Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Economic Argument

1,276 comments
Page 34 of 64
Ive switched from buying things from the united states, and instead im buying from canada.
Ive switched from buying things from the united states, and instead im buying from canada.
Describes a personal purchasing decision shift from US to Canadian goods, implicitly supporting Canadian economy in response to trade tensions.
@Bugs_Bonnie Mar 4, 2025
Canada wanted foreigners to do the dirty work - menial work Millions of educated indians got green card - without having a job They came to canada - they found out 30% found jobs - …
Canada wanted foreigners to do the dirty work - menial work Millions of educated indians got green card - without having a job They came to canada - they found out 30% found jobs - 70% did low pay work And Brampton - brown town - erupted - symbol of Canadian Greed
Analyzes employment outcomes and wage disparities for educated immigrants, critiquing both immigration policy and employer exploitation.
Yjs11 Sep 21, 2025
All are selfish people in the world! That's why any opportunity for the job first gets hard-working people. All white people are also immigrants in history. white people think 'indian don't pay any tax' fuck …
All are selfish people in the world! That's why any opportunity for the job first gets hard-working people. All white people are also immigrants in history. white people think 'indian don't pay any tax' fuck of, we pay more compared to you and get less services.
Defends Indian immigrants' economic contributions by claiming they pay more taxes and receive fewer services than white Canadians, countering stereotypes.
sandipshiroya07 Sep 24, 2025
time to build high density housing there instead of single family homes with backyards and a pool vertical growth
time to build high density housing there instead of single family homes with backyards and a pool vertical growth
Proposal for urban planning solution (high-density housing) to address housing pressures related to immigration.
SCP_X1 Sep 19, 2025
For any non Canadians, if you live anywhere near here, your insurance rates sky rocket to unaffordable amounts. Truly one of the worst places to be in or around.
For any non Canadians, if you live anywhere near here, your insurance rates sky rocket to unaffordable amounts. Truly one of the worst places to be in or around.
Cites rising insurance costs as a negative economic consequence of immigration concentration in specific areas.
Genital.Wartzenegger Sep 22, 2025
it not just Brampton it all over Ontario my little town of wallaceburg just over night after covid we seen raise in the indian. i can't even get work cause of it.
it not just Brampton it all over Ontario my little town of wallaceburg just over night after covid we seen raise in the indian. i can't even get work cause of it.
Attributes job loss to increased immigration in the local area, combining economic grievance with demographic anxiety.
chadcarron8094 Sep 20, 2025
Everything will even out.\nWe, the normal people, will foot the bill.
Everything will even out.\nWe, the normal people, will foot the bill.
Critiques the economic burden of immigration policy, suggesting ordinary citizens will bear financial costs.
@odmeli4183 Mar 4, 2025
Indians commit no crime, keep to themselves, and don’t damage public spaces. They’re an ideal immigrant group and for whatever reason people hate them more than groups that do all of those things listed above. …
Indians commit no crime, keep to themselves, and don’t damage public spaces. They’re an ideal immigrant group and for whatever reason people hate them more than groups that do all of those things listed above. I think it’s jealousy because they earn more money than the natives. Harder working people of similar or higher intelligence.
Attributes negative attitudes toward Indians to economic jealousy and wage/intelligence comparisons.
Hawkem248 Sep 19, 2025
Looks like there is a lot of economic activity in the town, what’s the problem? With all the negatives it looks like it’s a net positive? Otherwise it would be a ghost town in no …
Looks like there is a lot of economic activity in the town, what’s the problem? With all the negatives it looks like it’s a net positive? Otherwise it would be a ghost town in no time. I’d suggest the immigrants who are setting up businesses to extend their employment to other racial groups. The government should screen better and slow or shut immigration down for some time.
Analyzes economic activity as net positive while suggesting better screening and temporary immigration slowdown as policy adjustment.
kusali11 Sep 19, 2025
When half your city is on welfare.
When half your city is on welfare.
Claims about welfare dependency in immigrant-receiving cities, presenting an unverified economic impact assertion.
scotthabshi843 Sep 18, 2025
No only Canada, many countries in the world are going to hard times with everything so expensive.
No only Canada, many countries in the world are going to hard times with everything so expensive.
Discusses rising costs and economic hardship, comparing Canada's situation to global economic trends.
Laura23971 Sep 9, 2025
then explain how we are literally the most successful group in the west especially in the US? Also tell that to Kash Patel, Vivek Ramaswamy and the numerous Indian CEOs all over America. Indians in …
then explain how we are literally the most successful group in the west especially in the US? Also tell that to Kash Patel, Vivek Ramaswamy and the numerous Indian CEOs all over America. Indians in the UK USA Australia according to govt stats themselves have the highest income per capita, tax contribution per capita lowest crime rate and highest education levels (in the USA it is measured by standardized test scores like avg SAT scores and % of population with college degrees). This is a proven fact based on the figures no other community/demographic is as law abidding and successful as Indians in every single western country. Indians are CEOs of major tech firms like microsoft google adobe ibm etc yet you won't mention that cause it goes against your agenda. The most successful demographic in the west (US UK Canada) are Indians. Highest income per capita, highest education levels and lowest cmre rates. When Indians move into a neighborhood property prices rise. This isn't creating chaos as this kid claims as Indians assimilate pay taxes have extremely low crmre rates and also the highest tax and income contribution per capita. Instead of making videos constantly deriding Indians why don't you point out the fact street harrassers across western europe targeting women are almost all Muslims from Afghanistan, Pakistan etc. Most pdfile groomong gongs in the UK are comprised of pakistani abdools. They have been operating in every town and city since the 60s. This youtuber probably doesn't even know who Tommy Robinson is
Presents statistical claims about Indian immigrant success (income, education, crime rates, property values) to counter criticism, with comparative framing against other groups.
shaheedbhaghatsingh3974 Jan 27, 2026
It’s time to stop all these creative wars that’s going on.Canadian are suffering financially and our monies are supporting war when Canadians are struggling to buy food. Th3 government needs to do something about this …
It’s time to stop all these creative wars that’s going on.Canadian are suffering financially and our monies are supporting war when Canadians are struggling to buy food. Th3 government needs to do something about this problem now.
