people to slowly turn Canada into India. I was sold the idea of diversity, and I fell for it. I’m the minority of the minorities. Despite being a full Canadian now, every single day I think more and more of just going home. I’m tired of Canada.

Yes they do want to leave! I have seen many of them waiting for donations just to leave their land so that they can live don’t lie

What is this about labor shortages that the government wants to fill with immigrants, when there are no jobs at all anywhere in Canada for the Canadian citizens? It is a fantasy land of deliberate untruth or ignorance.

This guy is a monster. His statement „The palestinians want to life in their land“ is false. Even the leaders of hamas are not in palestine. They are hiding in their dubai penthouses. Get the children and women out of there!

These plant Journalists think everyone is stupid, the whole world sees Israel's agenda and that is to drive Palestinians off of their land and make it theirs. This is why Israeli politicians are creating the conditions they put the native of the land into, hoping that Palestinian people would leave or other Arab countries would take them as refugees, but unfortunately for Israel, the Arab world sees the Zionist's plan all along. Palestinian people don't want to leave their land as a matter of fact, they want the recognised UN borders of 1967 to be observed by Israel not leaving their land become refugees somewhere else..

Ohh yes sure, all the Saudis care about is the future of the Palestinians and their desire to remain on that land... it's not about the Saudis not wanting any Palestinians im their country ???

They should be asking the weak Arab leaders why they're continuing to pursue trade relations with Israel? If they want to lift the weight of the Palestinians, then why are they allowing Israeli goods to pass through their lands in order to bypass the Yemeni blockade?

That's not Palestinean land. Never was and never will be. However; Israel hS tried to live in peace,but the so called Palestinians do not want to.

I am one of the persons(Punjabi and International Student) being talked about in this video. Please allow me to get express some things. \n\nFirst, our homeland was divided into two, one part went to Muslims(Pakistan) and one went to Hindus(India). If we talk about our own state, we are labelled as terrorists. Recently, a 21 year old protester(Google the name Shubhkarman) was shot at by the police and nobody was held accountable. Over 700 people died, in 2021, on the streets of Delhi while protesting for a year to stop corporate buyouts of our agriculture lands(these lands are not 100-200 acre like in West, average land holding by Punjabi farmers is 2.4 acre). Our parents want us to survive, so they send at least one kid to foreign land(Australia, NZ, Canada, US, Dubai, Malaysia, Italy, you name a country).\n\nIndians call us terrorists, westerners call us cheap unskilled labour and some even call us shit skinned, pajeets, diaperheads. \n\nI guess we are just sub-humans who have no rights.

Why does the Arabs have to take the Palestinians in for?\nThe Israelis basically want to take the land after they leave because they’ll be like we need to “extend the border zone for our safety”\nBut just take the land over \nThey’re bombing Rafah to do the same thing \nEventually take the land for themselves

Force them to leave their land? If you feel an ounce of compassion for those palestinians, you would welcome them with open arms. Truth is You do not want the Palestinians. You just used your most pathetic diplomatic language to make this clear to the world! I am 100% certain that no Palestinian , that does not support Hamas, wants to remain in Gaza. BS

He is right. Why would they live their land for the zionists to take over it. That's what the West wants.

I like how he answered the question, if the Arab world take the Palestinians as refugees, that's what Israel wants ,,The Palestinian people has there land ,they don't want to leave there land.

Open raffa crossing let me see if Palestinians don't want to leave their land.. ???

Because Israel wants to empty Palestina's land Israel wants The Arabs to take care the Palestinos and help Israel to steal Palestino' s land.

since when does it matter to the system what canadians want?!? subjects of the land are not meant to have a say and to matter aside their prescribed role and position - ie, commodities that must obey and which need to be exploited and subjugated in every form and way possible for the benefit of the establishment.

So open egipt border, if gazaties really want stay in their land shuldnt be a problem

I want to come to Canada , land of oprtionity