Close Reading

I am an immigrant myself and came here through Express Entry, before that I studied in the U.S. I am all for Immigration but with recent events, I think the government should spend more time on the cost of living crisis and housing crisis. What I am proposing is we make room and keep cost low if we are to bring in more immigrants. The hard to find workers argument is basically people not working low paying jobs, most of these immigrants will be educated, have degrees and mostly in Finance or Tech fields, the talent in these fields are saturated and it's very hard to have job mobility in these sectors. I am not for kicking the ladder down once I made it, I am just saying we should focus on cost of living and housing so that these immigrants can succeed and better contribute when they come here, instead of living in the living room because they can't afford rent in the cities and not finding work since most are in saturated fields.

Why cant we meet our Paris Agreement numbers?? Because our government is bringing in more immigrants that need housing (cutting down trees), that need to get to places that cars need to be used to get to, that need to build new sewage treatment plants, that breathe in more air.\nYes! With more people coming into the country, our greenhouse gas emissions go up, so what does this government do?? Increase the carbon tax thats supposed to be used to fight climate change. Great scheme, increase carbon emissions by increasing our population so we have all the excuse in the world to increase the carbon tax at a time when energy prices are at a record high.

We have a massive homeless problem in Canada, people can't feed themselves, if you can't keep clean and feed yourself, you can't work......the government just wants fresh money to fill their pockets.

Nothing against the immigrates can’t blame them for wanting a better life, but this will destroy us as a country. We will look back at this years from now as a bad decision. We don’t have enough now for all the people who already are here what about them? How can they just add more people to our problems and expect different outcomes? It’s not lack of people lots of people are out of jobs. It’s about lack of living standards and inequality. This is like throwing a wrench in the whole situation, and will solve nothing but make things worse, but it’s designed to take away the attention from the current and ongoing problems we have, but most Canadians are waking up and realizing the lies of our government. They screwed our country over, and we may never recover now. They should all be let go for treason

We are governed by fools.

To make this work you have to RECOGNIZE THE QUALIFICATIONS OF PEOPLE FROM COMMONWEALTH COUNTRIES. Many people who are well-qualified are not recognized in Canada.\nChange the law. Whoever has STUDIED AND HAS CANADIAN QUALIFICATIONS AND IS FROM A COMMONWEALTH COUNTRY,, MAKE IT EASIER. MAKE THEM AUTOMATIC PERMANENT RESIDENTS ONCE THEY DECIDE TO STAY IN CANADA.\nThis system will make your goal to attract more people much more EASIER. ------ You have to REVAMP THE SYSTEM. START THINKING OUT OF THE BOX.\n Currently, the system is NOT FRIENDLY TOWARDS YOUR GOAL OF BRINGING MORE PEOPLE TO CANADA.\n\nThe Government has to help with housing and medical. Currently, it is in CRISIS.

Stop bringing in people who are so different from us. Look at what the government has caused. Racisim and hate. We love immigrants but ones that will fit in. When in Rome do as the Romans do. You are bringing in people who have 100 or more years of anger. And commit crimes and don't blend in.

We can't not afford more immigrants ,when they arrive we give them free medical..and social benefices we older people we had pay for that free medcal by our high income taxes high taxes.we didn't have any help from the governement to raise our children.we work 2 or 3 jobs they dont'work because they don 't know french or english.we don't have any appartement, the hospitals are 150% full we don't have enough teacher ,enough doctor and you want to bring more people.ask them to go on a farm and raise thei own animal and have garden to feed their family like our ancestor did

So basically, the Liberal government plans to depress wages further while increasing the cost of living. I guess rent wasn't high enough so obviously we need to steal a portion of everyone's income to increase the demand for housing by bringing in half a million immigrants per year. This plan is blatantly evil.

This liberal f@got does not talk about prosperity of the Canadians, but they want more unskilled immigrant to vote for liberal government gang.

Get rid of dual citizenship passports then we can talk ? can our government do that ?if so welcome to Canada but don't complain too many minority or too little majority in the country.

Probably for votes. Many Canadians are delusional and dissatisfied with the current Trudeau government, that many Canadians, especially those born and long termed non Canadian born Canadian citizens would most likely vote other party, especially Conservative party, who put Canadians first.