Focuses on financial hardship of Canadians and government spending priorities, framing immigration as economically problematic.
yvonnethomas5599 Sep 8, 2025
We need to be asylum seekers in are our own Country from our own Hostel Government and Collect 7000 a month to live that's how expensive living is in Canada and what Canada give to …
We need to be asylum seekers in are our own Country from our own Hostel Government and Collect 7000 a month to live that's how expensive living is in Canada and what Canada give to the immigrants while the Government cuts our program to pay for the immigrants only giving us 1/3 the immigrants get Also when Quality of life is so low we cant afford to have children
Focuses on cost-of-living disparities, government spending allocation between citizens and immigrants, and inability to afford children due to economic conditions.
paulhoyle88TRUTH-or-LIE Sep 7, 2025
The biggest problem is they come to our home to escape a hell in their own country. But then they try to turn our country into the one they ran from. They try to change …
The biggest problem is they come to our home to escape a hell in their own country. But then they try to turn our country into the one they ran from. They try to change the ways we who were born and raised here are aloud to live our lives as we always have. My first job ever was tim hortons. Now im watching teens unable to gain independence unless their parents i Know someoneone who can hire them meanwhile no one can understand the person taking their order at tim hortons...Canada is to expensive now and we dont have the means to support these people anymore. Its costing us more with what they have done to our economy . Some of these people have zero care for human life ether they drive like A holes and cause accidents that cost lives. Canada is no longer a welcoming happy country. We are exhausted from busting our ass to keep a roof over our head leaving us unable to afford other things even food. Its not that they are all awful people (some are) but we CANT support them anymore we need to be able to support ourselves again !! The last 2 prime ministers are also to blame in reality. As an albertan i dont even care about anyone east of manitoba because they chose to vote this reality to life. I wanna see western canadas money stay on the west end of this country. There is a canadian divide and its time to seperate so not every canadian has to suffer for the stupidity out that way
Argues immigrants harm Canada's economy and job market for citizens, combined with cultural assimilation concerns and regional political grievances.
leanne3093 Aug 30, 2025
You guys are so missing the whole point, and it is perfect like rhat. One migrant equals one public job, Don t you understand that your public workers, the government workers sold your country to …
You guys are so missing the whole point, and it is perfect like rhat. One migrant equals one public job, Don t you understand that your public workers, the government workers sold your country to strangers. Everything our fathers worked for, they gave it away in exchange for a 23$ per hour job. They kept unworking, seeling your futur.......THIS is the core of the problem. Do you know a single public worker in the last 10 years who lost his job ?, lost wages ? Lost any life quality ? But every single private worker did........
Argues that immigration creates public sector jobs while harming private workers' wages and job security, framing immigration as economically redistributive.
paspep Sep 13, 2025
Indians are literally the highest earning and highest tax paying citizens of the country this is why everybody is racist to them , cus they are successful and more skilled and are taking jobs
Indians are literally the highest earning and highest tax paying citizens of the country this is why everybody is racist to them , cus they are successful and more skilled and are taking jobs
Defends Indian immigrants by citing economic contributions (earnings, taxes) and attributes racism to their success.
locked_in_human Feb 7, 2026
Canadian economy is heavily propped up with exploiting people, everyone gets a share of the spoils, colleges, employment, real estate 10s of billions of dollars 2 million people by $500 a month in rent minimum …
Canadian economy is heavily propped up with exploiting people, everyone gets a share of the spoils, colleges, employment, real estate 10s of billions of dollars 2 million people by $500 a month in rent minimum 2 million x 365 days x $10 in food 2 million x $20,000 in tuition per year, and this is all low end numbers I'm using.
Uses detailed economic calculations to argue that Canada's economy exploits immigrants through housing, food, and tuition costs, framing immigration as economically extractive.
D_4xe Feb 5, 2026
Quebec you don't even make 20 $ an hour
Quebec you don't even make 20 $ an hour
References low wages in Quebec, raising economic concerns about income levels.
madmann4399 Sep 8, 2025
Canada is not bringing in immigrants to work. I am a child of immigrants. My parents worked hard from the day they landed and given 0 from the government. Today, these "new Canadians " get …
Canada is not bringing in immigrants to work. I am a child of immigrants. My parents worked hard from the day they landed and given 0 from the government. Today, these "new Canadians " get free housing, free large amounts of money(which they use to send back to their homeland)...while we , born Canadians find it hard to pay our everyday expenses. Does this make sense.? The government has to stop handing out our hard earned money. Take care of your own first. And we have to endure bending to their culture not them learning our culture...our humility and kindness. This is not about to being welcoming to everyone , this is about calling out to the government start cleaning up this mess before we ( born Canadians) find ourselves without a country of our own.
Uses personal immigrant family background to argue new immigrants receive excessive government benefits while born Canadians struggle financially, mixing narrative with unverified welfare claims.
Rose-h4y3v Sep 8, 2025
« Prev 34 / 64 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)