Weaponized immigration by WEF stooges controlling our Canadian government is a BAD THING for society.

I swear it is as if the government is expecting a massive die-off in the future and needs replacement ?

WHY??? GOVERNMENT CANT TAKE CARE OF THE POPULATION NOW, AND THEY WANT TO BRING MORE THAT YOU WONT BE ABLE TO HAVE RESIDENCE FOR THEM

Canada is broken the Canadian government just wants more ppl here it's bullshit because these ppl end up on the streets and I end up paying for it

Why go on out when there is fantastic education in India? When Modi government is doing a fantastic job creating more job opportunities.

Wow. Canada is so backwards. In the UK to apply for a insurance number to work it's done online via the government website, once applied you go for a face to face interview.\nAnd to find work you would only travel mostly about 10km. Part time jobs are plenty.

Government will always try to find a way to make some money , it’s sad

Indian Government should start making at least 30 medical colleges and 20 TECH UNIVERSITIES \nbefore 2015\nnow we are suffering ? coz of lack of Good Government education

So no one is taking responsibility on the side of the Canadian government.

why is canada doing it,student can work,in the u.s.,if you are student you are only a student,thats not right,it should be look into by the government of canada...

Just do one thing, limit number of international students to 60% - 70% in every college. And college cannot be started if rest 30% - 40% of seats for domestic students is not filled first. If any college wants to go for international students only, then their admission process/audit should go through Canadian government. So there is no exploitation of international students.

Atrocities towards panjab state and sikhs by Central Indian government genocides done by Indian government are rootcause for students migration

This whole system needs an overhaul. Why is Canada recruiting so many international students just from India anyway? If there has been a need for housing/hostels for international students why doesn't the government tackle this. In Kenya private developers build studio apartments in areas with Colleges/Universities, this works out pretty well. A private space is better than strangers huddled up together

The core problem lies with the failure of the Indian and Punjab governments to offer viable education to their youth.

Quality of studies by all these colleges is zero and students cannot speak up due to fear of being deported . It’s a mafia making money exploiting poor kids. Businesses come in to exploit further by taking advantage of students paying under minimum wage, all of these violators should be sacked. Shame on the government watching all this happen.

The government has ushered in the slave class from India under the guise of higher education.

Government of Canada can do a lot to stop the exploitation: run Social media/TV/Print awareness campaigns in local languages in India to inform parents and students about studying in Canada, make it easy to search for programs and colleges/universities, and proactively work with the Government of India and provincial governments in Punjab, Gujarat etc.

There is no end to this because this has become profitable for the government and educational institutions. Honestly, the whole International student program should be stopped.

Btw, garanty of success, of employment, doesn't exist and it's baked in the capitalism system that private enterprise and private college prioritize profits (btw, for non Canadian, education, is not subsidized). \nNow, if illegal/fraud practices are occurring, then like any Canadian, you will have to make a complaint to the police and/or take legal action (basically If you don't have money, you're F!). \n \nMaybe the Ontario government should have more stringent laws for private Colleges and recruiting agencies, like mandatory advertising for: \n\t- the required money for subsistence and the low likelihood of finding a good job that will enable students to work; \n\t- the % failure, homelessness, suicide,... \n\t- mental and social stress, differences,... \n \nMaybe Canada could: \n\t- be more stringent with student visa and have a written acknowledgement that states all the risks and pitfalls. \n\t- Guive visa only if the recruiting was done through accredited agencies \n\t- Do official advertisements in India about the risks and requirements of studying abroad. \n \nMaybe a full capitalism society is not moral, but it's the system we decided to live in.

Colleges like Sheridan College and scores of private colleges with partnerships with northern colleges are the cause of this mess. Canadian education quality has gone down the drain. None of these are genuine students. All finding a way to come work from day 1 and get PR. ApplyBoard is milking this and the government supports this. Shameful!

The problem here is that Canadian government and Canadian colleges think that international students mean Sikh students from Punjab... that's all I saw in this video.. when I saw the title of the video, I thought I might know about international students... but all I'm seeing is Sikhs, Sikhs everywhere... where is multiculturalism? Where are the other ethnicities? Are we missing something here?

Now that the students are allowed to work for 37.5 hours officially no more cash in hand work or no exploitation\n\nSo, every cry may not be heard by government but some for sure, I am hopeful for my Indians kids to survive and get them legitimate jobs.

Dear Asher Azim Bhai,\nAssalam O Alaikum,\n.\nGood To See You After Long Time. Thanks For Very Informative Video. Need Your Valuable Guidence, As I m Planning To Leave Pakistan. U Know Economical & Political Scenarios Over Here. I m a Government servant working as Asst. Accounts Officer (BPS-16)(SCUG), Ministry Of Local Bodies Goverment Of Sindh, While My Wife Is Dental Surgeon. We Dont Have Kids At The Moment.\n.\nCan U Guide Me How I Can Plan/ Start To Switch To Canada...? Which City In Canada Has Warm/ Hot Weather....??? (As I Have Medical condition, Cant Live In Too Cold Area). \nI m 46-years old, I Have just a Bachelor Of commerce degree, Though have (12-years) of experience in current government accountancy job.

It’s Canadian government’s fault who let those collages to exploit these young people.

The corporate government want them not to study only for cheep hard labourers in filthy warehouses ?

all illiterate Punjabis creating a ruckus for genuine people. Failure of the current government. Punjabis are ditching Punjabis. People are ready to pay millions of dollars. Due to these people so many back logs, something has to be done to stop this.

These students are nothing but cheap labour Canadian government is betting on! Government is 100% responsible for this situation.

The Canadian government is well aware of the scam private colleges and that the majority of these students aren’t getting an education and are just cheap labour for Canada. The Minister’s feigned shock that it’s happening is pathetic. The fact that Canada didn’t sign the Code of Conduct that other countries did says it all. If Canada is so interested in cheap labour, then just issue closed work permits with a path to permanent residency. Why make them spend tens of thousands of dollars and put their families into debt at useless private colleges?

CBC actions too late as this is going on 15 years ago if you are analysis numbers report you will see bug GAP - Cashed In Big Dirty Money. I feel sorry for the young students. Keep Speak Up - Your Voice to wake up all levels of the Governments.

❤Thanks for great work you do and I hope the government will do something about this issue and other issues you report to us.\n❤Charging 5X to foreign students are not fair and unjust and i feel sorry for international students and their families \n❤Many thugs of Sikh community in Canada are doing scams, frauds and corruptions in our innocent and unguarded systems and our government should stop them.\n❤

Sir I did 3 years diploma in general nursing and 1 year in midwifery after metric I am nurse by profession. I have 8 years experience working in government hospital can I apply for Canada immigration plz tell me about the requirements and cost

Hate crime HUH! Seems everything is a hate crime! Exactly what this lefty government news despots promote! A

Untold truth that you find out when you get here….They do Human trafficking and psychological domination by lying to people from other Countries to get them here it is so sad to see we try to be as nice as we can to people getting here but life is so miserable to find out you were lied to…..The truth is that we are born to have children and a family….and about the health care system is under attack and destroyed as well as our governing structure media’s educational and more being destroyed so you have to be really careful to survive right now for Canadians can you imagine people coming from other Countries being lied to and abused? WE ARE HOLDING THE LINE WE REALLY LOVE YOU????♥️

Shame on this kind of a security guard or a police officer when they get a free food from us they are happy but they don’t know about our culture Time the election all the official go over the temple gurdwara discussion situation the stupor don’t know about this shame on you government

Wait until we see if we shake the current tyrannical government we have here in Canada. As it is, the PM can lock you up and freeze your bank account if you say something he doesn’t like. Sounds simplistic and exaggerated but in essence it is true. Thankfully we have a champion for freedom PIERRE POILIEVRE so there is a ray of hope. If not for his success, I’d say don’t come. Many of us will be leaving if we are not able to regain freedom here.

It's a religious symbol. INDIAN government should address out this with USA government for implementing these stuff.

Well, the government has let them do whatever the F they want to do so why start complaining now? Islam is not the religion of peace it claims to be so stay away from them.

tax is too high, too much socialism, too many people on welfare, crazy government policies, the country really needs a reset